Jews Are Turning On Israel - With Huge Consequences - w/. Peter Beinart

News - Fast and Accurate
1 follower
Nov 13, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
There's a really dramatic shift going
on amongst Jewish Americans regarding Israel.
I think it's one of the kind of phenomena at the moment related
to the ongoing genocide against the Palestinian people
that I really think is worth really looking into.
Now, there's no better person really
to speak about that than Peter Beinart,
who is a really fascinating and always thought-provoking writer.
Thank
People might know his book, Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza.
I interviewed about that book a long time ago
and also the crisis of Zionism.
And.
And he's also got a Substack, which I recommend you subscribe
to immediately, peterbeinart.substack.com.
And also Jewish Currents, of course, which you're...
you.
Are you editor? Sorry, I should have checked.
Editor-at-large, yeah.
Editor-at-large.
I don't run it, but I kibitz.
You're the kind of front-facing thinker.
One of many, yeah.
One of many.
Well, it's great to speak to you.
Now, I just want to start, basically,
with some really fascinating polling going on at the moment
in terms of Jewish Americans and the attitude towards...
Israel. I just want to start with this one.
It's really interesting. It's a poll which I think came out,
let's have a look, this week or a few days ago, last week.
And 80% of Jewish Americans say Israel's action in Gaza,
the West Bank, increased anti-Semitism in the US.
66% say AIPAC, the pro-Israel, the main pro-Israel lobby,
that is campaign spending against candidates critical
of Israel increases anti-Semitism.
I think it's really quite striking because I think that argument,
when made often in public, is seen as basically an outrageous claim.
But we're talking here about overwhelming numbers
of Jewish Americans making that claim.
And I'm just wondering what your thoughts are about that one.
Yeah, I mean, you're right.
This is what's so bizarre about this moment
in American Jewish political discourse is that
many American Jews.
Hold views that are not just considered wrong
by the American Jewish leadership,
but actually considered anti-Semitic by the American Jewish leadership.
So it's it's a very, very bizarre situation.
I sometimes kind of joke that, you know,
the American Jewish establishment needs to confront the very
serious anti-Semitism problem they face among young American Jews.
Right. Because the terms of debate that they have laid out
and that they are very adamantly trying to maintain just bear less
and less resemblance.
To the actual opinions of American Jews and the way I think about it
is, is that there has been for my entire life,
I would say, a fundamental contradiction at the heart
of particularly American Jewish politics,
maybe other diaspora Jewish communities, but especially America.
The contradiction has been that since 1967, Israel support for Israel
has been at the heart of American Jewish organizational life.
And so this is support for a project of Jewish statehood,
right, a state that has clear legal hierarchies between Jews
and Palestinians and that is an ethno state.
And yet that the vast majority of American Jews,
when it comes to the United States,
are committed to exactly opposite of those principles.
They may not all be raging leftists, but they certainly would
be the first ones to object if someone talked about making America
a Christian and democratic state.
They're very well aware that as a small minority group,
our success depends on the idea of a state that moves towards
the idea of equality under the law and tries to treat people equally.
Regardless of their ethnicity, race, et cetera.
And I think what's happened, and you see in this polling,
is that in recent years, a number
of different factors have essentially brought
this contradiction to the fore.
And it has led, especially among younger American Jews,
to say, essentially, we need to have
one principle that governs the way we think about
the United States and the way we think
about Israel and Palestine.
And that's what has kind of destroyed the kind
of pro-Israel consensus among American
Jews.
I mean, there's a big generational shift going on, isn't there?
There's a generational divide opening up.
I mean, to be fair, there's a place like Britain, the United States,
quite a big generational divide in politics in general terms,
but it's not specific, obviously, to Jewish Americans.
I suppose it's different
because actually Jewish Americans traditionally
are a progressive bloc.
They've never...
There's never been a majority vote for the Republicans
in any election in American history.
But nonetheless, I mean, you know, this poll showed 60%...
Not since Franklin Roosevelt, yeah.
Oh, yeah. Was that, though, because I think, was this back in the 30s?
Sorry, because in 45, I know there was the split vote
because you got the, what was his name, left populist,
which he attracted a big chunk of the Jewish American vote as well.
Yeah, just, you know, before FDR remakes the Democratic Party,
when the Republican Party is still more the party of Lincoln,
you know, then the Jewish vote is less partisan.
