Magnus Carlsen held a grudge against Hikaru for 16 YEARS because of this game

Play & Learn Chess
142 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video analyzes a 2009 Norway Chess blitz game between Magnus Carlsen and Hikaru Nakamura. Despite achieving a positionally dominant advantage and being completely winning for the majority of the match, Carlsen suffered a shocking collapse in the endgame, allowing Nakamura to secure a victory—a result that Carlsen later admitted he held a grudge over.
Do you hold a grudge against me for anything?
Yes.
I think specifically the Norway Blitz tournament back in 2009.
That really hurt me.
Ah, yeah, the look of the pawn race.
Yeah.
One of them all.
But what actually happened?
Welcome to Norway Chess 2009, and it's Magnus Carlsen taking on Hikaru Nakamura,
who's currently covered up by a camera.
Look at the production value, by the way, back in 2009, and we're revisiting this game
because Magnus Carlsen did say that he held a grudge against Hikaru Nakamura for this game.
The players have blitzed out some theory of the Nimzo Indian defense,
and now Magnus, he drops his knight back to d2, trying to play f3 and e4,
setting up a nice pawn chain against the light-squared bishop on b7.
And now Hikaru strikes out with c5, trying to challenge Magnus in the center of the board,
brings his rook over to c8, hoping to take on d4 and make use of the semi-open c-file for his rook.
Bishop to d3 supports the center by Magnus, also getting ready to castle the kingside.
Now rook to e8, Hikaru not taking on d4 yet.
But Hikaru's doing exactly what every good chess player does, he's just maintaining the tension for now,
although he has to be a little bit careful because Magnus might not like keeping the tension in the middle,
and he might play d5, closing up the position.
Hikaru plays rook to c7, okay?
He's defending the knight, he's also making space for the queen maybe to go to c8 and double up on the c-file.
But now Magnus, he can just play the move pawn to d5, and this would not only shut out the light-squared bishop on b7,
but this would also cripple Hikaru's ability to open up the center of the board with cxd4.
Rook to d1 instead is played by Magnus, slightly improving the position,
but also maintaining tension in the middle of the board, giving Hikaru more decisions to make.
The more he has to think about this move, cxd4, every single turn, then he's gonna burn more and more time.
And Hikaru's doing exactly that, it's not clear.
Should he take on d4 right away?
That would be a pretty good move, I think, because it not only opens up the c-file, but also allows him to plant a knight on c5.
The downside is, though, that this d-pawn in the middle of the board might be weak,
and now after Hikaru has doubled up along the c-file with his queen and rook,
Magnus plays d5, shutting down the position, shutting down the pieces on the queen side.
And now it looks like Black is really struggling for space, and it's not clear how he should play.
He plays pawn to e5, shutting down the position,
maybe arguing that Magnus, with the bishop pair, wants to open up the position.
Rook to e1, played by Magnus, knight to h4, and Hikaru's trying to route his knight to the nice f4 square,
knight back to f1, this knight is going to e3 and maybe heading towards the f5 square,
which is a little bit weak, now that the bishop has been removed from the c8 h3 diagonal.
Knight to f8 by Hikaru, both knights are aiming towards the f4 square, queen to d8,
and now Hikaru is trying to bring his bishop back to c8 in order to defend the f5 square,
not wanting Magnus to plant his knight there.
Bishop back to f1, moving out of the way of the rooks, now b4, striking on the queenside.
Bishop d7 is played, centralizing the light squared bishop,
and now b takes c5, opening up the queenside, the rooks are going to start sliding over to there.
After b takes c5, I imagine, rook slides over to b1,
and White has a pretty pleasant position there, with a lot of space on the queenside,
and the first to occupy the file, but Hikaru, what he takes, rook takes c5,
now knight to f5 as a discovered attack against the rook, and the d6 pawn is unprotected!
There was no way to protect that pawn, Magnus is just picking up the d6 pawn,
and not only is that just a pawn, but that d6 pawn was previously anchoring the e5 pawn,
now the e5 pawn is quite weak, and that could be a target.
