" Kiera Cass' most DISAPPOINTING BOOK (The Betrothed series from the author of the SELECTION)"

The Book Club
24 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker provides a critical review of the *The Betrothed* duology, following Hollis Bright's journey from a noblewoman in Coroa to the leader of a unified kingdom. While the plot involves royal romance, political coups, and the overthrow of tyrants, the speaker heavily criticizes the series for poor character development, illogical plot twists, and a superficial allegory for racism.
Dude, that's your cousin's widow.
I thought they were gay for each other.
They're sisters.
Use your goddamn brain.
Maybe she is stupid.
Hey, Amelia.
I feel like I can't start this video without addressing the elephant in the room.
I started the month with a medical event.
It wasn't like a crisis.
Well, it was like lightly a crisis.
It wasn't a crisis.
I'm fine.
Lightly concussed.
Anyway, if you know anything about me, you know that the Selection series by Keira Cass
is like one of my all-time favorite, all-time greatest book series ever in the world.
Is it the most well-written piece of literature?
No.
I love it so much.
Like, if you were like, Desert Island, what's the one series you would bring, it would probably
be The Selection.
I have reread it probably once a year, and I've enjoyed it every time.
So imagine my shock and delight when I walk into The Thrift a couple months ago and I
see my icon diva Keira Cass on the shelf.
I would recognize this cover design anywhere, and I bought these immediately.
This is the Betrothed duology by Keira Cass.
They were published in 2020 and 2021, respectively.
When I was reading these books, I was super, super concussed.
I just need to take one moment right now and recognize my biases.
I tried really, really, really hard not to be comparing these books to The Selection,
but it's right on the frickin' front cover!
I'm the number one best-selling author of The Selection!
Alrighty, let's get crackin'.
Our main character, her name is Hollis Bright, and she is a noble lady in this kingdom called
Karoa.
In my heart, I think maybe, originally, the kingdom was called Karona, and then, um, the
events of 2020 happened.
They decided to change the name of the kingdom.
That is just a fan theory.
I have no backing for that, but that just feels like, cause Karoa doesn't roll off the
tongue, I would say.
This is the first paragraph.
It was the time of year when the sunrise still had frost on it, but winter was fading and
the flowers were starting to bloom, and the promise of a new season filled me with anticipation.
I legitimately started tearing up when I read this, because I was so excited to read this
book.
Anyway, Hollis is getting ready with her best friend Delia Grace.
They have been invited to go on this boat trip down the Colvard River with the literal
actual king.
His name is King Jameson.
He's like, young and hot and sexy.
He's also totally a player.
He's like, running through women like it's his frickin' job.
And his newest infatuation is Hollis.
And Hollis is like, probably he'll only be interested in me for like, a little bit.
She doesn't think they're gonna get married, but everyone else is like, oh my god, she's
the one.
They go to the boat trip down this river.
The king, Jameson, and Hollis are on one boat, and then everyone else is on another boat.
And it's a big deal that Hollis is on this one boat, because the boat that King Jameson
is on has the flag of Coroa.
It's a big statement that he's like, bringing her out under the flag.
They're flirting.
It's super sweet.
And then Hollis starts a food fight.
Not very classy.
Not very ladylike.
And then, Hollis falls into the river.
Oh my god, girl.
Get it together.
Jameson saves her, but she loses her shoes in the river.
Back to shore then, he ordered, still smiling.
He held me close, looking deep into my eyes.
I sense that in this moment, shoes gone, hair a mess, soaking wet.
He found me irresistible.
And the next day, King Jameson sends Hollis flowers.
The note says, in the event you have caught a cold and were unable to venture out into
nature today, I thought that nature ought to come to its queen.
The main drama right now is that Hollis really likes Jameson.
But she doesn't know if he actually wants to marry her, or if he's just sort of like,
you know, partying around with her for fun.
The vibe of every interaction we've seen so far is really giving he wants to marry you.
Like, I have not seen any textual evidence for him not being actually in love with her,
other than them saying like, oh, he sort of has flings every so often, you know?
Every other character has been like, oh, well, the way he interacts with you is really different
than how he's interacted with any of his other girls.
So I'm like, why aren't we believing this man?
Let's talk about Delia Grace real quick.
So Delia Grace is Hollis' best friend.
She is the subject of a lot of gossip in the kingdom because her parents got a divorce in Coroa.
That's like, way frowned upon.
The culture of this kingdom is that marriage is the most important thing.
It's like, once you're married, you're married.
And then when you do get a divorce, like, basically you're shunned forever.
I sighed. Coroa was a land of laws, many of them centered around family and marriage.
Being unfaithful to your spouse meant you were, at best, an outcast.
At worst, there would be a trip to the tower.
Divorce was something so rare, I'd never actually seen it happen with my own eyes.
But Delia Grace had.
Delia Grace, her full name is Delia Grace and she's referred to as Delia Grace the entire book.
I'm gonna start calling her Delia because Delia Grace is a frickin' mouthful.
She's a subject of a lot of judgment and gossip in the courts.
And Hollis' family really don't like that Hollis is such good friends with Delia
because they think that Delia is below their station.
But, crucially, Delia Grace was there when Jameson and Hollis had their meet-cute.
They were, like, at a ball together, I guess.
And Delia Grace and Hollis were dancing.
They both kind of fell and Hollis fell right into King Jameson and he was like,
Ahaha! That's so cute and charming!
And then that's, like, what started their sort of love story.
Crowning Day is coming up.
Crowning Day is this holiday where I think the king, like, renews his vows to the country.
Also, I'm pretty sure Jameson is going to propose to Hollis on Crowning Day.
It's either he's proposing to her on Crowning Day or they're getting married on Crowning Day.
Basically, they're not officially betrothed yet.
On Crowning Day, their relationship will become official.
All the lords and the people of the court are starting to see how important Hollis is to the king
and that she's probably about to become the queen.
And so they start coming to her to, like, gain some political leverage.
There's this one guy, Lord Cima.
Basically, he comes to Hollis' door and is like,
Hey, I have a question for you.
And she's like, Oh, what's the question?
And he's like, I'd like a royal survey of all the roads in Coroa.
I've tried to mention this to his majesty twice this year and he's brushed it off.
I was wondering if you could encourage him to make it a priority.
And Hollis is like, Yeah, I can do that.
However, you need to then start being really supportive of me in the court
because I think there's some people who don't like her.
I don't know.
If this project moves forward, I begin slowly.
I expect you to speak kindly of me to anyone you pass who mentions my name.
And if you discuss this interaction with other lords,
will you please tell them that I received you graciously?
Basically, Lord Cima's whole thing is that he is the representative of this place called Upchurch County.
