Ken Goshen en Atelier Mesones, día 2, parte 2: Valor, Saturación, Color.

The Art of Ken Goshen
1 follower
Mar 22, 2025
En este video se aborda la importancia de los elementos del color para pintura al óleo.
https://www.kengoshen.com/
https://www.ateliermesones.art/
https://www.instagram.com/kengoshen/
https://www.instagram.com/ateliermesones/
What's the most important out of these three?
Belly?
That's right!
What's the second most important?
Chroma?
That's right!
And that leaves us with hue.
In order to express this idea to you,
I would like you to imagine a black and white photograph.
A black and white photograph contains
almost all the information that we care about
from a realism standpoint.
It expresses the lighting,
the form,
the likeness,
the expression,
all those things
you don't need chroma and hue to express.
Meaning,
values are like 70%.
If you got the values right,
you're way on track
to getting the color to work.
Later you said,
chroma is the second most important part.
That is correct.
And hue is like
the cherry on top.
Like, 8% importance.
But,
a very common mistake that people make,
especially when they're just starting out with color,
is they look at life
and all they see is hue.
Even if they know this,
they're like,
oh that looks a little yellow,
oh that looks a little purple,
oh that looks a little blue.
That's not the way to go.
Obviously.
So,
we want to make sure that when we mix,
we prioritize
value,
then chroma,
and then hue.
Now,
something very important
that Axel brought up,
that we all should be mindful of,
is that
it is impossible
to mix
the exact colors
we see in reality.
In reality,
we have an endless spectrum
of values.
Just endless.
And we have an endless spectrum
of chroma variations and hues
more than any palette
could capture.
So how do people
make anything look like life?
Through the same method
that we've been using so far.
Making decisions,
sacrificing what's not important,
focusing on what is important.
Even in color.
And almost especially in color.
So,
we're going to discover
how to do that together.
Now the palette that I'm proposing
that we use
is something that
you've all sent me works,
and so
I gauged
the relative
degree of proficiency in color
across the class,
and I'm going to recommend
a palette that's like
one of the most famous limited palettes,
the Zorn palette.
If you're in some way opposed
to doing that,
if you want to limit it even more,
I can sit with you and we can
make something even more limited.
If you want to expand it a little more,
I'm probably going to say no,
but I'm going to be open to it.
I haven't seen anybody's work
that suggests to me that you're
going to be able to
get the most that you can
out of the Zorn palette.
And if you do by the end of tomorrow,
I'm going to be very, very excited.
Now,
when you are thinking about
these three properties,
what this diagram
suggests that you do
is think about it like a
three-dimensional space,
like an imaginary three-dimensional space
where when
we want to go lighter,
we move up the value range.
When we want to go more chromatic,
we move away from the center.
When we want to be,
to hit a different hue,
we spin across the axis.
So we create this diagram
in our mind.
We look at the color that we see
and then we ask ourselves,
where does it fit?
Where does it fit in this
three-dimensional space?
Is it high on the space?
Is it far from the center?
And where across the wheel is it?
These are the three questions.
How high or how low are we
in this three-dimensional space?
How far are we from the center?
And where on the wheel?
Now I'm going to have
some trick questions for you.
If I say,
let's imagine
a low-value,
high-chroma
green.
Sub-green.
Emerald.
Because sub-green is not green,
it's more like yellow-green.
Right?
What if I say
high-value,
low-chroma, red.
What is that called?
No. Why no?
Why strong no?
Cadmium red, extremely chromatic.
Don't think about a pigment.
Just imagine a color.
Theoretically.
High-value means light.
Low-chroma, not very saturated.
Red.
Pink.
Pink, right?
It's a color that we know.
When we talk scientifically
about what is pink,
high-value,
low-chroma, red.
Let's try another one.
Low-value,
low-chroma,
orange.
What color is that?
Brown.
Thank you.
Beautiful.
Let's try another one.
Low-value,
high-chroma,
yellow.
There isn't such a color.
Yeah.
It does not exist.
Why not?
Because
each color,
each hue,
has different chroma potential
in every value.
Yellows
can't be chromatic
when their value is low.
Cannot.
Doesn't exist.
Right?
So you have to think
that this three-dimensional space
is not symmetrical.
It's not just like a
neat little cylinder.
At the highest point of the cylinder,
the yellow can come out
way more than all the other colors.