But certainly for literally less,
almost the last hundred years, you're exactly right.
So this poll showed that 60% of Jewish American voters under
the age of 35 say Israel's committed genocide,
and nearly half sympathize more with Palestinians than Israelis.
That is quite, those are striking findings, I would say.
And that shows, I mean, that would be unthinkable in terms of just,
I don't know, 30, 20, 10 years ago.
Yeah. I mean, partly, as you said,
young American Jews are also young Americans.
And so their media consumption,
like other young Americans' media consumption, is more social media.
And so this is the place where Palestinians have developed some
permission to narrate, in Edward Said's kind of famous phrase,
because they've been so locked out of mainstream media.
So that, I think, that helps to explain the generational
divide among all Americans, but also among American Jews.
I also just think the life experience...
has been different. If you are, for older American Jews, there is
There's still a notion of Israel, perhaps, as a country
that had leaders that wanted to create a Palestinian state.
Now, to what degree people like Ehud Barak
and Ehud Olmert genuinely wanted to, Ariel Sharon, we can debate that.
But if you're younger, right,
if you're an American Jew under the age of 40, let's say,
you really never in your adult life had any leadership,
basically, that wasn't emphatically supportive of maintaining.
Permanent occupation and apartheid over Palestinians.
And now you've seen over the last three years
that you have a genocide in Gaza that has
had very widespread Israeli political support,
you know, pretty much across the Israeli-Jewish
political spectrum.
So I think that life experience also helps to explain some of this.
I mean, just in terms of the generational divide,
just to spell it out, I mean, I said
there 49% of Jewish voters aged 18 to 34.
Oh,
absolutely.
I mean, it's almost become a kind of cliche,
you know, that just kind of like, you know.
Average Americans talk about how they, you know, non-Jewish Americans
say we can't bring up politics over Thanksgiving because of Trump.
And American Jews say you can't bring up politics over at the Seder
or Shabbat because of Israel.
It's so divisive an issue in so many families,
especially among generational lines.
When I wrote my book, one of the things that was striking
to me was that oftentimes younger people would.
Say I bought your book to give it to my father or my uncle
or my grandmother or something like that, you know,
in order to try to kind of puncture this generational divide.
I do think that young people do have an impact on older people.
Well, I'm I'm.
So I think that it's not that there's
no shift happening among older people.
I also think there's one important caveat here, because there
is a little bit of a danger sometimes, particularly with progressives.
And we saw this kind of in the Obama era that like.
You think a certain demography is destiny
and leading you to a progressive panacea.
One of the things that's important
to remember about young American Jews is that like Israeli
Jews, there's also a larger percentage
of that cohort, which is Orthodox.
And the Orthodox community...
There's a very, very different cultural environment
and a very different political
debate. It's not that there are no young
progressive Orthodox Jews. There are,
and there's some actually really remarkable folks.
But that community, which is rising in
number and in influence, remains very wedded,
not just to a pro-Israel politics, but I would say
a generally right-leaning politics about Israel and the United States.
I mean, just in terms of what this means
in terms of the broader debate which goes on,
because, I mean, for example, in Britain,
there's a very different context.
There's a much smaller Jewish community between
a quarter of a million to 300,000,
which doesn't have that same, you know,
kind of each election voting decisively for progressive parties.
And...
And I mean, in 2015, the first Jewish leader of the Labour Party,
Ed Miliband, was leader of the Labour Party.
At the time, Jewish support for Labour collapsed.
It went down to about 23%, I think, at the time.
And...
So there's arguments here about politicians
who have a position on Israel.
There'll be arguments that that presents a threat
to Jewish safety.
And, you know, that will get some traction
or broader traction amongst the amongst the broader Jewish community,
which is obviously, I said, much smaller.
Is that different? I mean, does this change the dynamic in America?
I mean, I can see polling here, for example, 49 percent
of Jewish Americans have a favorable view of Zalman Darnik compared
to 20 percent who have a positive view of Benjamin Netanyahu.
Yeah, I mean, I think the politics, the political dynamics
are different in the US and the UK for various reasons.
First of all, I think that America is different than almost all the
other diaspora Jewish communities, let's say, you know, and, you know,
The Anglophone ones, let's say Canada, Australia, Britain,
because our political right is so different, right?
American Jews, if you're I think if you're British
or Canadian or Australian Jew and you're pretty,
you know, you don't you don't like the left very much.