And it's a really poor county in the kingdom and the roads in the county.
It's basically impossible to travel on those roads because they're so bad.
And he's asking Hollis if she can please do some work in getting the roads fixed.
I started watching The L Word this past week.
I've already finished season one.
I'm halfway through season two.
Anyway, the reason I thought of that is because in the first season,
obviously, Bette and Tina are trying to get pregnant.
And so I just rewatched the first episode where they're like trying to find a sperm donor.
Anyway, shut up, Ainsley.
Oh, my God.
The next day, Hollis goes to King Jameson
and she uses her like feminine wiles to sort of manipulate him into wanting to fix the roads.
She's like, I want to go traveling.
And he's like, if you could go anywhere in the kingdom, where would you go?
And she's like, well, I want to go here, but the roads are too bad.
The roads are so bad.
And he's like, well, then let's fix the roads.
Oh, my God.
I don't understand in general when the male love interest has no sort of ability
to see outside of himself unless a person he's attracted to is like,
you should care about poor people.
Why don't you just want all the infrastructure in your kingdom to be effective?
You know, like, why do you need some gorgeous woman to be like,
God, the roads are so bad.
You should fix them.
Like, just fix the ******* roads.
Hollis is having a really fun time pretending to be the queen and like having all this power.
I had thought nothing could be as much fun as winning over the heart of the king.
But I was wrong.
It was much more thrilling to win over the heart of countless people at once.
Oh, also somewhere in here, Hollis gets called down to sit in on a court proceeding.
This court proceeding is for a family who is coming and seeking refuge from their kingdom.
Basically, this is really important, the plot.
So lock in, pay attention.
King Jameson invites Hollis down to witness this court proceeding,
and he lets her decide whether or not to let this family stay in the kingdom.
This is how the family is described.
An older gentleman and his wife entered the room.
Her hand gracefully perched upon his.
Behind them followed their four children, three boys and a girl.
The children all had pale skin and hair in varying shades of yellow.
While their parents were starting to gray, the youngest boy was on edge,
clutching his sister's hand tightly.
While she was canvassing the room in a much different way,
her eyes suggested she was looking for something.
How old are you picturing these children to be?
I know it said the parents were older, but I was picturing like maximum 10 years old.
Like, I think the three kids were probably between the ages of like 6 and 12.
However, that's not true, because this is the Estoff family.
The kids are in their 20s, which you will understand my confusion imminently.
But just imagine the rest of this plot, but I'm picturing a child.
So, this is the Estoff family, and they are from a kingdom that's like neighboring Karoah called Isol.
They're sort of, I guess, political refugees of their home kingdom.
Hollis locks eyes with one of the sons.
He was still on his knees, hands clutching the velvet wrap.
His eyes locked with mine.
For a moment, the world stilled.
I found myself completely lost in his gaze, unable to look away.
His eyes were a shocking blue, a color rare in Karoah and completely unique to anything I'd ever seen before.
It wasn't the shade of sky or water.
I didn't have a word for it, and the blue pulled me in, refusing to let me go.
At this point, I'm still picturing this kid to be 8 years old.
Hollis decides, yes, she'll let them stay in Karoah.
Yay!
Hope nothing bad happens because of that.
Jameson takes Hollis into the queen's jewel room, and she's like, I'm so in!
This whole time, she's been sort of like, I don't know if he's gonna propose to me.
I don't know if we're gonna get married.
He takes her to see the queen's literal jewels, and she's like, I'm locked in.
I'm in.
I'm in it for the long haul.
He's gonna marry me.
And while they're in the jewel room, he's like, I wanna marry you.
I'm going to propose to you.
I'm going to propose to you on crowning day, so like, heads up.
However, King Quentin, who's the mean, evil king of Isolt, he's coming to visit Karoah.
Jameson wants Hollis to, for all intents and purposes, behave as though she is already the queen.
I'm sort of like, confused as to where the logic for that is.
It sort of seems like the kings are in a bit of a pissing contest.
Like, King Jameson is like, I want the guy to see that I also have a beautiful wife,
because he also has a beautiful wife.
Also, King Quentin is really old, and he has a very young wife, like, Hollis' age.
And King Quentin is like, Hollis' granddad's age.
Well, I hope they're happy.
They're not.
They're really not.
King Quentin's young hot wife is named Valentina, and the reason why he has this young hot wife
is because his former wife, she bore one child.
God, he had a stupid name.
It started with an H.
Henderson?
Basically, this son is, like, super sickly, and sort of the fear that King Quentin has
is that his son, Hendrix, there's no X, is not gonna be able to, like, produce an heir.
And so, if he dies without having a son, then the royal family ends.
King Jameson is trying to have, like, a backup heir.
He killed off his other wife and married a new young wife, Valentina.
Very King Henry VIII of him.
He said, you can't give me an heir.
I'm gonna kill you.
I'm gonna murder you dead so that I can get a beautiful hot wife who can have babies,
who's so young and fertile.
I actually hated that I just said that.
Basically, Hollis has to learn how to entertain the queen of Iseult.
Hollis doesn't know anything about anything, though.
She's stupid as ****.
Every single time they mention, like, she's gonna have to learn something,
everyone's like, well, she was such a bad student.
She's so dumb.
She's not gonna learn.
Oh my god.
Sorry to go back.
They're in the queen's jewel room.
Hollis is like, I can't do this.
Jameson goes, all I ask is that you be everything you already are.
That, my sweet Hollis, is what I love you for.
And then Hollis starts crashing out.
She's like, oh my god, what I love you for?
What I love you for?
This reminds me of a fun little anecdote I have.
A person that I was in a relationship with.
This is a bit of a tangent, but this relationship started as very, like, will they, won't they.
So there was, like, a couple months of that.
We didn't move very quickly.
We had been seeing each other.
I don't think we'd been, like, technically dating for that long, but we'd been seeing each other for a while.
She said something like that, like, oh, this is what I love you for.
I don't remember exactly what she said, because this wasn't a big deal to me.
She was like, oh, that's something I love about you.
And she sort of had a big crash out about that, because she was like, oh my god, I said I love you way too soon.
But my dumb ass, either I don't- I think I might just not listen a lot.
I, like, totally didn't register that.
I was like, yeah, it's a normal comment to make.
And I didn't take it as like a, oh, I'm saying I love you for the first time.
Anyway, King Jameson.
Basically, he, like, proposes to her, but in secret.
He's like, I am gonna propose to you.
I do want to get married, but we just can't make it official just yet.
There's another woman that is maybe a more, like, politically advantageous match for King Jameson.
And so he has to do some, like, convincing.
It doesn't matter.
Basically, they're gonna get married, but they can't tell anybody yet.