Because yellow has high chroma potential
when it's light,
around value 9.
When you come closer to the middle,
reds become the most
chromatically,
the potential of reds to express themselves chromatically
is higher around the middle.
Think about blue.
Where does blue go?
The dark values have the most
chroma potential for blues.
The possibility of every color
to express itself chromatically
depends
on their value expression.
Okay?
Now, if I'm working with the Zorn palette,
which has
white, black,
yellow ochre,
and cadmium red light.
Am I limited in my ability
to express value?
Why?
And?
Thank you.
I can express all the values.
Can I have
as much chroma potential
in the yellows and in the reds?
Yeah.
Why?
Who's skeptical?
I think only in the reds.
My red
is much more chromatic than my yellow.
If I wanted this to be
balanced, I would have
cadmium red, cadmium yellow.
But I don't have cadmium red, cadmium yellow.
I have cadmium red light,
yellow ochre. Why?
Because the skin is not that chromatic.
Thank you. In the yellows.
Right?
Because of the skin.
If we're painting the human figure,
the human figure
has many areas
that are very chromatic.
More chromatic in terms of
their red lips,
ears, other areas.
Yellows, however,
when somebody looks very yellow,
we send them to the hospital.
We don't
need the high chroma yellow
here.
If we don't need the high chroma yellow here,
that means if that was the color on our
palette, we would be working very
hard. Every time we
use it, we would have to also add
black to bring the
chroma down. Would I
want to switch them if I was painting a lemon?
Probably.
Right? If I'm painting a lemon, I need
my cadmium yellow. I probably don't
need my cadmium red.
Any red at all,
burnt sienna would be enough for a yellow.
For a lemon.
Lemons don't have a lot of red
in them.
When you're picking what color you want to use,
it's not a question like
Oh!
What is my favorite combination of pigments?
It's what visual effect
am I going for?
And then what pigments are going to get
there with the least amount of work?
Right? So in this case,
if I had a high chroma yellow, it would
hold me back. It would give me more
chroma potential that I don't want.
And I don't need.
And therefore, I wasted my time.
Right?
Now,
am I limited in my ability to express hue?
Hue?
Yes.
Because they don't have blue.
I don't have blue. What else don't I have?
Green.
What else don't I have?
Purple.
Right.
So, what hues do I have?
Red.
Yellow.
And orange.
Essentially, what we learned
is that through this palette,
if I look at the model,
what questions am I asking?
How light do I end up? How dark?
I'm good.
And then,
how saturated is it?
And then, where is it between yellow and red?
That's it.
Now, as
some of you have already alluded to,
there is a
hack over here that we could use,
a trick, to
express
a semi-green and a semi-blue
and a semi-purple.
This is
the result of several things,
several effects,
but mostly it has
to do with
the relationship
of the colors to each other.
Let me just show you, for example,
we were talking about a
low-chroma, low-value
yellow.
And we said that didn't exist.
So what's going to happen
if I try
to make a low-chroma,
low-value yellow?
I have yellow,
and do I have a pigment here
that's going to reduce both the chroma
and the value?
Black.
Black reduces value,
reduces chroma.
But low-chroma, low-value
yellow doesn't exist.
So what is it going to be?
Reduce.
There you go.
This becomes
kind of
olive green.
See?
If we only have three
hues, we better
see them on the palette.
That's going to be a big shortcut.
So let's mix an orange.
I'm using much more ochre than I'm
using cadmium red light. Why?
Because the tinting strength,
the tinting strength of
cadmium red light is much greater than the
tinting strength of ochre.
These different pigments are not identical
in their...
Yes, some pigments
are much stronger than others.
And way easier
to
overpower
the mixture. So in this case,
we arrived at an orange
that I like. And then,
what was
our answer to the question
low-value, low-chroma
orange is what?
Brown.
Brown is a useful pigment in this context,
a useful color in this context, right?
There's a lot of brown in skins.
Let's mix ourselves a brown.
So we take our orange
with some black,
get a brown. Can everybody see?
There we go.
So,
what's the next combination that
almost begs us
to pay attention to it?
We have yellow and black.
We have orange and black.
What didn't we try?
Red and black.
Thank you. Red and black.
What's it going to give us?
More brown?
Yeah, something like
maroonish.
I'm going to add a little bit more black here
because I want them to be of similar value.
Some of you
know
my work from Instagram, so you may know
that I
have a very, very, very clean
mixer.