You kind of don't want higher taxes. You know,
you can feel comfortable voting to the right of center party. Right.
But because the American part of right has been since the 1980s,
so deeply connected to the idea of a kind
of Christian evangelical politics.
It's very difficult, even for American Jews who are not really
that far to the left to vote for the Republican Party
because they see it as representing a Christian America.
And American Jews are also tend to be very libertarian
on cultural issues, on issues like
and generally quite supportive of women's rights and LGBT rights.
So that's why, in a way, a lot of this fight
is taking place within the Democratic Party.
Because you have Jews in the Democratic Party
who are genuinely progressive, like Zohran Mamdani for a whole series
of reasons, including his views on Israel and Palestine.
And then you have American Jews who are in the Democratic Party
because they can't imagine voting Republican.
In some ways, being a Democrat is part
of what it has meant to be an American Jew.
But they're not very progressive in general.
And they're certainly not progressive
when it comes to Israel and Palestine.
And what you find is those people speak very loudly in the public
conversation, right, because they have more resources, right?
Look at what happened in the Michigan Senate race.
The whole conversation was so much
of the conversation was dominated by the attacks
on Abdul El-Sayed as being hostile to Jews.
AIPAC, you know, spent tens and tens of millions of dollars.
But in fact, as a political matter,
it ultimately wasn't relevant to most Michigan
People in Michigan, this wasn't what they were voting on.
And also, even a majority of Jews in Michigan
were not going to abandon the Democratic Party.
So in some ways, the media conversation here in the United States,
I think often amplifies the voices of Jews
who are not necessarily representative of American Jews as a whole.
I mean, do you think, I mean, you know, I mean,
traditionally throughout history, Jewish people have
been overrepresented in movements of the left, progressive movements.
One of the many reasons anti-Semites, particularly the first half
of the 20th century, really targeted Jewish people.
I mean, do you think, I mean,
we can see that in the U.S. currently in terms of the new left.
I mean, there's a big Jewish contingent in those, in leadership level
or within the kind of activist base of those movements.
Yes, certainly that's the case,
and I think for historical reasons, you know, certainly
particularly Ashkenazi Jews,
given their experience in Eastern Europe and Tsarist Russia, have
had an association with the left.
There's nothing, there's no guarantee that that will always continue.
I mean, Jewish religious texts have, you know,
universalistic ideas and deeply, deeply tribal
and racist ideas, just like every other religious tradition.
I think that the challenge, I would say,
In the conversation today
or in the discourse is that although American Jews remain very,
very represented in these leftist groups.
We are also in the midst of a kind
of cultural demographic transition in the United States,
a very natural and healthy one, right,
that you can see represented by Zoran Mamdani and
Abdul El-Sayed and a number of these members of Congress.
And I think this is, to me, this is what I love,
one of the things I love most about
the United States, even with all my frustrations,
right, that we have this history of people
coming as outsiders, claiming American-ness,
fighting their way through the front door,
And then basically saying.
You know, as Abdullah essentially said,
you know, I am just as American as you are.
But what's happening for the American Jewish establishment
is this is interpreted as the end of the American Jewish age, right?
That American, in some ways,
there's a little bit of a kind of main actor syndrome, you could say.
Like, we were the minority group par excellence.
We had so much influence over the public conversation.
And American Jews do still have a lot of...
influence over the public conversation, but in a very natural way,
we are now seeing that groups of people who came to the United States
more recently and have been subject to more vicious discrimination
and racism and prejudice, particularly Muslims, but not only Muslims,
are now in some ways starting to enter the public conversation.
I think it's a really, really wonderful and beautiful thing,
but you can see that there's this anxiety, especially
because some of some of these folks, for very understandable reasons,
are very, very critical of the state of Israel.
Do you think this matters in terms of the kind of legitimacy
of Israel in the longer term, in terms of the shift, given,
you know, I mean, Israel presents itself as the Jewish state,
the state representing Jews everywhere, not just in Israel.
I mean, that's that's it's, you know, in the diaspora,
about as many Jews live in the United States as live in Israel.
So if this shift continues, what do you think?
Does that have does that have an impact on that whole,
I guess, argument or claim?
Yeah, I mean, I think what you're starting to see in the United States
is a genuine effort to try to create Jewish institutions,
Jewish communal life, which are not, I would say, don't suffer
from the moral corruption of their support for the state of Israel.
