Masaccio and the Renaissance

Masaccio
12 followers
18 Video Views·Jun 8, 2026
A 40 minute discussion of the art of Masaccio, one of the most influential artists in the Italian Renaissance
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis lecture examines Masaccio's revolutionary impact on 15th-century Florentine painting, focusing on his work in the Brancacci Chapel. By integrating classical humanism, mathematical perspective, and psychological depth, Masaccio moved beyond the International Gothic style to create \"istoria\"—narratives designed to move the viewer's soul through realism and intellectual rigor.
Hello everyone. In this lecture I want to focus primarily on the development of painting
in the 15th century in Florence, and the focus is going to be primarily on the frescoes
by an artist known as Masaccio. His full name is Tommaso di Ser Giovanni di Monica Sai,
but his nickname, his working name, is Masaccio, meaning, roughly speaking,
Dirty Tom or Sloppy Tom, giving indication of a large and unkempt individual who isn't particularly
careful about his personal habits or his outgoing and bold personality. There's no question that he
made a huge impact on the art scene and ideas about art in the 15th century. This is due
primarily to the efforts of two writers. One closest in time to Masaccio is going to be
Leon Battista Alberti in his work on painting, first written out in Italian, sorry, in Latin
in 1435 and translated into Italian in 1436. In his work on painting, he describes Masaccio as
one of the progenitors of a new style that's beginning to revolutionize art and put it on a
similar footing to that of the ancients, which of course is a preoccupation of Alberti in all
his writings, since he's a classical humanist himself and finds that an important point of
comparison to be in a dialogue essentially with the great figures of classical art and culture
in general. So there's no question that Masaccio's art made a great impact on people of his time,
both artists and writers. The focus primarily for this lecture is going to be on the frescoes
of the Brancacci Chapel in Santa Maria del Carmine, which is in the district of the city
opposite most of the major monuments that would be found, for instance, in the Duomo,
the Medici Palace, or what have you. There's a lot of stuff in the middle of the city of Florence,
but the Masaccio frescoes are found somewhat out of the way from that, and that's significant in a
really stand apart geographically and for their time artistically. I think that's kind of an
interesting point to bear in mind. So the frescoes themselves are painted in the years about 1425 to
1427. The artist Masaccio himself dies in 1428 at the age of 27, which means that he made a
profoundly influential mark on the trajectory of Italian art and world art in general by the age
of about 25, and it's a very striking contribution based on that alone. He, as I've already mentioned,
was recognized immediately by the likes of Val Verdi for his innovations, his really radical
innovations, and especially in the...you can see these most clearly, I think, in the frescoes
of the Brancacci Chapel in particular, and that's really what we're going to focus on
for the majority of time in this lecture. What I want to give as sort of a context or background
is make some remarks on what might be more typical at the time as an accepted style, accepted
motive of portraying a narrative, and I think we can see this in a work, a very famous work,
of Masaccio's time, one he could not have...he must have known about it to some degree or another,
and Gentile de Fabriano himself is a very well-known artist on the Italian peninsula,
influential in a number of places, most remarkably probably in Venice for his work with
Jacopo Bellini, who indeed names one of his sons Gentile Bellini after his master Gentile de Fabriano.
If we look at the Adoration of Magi, and this is dated from about 1423,
we see a really splendid altarpiece, an altarpiece that was made for the Strozzi family, which is a
fabulously wealthy banking family, one that is going to fall into ruin, I think, political and
financial in just a few years with the rise of the Medici, but this gives us an indication,
this altarpiece, of the wealth and status of that family. The altarpiece is done in a style
that's often described as international gothic, that it really retains many of the features
typical for altarpieces of the 14th century, and some of those include an ornate architectural frame,
although there are not necessarily pointed arches, which is very typical for many
frames of the 14th century. The overall feeling is one, again, much like a kind of miniature church
that frames the entire scene. We have an abundance of gold leaf and other decorative elements.