Clean palette, clean your mind.
Red,
black.
On this palette right now,
we have
how many colors?
Eight.
How many pigments?
Four. Thank you.
Four pigments,
eight colors.
Right?
Does this palette strike you as limited?
Right?
When you just put red,
yellow, black, white, it looks like
what am I going to do?
It doesn't look like
it's going to be enough
to do all the stuff I need to do.
Now that I have red,
orange, yellow,
a kind of green, a kind of brown,
a kind of maroon, black, white,
the sky's the limit
for what I can do with this,
and it's the same number of pigments.
It's all
in the relationships between the colors.
A good painter
knows how to take very little,
very few pigments,
and extract out of them
variety.
When you
look at ancient portraits,
do you know the ancient portraits
from Egypt,
the Fayum portraits?
Those are done
basically with this kind of,
even less chromatic red.
They only had mud to work with.
Right?
Some earthy yellow, some earthy red,
some black,
barely white,
that's it.
And they make portraits
sublime, gorgeous.
It's not
how many colors you have,
it's whether or not
you can extract the most
out of it.
It's extracting the most out of the
pigments that creates richness
and beauty. It's better
to use better.
Scratch that word.
It's more aesthetically pleasing
to use fewer pigments
and make them
stretch their ability
to the edge, as opposed to
using a wide number of pigments
and say a tiny
fraction of what they can express.
Right? So you're right.
My idea is
can I use 10
colors on my palette?
My answer is
in your painting, will you be able
to make the most out of those pigments?
Or are you just going to use
a dab here, a dab there?
Are you going to put alizarin crimson on your palette
to just use it in one mark?
That mark's going to stick out.
That mark's not going to feel like
it's connected to the other marks.
All these pigments need to be
in harmony,
which means if you put one pigment
in one place, the eye's going to expect
to see it in several other places.
If I put alizarin crimson on my palette,
I'm going to want to use it
in a way that respects
the pigment. I'm going to want to see alizarin
in several areas. If you're
going to use a pigment on your palette,
that pigment needs to be
some kind of player
in your design. Otherwise,
scrap it
and find a replacement that you can mix
from the other pigments that you can't do
without.
The road to harmony
is much
clearer and faster with
fewer pigments on the palette,
and the road to beauty
is through taking those pigments
and expressing them
to their fullest potential.
Reserve the use
of white for when you're actually
using it to make the specific colors
for your piece,
not these shortcuts.
This is because,
as some of you have alluded to,
white is a very, very
opaque pigment.
You need to reserve it
for the parts of your design
that you want to paint
opaquely.
Right now, all these colors
I can use both
for areas that I prefer to paint transparently
and for areas that
I can paint opaquely by just
adding white to them. I can always add white
later, but I can never take the white
away.
So by not using white
in any of these premixes, I keep more
of my options open.
Alright,
so I think what I'm going to do, I'm going to
mix a few colors from the model
and then you're going to
mix a few colors from the model.
And as I said, we are
not going to use these colors
today. I brought
containers.
You have all day,
all the rest of the day,
just to mix.
And if you do well today
and you mix a nice set
of 10 colors,
10 great colors, 10 colors
you're proud of, 10 colors
that look amazing on the palette,
tomorrow morning
you wake up, they're yours.
How bad is the painting going to look
if all your 10 colors look amazing
in of themselves and look amazing
together? Color harmony
can happen on the palette
regardless of what's going on with the
painting. And that's what we're going to try to do.
I'm going to mix a color that
later, when I work with the brush, I can
create small adjustments.
But, as we said,
in reality, there's
almost an endless amount of
colors, so I couldn't mix
all of them, but I could use
later variations with my brush when
I do this. So I'm going to try to mix an
approximation of light,
of the lightest moment, and I'm going to
look at this area or this area
because they are easy for me to see.
So, how's the
value on that area?
10. Thank you. How's the
chroma on that area?
Low. What am I going to
do? What's the hue?
Orange.
Chroma feels too high.
What are my two ways
for reducing chroma
on this palette?
Complementary colors?
Do I have a complementary color anywhere
on this palette? No.
No. Gray?
Maybe gray. Two ways.
Two ways.
I want a list of two.
Black?
Black is one.
Black or white?
White is a zero chroma color.
Right?
So if I add white, I bring
the chroma down and I do what to the value?