When Hollis is walking back to her room, she, in the hallway, runs into
The ones that she allowed to stay in the kingdom.
This kid's name is Silas.
He's, like, a metalsmith.
He was a nobleman, but also, like, learned a craft for fun.
He makes, like, swords, but he also makes, like, jewelry.
Unfortunately, Hollis thinks that Silas is hot and sexy.
I need you to walk with me through this, because imagine my shock and horror.
I'm picturing this as an actual child.
And she goes, oh my god, he's hot and sexy.
The eight-year-old?
The child?
He's not a child.
He's her age.
It was not very clearly communicated, and so I had a moment of, like, no!
No, don't do it!
Okay, so Hollis gets back to her room.
She is essentially all but officially the queen.
It's, like, official except for on paper.
She's, like, I'm so in.
So Hollis is starting to pick her ladies-in-waiting.
She obviously picks Delia Grace as the, like, head ladies' maid.
And then Hollis picks Nora as her other ladies' maid.
Now, here's some drama.
Nora engaged heavily in some bullying behavior of Delia Grace.
When Hollis, like, brings Nora to Delia Grace and be like,
hey ladies' maids, you're gonna be my ladies' maids,
Delia Grace freaks the **** out.
And she sort of, like, never really recovers from it.
She kind of stays a little bit mean to Hollis for the rest of the series.
I don't care at all.
Not to compare this to the selection, but I'm going to, okay?
So just, like, stay with me here.
These people don't feel real.
I don't care about any of these characters' emotional experiences,
because I don't really feel like it's justified properly.
I'm going to talk about the Celeste redemption arc.
So Celeste, if you've never read the selection,
she was, like, a pretty major antagonist within the actual process of the selection.
Towards the end of the third book, she gets a bit of a redemption
where, like, America and Celeste reconcile and sort of put aside their differences.
And the reason I cared about that was because each individual character,
their motivations were very, very clear.
Ugh, the selection is so good.
Mostly what I felt while I was reading this book
is that I wish that it was the selection.
Okay, just before King Quentin arrives from Isolt,
Jameson moves Hollis into the Queen's room.
While this is happening, Hollis suggests to Jameson
that he hires the Estoff brothers to make friendship rings for him and King Quentin.
As the Estoffs are artisans,
mightn't it be nice to have something made to mark the occasion?
Twin items of some kind for you and King Quentin.
Something to mark you as peers,
especially if he's intimidated by your youth and your strength.
Which very well may be the cause for him parading his wife.
Perhaps it would pacify him to offer up a gesture of peace.
Also, Scarlet, who is the sister of the Estoff family,
her task is that she has to teach Hollis about all the Isoltan manners and traditions
so that she doesn't accidentally offend Queen Valentina.
But, like I said, Hollis is stupid and she can't learn anything.
And they spend the entire time just kind of like,
well, basically, this is a way in which, like, we as the audience
are being given a lot of exposition for, like, who King Quentin is
and why he's so evil.
Basically, he, like, kills people.
Big whoop.
The purpose of the scene was so that Hollis could learn about the customs
of the kingdom of the visiting people.
I feel like there was a way to sort of, like, better handle both.
Like, such as, for example, in The Selection, there is a challenge.
This book is so- read The Selection, please.
It's so good.
There's a challenge where, basically, there are, like,
royalty from a bunch of different kingdoms coming to visit
and each girl is assigned to host these kingdoms.
You get both the, like,
they're learning about customs of it.
Also, at the actual party, that's when you get the exposition of, like,
what are these actual political relationships.
There is room for both.
And I know that Caracass can do it because she's done it before,
but this is not it.
Anyway, but I might as well communicate to you
the sort of information that we've just learned.
Like all countries, we have had good kings and bad ones,
but there's something dark about King Quentin.
He's always been hungry for power, wielding it carelessly as a child,
but fear has made him worse with age, and now he's old and paranoid.
So, King Quentin and Queen Valentina show up.
Immediately, King Quentin has very sinister vibes.
He is a scary guy.
The kings are sitting next to each other,
and then Hollis and Valentina are sitting next to each other.
One of the pieces of etiquette that we do get
is that the person with the higher status has to start the conversation.
So, Hollis, because she's literally a nobody,
she's not the queen, she's not a princess,
she's not allowed to engage Valentina in conversation
unless Valentina starts it.
And then immediately, Hollis biffs it.
She- oh, that was my shoulder.
Valentina sits down and Hollis is like,
You learned one thing.
You learned one piece of etiquette.
You couldn't even do that, right?
Oh my god.
Maybe she is stupid.
Hollis is having a bad time at this, like, banquet,
so she goes back to her queen's room and has, like, a separate party
for just her and her friends.
She invites the East Offs.
The East Offs invite their cousins, the Northcots.
So creative.
And this is where we meet-
How do you pronounce his name?
Eitan?
Pronouncenames.com.
Eitan.
I'm going with it.
Eaten.
Eaten!
That can't be right.
I'm going Eitan.
Hollis meets the Northcots.
One of the main Northcots is Eitan, and he is, like, a big soldier,
and he immediately, immediately hates Hollis.
Well, she sort of insults his culture.
They're making conversation small talk, and she's like,
ISIL doesn't have any art.
It's all imported from Coroa.
And he's like, we have actually a rich, beautiful culture
that you just disrespected right now.
So, like, I get it.
I understand why he doesn't like her.
At the party, Silas and Eitan are talking with Hollis,
and Eitan is like,
How are you gonna be a queen if you don't even know what's happening at your own border?
If you don't know what's happening along your own border,
what's happening to your own people,
I can only conclude that you, my lady, are the exact same.
A decoration for your king.
Hollis then begins to spiral.
She's like, oh my god.
Maybe he doesn't truly love me.
Maybe he doesn't think I'm politically important.
Maybe Jameson doesn't actually love me.
Maybe he's just marrying me so that I can sit there and look pretty.
Which, nothing up until this point,
other than this conversation with a random guy,
would have given anyone that impression.
I would take it with a grain of salt.
All of a sudden, like, four pages later,
Silas and Hollis are in love.
What was it about Silas Eastoff that turned the air in the room into something sweeter?
He made everything feel easy.
Words came out clearer.
Thoughts became less foggy.
I didn't realize people could do that, make everything sharper.
I cannot stress enough how little this relationship makes to my brain.
They don't know each other.
They don't have any, like,
there really feels like no chemistry until all of a sudden we're told,
like, oh, they actually really like each other.
I don't feel it.
I don't see it.
I don't care about it.
What happens later is that Hollis does this, like, total 180,
where she's like, I actually never liked King Jameson.
He was always shitty to me.