The primary scene, that is to say the Adoration of the Magi, if we go in just a little bit closer
and look at that, also has many of the hallmarks of the international gothic reliance on
a gold leaf decorative pattern, a certain sense of two-dimensionality, particularly in the robes
of these three kings right here. The widespread use throughout the scene of processions of people
crammed together in a small space, not necessarily paying a lot of attention to
perspective, spatial awareness, I suppose is a great way of putting it. That said, it's not a
completely backward-looking piece. The ways in which animals and people, for instance, are
foreshortened. You can see, for instance, this figure here looking up into the sky, very nicely
rendered. A face right here, the sense of looking at a human head from multiple angles, multiple
areas of foreshortening. As we go down a little bit into the scene, you can see the same things
at work with the representations of the animals. So this is very much, I think,
more contemporary, perhaps, than the label international gothic perhaps would indicate.
The most innovative sections, it's worth pointing out, are probably going to be, and this is often
the case, in the predella areas. If we go over, especially in the two landscape areas, we see
here this adoration, not so much by the sort of nativity scene, not so much adoration by the
Magi, but by Mary sleeping Joseph off to the side here. I think we get a pretty good
close-up detail. You can see a very remarkable representation of a nighttime
landscape, right? The sky dotted with stars. The effects of light and shadow at night
are represented here in a way that's very rarely seen elsewhere in Italian art at the time.
And if we go over just a little bit to the flight into Egypt, we've got a very, very popular
motif. We see this, for instance, in Giotto in the Chapel of Frescoes. If we look at that scene,
we can see a daring new emphasis, really, on natural effects of light, shade, atmosphere.
The sense of space and openness in the picture is really remarkable for its time.
So Gentile di Fabriano sits, in terms of painting, on a kind of
middle ground between the traditions of the 14th century and the quite radical innovations of the
15th century. And one of the most important things to remember about the Renaissance is,
indeed, its self-awareness that it's changing history, that it's changing the accepted ways
of understanding and doing things. Now let's move forward to another example that we might compare,
and this is from the north. And that, of course, is the Ghent Altarpiece. And this is just a kind
of reminder to see, again, this is very roughly contemporary, day 1432, so it's just a little bit
after Masaccio's work. And it really stands out, just like Masaccio does, as a prime example of
the values of the culture of the time when it came to painting. And again, the distinguishing
characteristics, as opposed to Gentile di Fabriano, working primarily in tempera. Jan van Eyck is
working in wood. The mode of representation in oil that Jan van Eyck presents is very, very
different from the two Italian examples. The focus on, again, very closely observed detail,
behavior of light, the sense of a kind of almost mystical, meditative, still quality pervades
really each of the other frames. In other words, the sense of action, I think, is not particularly
strong. A contemplative, meditative emphasis is much more apparent here. Therefore, the reason
I'm sort of giving this background is that when we move to the, let's just take this one very,
very well-known example from the Brancacci frescoes, and that, of course, is the Tribute Money,
a very different emphasis, a very different, in a sense, understanding of the problems of art and
their solution, I think, is seen. So this is primarily what we want to focus on.
The Tribute Money, as an episode, is a pretty rare subject matter in Christian art. It's
not commonly represented, and there are probably a number of reasons for this.
Its message is not necessarily that direct. It doesn't have the same kinds of instructive or
affective properties that a number of other much more commonly depicted episodes would have.
But it did present Masaccio with the opportunity to work in a different idiom, I guess, for painting,
and this is one that's going to be very much more influenced by classical art.
So that's, I think, an important motif to keep in mind when we look at the Tribute Money. I think
that's something to consider. We're looking right now at a close-up detail of the central group of
figures in the Tribute Money, and what we should probably do is take a quick look at what they're
doing. In the foreground, we see right here an individual who's a Roman tax collector. The
episode is taken from the Gospel of Matthew, and the Roman tax collector at Capernaum is basically
insisting that Christ and his disciples pay a kind of a poll tax, essentially,
rendering tribute to the Roman government. And, of course, the disciples really recognize no
leader besides Christ, and they're going to be very resistant to this idea.
But Christ resolves the situation by telling Peter to go to the Lake Galilee and catch a fish,
which is Peter's job. And he catches the fish, and as Christ predicts it, there is a coin in the
mouth of the fish. So the situation is resolved, and we have a kind of working out of render on
the Caesar the things that are Caesar's type of lesson. Scholars have been definitely not
entirely sure what the significance of this episode implied to the patron or to the city.