10. Thank you.
If I add black, I
reduce chroma and do what to the value?
Low. Thank you.
If I want to keep the value the same,
what do I do? And I still want to reduce the chroma.
Gray.
Also gray. Thank you.
Excellent.
Gray is the...
Gray means
both white and
black. If black
reduces my value
and white increases my value,
adding both
keeps them similar.
Now I'm
trying to mix for this area
right here.
It's not very chromatic.
So I'm trying to
balance it out. It can't be as
light as that. So I have
a hierarchy.
This needs to be the amount of a value drop.
I'm going to need to add more white there.
Next up
on my list,
these little shadows here,
they get
even darker.
Right? But not by
a lot. Not by too much.
Now,
next up
on this list, I want this value.
Right?
That's even darker.
So we proceed
to go even lower on the value
O. I'm using this
green a lot today.
So I feel like what I have right now
so far is like I got the
light, I got the semi-light,
I got the shadow
here and here, I have a good
transition color,
and now I'm starting to go
into the shadow universe.
So what's the biggest
difference that
I need to be mindful of when I'm going into
the shadow universe? What happens to
the biggest transformation of the color?
That value
goes lower.
Right? Goes much lower.
Is there a difference between this color
here and this color
here? What is the
difference?
Over here,
we have lower chroma
than over here
and over here.
This side of the hand
is pretty chromatic.
But then when you shift over here, the
chroma drops. Noticing this?
No.
So let's try to mix these two
colors in a proper relationship
to each other. Both of them
need to have
low value, but one with
chroma that is higher than the other.
If you noticed, I did not
use white in this
color. It has no reason
to be white, to have
any white in it, as far as I'm
concerned right now. And if I
don't have to add white, I
prefer not to, because it keeps my
options more open with
regards to transparencies and different
color effects. If all my colors
are opaque, my painting doesn't
feel as rich. So now my goal
is to mix a color that is
similar to this color,
very similar to this color, but
has lower chroma.
Okay, so lower chroma.
Already
suggested I need to use more yellow and less
red. What did we say
the reason for that was?
My yellow is
lower chroma than my red.
Nice.
See these two colors?
Value, extremely
similar. Chroma
is different.
That's
hue.
Bingo.
That's right.
So this is going to be
my good friend here.
This
is going to be my good friend here.
I already have a lot
to work with. This is fantastic.
Now,
what significant colors am
I still missing?
Of course
this accent is
very low chroma
and value.
Thank you. Darker.
This thing, darker than
this thing, right? By a pretty
significant margin.
Let's do that.
I'm going to do
a similar
thing for
the hair. It's going to be useful.
But for that,
I prefer my chroma to be a little bit
lower. So I'm going to do a similar
thing to what you saw me do here
with another dark color here.
Lots of black
and very little
orange.
For the background color,
I think I'm going to mix
maybe
two colors at least.
Let's see how this goes.
Somebody described the background
to me in terms of color properties.
What's going on there?
Medium chroma.
Medium value.
And what about the chroma?
Low chroma.
But is it zero when I just mix black and white
like this?
No.
What am I missing?
I'm comparing this to these.
Ah, okay.
They need to be similar.
We already said there's not a lot of difference here.
Why am I spending so
long on my palette?
I am able to make comparisons here.
If I just look at the value
comparing it to nothing,
it doesn't mean anything.
This value has to be similar
to the values of the shadow.
To preserve harmony?
To preserve harmony is cool,
but also to obey the actual
relationship that we see there.
Okay, so what do I need to add here in terms of
chroma? This is too gray. Everybody agrees?
Okay, what am I going to add?
Okay, am I going to add red?
No, yellow.
Let's add yellow.
It's kind of greenish.
And then, let's make one lighter version.
And in this
particular lighter one,
I'm going to just add a little bit of red.
Why do you
have
cadmium red?
Why do I have cadmium red light?
It's a very good
question in this context because indeed
we're not seeing a whole lot
of high-chroma
reds
in this environment, but
if I had reds that
had lower chroma, I might have
a harder time reaching
this, potentially. But you're
right. If you gave me a lower chroma
red, I would do okay. If you gave me venetian
red, I'd be fine. I'd definitely be fine.
Okay, so we have two
background colors that we like.
And so now...
That's a break.
So how many
did we mix? 1, 2, 3,
4, 5, 6, 7, 8,
9, 10.
Start with 10.
Okay, let's go.