Which is just, I feel not backed up by the text.
All right, it's competition day.
Basically, competition day is a day where they all joust.
Each soldier is wearing the color of their country,
so Coroa is red and Iselton is blue.
Silas jousts, but he doesn't wear red or blue.
During competition day,
girls are supposed to, like, give tokens of their appreciation
to the soldier that they're rooting for.
Hollis, like, sneaky, like, drops her handkerchief next to Silas,
and he picks it up.
King Jameson and King Quentin are sitting next to each other,
and they're like...
And so Jameson and Hollis kind of get into this debate
as to whether or not Silas wearing no colors
was, like, a nice show of solidarity and, like, peace,
or whether or not it was, like, sort of treasonous.
Jameson gets frustrated at Hollis
and tells her basically to, like, stop arguing about this
and worry about her own business.
He goes,
All I need you to do is to show Coroa how good a queen you can be.
Upstage that girl of Quentin's.
I swallowed.
Surely considering how to better our relationship
with the largest country on the continent
is part of being a good queen.
I'll do that, Hollis.
He shook his head.
Hollis is crashing out.
She's like,
Oh my god, maybe he really is just marrying me
so that I can be, like, arm candy.
Which, again, I don't think that this is giving, like,
He hates you.
You don't know anything.
This whole book, they're like,
She's kind of stupid.
She can't learn very well.
And then she's, like, offended that he's not, like,
putting a bunch of weight into her international relation choices.
Like, I just don't understand why it's such a big deal.
Anyway, Hollis sneaky kisses Silas.
It's a whole thing.
Silas cupped my cheeks, holding me with such tenderness
that I felt everything inside my body melting.
I could feel the calluses on his fingers
as they traced the edges of my face,
and I couldn't help but compare the feeling
to that of Jameson's perfectly smooth hands.
There was something about the awareness of Silas's hard work,
the labor that earned him those calluses,
that made me treasure his touch.
So they kiss, and then she, like, jerks away
because she's like, Oh my god, what have I done?
She kind of, like, runs away without acknowledging the kiss.
That night, Valentina and Hollis have game night,
just the two of them.
They have girl night, girl game night.
Valentina basically tells Hollis that Quentin is super abusive,
which, shocker, who saw that one coming?
Not me.
Also, Valentina tells Hollis that her whole purpose
as a person in the world is to have an heir for King Quentin,
but she keeps having miscarriages.
King Quentin is getting really mad at her
because she can't have a baby.
But, Valentina is pregnant, currently, right now as we speak.
Valentina also tells Hollis about these people
called the Dark Knights.
Basically, they are sort of like evil henchmen
of King Quentin who do his bidding.
They killed Valentina's parents to force her to become queen.
Nobody knows officially if they are, like,
officially a member of King Quentin's party,
so he still has some, like, plausible deniability.
After all this, Valentina is like,
Please don't tell anyone about this, especially the pregnancy.
But they're, like, friends.
They're becoming really good friends.
Valentina leaves, Hollis has a sneaky meeting with Silas,
and immediately, she tells all of Valentina's hot gossip.
After, Valentina said, Please keep this quiet.
She's a bad friend.
During this meeting, Hollis keeps being like,
We can't, we can't be doing this, Silas.
And Silas goes, I thought you said the king hadn't proposed.
I sighed.
No, he hasn't.
He can't just yet.
But then what promise would you be breaking?
Um, um, um, uh, I actually don't-
Hello?
They are basically engaged.
They're not, like, officially on paper engaged,
but, like, you are still cheating on him.
Pissing me off.
Uh, maybe it's that night.
Maybe it's the next night.
Anyway, it's, like, late, late, late in one night,
and Jameson calls for Hollis,
and she gets all dressed.
She comes down to this big meeting room.
Jameson is there,
and, like, a bunch of members of the court are there,
and King Quentin and Valentina are also there,
and they sign the baby agreement.
So let us both be in agreement,
Jameson stated firmly, looking directly at King Quentin.
Our eldest daughter will go to the eldest son of Prince Hadrian,
but only if we also produce a son to have a direct male heir.
But because girls are not passed over in succession in Coroa,
if we only have girls,
our second oldest daughter shall be his bride instead.
Is that acceptable?
Obviously, this is super, super not chill with Hollis.
So she flips out.
She flips out on Jameson.
Hollis goes,
Either way, next time you plan to sign away our children to another kingdom,
could I have a warning before I walk into the room?
He scoffed.
Oh, Hollis.
They aren't our children.
They're mine.
What?
I forced myself to keep a smile on my face.
Any children we make are arrows in my quiver,
and I will aim them wherever I must for the sake of Coroa.
I just think that this is a really, sort of, jarring switch up.
That, again, like, the writing could have supported better.
Like, this came out of nowhere.
Not in a, like, whoa, twist kind of way.
In a, like, this makes no sense for his character kind of way, you know?
So Hollis goes back and tries to, like, confide in and reason with Delia Grace.
Delia also does, like, a crazy switcheroo.
She goes,
I said it should have been me.
If you'd been paying attention to anyone but yourself,
then you'd have seen that I was watching Jameson very carefully.
I was trying to make you fall on your backside so I could rush over to your aid.
I saw the king coming behind you and was intending to arrange a memorable meeting,
one where he might be able to tell me apart from the scores of girls fawning over him.
I thought I could make an impression.
He'd at least see me, but I let go at the wrong time, fell myself, and he caught you.
She said this with a bitterness that stung like arrows.
I made a mistake and erased myself from his thoughts completely.
Again, like, lightly out of left field and in a way that, like,
I've not really been given a reason to care about Delia Grace
and to understand why she feels entitled to this
or why she's stayed friends with her.
It just all doesn't work for me.
It is crowning day and Jameson is proposing after the crowning day ceremony.
So Jameson sends a bunch of crowns to Hollis to pick from for crowning day,
but she ends up wearing this beautiful flower crown that she made herself.
Silas pulls up and he is like,
I'm going to the countryside with my family.
We're gonna live there and I want you to come with me.
He says,
Don't be silly.
You're Hollis Bright.
You dance and sing, but you ask questions too.
You battle with ladies on boats, but you provide for those around you.
You love to laugh, but you're learning about sorrow.
You are loved by a king, but can see him as a mortal.
You met a foreigner and treated him like a friend.
In a short time, that's what I've seen.
To know everything about you would take years of study,
but you're the only person in the world I truly want to know.
Like, not to be that guy, but those are just observations.
I don't think that they're in love and I don't think they should get married.
And then all of a sudden she realizes she doesn't want to be queen
and she actually does want to be with Silas.
I stared deep into the eyes of Silas Estoff and I knew I had to go with him.