The actual patron of this, Felice Brancacci, may have had his own reasons for focusing on
tribute mining, because it's a very, very big scene within the cycle of frescoes. There must
have been some meaning for him. But it's not entirely clear. Does this support government
taxation? Is this a protest? Some scholars have tried to link it with roughly contemporary
political events, including the so-called Catasta, the tax survey, which is an invaluable
document for historians of Renaissance Florence, as we have all kinds of testimonies about people's
income and property and what have you. It's not really clear what the message is. Is this about
sacrifice on behalf of the Florentine public? It's still not entirely clearly defined.
That being said, it certainly gave Masaccio the opportunity to focus on what will become a major
theme, I think, within Italian art of the 15th century, and that is the large-scale narrative,
showing figures in action, doing important things. There's a term for this that gains
widespread usage in the 15th and into the 16th century, and that is the istoria,
I-S-T-O-R-I-A. This is the focus of an artist's work, and this is something that
Leo Battista Alberti makes abundantly clear in his work on painting, that this is the highest
ambition that an artist can aspire to, to create an istoria that impresses upon the
mind and really soul of the viewer the significance of the actions of the people
portrayed in the painting, and indeed seeks to alter or influence the viewer in some way.
So, for instance, in this scene right here, somebody looking at the fresco and seeing the
actions of Christ and the discussions the disciples might himself, and this is really
addressed primarily for the male population, be influenced to do similar great things in his life.
The kind of visual rhetoric that's appropriate to an istoria was a subject of discussion in
Alberti's own work, and he describes at some length the kinds of things that the artist
should be able to do in order to make an istoria work. So, primarily among these are going to be
the use of gesture, which we can see abundantly in the Tribute Monument. The use, for instance,
of hands and pointing to the image there of Peter. It's worth pointing out that there's this
in this scene, and this detail is skipping one part where Peter actually pays the tax
collector off to the right. We'll see if we can find that detail. But the sense of hands
pointing, here's Peter, then here's Peter again, giving a sense of flow of time and place is
important. Another aspect of the istoria that's crucial for Alberti is emotional expression,
and you can see the ways in which Masaccio has presented
Bryson's disciples in this kind of monumental and serious fashion. There's a term for this
in Roman rhetoric. The sense of gravitas, the sense of responsibility and seriousness,
is enhanced by these solid figures. And of course, it doesn't hurt that Masaccio has
given them very stable postures and clad them in very Roman-looking robes, beautiful colors,
but carefully controlled colors. And in a sense, drawing upon the legacy of Giotto, because I think
it must have been the case that Masaccio somehow had an unknowledgeable understanding of the
chapel in Padua, drawing upon Giotto, he takes it one step further, giving these figures weight
and substance. And that is through the use of light. We'll dig a little bit more into that in
a second. Okay, so we're still talking about the idea of the istoria and the sense of a serious
narrative. So Masaccio is given this episode, a kind of aura of grandeur, I guess is the best way
of describing it, that I think is very much rooted in classical humanist precepts.
But nevertheless, Masaccio is an artist, he's not a humanist, and so he may quote
classical sculpture. We can see that, for instance, in the contrapposto
attitude here of the tax collector. There's clearly a sense of, again, borrowings from
classical statuary in the group of the disciples. There's also, though, I think, a recognition
of contemporary developments, and for that we should maybe take a quick look at sculpture.
Okay, so when I was talking about sculpture, I'm talking really about contemporary developments
in sculpture. Obviously Roman sculpture is still around in Italy, and people can certainly,
artists can refer to that. But more specifically, I want to focus on the work of
Masaccio's contemporaries, what would have been available right there in the streets
in Florence, for instance. And a great place to begin, I think, is to consider the figures
that we would see, for instance, in a work by the sculptor Nanni de Banco on the exterior of
Orsanmichele, right in the heart of Florence, which Masaccio, growing up in Florence, could hardly have
ignored. And it shows, and I think this is why it's such a good example of what I'm talking
about, it shows four actors on a stage of sorts, right, in this architectural niche.
