House Minority Leader Michael W. Chippendale (R District 40 - Coventry, Foster, Glocester), speaks in opposition to 2026 H 8058, a bill relating to criminal offenses and computer crime. Referencing a letter from the Public Defender's office, he argues that the legislation sets an unconstitutionally low threshold for cyberstalking, potentially criminalizing the act of sending multiple "annoying" emails to a legislator. While acknowledging he has received and properly reported genuine threats to law enforcement agencies like the FBI and Rhode Island State Police, Leader Chippendale stresses the danger of conflating legitimate threats with merely annoying communications. He concludes by calling the proposed statute "foolishness" and expresses hope that the Senate will reject the measure.
House Bill No. 8058 BY Caldwell, McEntee, Casimiro, Speakman, Donovan, Kislak, Spears, Dawson ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO CRIMINAL OFFENSES -- COMPUTER CRIME (Makes it unnecessary to prove that a person's transmission of electronic communications be for the sole purpose of harassment before being found guilty of cyberstalking or cyberharassment.) {LC5714/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText26/HouseText26/H8058.pdf
Those of us here in this building are very used to dealing with not just our own constituents,
but we deal with people from all over, sometimes the world, certainly all over Rhode Island and
all over the U.S. And when this bill was brought to my attention, I read a letter submitted by the
public defender's office and it made a point that was like an aha light bulb over my dumb head
moment. And I merely only need to feel annoyed at an email or several emails, however many we get
them all the time. And now this statute applies criminally to someone for cyber stalking. I mean,
Jason, I'll tell you, I am no constitutional mastermind or attorney, but I can't see how
passing a law that literally stifles the first amendment could possibly be acceptable.
If even if it's constitutional, how it could be acceptable to our consciences. I have, we all have,
I'm not unique, those constituents who know where we stand on an issue and they will continue to
engage us. And I can be annoyed by that, but I every two years put my name on a piece of paper
and asked to come here. So if I get annoyed by that, then maybe I need to reconsider what the
heck it is I'm doing. I'll also say this. I have gotten some really concerning emails, phone
messages, and communications before. And in every single case I've brought them either to the
Providence office of the FBI or to the Rhode Island state police, and they were dealt with.
Even if I, it was only my perception, they were dealt with and disposed of properly by
law enforcement that exists. But for us to say, you know, my, my pettish uses apples and oranges
or whatever. And if somebody sends me too many emails that annoy me, I could possibly feel like
I'm sorry. I just, it doesn't make any sense. I'm sure someone will try to make it make sense,
but I am hoping that the Senate has a good frame of mind to not even entertain this foolishness.
Thank you, Speaker.