I mean, I really think that.
Just like the Trump era, Trump for some American Christians has become,
or America has, American
nationals have become a kind of idolatry,
right, where you worship the state.
You see, if someone doesn't have an American
passport, they're basically worthless.
I think there is an element in the Jewish world
of idolatry vis-a-vis the state of Israel,
right, that the test of what it really means
to be Jewish at the end of the day is your
connection to this and support for this state,
right, and essentially a kind of worship of
Of the state, which is.
Idolatry is the worship of something created by human beings
and a state is something created by, you know, created by human beings.
And and I so I think we're starting to see really,
really exciting and energizing efforts to basically by mostly led
by young people to create Jewish life, which is separate from that.
Right. Doesn't mean that they don't care about Israeli Jews.
Doesn't mean that they don't pray facing Jerusalem.
But all of these things, you know, those things, a sense of connection
to other Jews, a sense of connection to the land as a place of kind of.
Messianic longing. Those are very separate than
the support for this state and its political system.
But the danger is we still have
so many powerful American Jewish institutions that bind their
notion of Jewishness up
with unconditional support for the state of Israel.
And this creates a very dangerous dynamic
because we need to tell people again and again
that Israel and Jews are not the same, right?
And we need to tell them that it is wrong
to take out your anger at Israel against Jews,
just like it would be wrong to take out your anger against...
Iran against Muslim Americans, anger against
the People's Republic of China against Chinese Americans, right?
It's a category error.
But that work is made harder when so many of the legacy American
Jewish institutions insist that these two things are one and the same.
And that conflation worries me.
I mean, I think it's such a crucial point,
something I've been thinking about a lot in the way
that Israel's cheerleaders have really doubled down on that conflation.
It's quite striking because, you know,
the the the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, which, you know,
has all sorts of problems, which I'm not going to go into now.
But but, you know, it actually it says correctly one
of the examples it gives of anti-Semitism, which is correct,
is holding Jews collectively responsible for the actions of Israel.
But yeah, Israel's cheerleaders have wantonly trashed that conflation
by arguing that attacking what Israel does is attacking Jewish people
because then it drives the idea when the vast majority of people
now in the West reject what Israel's done.
So that's obviously going to drive, you're going to make people,
well, some anti-Semites will be able
to recruit from that pool potentially
because they'll say, well, yes, correct,
this is representative of Jewish people.
Yes, absolutely. No, no.
And I think, you know.
In some ways, I think it's very important
for the Jews in this conversation, right?
Because it's, you know, it's, it's.
People will in bad faith take this conversation and say,
aha, you're blaming a synagogue gets
attacked. You're blaming the people
in the synagogue for being attacked. No, you're not
blaming the people. Of course, they should never have
been attacked. Of course, people should not
hold Jews responsible.
But if we want to make sure that doesn't happen, we have to be smart
enough to recognize that we need to keep
these two things separate as well. And I worry that
that on the American right.
Which is also where anti-Israel sentiment is also emerging.
Some of that is genuine, is motivated by genuine.
You know, concern for Palestinians, which is great.
You don't have to be a left winger to believe Palestinian life matters.
Some of it is about what's happened with the war in Iran.
But sometimes you see that those folks,
just if you listen to Nick Fuentes or Candace Owens
or Tucker Carlson, sometimes they end up suggesting
that the reason Israel is doing these terrible
things is that in some way it lacks a kind
of spirit of Christian goodness to it.
you know and that's where you get into trouble
because then they're actually essentially saying
that what israel is doing is because
of its jewishness whereas in fact israel is really
Acting like other settler colonies do.
I mean, there are always particular circumstances.
But really, the way to understand Israel is through
the lens of imperialism and settler colonialism,
not by looking, not by going looking at the Talmud.
That's not going to help you understand why Israel's doing what it's
doing any more than you would be helped to understand, you know,
what the United States was doing in the 19th century by going
and looking at, you know, at Christian texts.
Yeah I have to say whenever I see hard right
and people shifting or becoming kind of anti-Israel I
always think guilty until proven innocent
because if you're on the left you have a you
we believe in universal rights right all humans irrespective
and despite the attacks
on the pro-Palestinian movement
that is actually what we're driven by and that's just not where
these people are coming from they don't they
don't have a commitment to universalism.