Magnus up a clean pawn, and has a very dominant position.
The rook slides over to f8, dodging the way of the knight,
and now c5 is played by Magnus, amazing move, opening up the light squared bishop,
but he's also opening up the c-file for his major pieces to play, and then penetrate the position later.
Now rook to c1, Magnus not taking with the bishop,
because he didn't want his queen and bishop to be pinned along the c-file,
so now this queen will move out of the way, and Magnus should be picking up a second pawn,
that pawn on c5, and White is just so positionally dominant, it's crazy!
To think that Magnus holds a grudge against Hikaru because of this game,
it looks like the goat is just going to win.
Knight to f4 is a nice move by Black, trying to really set up some tactical possibilities on the king side,
perhaps queen to g5 could be coming later,
and this knight and queen together are eyeing the g2 square.
Queen to a5, pinning the rook against the queen,
and now rook takes c5, looks like a very strong move by Magnus Carlsen,
adding pressure to the pinned rook on c7, and Hikaru taking his first long think of the game.
Both players so far have been blitzing out all of their moves, by the way,
while Hikaru thinks about his response, if you're enjoying the content so far,
and you want to support the channel, remember to like, comment, and subscribe,
that would mean a lot, thank you so much.
And now Hikaru still burning precious seconds on the clock,
and finally he plays the move, pawn to c4, sacrificing the pawn this way,
now Magnus has a very pleasant decision to make, rook takes c4, or bishop takes c4,
personally I think taking with the rook is a lot more natural,
trying to double up along the c-file, and also leaving the bishop on f1 to protect the king,
rook takes c4 is exactly what Magnus plays,
now queen g5 is played, what a move by Hikaru,
leaving his rook on c7 completely hanging to the queen or the rook,
but I think if Magnus takes that one, then knight h3 check, king h1, knight takes f2,
and there, black has perpetual check, the tactics in this game so far have been amazing,
and now Magnus thinking carefully about how he should respond to this threat of knight to h3 check,
perhaps sidestepping king to h1 is the best response, getting out of the checking zone of the knight,
and there, knight h3 is not even possible because g takes h3 is possible,
now rook takes c4, knight takes c4, the knight is moving its way out of the d5 pawn,
this d pawn is a pass pawn that Magnus is going to start launching up the board,
the knight is also putting some pressure on e5, and Hikaru's position is absolutely hopeless,
the pawn on a7 is hanging, after white captures that, then two pass pawns will be running up the board,
and Hikaru, desperate to create some counterplay on the king side, plays pawn to f5,
leaving the a7 pawn hanging, now bishop takes f5,
and perhaps a cheap trick that the American grandmaster could try to play is bishop to d3,
deflecting the f1 bishop away from protecting g2, and there, black would be checkmating white,
but I don't think Magnus is going to fall for that,
but Magnus is taking his time here because he's trying to think up of a defensive arrangement for his pieces,
both bishops are currently defending the king quite well, but if his bishops start to wander away,
perhaps the white king could become checkmated, now pawn to d6,
perhaps opening up the light square diagonal for his queen to give a check on d5 later,
bishop to g3 is a very nice move by Magnus because it's cutting off the black queen from seeing the g2 pawn,
and knight to e2 is played by Hikaru, trying to get rid of the defensive bishop on g3,
but also trying to trade off the superfluous knights,
the knights were stepping on each other's toes previously, both trying to occupy the f4 square,
and things are starting to get really tense in the playing hall,
perhaps it's even, are they playing in a shopping mall or something, it looks like Magnus,
he very bravely snaps off the pawn on e5, that pawn was previously anchoring down the knights on f4,
and now after knight to f4, the king looks a little bit naked,
first, Magnus can start by trading off his bishop for the knight,
but if I was playing white, I would be a little bit concerned about the king's safety with the rook on the semi-open f file,
as well as the queen and the knight pointing towards his g2 pawn,