Four individuals grouped in a semicircle within this niche, and they're trying to decide
essentially what to do. And the situation is remarkably similar to that of Christ and the
Disciples, because these sculptors are from the era of Roman antiquity. They're
sculptors who've been asked by the Emperor Diocletian, one of the most notorious persecutors
of Christianity, they've been asked by Diocletian to make a pagan idol, and they have refused,
and therefore their lives essentially are forfeited. They're going to be
prosecuted and executed by the Emperor. So, I think it's very, very likely, especially given
the strong visual similarities, the robes, the distinguished postures and gestures of these
figures, it's very, very likely that Masaccio drew upon this sculptural group in particular
for inspiration and understanding of how to organize figures in a group, thinking and doing
serious things. And we can see the use of contrapposto, the sense of weight shift is
very strong in the Banco's work, as you can see in this figure right here, moving weight from
one leg to the next, one leg to the other, the term being contrapposto, C-O-N-T-R-A-P-P-O-S-T-O.
A technique that was perfected, really, in the era of Greek art and preserved in
Roman art as well. So, I think that looking at Nonna di Banco as a point of comparison,
I think, is very strong. And the sense of three-dimensionality and relief, which is another
important part of Italian art theory at the time, is also evident in this group, and I think that
Masaccio must have, again, derived inspiration for his perhaps most inventive visual technique,
and that is a good understanding of the properties of light. Now, in this way, or at least
in this section, when I talk about light, I want to try to draw a distinction between the way
that someone like Jan van Eyck, for instance, might perceive and represent light in the way
that Masaccio does. It, I think, is not too much of a generalization. When we think of
the sort of Eyckian mode of light, to go and take this and look really, really quickly back,
just a few slides there, to look at that Ghent altar piece in just a little bit of detail,
and we can just literally zoom in anywhere we like. I think a great place to start
might be just the central group here. And as we close in on these figures, we can see
the extraordinary precision with which Jan van Eyck has shown the way that light lands on the
surface of things. So, for instance, this scepter right here is clearly made of crystal or glass,
the reflective properties of gems and so on. And the extraordinary accuracy
with which Jan van Eyck has represented this sort of draws us in to his world, his visual world.
But something that's a little bit lacking, I think, and we can maybe sense this as we pull out
just a bit, is the idea that these figures possess a kind of independent three-dimensionality.
There's still this feeling that they're somehow within the matrix of the painted panel,
that the space that they inhabit is not entirely believable. And this is not helped, for instance,
in this group of angels on the left by the sense of compression, for instance, on the space.
Now, let's again compare this really, really quickly with the sense of the figures. I'm just
The way in which these figures, this group, stands apart from their setting,
and the way that they do possess a kind of independent three-dimensionality. Each figure
stands apart. We don't have any trouble making that mental leap from two-dimensional fresco
right here to three-dimensional figures operating within that pictorial space.
So, we don't get the sense of painted figures necessarily on a surface. However, immaculately,
Jan van Eyck represents the textures of fabrics or hair, whatever. We never get the sense that
the figures are actually operating independently in space. And Jadot, especially through his use
of light, makes that work for us. We can see a very clearly identifiable light source coming
in from the upper left that strikes the figures and defines them in clear relief.
And they create very distinct shadows that behave the way that we'd expect shadows to
behave. And so, the entire group here seems somehow to exist almost independently of the
two-dimensional surface they're painting on. And this is a really path-breaking discovery,
and in many ways, I think, did surpass any of the contributions made by classical art,
at least the ones that we have access to, because it makes this mental leap from two-dimensional
flat paintings, say, on a panel like a tempra or on fresco. And even Jadot's figures, despite their
three-dimensionality, never skip that sense of independence from the painted surface.
That Masaccio's real contribution is precisely that of independent actors making decisions
and doing so in a believable way. So again, as we look at this scene here, we see the Roman tax
collector asking for the money. Again, a very beautifully posed classical figure right here.