Right. And so this creates, I think,
a real dilemma and a challenge for people who, you know,
who support Palestinian freedom because they believe in human equality
and they want a world in which states treat everybody equally,
irrespective of race, religion and sex, because you end up allying
with people in the United States who don't want that for the U.S.
Right. I mean, this is the you know, this is the weird dynamic.
We went through a long period where...
Ethno, you know, white Christian nationalists
in the United States admired Israel because they
wanted America to be more like Israel.
And we still have some people like that. But now we have
a different group of people who,
if you look at Tucker Carlson, right, on the one hand, he's
arguing against Jewish supremacy in Israel,
which is good, but he's still doing the great replacement
theory, essentially white Christian
supremacy stuff here. And I think that...
This is going to create a lot of, I think,
genuine dilemmas and strategic issues for
the pro-Palestine movement in the United States, right?
If you want to pass legislation in the United States,
you're probably going to need the
votes of some people whose worldview is somewhat like Tucker Carlson.
But you also need to make it clear, right,
that that's antithetical to what you believe.
There is also this tradition as well, a Jewish-American tradition,
which obviously got suppressed with the rise of Israel and Zionism.
I was really interested.
I read this petition to U.S. President at the time, Woodrow Wilson.
This was, I think, in 1919.
It was after the Balfour Declaration,
where obviously the British Empire
promised the land of Palestine to the Zionist movement.
But it was a letter signed by prominent Jewish-Americans,
including Henry Morgenthau Sr., who was the former U.S. ambassador
to the Ottoman Empire.
The publisher of the New York Times,
Adolf Ochs and Congressman Julius Kahn,
it's really prescient.
They said the Zionist project would jeopardize
the rights of Jews elsewhere.
They rejected Zionist assurances that non-Jews in Palestine
would be treated fairly under what they said was Jewish dominance.
They said the keynotes of democracy
are neither condescension nor tolerance
but justice and equality.
And they called for an independent democratic Palestine
with equal rights for all regardless of their religion and ethnicity,
saying this would transform the land
into a land of promise for everyone.
And as well as supporting providing refuge in Palestine,
who's fleeing persecution,
but opposing what they argued would establish
the state privileging one people over the other.
I mean, you know, these are establishment types as well.
These are not radical. But there
is that tradition that actually just got erased.
Yes. And also in the UK, if you look
at someone like Edwin Montague, you know, in the British
cabinet who basically opposes the Balfour Declaration,
I think one of the things that's
interesting and in some ways exciting about
this moment is that, as you say, there are these
various, I would say,
kind of lost or even suppressed Jewish traditions. You know, from the
moment Zionism emerges as an answer to the problems that Jews face,
you know, there are very
powerful responses, but a lot
of those responses have been kind of buried.
Some of them, you know, in the early 20th century spoke,
you know, were afraid that basically if
there was a Jewish state,
the Jews would be not considered fully loyal members of the states in
which they were. Some of them were religious responses.
There was a very, if you, you know,
a lot of the most fervent early opponents
of Zionism are arguing from a religious perspective
based on a particular interpretation of Talmud,
but also they're arguing essentially that
That nationalism is antithetical to Judaism.
And I think that's a very,
very important thing to recover in this moment where all
of these different religious traditions, Christianity,
Judaism, Hinduism, are all in some ways at
risk of being subsumed by these forms of ethno-nationalism.
Um, and
And yes, there was also a kind of left anti-colonial perspective,
which could see that a participation
in an imperial project was going to brutally,
you know, brutally harm the rights of
I think what you're seeing among American younger people
in particular today is an effort to kind of find this usable past
and figure out how to apply it in this moment.
Do you think it's quite an interesting phenomenon,
but I haven't seen much written about, but it's a great schism
taking place within, I guess, the global Jewish community
that the vast majority either live in the United States or Israel.
If we look at the polling of Jewish Israelis,
catastrophic, to be honest.
76% think there are no innocent people in Gaza.
Just so, I mean, just fascistic.
And that's become more worse and worse.
It's a radicalizing, hot genocidal hothouse in that society.
Whereas Jewish Americans are becoming more and more progressive
and shifting in a completely different direction.
Yeah.
Yeah, I mean, again, in some ways...
This makes a certain degree of sense, again,
because the American Jewish tradition,
as it relates to the United States, has largely been a tradition
in which you want a secular state that treats people equally.