now Hikaru, he takes with the queen instead, and in response, Magnus gives a check on d5,
that's kind of why he moved the pawn up to d6 earlier, opening up the light square diagonal,
and now d7, this pawn is ready to promote,
in response to the threat of d8 queen, Hikaru manages to slide his queen over to h4,
guarding the d8 square, but also, knight to g3 was a threat, trying to fork the king and the rook,
because the h pawn is pinned, now queen to d6, great move by Magnus,
stopping knight to g3, and now that all of black's pieces are completely paralyzed,
because of this d7 pawn, white can slowly start to improve the position,
rook f to d1 perhaps, in order to guard the d7 pawn,
and there, knight a5, knight b7, looks like a pretty simple win,
in order to dislodge the rook away from protecting d8,
now Magnus hesitating for a little bit here, because perhaps,
there are a lot of ways to win, and decision fatigue is slowly,
maybe starting to creep in for the young Norwegian grandmaster,
he's thinking for a while here, rook to d1, slowly improving the position,
I like that move, and now knight to a5, knight b7,
is probably the surest way, probably the easiest way to win,
knight e5 would be a mistake, trying to get the knight into f7 g6,
because that would cut off the queen from looking to the g3 square,
and you might be wondering, how is this the game that Magnus Carlsen
holds a grudge against Hikaru Nakamura for, because he is completely winning,
Magnus grabs the queen, so confident in his d7 pawn reaching the end of the board,
and Hikaru is so desperate to create some sort of counterplay,
to create some sort of tricks on the board, trying to last a few moves longer,
trying to trick Magnus into blundering this game away,
but Magnus' victory seems so sure, even without this evaluation bar screaming
that white is completely winning, everyone, and their grandma,
could probably win this game, knight to c3, attacks the rook on d1,
knight to e5 by Magnus, and after a few checks, it looks like Magnus
is slowly starting to invade the position, queen to g6, check,
king to g8, and then queen to e8, I think that's good enough,
queen to g6, king to g8, and then you can fork the rook and the king,
now here, black doesn't have to take the queen on e8, but you can take,
Magnus does it, and he goes knight to c6, now black's only choice really
is to sacrifice itself for the d pawn, and Magnus does that,
but Magnus has panicked a little bit, he's dropped the rook on d1,
and now, even though this knight and pawn endgame is winning,
it's a 3 on 2 on the king side, things have gone a lot more messy
than they should've, now both players, they're desperately bringing their kings
towards the center of the board, following basic endgame principles,
Hikaru's knight on c3, under attack by the white king,
hesitating for a little bit, now the knight goes back to d5,
the knight drops back to e2 for white, the black king is running
towards the queen side, and Hikaru desperately trying to create a fortress,
but Magnus, he is gonna make his way through, knight to b5, check,
there we go, king c6, and I think, again, something like king to c6
or king to c5, he can bring his king up to e5, and both knights
would be hanging in that position, but the resulting king and pawn
endgame should be winning by white, because of this king side majority,
king takes e6, I think best move, now f4, f4 is winning,
because you go g4, and then f5, and the f1 becomes a queen,
but Magnus, he's making the f1 into a passer this way,
and the white king is on a bad square, look at Magnus reacting,
because now Hikaru, he promotes a queen with check, and to rub
even more salt into the wound, this position would actually be a draw,
but because of Magnus's two extra pawns on g2 and h2,
this position is completely winning for black, and now the white king
has to run this way in order to protect the pawn, and Magnus
desperately trying to get rid of his h and g pawns, and run his king
into the corner there, that would be a draw, and look at Hikaru
professional as ever, just making sure that after he takes on g4,
the black queen is cutting off the white king from jumping into
the corner of the board, now king to e7, queen up to g7,
and this was the game that made Magnus Carlsen hold a grudge
against Hikaru, if you enjoyed this game and you want to see more,
remember to like, comment, and subscribe, I'll see you guys in the next one, bye.