The disciple here, Peter, is given the command to go to the Lake of Galilee, which he does,
and he gets the fish, and the money's within the fish's mouth. And we come back again to Peter
paying off the tax collector. And you'll notice that the tax collector himself is basically just
a mirror image from the back and from the front in these two instances. So you get the sense of
the narrative sort of coming full circle. This technique of simultaneous narrative is a very
old-fashioned one, so it's worth pointing out. One that somewhat unrealistically has multiple
iterations of the same figure, in this case St. Peter. Okay, well, that's not the only thing that
Masaccio does. It's very, very impressive. And again, Vasari, writing in the 16th century,
makes the note that the works before Masaccio's day can be said to be painted. Masaccio's figures
are living, real, and natural. Well, it's again not just the figures themselves that are doing
this, it's also the setting. So Masaccio presents the viewer with a coherent total environment in
which to do the things that are important, the things that we look on at, that we view.
To show you what I mean by that, we see the ways in which, for instance, he's incorporated linear
perspective in the building to the right. There's this little loggia-like, this porch-like area
right here, very nicely done, again in terms of light and shade. But we can see the ways in which
he's tried to construct a mathematically accurate representation of linear perspective in that
structure as well. And then, to take it further and deeper into space, he creates a landscape in
the background which moves very, very subtly, but effectively, from relatively close up. So,
for instance, we can see here hills with the characteristic dividing hedges and trees and
small houses and villages, what have you. And then, as we move further back, and this is visually,
we're basically just moving along here, we can see those details begin to fade away,
and then they begin to disappear altogether, and the mountains become much paler and more blue.
And this is a great illustration of the use of what's called linear, not linear, but aerial
perspective, atmospheric perspective, which represents not the mathematical certainty of
the measurable certainty of linear perspective, but a kind of intuitive visual perspective that
reflects our own experiences looking at distant, say, mountain ranges or things like this,
where colors and details fade and generally become cooler and grayer. So, Masaccio gives us
a total environment of sorts. If we look at these trees, we can notice that some of the leaves,
for instance, have been preserved here, but these really bare ones are probably bare by accident,
but these may well have been applied a secco so that we're missing the really close details here
that would enhance that sense of transition from foreground to middle ground to distance right here.
So, in the Brancacci Chapel, we see, particularly in the tribute money, this kind of full realization
of new currents in Florentine art. And let's just walk through those really quickly one more time.
There's a sense of borrowing from classical antiquity in the posture and arrangement of the
sense of a believable and important narrative being sustained by gesture and expression that's
at the heart of Alberti's program in his really foundational work on painting. So, the understanding
of human anatomy, human gesture, human posture, expression, and all that stuff is really fully
realized here. Masaccio is understanding the use of light and the way in which light behaves,
not just on the surface, but also the way in which it models mass, three-dimensionality.
He also has created a total environment for his figures to act within, again, mirroring our own
experiences and making the episode of the tribute money, in a sense, part of our own experience.
We're invited, in essence, to try to understand its significance because it relates directly to
our own experience. Now, elsewhere in the Brancacci Chapel, we see some important developments.
One of the most significant, I think, is the expulsion of Adam and Eve, because here we see
probably one of the first very, very direct experiments in human psychology and art. In other
words, if we compare this, say, with Giotto's angels that are crying in the Lamentation in
Padua, there is something much more harrowing, much more intense, much more direct, I think,
in Masaccio's expressions here. And that, I think, is enhanced considerably by the use
of nudity. And really, prior to this point in time, we've not seen anything quite like this on
quite the scale, at least in Italian art. It's very different, again, if we think of this in comparison
with, say, the figures with Jan van Eyck's altarpiece. So, let's just look really, really
quickly. We can look at Eve, for instance. So, if we consider Eve, she's definitely a nude figure,
but there's an emotional aspect. She's a blank. There's no real way of understanding her
emotional inner life, and that is clearly not the case, I think, with these figures.
There's also, it's worth pointing out, a very obvious reference, I think people would have
recognized it, to the classic Venus type, which shows up time and time again in Florentine art.
We'll see it, for instance, in Botticelli's Birth of Venus, where, in this case, Eve covers her
breasts and genitalia in a gesture that's very, very commonly seen in representations of Venus.