And so in some ways, what American Jews are doing
is essentially they're moving towards applying
that paradigm more towards Israel and Palestine.
And I think they're doing it because they've been listening
to Palestinians who've been saying, this is what we want there.
Whereas Israel, Israel's always from its very beginning, you know.
They're different for, you know, whether it's secular Zionism
or religious Zionism has always been based on the idea that basically
this must be a country that where Jews rule and you should have
as few Palestinians as possible and that the Palestinians shouldn't
be allowed to challenge the fact that Jews.
I think the challenge, honestly,
is that or I would say for myself is that.
There are bonds of solidarity and concern and empathy
that I think are very important for us to maintain
and lines of communication and conversation.
Many of us who came to the United States
or families who came to the United States
could have ended up in Palestine, right?
I mean, it's important to remember
that a lot of the Israeli, the people,
the grandparents or great-grandparents
or parents of Israeli Jews
didn't necessarily come to Palestine
because they were fervent Zionists.
The United States and the rest of the world shut
their doors in the 1920s, continued.
So Palestine was really, for many people,
the only option in the 1930s and 40s.
And so I think one of the things that I that I try
to remember is that I want to maintain a sense of.
I do believe that Jews are a people
and we should have a sense of loyalty and obligation to one another.
But in this moment, I think that loyalty and obligation has
to come with a kind of moral challenge to say, we care about you,
but the path that you are on is morally catastrophic.
And, and reprehensible, and to me, fundamentally violates the core,
what I consider would seem to be the core principle of Torah,
which is that all human beings are created in God's image,
and that it is human, it is the right of human beings to exist,
which always has to trump the right of states
to exist under some particular political system.
Just on that point about Jewish refugees
who ended up driven to Palestine against their will.
I mean, really striking example of Bundists from Poland,
anti-Zionist leftists.
Who survived the Holocaust and then returned to anti-Semitic pogroms
and then tried to go to the U.S. or Britain and the doors were closed
and were literally driven, forced to Palestine.
They ended up there against their will altogether.
Thank
Exactly. This is one of the reasons historians say that, you know,
that Truman wanted to recognize the state of Israel because there
were still a lot of Jews in displaced persons camps in Germany.
you
The United States did not want to let them in.
The United States still was not open to allowing Jews
very
in even after World War II because Jews
were associated with communism.
And the idea was that if there was a Jewish
state created in Israel, then those people
much.
could leave Germany, Germany, that Germany could,
you know, the West German state could
be created.
But essentially, you say that the part
of the key point was still, we don't want these
people coming here.
Just finally, just more broadly, America,
the United States and the debate on Israel.
Well, what do you think?
How has it kind of...
Has a threshold, has a line been crossed now in terms of, because,
I mean, look, three years ago, before the genocide began,
you just could not be a politician who...
Basically spoke out about Israel
and expect your political career to go anywhere.
It was like a boat and a jet.
Yes.
Public opinion now has shifted very, very dramatically.
Most Americans have a negative view of Israel,
more sympathize with Palestinians in Israel for the first time ever.
And one poll show 50 percent think genocide has
been committed against 35 percent who disagree.
I mean, do you think now, you know,
because a lot of that is a kind of collective fear.
There's a sense of why would I speak out about this issue?
Because there's no political dividend,
but I'll just get absolutely torn apart.
AIPAC will throw loads of money to destroy me.
But do you think that spell, the spell is broken now
and you kind of, it becomes an exponential kind of, you know.
A place where public opinion basically is able to assert itself
and American politics will be forced to shift.
And even, again, J.D. Vance, again, awful far right extremist.
He was talking now about the U.S. relationship with Israel
because he's thinking ahead about where public opinion is shifting.
Yes, I think I think a spell has broken.
I think it's really quite remarkable.
I mean, one of the reasons I think that the shift has happened
so fast is that there were a lot of people,
especially in the Democratic Party, but not only the Democratic Party,
who never really necessarily believed the argument
for unconditional support for Israel to begin with. Right.
Right. But they were afraid they were intimidated.
And so once that fear leaves, they move very quickly.
Right. Because it was not really.
There was no there wasn't you don't really need
to make that much of an intellectual argument.
You just need to tell people
that they can still hold on to their seats.
And I think one of the things that Abdul El-Sayed did
that was really important is in the face of all
of this money from AIPAC, he made the AIPAC money the issue.