Yes, love was a part of it.
A huge sweeping part that I've been terrified to own up to.
She's like, I don't actually want to be queen.
I'm in love with Silas.
Okay.
She tells Jameson that she can't marry him and then she goes and runs away with Silas.
And Silas and Hollis are going to be married as soon as they get to wherever they're going.
She writes a letter to Valentina in which it says,
It's quite possible that I've loved Silas Estoff since the moment I laid eyes upon him.
That just can't possibly be true.
Oh, maybe it is.
Who am I to judge?
Anyway, in this letter, she gives Valentina her entire new mailing address,
which is a crazy choice for a woman who's married to an abusive, murderous king.
So Hollis and the Estoffs go to Hollis's family manor
to try to like plead her case to her parents to approve of her marriage to Silas.
Because basically in Coroa,
getting married without parental consent is like one of the worst things you could ever do, I guess.
But her parents are super, super pissed because they were about to become royalty.
And so they were like,
We will not under any circumstances approve of your marriage to Silas.
She's planning on doing it anyway, even if her parents don't consent.
There's some more letters.
Delia writes to Hollis to be like,
I'm in with the king, yes!
And also there's like some political stuff happening.
Oh, um, a wing of the castle set fire.
Valentina also writes to tell Hollis that she lost the baby.
She does it in like code because King Quentin reads her letters.
And then again, Hollis immediately goes and tells the Estoffs,
which is, she's a bad friend.
I would be so livid.
Hollis invites Valentina to her wedding to Silas.
She gives her the exact date and time and everything.
It's wedding day.
Hollis's parents do end up going to the wedding.
Silas and Hollis get married.
During the party, Lady Estoff, so Silas's mom,
pulls Hollis aside and gives her this like fancy family heirloom ring.
While this is happening, they're in the garden.
And then there is a mass casualty event.
Everyone is murdered.
And then the building is set on fire.
And the only person who survives is Scarlet and Lady Estoff and Hollis
because they were in the garden.
Hollis thinks probably it's the Dark Knights that did this
because she gave all of her ******* information to Valentina.
Use your brain, girl.
Use your goddamn brain.
The three survivors go to Hollis's house,
which she is now the lady of because her entire family died.
Lady Estoff tells Hollis their big family lore,
which is basically that they are descendant of the royal bloodline.
Because of course they are.
King Quentin is the direct descendant of Jeddrek the Great.
The crown was passed to Jeddrek's firstborn son.
And Quentin is of that line.
So the crown has been his.
But Jeddrek the Great had three sons and four daughters.
The Estoff family is one of the branches of that family tree that still lives.
The direct descendants of the fifth born child Oberon.
Besides Quentin and Hadrian and obviously us,
there are only one other family that belongs to the Pardus line.
The Northcots.
Do you remember them?
So basically the Estoffs and the Northcots were like
lightly planning on overthrowing King Quentin
because they like technically have claim to the throne
if King Quentin's son died.
So Scarlet and Lady Estoff are gonna go back to Iseult
to be with the Northcots to sort of like keep scheming and planning.
Right before they leave, King Jameson sends Hollis a **** ton of money.
I guess in Coroa you get money for being a widow.
In the letter with the money also he's like,
come back to the castle, I'll welcome you back with open arms.
It's fine.
This spooks Hollis.
She decides to go with the Estoffs to Iseult.
And that is the end of The Betrothed.
How we feeling?
I feel crazy. I feel concussed.
I started the first book pre-concussion
and this book took me for ******* ever to finish.
And then I started this book in the hospital.
So I don't totally remember it as well.
Okay, book two, The Betrayed.
I personally found this book a lot more compelling than the first book.
I think this fell into the trap that a lot of the books
I've been reading recently have been falling into
which is the first book is just so much exposition
and it feels like way overwritten
to the point where I'm like just condense it to 100 pages
and then make this book a 400 page book, you know?
So Scarlet and Lady Estoff who is Silas's mom
and from here on out, Hollis calls her mother.
So anytime I refer to mother, it's Lady Estoff.
Scarlet, Lady Estoff, and Hollis are all on their way to Iseult
and they're accompanied by Eitan Northcott, the cousin of whatever.
He does not like or trust Hollis one little eeny weeny tiny little bit.
When they make it to the border, the guy at the border is like,
I don't keep up much with things going on in Coroa
but it's impossible not to hear how your king has all but gone mad.
Apparently some girl rejected him and he's been erratic ever since.
Rumors are he's taken an axe to one of his best boats
right there on the river where anyone could see.
We've heard that he's got someone new but isn't faithful to her
in any sense of the word.
Heard he set his castle on fire a few weeks ago too.
Hollis is like, no there's no way this is true.
They make it through the border and they end up at the Northcott's house
and they are plotting and planning and scheming.
They want to overthrow Quentin and put Eitan on the throne
but Iseult is a land of laws and so their plan is
they need a way to prove concretely that King Quentin is behind
all of the like dark knight murdering
because if they overthrow him without concrete proof
they won't be accepted as the new rulers of the kingdom.
So the first phase of their plan is to like find proof of King Quentin's wrongdoings.
Throughout all of this, Scarlet and Hollis are becoming very close friends
and for one brief beautiful moment, I thought they might turn into lesbians.
In fact, they are not but that's okay.
One night, that night, maybe the next night,
Hollis has run out of firewood in her room.
Here's the thing, in this world there is racism
but the racism is between the blondes and the brunettes.
It's so unserious.
So the Iseultans are blonde, the Coroans are brunette
and they don't like each other.
Hollis, if we can see on our beautiful front cover,
she's like not quite blonde, not quite brunette.
So she's like more blonde than would be expected in Coroa
but she's not quite blonde enough to fit in at Iseultan
and all of the people who work in the Northcott's home
are like really prejudiced towards Hollis because she's a Coroan.
They don't like them because of racism.
So anytime Scarlet is like needing something from her room
and she'll ask one of the staff to get it for her,
they won't get it for her.
So she's run out of firewood
and none of the staff are bringing her new firewood.
So she ventures out into the world
and she doesn't know where to get more firewood
and it's really cold.
So she goes into Eitan's room
which is right next to hers to borrow some.
He opens the door.
I was temporarily distracted by the fact
that his shirt was both untucked and untied.
Half of it slung off his shoulder.
I could see at least three different scars on his chest,
presumably marks from his time as a soldier.
I already know this is about to be
some stupid enemies to lovers type ----.
Dude, that's your cousin's widow.
I love my cousin.
If one of them were married and then they died,
I feel like their widow would be off limits, you know?
Like I feel like I wouldn't personally go there.
So Hollis likes Eitan, but they still hate each other.
