Legal Expert on White House Warning to Democrats over Possible Trump Investigations
Nov 14, 2026
The White House is warning Democrats that threats to investigate the Trump administration could constitute an abuse of power as the new Congress prepares to take office.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA legal conflict is emerging between the White House and the House Oversight Committee over potential investigations into administration officials. White House counsel Will Scharf argues that such probes must have a legitimate legislative purpose to avoid being an abuse of power, while legal analysts discuss the constitutional boundaries and protections governing these disputes.
A legal showdown is brewing between
the White House and the incoming Congress.
White House counsel Will Scharf warned Democrats
on the House Oversight Committee this week saying
their threats to potentially investigate
administration officials, quote, may cross
the line into blatant criminality.
He said Congress is required to identify a legitimate
legislative purpose for any investigative act.
Scharf warned failure to do so represents a clear
abuse of power and an affront to both
our constitutional system and the rule of law.
CBS News legal analyst Jessica Levinson joins us now to discuss.
So, Jessica, what limits does the Constitution impose
on congressional investigations and subpoenas
Yes, because of course we're talking about two co-equal branches.
And the answer really
is in the question that you asked,
which is that the House does need to have a legitimate
legislative purpose. It can't go on a fishing expedition.
It can't say, I want to investigate
you because I don't like you or I don't like your policies
But for everybody who's watching,
they're hearing those words legitimate legislative
And understanding that that is very broad
It's Congress's role really to get information
to what problems are out there and then either
to propose new legislation or amend legislation.
And so it sounds like
the house is really confined just legitimate legislative purpose.
But in fact, there's a lot that very properly falls within that bucket.
US lawmakers are protected by the Constitution's speech or debate clause
So explain how that could apply.
So the speech and debate clause really provides for immunity
when we're talking about members
of the House or the Senate
who are doing something like debating a bill, they're taking a vote,
they are conducting hearings, etc.
I think there's a very, very good argument
that this particular constitutional provision
does not apply to things like press conferences.
So to the extent that there's any question of.
Whether people like members of the House can say
we are going to investigate the Trump
administration, those statements
if they're made in a press conference, are not protected
under the speech and debate clause.
I think they are protected under the First Amendment,
but not the speech and debate clause.
All right, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's
name was mentioned in the letter with the White
House quoting a lawmaker saying she
wanted to see him squirm.
We know articles of impeachment were struck down this week.
Is that the end of the story?
It's likely not the end of the story because we know that impeachment,
impeachment power is in the
Constitution, but it really is a political decision as to whether
or not you want to
institute impeachment proceedings.
And so this question of high crimes and misdemeanors,
I mean, the word crimes sounds legal, but in fact
it's a political decision as to whether
or not you think in this case,
a member of the cabinet or someone else has.
Engage in behavior that rises to that level
So the answer is it's not the end of the story
if members of the House
and the Senate decide it's not the end of the story.
All right, Jessica, thank you

