Johan Norberg - Free or Equal - Free to Choose 30 years later 3/5 Milton Friedman

Outstanding Economics
52 followers
19 Video Views·Nov 6, 2023
But when only the flexible and adaptable survive, it means that other businesses fail.
Economists call this constant renewal of the economy, creative destruction.
If we want to increase our wealth and opportunities, we have to stop doing old things in old ways,
and start doing innovative things in better ways.
In other words, we have to be creative.
But when consumers move on to new goods, it can be difficult and painful, because old
factories and old shops close, and people lose their jobs.
That is the destructive part.
And yet, most economists think that creative destruction is necessary for economic development.
Mrs. Lee starts out every day with her lunch, her teapot, and her cell phone.
Cell phones are important for boat drivers around here, because they use to pass messages
by shouting to one another.
Not terribly efficient, and very bad for your voice.
Hong Kong has the most cell phones in the world, 1.7 cell phones per person.
But all around the globe, we've seen a cell phone revolution.
In 1980, there were 11 million cell phones on the planet.
Today, almost 4 billion people have access to cell phones.
This is an example of creative destruction.
It used to be all landlines made of copper, but now they become less and less important,
especially in the developing world.
This farmer in Bangladesh was always dependent on one buyer of her eggs, and had to accept
his prices.
But now she can check the price of eggs in other village markets with her cell phone
before she sells, and so she can negotiate a better price.
In Tanzania, it used to be that the customer often had to sit and wait for hours at the
butchers for the meat to arrive.
And sometimes in Peru, the meat had to wait, because the customers didn't know that it
was already there.
Today, you coordinate the business with a cell phone, and the food ends up in people's
stomachs, and not in the garbage.
We have rarely seen a technology that has meant so much for human development.
But that was not the intention.
The telecom companies wanted more market share.
Those who adapted and distributed the technology locally wanted to make money.
And butchers and egg farmers just wanted to improve their own lives.
Adam Smith would say that it was as if they were led by an invisible hand when they rolled
out this technology faster than any technology in world history.
And many would say that this revolution did more to give the average person power, and
to reduce poverty more than any government program.
But all progress comes at a cost.
Market forces are both creative and destructive.
As people buy cell phones, they ditch their home phones.
And then, there is no need for all those workers who used to connect homes to wires
and repair telephone lines.
And that is tens of thousands of people who worked hard and supported their families,
and through no fault of their own, lost their jobs, and whose skills might not be in demand
as the technology takes a new leap.
Some succeed in inventing the next smartphone, and become incredibly rich.
Others are stuck with an obsolete technology.
Some win, some lose, and the result is something that most people have a problem with- inequality.
Equality is a powerful concept, one that we can all cherish to some degree.
In fact, it's fair to say that in one sense, America was built on the idea of equality.
Equality is so important that here in Washington, D.C., there is a monument dedicated to Thomas
Jefferson.
Thomas Jefferson was one of the founding fathers, and he wrote the American Declaration of Independence.
With these words, we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created
equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights.
Among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
What did Thomas Jefferson mean by the words, all men are created equal?
What he meant by the words, equal, can be seen in the phrase, endowed by their creator.
To Thomas Jefferson, all men are equal in the eyes of God.
They all must be treated as individuals who have, each separately, a right to life, liberty,
and the pursuit of happiness.
Of course, practice did not conform to the ideals in Jefferson's life, or in ours as
a nation.
He agonized repeatedly during his lifetime about the conflict between the institution
of slavery and the fine words of the Declaration.
And yet, during his whole life, he was a slave owner.
But during the 19th century, the powerful words and ideals of the Declaration of Independence
helped more people to see the horrors of slavery, and it helped to end forced labor.
Practice began to catch up with the ideals.
The idea of equality came more and more to mean that everyone should have the same opportunity
to make what he could of his capacities.
That all careers should be open to people on the basis of their talents, independently
of the race, or religion, or belief, or social class that characterized them.
This concept of equality of opportunity offers no conflict at all with the concept of freedom.
On the contrary, they reinforce one another, and it is no doubt the concept that even today
is most widely held.
During the 20th century, as people were confronted with some of the differences of outcome that
were the result of free markets, a very different ideal began to emerge.
And Friedman thought that this ideal was in conflict with freedom.
That is the ideal that everyone should be equal in income, in level of living, in what
he has.
The idea that the economic race should be so arranged that everybody ends at the finish
line at the same time, rather than that everyone starts at the beginning line at the same time.
This concept raises a very serious problem for freedom.
It is clearly in conflict with it, since it requires that the freedom of some be restricted
in order to provide greater benefits to others.
How did the idea that governments should change economic outcomes become popular in the West?