And in a way, he did to AIPAC a version
of what people like Tatarka did in Texas with Elon Musk's money.
It is very, very important
because America is such a vastly unequal and oligarchic society.
The disparities of wealth are so massive.
So the AIPAC is part of that within
the kind of pro-Israel Jewish space.
But we see it in general that the only way, I think, to counter that.
Is to go after the money itself and make the money
so toxic that basically when you take the money as a politician,
it stops being a political plus and starts being a political minus.
And that's what El-Sayed did to Haley Stevens and to Mike Rogers.
And in some ways, it's it's delicious to see in a way, because AIPAC
still has the capacity to accept to raise huge amounts of money.
But the question now is who's going to take that money?
Right. Because because taking the money, actually,
no one would have imagined this is possible.
But the money has become so toxic
that in some ways it's a political liability.
And that really is I would not have predicted that we would
be in this situation even a couple of years ago.
And just in terms of the weaponization
of Jewish safety by the far right party,
the likes of Donald Trump in overtly anti-Semitic ways.
I mean, he'll say, you know,
Jews who don't vote for the Republicans are hate them,
hate their religion and all the rest of it.
Where do you see that kind of heading?
And has that lost its salience or is it backfiring?
I mean, I think that if the Trump authoritarian project
really succeeds. And we have a kind
of Orban-style political system in America where
the opposition party can't take power.
I do think that it's possible that that would sustain
American support for Israel more.
That I've always felt like the shift in U.S. policy towards Israel
was interconnected with the question
of whether liberal democracy survives in the United States,
because it's liberal democracy that allows
a transmission mechanism between public opinion
If it's just an authoritarian or Orbán-like system,
it's kind of like whoever puts the most money in Donald Trump's pocket
is going to get that is the way the Trump administration works.
And so I think what's hopeful about this moment
and what happened last week is these two things are interconnected.
Right. The shift in the in the shift in the debate over Israel,
the fact that we're going to have lots and lots of new members
of Congress who want to put serious restrictions on arms sales.
But also the fact that.
This was a setback to the Republican Party's authoritarian project.
It's certainly not dead.
We, you know, the story is not over
and the story may play out for the rest of my life.
But but it was a significant setback.
And I think that's that makes it more likely
that the debate will shift on U.S. policy towards Israel.
I mean, finally, I just just.
I guess that's what I was wondering where you think
this is in what time frame do you think
it's realistic that you'd have a U.S. administration
which would dramatically shift
the relationship not not just you know like
not sanctioned illegal settlements type thing I mean
actual substantive pressure on Israel
which the U.S. obviously has massive leverage.
I think, you know, this is going to be a big debate
in the 2028 presidential campaign.
But I think if the Democrats win,
maybe even if the Republicans win, but certainly if the
Democrats win, I think you're going to see
a policy that is more like the policy of the
British government has.
But I think it's going to go further than that,
first of all, because it's not only
going to be because the sanctions on West Bank settlements, I think.
Almost inevitably have to go beyond West Bank settlements
because any coherent effort to stop the settlement project
from expanding has to deal with the sources of the financing
of the settlements, which are not coming from the settlements.
It's coming from banks, insurance companies, essentially in Israel.
So I think that's where we're headed.
And I also think we're headed towards restrictions,
maybe not a complete arms embargo, but at the very least,
substantial restrictions on the U.S. sale of weapons.
And I hope that Europe moves in that direction as well.
This creates at least the possibility of some change on the ground
because Israeli elites are not going to.
genuinely think differently,
as long as their plan B will always be to continue along this road,
which is a road towards essentially
the destruction of the Palestinian people.
And this will be the path that Israeli elites continue
on until it becomes impossible for them
to continue on that path, right?
And I think that we can see now we're in the foothills of being able
to see a policy from the US and Europe,
essentially that make that path impossible, and then potentially
create a possibility.
For some different future, a future that involves actual justice
and equality for the Palestinian people.
Very hopeful place to end.
Absolutely fascinating stuff.
Do make sure you subscribe to peterbaynard.substack.com.
Get his brilliant book, Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza.
It's a really compelling, thoroughly researched and humane book.
Please like and subscribe, leave your thoughts,
leave your comments, do share the video but honestly
as ever your work's been so so important during this horror
and thanks for joining us.
I'm grateful for you for saying that, thanks very much, appreciate it.