But honestly, I am frustrated by this plot point.
However, I find they have so much more chemistry
than Hollis and Silas had.
Maybe this is my own bias.
Like I do tend to prefer a like strong dislike to lovers arc.
I find it more compelling.
I was like kind of blushing, giggling,
kicking my feet a little bit.
I'm not gonna lie.
I kind of thought it was kind of cutie.
Shortly after this, Hollis learns that racism is in fact bad.
Yes, I'd come to love a man from Isolt.
I loved his family.
I loved their queen,
but I only loved them because I knew them.
I laughed at Scarlet's clothes
the first day she walked into the great room
and I disliked Valentina for being typically standoffish
as I knew Isoltans would be.
I love them now, but I judged them on first sight.
I thought myself more stylish, wiser.
I thought myself better.
And when I thought about it all,
one of two things was absolutely true.
Either I deserve to be treated this way,
or no one did ever.
Groundbreaking stuff happening here.
And might I remind you,
this book was published in 2020.
I think sometimes I'm inclined to give books
that tackle this sort of subject matter,
especially YA books that were written 10, 20 years ago,
a bit more grace
because I think the language that we use
and the sort of social awareness
that we have around these things
has come really far,
even in just last 10 years,
but especially like from the 2000s to now.
But this was, I guess, six years ago.
Holy Jesus.
This was not groundbreaking in 2020.
So it feels a little bit like silly
to be reading about a person who's like,
maybe I shouldn't be racist against brunettes.
Anyway, a few days later, it's after bread day.
Basically bread day,
the Northcott family makes a bunch of bread
for all the people who work on the land.
Very cute.
During bread day,
Hollis finds out that it is Uncle Reed's birthday.
Uncle Reed is like the Northcott uncle.
She's like, we should celebrate his birthday.
What are the Isoltan birthday traditions?
So they like bake a bunch of treats.
They have a nice banquet.
At the banquet,
Hollis and Eitan get into a huge fight.
Like just yelling at each other over the birthday table.
Eitan is like, I hate you.
And Hollis is like, I hate you.
And this really upsets Hollis.
So she just like starts, she runs away.
She's like, I guess I'm going back to Coroa.
I don't know.
I'm like leaving here.
So she runs off in the night
with Neri, a plan in the world.
Eitan comes after her.
Stop, why am I blushing?
She's like, why did you come for me?
And he's like, cause I know you.
And she's like, no, you don't.
And he says, yes, I do.
I know that you have already had your fill of death.
I know that you would rather live a long life alone
in agony if it meant those you loved
could walk the earth a little longer.
I know that even when you're miserable,
you look out for other people.
But it's been years since I've seen my mother smile
the way she did when you put flowers in her hair.
Exactly the same profession of love as Silas did.
I guess it runs in the family.
But I do find this one a little bit sweeter
because it's like actually comments on her personhood.
Not just like, you like to laugh.
You go swimming and dancing and singing sometimes.
You know, that's like less romantic to me.
Eitan and Hollis decide that they are not
going to hate each other anymore.
They have called a truce.
And Eitan also said that he was going to yell at the staff
and make sure that they help her when she asks for help.
Racism solved.
In the mail, the Northcots get an invitation
to the Isleton royal wedding.
Quentin's sickly son is getting married.
Woo woo!
Good for him!
Let's go!
And everyone's like, oh, we shouldn't go.
And then Hollis is like, oh my gosh, a party.
What a good opportunity to commit some treason.
Like, we'll be in the castle and we'll be able to like
search for information that we need.
Uncle Reed is like, everyone should have
Hollis's same positive attitude.
Like, she's so right.
This is such a great opportunity to be able to like
find what we're looking for and overthrow the king.
So they kind of pair off for the royal wedding
and Eitan is Hollis's date.
So they have to like stick by each other the whole time.
And surprisingly, they're both kind of happy about it.
Things are changing.
They're kind of in love.
They arrive at the castle and they're all at this like
pre-wedding party when a soldier comes into the Great Hall
and says, your majesty, we must report that another battalion
has been attacked by the border with Karoa.
We are the only ones to survive.
Obviously, that puts Hollis in a bit of an uncomfortable
situation because she is famously Karoan
and everyone knows that she's Karoan.
So the king is like, wait a minute,
let me humiliate this girl real quick.
So he makes her stand up like on a table
and he's like, why shouldn't I kill you?
Your people just killed all my people.
So why shouldn't I kill you right now?
She like handles it pretty well, but she's like,
hey, you guys, I have an idea.
I have a really good idea actually.
She's saying this, standing on the table
in the middle of a party to the literal king.
I'm so caffeinated.
Can you tell I had a coffee just before this?
She's standing on the table in the middle of this room
surrounded by Isletans that don't know her
and don't like her.
And she's talking to the king and she's like,
hey, King Quentin, I have an idea.
I'm going to solve your problems.
What if, hear me out, you just give Karoa some of your land?
What if you just like move the border
like just a little bit and then everyone's happy?
That's literally what the war is about.
She's like, guys, I have an idea.
What if we just stop fighting?
And I have to say, I understand why Jamison
didn't want her in the political rooms
because she is sort of confused.
She just like doesn't quite get it.
She's an optimist and that's so beautiful.
And the king is like, you have a point there.
This is something I've not mentioned up until now.
Scarlet and Hollis, they have this beautiful friendship.
One of their like running jokes is that they're gonna run away
and become a word that we don't really say anymore.
That starts with a G.
This book came out in, again, 2021,
which I feel like you knew better.
After the party, Hollis comes up with another brilliant plan.
Basically, she's talking to Uncle Reed
and I think the woman's name is Giovanna?
Aunt Giovanna.
Uncle Reed and Aunt Giovanna are the Northcots.
And she's like, we need to get Valentina on our side
because she's also in danger
and so I think she'd be inclined to help us.
So the plan is Hollis is gonna write a note
to the queen arranging a meeting
and then tomorrow, which is competition day,
they're gonna like sneaky give it to Valentina
with a time designated to meet
and then they're gonna try to get Valentina on board
with their plan, which is essentially Valentina
is going to like rifle through King Quentin's stuff
and like find proof of him doing illegal business.
I'm still just like totally aghast
and a little bit agog
that Hollis cannot keep her goddamn ******* trap shut
for one second about Valentina's business.
She's like talking to the Northcots being like,
yeah, Valentina just had a miscarriage.
Maybe we can exploit that so that she can help us.
Hello?
I'm not telling Hollis the secret.
She will spill my business all over the place.
It's competition day.
Hollis is going to drop her letter with Valentina.
Eitan is competing in competition day,
even though Hollis, because she's like,
I'm grieving so I'm not gonna give
any of the soldiers a token.