In a way, it started here, in 1929, when the stock market crashed.
The Wall Street crash was followed by the worst depression in American history.
That depression has been blamed on the failure of capitalism.
It was no such thing, but the myth lives on.
Friedman thought that the Great Depression was the result of massive government failure,
of stupid monetary policies and tariffs that created a trade war.
But the common interpretation at the time was that capitalism had failed, and that you
couldn't just leave things for themselves in the face of massive unemployment and widespread
poverty.
So politicians worldwide were looking for a new approach.
Roosevelt's first priority after his election was to deal with massive unemployment.
A public works program was started.
The government financed projects to build highways, bridges and dams.
Roosevelt wanted to see America move into a new era.
The Social Security Act was passed, and other measures followed.
Unemployment benefits, welfare payments, distribution of surplus food.
With these measures, of course, came rules, regulations and red tape, as familiar today
as they were novel then.
The government bureaucracy began to grow, and it's been growing ever since.
The United States became a bit more like European countries, like my home country, Sweden, by
introducing some wealth redistribution, and more government control over the economy.
My country has made an effort to make people's lives more equal.
We have relatively free markets in business.
It's fairly easy to start a company and compete without being stopped by licenses, regulations
and tariffs.
But when people are allowed to compete freely, some win and make a lot of money, some lose
and they lag behind.
That's when the Swedish government steps in.
To reduce differences of outcome, we tax heavily and redistribute wealth among our citizens.
To many, this is the best of both worlds, since we don't really have equal chances
in life.
Some people have parents who give them an interest in learning, ambition and opportunities.
Some don't.
Some are lucky in the genetic lottery, and some aren't.
Some have good health, and some don't.
To reduce the gaps that such differences might lead to, our government steps in.
Sweden chose to make equality a priority in the 1970s, when we were already one of the
richest countries in the world.
Taxes were raised, and benefit systems were made more generous.
Public spending almost doubled between 1960 and 1980, from 31% to 60% of GDP.
Some would say that this has made our country better, but it has also reduced the rewards
for working hard and taking risks.
This is a museum recreation of the original workshop of Lars Magnus Eriksson.
He was a very important person in Swedish history, because more than 130 years ago,
he produced cheap and reliable versions of the telephones that he had seen in the United
States.
And because of this, Stockholm became a global center for telecommunication in the late 19th
century, and it laid the groundwork for one of Sweden's most successful companies,
Ericsson.
Even today, it still employs more than 80,000 people in 150 countries.
This should make me proud as a Swede, but in fact, it makes me a bit worried, because
almost all big Swedish businesses share Eriksson's heritage, and they probably all had boardrooms
that looked a bit like this.
The average big Swedish company is 94 years old.
We have apparently not had the policies that encourage people to start the new businesses
that might become tomorrow's Eriksson.
Today, Swedish entrepreneurs are the oldest in the world.
This is the other side of the coin.
The young people, and the immigrants who should be our future, are not starting the new Erikssons.
In fact, we have many examples of young Swedes and entrepreneurial immigrants who move from
Sweden to Britain or the United States, because the rewards are much greater there, where
taxes are lower.
In many suburbs like this outside of Stockholm, the unemployment rate is higher than 50 percent.
Even in the midst of the economic boom, almost a quarter of the working-age population in
Sweden did not go to work in the morning, but got their checks from the government.
It does seem to support the view that economic incentives matter.
With a sickness benefit of up to 80 percent of your income, perhaps it wasn't surprising
that Swedes were off sick more than any other people, even though we objectively were healthier
than almost any other population.
In 2004, sickness benefits absorbed 16 percent of the government's budget.
These statistics have improved since, but interestingly, only after a determined effort
by the government to reduce the equality of income, by lowering taxes and making benefit
systems less generous.
So it seems that these changes increase the incentives to work.
Friedman emphasized something counter-intuitive.
There is a positive benefit to inequality of outcome for everybody.
Some people become millionaires, and some become billionaires, but that is because they
were the ones who made their customers happy.
That's the economic system that has transformed our society in the past century and more.
That's what gave the Henry Fords, the Thomas Alva Edisons, the incentives to produce the
miracles that have benefited us all.
They went in with their eyes open, they knew what they were doing, and win or lose, we
society benefited from their willingness to take a chance.
If we did not allow a Lars Magnus Eriksson, a Thomas Edison, or a Bill Gates to become
incredibly rich, we would be more equal.
But Friedman would ask, would we be better off?
If entrepreneurs did not think that a possible reward for all the sacrifices they make, all
their hard work, all the risks they take, is a lot of wealth, then they might do something
else instead.
And in that case, we would not have the goods and the services and technologies that make
our lives better.