So, again, classical allusions are present here. But the primary innovation, besides the use of
light, which we've already discussed in the main scene of the Tribute Money, the primary
innovation is this attempt to really convey the inner psychological state of the figures here,
and it's very, very striking the way in which Masaccio can switch from the grandeur of the
figures of the Tribute Money, operating here as a group of Roman senators, to that direct, very
human, in fact, almost too human, despair and tragedy of the Adam and Eve figures.
Perhaps, when we're thinking of Masaccio, his grandest conception, pictorially, is going to
be his representation of the Holy Trinity, again, dating right around the same time as the Tribute
Money. This is in the Dominican Church, a Santa Maria Novella, again in Florence, and is a
striking illustration, really, of the principles of disegno. Disegno is an Italian concept that
refers to the sense of structure and planning, intellectual foundations for a work of art.
And in this highly meditative and contemplative work, we see an extraordinary attention paid to
really almost mathematical visual rigor, particularly in the application of linear
perspective, a very, very close quotation understanding of classical architectural models,
and an overall geometrical construction of the work. To illustrate what I mean, if we look,
for instance, just a little bit closer at this barrel vault, essentially we have this fictive
chapel. The artist has created an architectural chapel in fresco on the side of the church wall.
We can very closely measure, in mathematical terms, the actual dimensions of these ceiling
coffers, the height of the columns in relation to the average height of an adult male or female.
The way in which this has been constructed gives the viewer a kind of access, in an intellectual
sense, and I think this reflects work that's being done in architecture by the likes of Brunelowski
in a very intellectually, rationally comprehensible way. It gives us access to this space
inside this very sacred chapel. Note that the donors are kept to the exterior here.
They're not allowed in here. Lorenzo Lenzi, the patron on the right, and his wife are
kept just outside, but we're allowed to travel visually thanks to this mathematical precision
that we see here. The quotation of classical architecture is immaculate. Corinthian order
plasters here, ionic columns, a beautiful triumphal arch overall here. All this is done
with great attention to the original Roman models. Again, the likes of Brunelowski are
going to be key, and Alberi writes as much in essence. Brunelowski's understanding of
architecture is fundamental to the Quattrocento in Florence. Then the sense of a mathematically
ordered composition is very apparent, for instance, in the strong pyramidal,
really triangular, not quite pyramidal because it's not very three-dimensional, but triangular
arrangement, very, very stable between the patron, the Virgin Mary, the head of Christ,
culminating, of course, just a little bit higher in God the Father. We have the sense of the
Trinity again, the Son, the Holy Ghost, and God all stacked in a very logical and comprehensible
fashion. So the piece is very, very rigorous intellectually, and that, of course, is enhanced
by the representation of the human skeleton at the base on a kind of an altar, and again,
a contrast between the presentation of death in the skeleton right here and the possibility
for redemption in Christ's sacrifice just above. If you look a little more closely
at the altar, you can see in Italian words essentially translating,
I was once what you are, and you will be what I am now. This memento mori, again, invites the
viewer to meditate on the inevitability of death and the possibility of salvation, again, thanks to
the sacrifice by God of his only Son. So it's a very serious work and very, very structured and
given a sense, again, of nobility, grandeur, intellectual rigor, which is very, very characteristic
of the disegno model in Italian art. Masaccio proves to be hugely influential on later artists,
and in particular, think about the likes of Michelangelo in the 16th century. He really
sets the parameters for what constitutes, again, using Alberti's terminology and ideas, the
historia, a serious narrative typically drawn from the Bible or, as we'll see, classical history,
with the idea of conveying a vitally important moral message. And so for this historia to work
successfully, and Alberti argues this, and I think contemporary art theorists would all go along with
it, the artist needs a complete command of gesture, human anatomy, expression, rationalization of
space, understanding of optics and light, to basically create a believable image that moves
through the eye, moves the viewer's soul. And much of the 1400s, the so-called Quattrocento,
the 15th century, we are going to see the development of all of these tools, perspective,
especially linear perspective, development of understandings of human anatomy,
perhaps culminating in the idea of the artist-scientist in the work of Leonardo da Vinci.
Also, though, working further forward, we'll see that artists, and Michelangelo is a great example
of this, begin to see the limits of this approach to art, and a new chapter in the ideas of art
begins in earnest, probably about the time of 1500 or so, but that's a subject for another lecture.