She ends up giving Eitan her gold handkerchief.
Handkerchief?
Handkerchief.
I feel like it's handkerchief.
How to pronounce handkerchief.
Handkerchief.
That doesn't feel right in my mouth.
You are looking at Julian's pronunciation guide
where we look at how to pronounce better
some of the most mispronounced words in the world.
You're gonna have to listen carefully here.
British English pronunciation.
Handkerchief.
Hang.
Ker.
Chief.
Okay.
American English pronunciation is a little bit different.
Handkerchief.
Hand. Ker. Chiff.
Okay.
Handkerchief.
I'm gonna go with handkerchief.
Handkerchief.
Oh gosh.
Hollis gives Eitan her handkerchief.
Also apparently Eitan is like not good at competition day
which I'm confused by
because he's like supposed to be
I thought he was supposed to be a really good soldier
but then they're like
yeah he's never won a challenge in challenge day.
Like he's so bad at jousting.
I had a hard time reconciling that
with the image I had of his character in my brain
and then he ends up winning the entire competition
which everyone's like sort of confused by
because famously as Scarlett said earlier
he's a bad ******* soldier.
Somewhere in that Hollis has dropped the note to Valentina
and in the note she says meet me at the banquet
because there's a big like party banquet afterwards.
She said meet me at the banquet
and then they're gonna like plan at the banquet
because Hollis is like
the best way to hide things is in plain sight.
Everyone will just think we're talking.
So they're at the banquet.
Eitan and Hollis are flirting so hard
as though this is not your dead husband's cousin.
Hollis she doesn't see Valentina
so she like goes to leave
and Eitan follows her.
Hollis goes well if it isn't lord jouster supreme
defeater of old men
master of large sticks.
To what do I owe this honor?
Eitan rolled his eyes relaxing.
Ha ha I noticed you were gone
and assumed you might need someone to guide you
to an appropriate place to vomit.
I was merely asking for help.
I smiled.
Lucky for you I'm just fine.
Just a little too warm is all.
You may return to your door in crowds if you wish.
And then they literally kiss.
They literally kiss.
All my tension suddenly melted away
under the sweet kisses of Eitan Northcott.
I'd never been close enough to smell him before
but he had a scent all of his own.
Something that reminded me of being outside.
He held on to my arms keeping me in place
but his hands were gentle
and that was miraculous
because I'd seen what his hands were capable of.
It was all miraculous actually.
So they finish kissing
and then Hollis is like
I have to go and see if Valentina arrived at the party
and then Eitan is like
oh god I biffed it.
She didn't want to kiss
because that's my cousin's widow.
So they kind of like go their separate ways
without addressing it.
When they get back into the hall
Valentina is there
and Valentina and Hollis begin plotting and scheming.
Valentina agrees to help.
She's gonna sneak into Quentin's office
and like find stuff that's incriminating to him
but her one condition is
she wants to be able to escape.
So she's like I will help you
if you help me run away.
The next day after the party
Hollis and Scarlett are kind of like chilling.
They're bonding.
Hollis in her brain she goes about Silas
granted everything between us had happened so quickly.
We'd run away together only a handful of days after we met
and married two weeks after that.
I'd spent more time as Silas's widow
than as his beloved.
I appreciate the self-awareness
because we were all thinking it
so I'm glad you said it
so I didn't have to
and then Scarlett is like
well I think Eitan actually really likes you.
Hollis is like no no way.
Scarlett side pushing herself up.
I know Eitan hasn't really smiled in years
but you make him laugh.
I know he doesn't take ladies favor
because he never wants his wins to be shared
but he took yours.
I know he doesn't like to admit when he's wrong
but he concedes to you
and I know he has never ever looked at anyone
the way he looks at you.
This same exact speech got copy and pasted three times.
First Silas says it about Hollis
and then Eitan says it about Hollis
and now Scarlett is saying it about Eitan.
Why are they all talking exactly the same?
I swear to god it's copy and pasted.
Hollis is like no Eitan has been clear to me
that he doesn't like me like that.
I'm like he kissed you.
What?
This ---- pisses me off so hard.
It's so confusing to me
when like the main character is like
I have no reason to believe
that their feelings have changed for me at all.
Now you're kissing and flirting
that's different from when he hated you.
Use your little brain for one freaking minute
to understand that like people's feelings change sometimes
dumbass.
Next day it's the royal wedding.
The whole family goes to the royal wedding
and prince what's-his-face does not look good.
He looks like he's about to die
and everyone's like this timing of this wedding
is a little suspicious.
Like it seemed to be moving really fast.
After the wedding Valentina sneakily gives Hollis
a bunch of letters from King Quentin's office.
The letters prove a few things.
First of all there's a letter
that's basically ordering the dark knights
to kill Valentina's family.
This is enough proof to implicate King Quentin
and to be able to overthrow the government.
So their plan to overthrow
basically Eitan is going to go to the countryside
and rally all of the people in the country
while the rest of the family's staying in the castle
and sort of using their whisper network
to spread the news that they're going to overthrow the king.
Which is going to be super easy
because nobody likes him
because he kills everybody's family.
They've just been like looking for a reason to overthrow him
so now that they have proof everyone is like yay!
And then one morning Eitan is coming
with like a big group of people
and all the nobles from the castle are there.
There's this big crowd.
King Quentin comes down
and they're like we're gonna overthrow your government
and King Quentin is like
luckily for you Prince Hadrian actually died this morning
so you're totally able easily to overthrow my freaking government.
The king gets overthrown
and the crowd really wants to kill King Quentin
but Eitan who's the king now he's like
no we're not gonna be like him
we're gonna make sure he has a fair and equitable trial.
Quentin also says
Did I have Valentina's family killed?
Yes, it had to happen.
I've had so many people killed in the name of my own peace
I can't count them.
But Sir Estoff, that upstart Silas
I can't take credit for that.
If you didn't do it then who did Scarlet demanded?
Took me a while to figure it out myself Quentin said.
For the multitudes of people standing in front of us
we might have been able to hear a pinfall to the ground
for how quietly and intently we were all listening
to find the truth behind their deaths
but it all makes sense now.
If you want to know you should ask her
and I froze with horror as Quentin tipped his chin at me.
He's insinuating that King Jameson had
all of Hollis's family and wedding guests killed.
As this happens Scarlet has this like recovered memory
because she's the only one who was left alive
during the brutal mass casualty event
that happened at Hollis's wedding.
And she remembers that one of the people who grabbed her
and then let her go had a Corowen ring
a ring of the Corowen crest.
A bunch of stuff clicked.
She's like oh my god King Jameson 100% did
try to kill my entire goddamn family and succeeded.
So she runs away to confront him.
Eitan comes as well because they're in love.
They get to Jameson's castle and plot twist
Hollis and Jameson were already married.
In Corowa there's this thing
this contract that your parents can sign for you
which basically like is a formal betrothal
and then there's like a date
and when the date passes the contract goes into effect
and you're officially married.
Hollis's family did that for her and Jameson
so that the day crowning day happened
remember back in the first book
they officially became married.
They didn't have to go through the wedding ceremony.
This bit's a little bit convoluted.
Basically Hollis is there and she's like really sad
and then the guy who ordained the contract
comes and finds her after and is like
I'm so sorry I did that.
I didn't know what I was doing
and gives her a letter that King Jameson had written.
These evil motherfuckers have to stop putting
their entire plan into writing.
You're gonna get caught.
In Jameson's handwriting the letter detailed
when and where my wedding was to take place
and spelled out a mission of the men he'd hired.
Jameson is in the middle of this banquet.
Hollis is also there I guess because she's married to him.
He like gets up on a table and is like
gesticulating wildly and talking all crazy
and he gets his sword out
and then he ******* falls onto his sword and dies.
This dumbass trips and falls
and accidentally kills himself on his literal own sword.
Let's go I guess.
So if you're paying attention that means Hollis
is actually now the entire queen of Coroa
because she was married to him.
Now if you're paying extra attention
you'll notice that now Aeton is king and Hollis is queen
which means they can't be together.
They have to govern their respective countries.
We are 40 pages from the end.
I'm left wondering how we're gonna get out of this pickle
because I know, I know Hollis and Aeton
are gonna end up together.
I wonder how we're gonna untangle this wild web that we're weaving
and the answer to that is a time jump three months later.
I hate when that happens.
Makes me mad.
It's one of my biggest pet peeves.
We get a whole bunch of exposition all at once
by way of letters to Delia Grace.
Delia Grace goes traveling to like expand her horizons.
Hollis turned her family home in the countryside
into a school for poor people
and Hollis is now meant to be married to this like total rando.
Aeton is also meant to get married to a different rando
but they're still gonna be friends.
Aeton and his rando come to visit Coroa to discuss like politics
now that stuff has sort of settled down
and everyone's like accepted Hollis into being queen.
Some of the stuff that they do,
they start a program where doctors from Isolt-
I forgot to explain this part of the lore.
Basically like Coroa is a place of beautiful art
and a lot of culture
and Isolt has like a lot less culture
but they've got a lot of like medical advancements.
So they start this program where all the doctors from Isolt
are gonna come to Coroa
and they're gonna like do doctor stuff
but they're also gonna train doctors in Coroa
so that Coroa has their own doctors also.
Aeton also proposes moving the border
and giving some of the land of Isolt to Coroa
like how Hollis had suggested to King Quentin way back
and this solves racism.
Valentina is Hollis's lady-in-waiting.
The two randos, so Aeton's rando, her name is Ayanna
and Hollis's rando, whose name is Hagen.
Anyway, they run away together.
They get married.
So good for them.
And then Aeton and Hollis are like,
Oh my gosh, if you and I get married,
we can make one super kingdom
and it'll have the biggest land area in the entire world.
Here's the thing is that like both of these books,
they've been like Coroans and Isoltans hate each other.
They're super racist towards each other.
The blondes and the brunettes,
they ******* hate each other
to the point where they're like literally at war
because they hate each other so much.
And then I meant to believe
that everyone's just gonna like get over it
because Aeton and Hollis get married.
Could we make this work?
Aeton asks genuinely.
They're still two different peoples.
Not like they used to be, Aeton.
I've been watching so carefully over this trip.
Things have changed.
Probably because of us.
It's surprisingly easy to teach people not to hate.
I think it will work, Aeton.
I really do.
They changed the national color from red and blue to purple
because it's a mix of red and blue.
Aw.
Anyway, they live happily ever after the end.
I have been listening to so much Tegan and Sarah.
I'm really feeling connected to my culture right now
because as I said, I just started watching The L Word
and it's just like making me feel like such a lesbian.
I'm gonna soft launch this.
I think we should bring back terms like lezzing out.
I wanna lezz out.
Just being a big lesbian.
Lezzing out.
Anyway, so I started watching The L Word
and then I was like, I have to listen to Tegan and Sarah.
And I'll actually show you.
I don't remember where I got this.
I think I found this at the thrift store.
But I found the first Tegan and Sarah album,
This Business of Art.
A CD of it.
This is my most listened to CD probably ever.
I **** with this ---- so hard.
That's my recommendation for you today.
Instead of reading these books,
go listen to This Business of Art by Tegan and Sarah.
I think it's their second studio album actually.
Didn't know until recently that Tegan and Sarah
are identical twins.
I thought they were lezzing each other.
Now how would you use that as a verb?
Lezzing out with each other?
I thought they were gay for each other.
They're sisters.
Okay, final thoughts.
I cannot stand like a half-baked allegory for racism
in a young adult series.
That ---- grinds my gears so ******* hard.
I'm okay with like a thought out allegory for racism.
But like they don't like each other
because one has blonde hair and one has brown hair.
And they're all white.
The other thing is, and I said that I wouldn't,
but this is the time in which I'm going to compare
The Selection to The Betrothal.
Is it called The Betrothal?
The Betrothed.
The Selection, is it the best written book series
I've ever read?
No, absolutely not.
Far from it.
However, it has a really, really strong concept.
Like a really strong framework.
All of the characters within the framework
get really, really fleshed out.
Like you really understand pretty much
every single character's primary motivations.
All of their actions feel really justified.
Even the ones that like you don't personally agree with.
You understand why it's happening.
And it makes for a really, really compelling read.
And it makes you care so deeply about what's happening.
At least it makes me care so deeply about what's happening.
In contrast to these books,
everything just sort of felt like it was happening
because like that was the next plot beat.
I didn't care.
I didn't care about the characters.
I didn't care about the story.
Also, this book fell into a trap
that I experience often in young adult books.
It felt like it didn't trust the reader so much.
There would be a reveal
and then you would get like three paragraphs
about like why this reveal was important.
Instead of just like having the reveal
and trusting that your audience understands
why it's important implicitly,
you would get this reveal and then you'd be like,
this is why it's important that Valentina has a miscarriage.
Young adult audiences are smart.
Children are really smart.
They have the ability to make connections.
They don't need it spelled out for them.
Yeah, that's all I have for you today.
My Instagram and my Goodreads are linked below
to hang out with me between videos.
I also have a suggestion box.
If you have a book that you really like
or you really like to hate,
put it in the suggestion box or send me an email.
That also works.
Bye-bye.
