Is the UK trying to renegotiate Brexit? | BBC News

UK Prime Ministers
23 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 27, 2026
UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said he would welcome an "honest discussion" about the prospect of returning to free movement between the UK and European Union.
In an interview with the Sunday Times political editor Ben Riley-Smith, he said a new relationship with Brussels could also include full EU membership or joining the single market.
Ben is in the studio to talk about what the PM told him, along with Laura, Paddy and Joe Pike.
AI Generated·May contain errors
So the Prime Minister's doing one of those things
where he says a big thing that could happen in the future.
Yes, one of his favourite things, as we were discussing.
Short-term things, little things that mean a lot,
lots of big ideas for the future,
difficult second album in the middle not written yet,
but here we are with another of these big,
possible long-term ambitions of the Prime Minister.
Which is to talk about return to freedom of movement with the EU.
Yes, which of course is unlimited immigration
of British citizens to the European Union, and vice versa.
And you don't need me to tell you that that was absolutely at the heart
of the noisy, divisive, difficult Brexit referendum campaign
and then the years in Parliament that came after.
So it's a really big moment, I think,
for Andy Burnham actually to say this out loud.
It could be a genius move
or it could open the door to more years of division and chaos.
We will discuss that on this Sunday's Newscast.
Hello, it's Paddy in the studio.
Hey, it's Laura in the studio.
It's Joe Pike, also in the studio. Hi, guys.
And if you are listening, not watching,
I have to say in front of me is corduroy and I think velour.
Well, look, this is not velour.
What is it?
I don't know. It's like...
Is it fleece?
It's like it's been in the wrong wash cycle.
I love it. No, I really like it.
I would say it's a sort of slightly fuzzy jumper.
It's not a... It's not velour.
And the smartest man in the room is Ben Riley-Smith.
Hello.
Political editor of the Sunday Times.
Hello.
Lovely to be here. The last time I was here,
I was wearing incredibly untidy Converse trainers,
and you both picked up on it, so I've come with my shiny black shoes.
We would never criticise their clothes, though, would we?
Well, I was going to say, you're dapper,
beautiful suit, shiny shoes, excellent socks,
and then we have my chums in fleece and corduroy.
Anyway, so the reason you're here, Ben, is...
Well, I've been interviewing Andy Burnham four times over the 100 days,
and it was in the fourth of those interviews on Monday
that he made these comments about free movement.
And these comments were?
I'm going to give you the comments so you can read them,
because it's your story.
So you read them out.
They're highlighted there for you.
Freedom of movement had very significant challenges associated with it,
and I spoke about them in my previous time in Parliament.
This is Andy Burnham, obviously.
But at the same time, it was a type of immigration
that perhaps wasn't as difficult.
As now, revolving door migration where people would come
and then go back is different.
The balance of migration has changed, hasn't it, since then?
I think we've got to have an honest
discussion about those things.
So he's basically arguing in free movement when we were in the EU,
yes, people would come here,
then they'd work for a few years and they go back. But post-Brexit,
he is arguing lots of people are coming and staying permanently.
Wasn't it better back then?
Now, we'll talk about all the issues around it in a few minutes,
but just take us into the moment, though,
where you're actually doing an interview,
because it's one of my favourite moments ever,
where a politician or someone you're interviewing says something
and your spidey senses go off and you go,
oh, that's a really big story.
But you have to be completely deadpan.
What happened?
Well, we're on the train to London Paddington,
Monday afternoon, rumbling around with the carriage.
Thank
And we've done three of these interviews.
This whole project was all about trying to understand him,
his politics, personality.
So we did a lot of kind of background.
But in this interview, I wanted to probe a bit more about policy.
you
And we all know who we've been talking about.
He has this loose current position,
which is let's have a big conversation about different options,
so
getting close to the EU.
And I wanted to understand, were there any red lines for him?
much.
So I said, staying out of free movement, is that a red line for you?
Kind of expecting he might say yes.
But he didn't say yes.
And he launched into what, to my mind,
was some arguments he'd been mulling over for a while
about why actually there's an argument that...
you could return to free movement
and even more intriguingly he did spell out red lines and other
things he said like I wouldn't adopt euro, wouldn't go back
into the Schengen area which is the kind of
area where you can move across borders without showing
your passport but he didn't say that on
free movement and said he spelled out
these arguments about the revolving door about how
his father Roy in the 1990s had benefited
from the rules gone to Germany uh to create their
mobile phone network and come back and also said
because we've left we're out of this um
biometric database called Eurodac that meant we couldn't
through the border. So it seems to me he had thought about it.
And I love there's a classic, if ever there were a classic,
Andy Burnham cultural reference quote
because he talks about his dad being able
to go having been able to go and work in Germany.
But he says you could say it was part of Auf Wiedersehen Pet era
when people were struggling
here. I think people have forgotten that in the 90s
and 80s people did have to travel to find work.
Now, Paddy, not to pick on you as the elder statesman of this podcast.
Not when we say statesman.
I feel a butt or something.
I feel a butt coming on.
But I feel he's saying Pet.
For younger newscasters
who haven't found it as a joy that it is on ITVX,
I feel his name Pet.
Yeah, so including the title, it was about travelling,
looking for work when work was difficult in your home country.
It was a great series that you can still find.
But the thing is that you said you did this interview on the train.
Yes.
And I want to talk about the third rail of British politics,
which was Labour said there would be no return
to this type of discussion under Keir Starmer.
Yeah.
Well, there's no prime minister in the last decade
who has openly talked about embracing it.
There is no Labour leader since Starmer won,
and I should say since he won,
because there was a period when he ran for the leadership,
he was loosely flirting with it.
But since then, 2019, there's been no murmur about talking about...
rejoining in any capacity, and Burnham has willingly reopened it.
And the Labour manifesto said in black and white, in big letters,
there will be no return to freedom of movement.
And, Jo, in the Makerfield by-election,
Andy Burnham, when he was campaigning to become an MP,
stood on the stage and said
we mustn't reopen the Brexit arguments,
that would be a dreadful thing to do.
Slightly paraphrasing, but that was May,
now it's October, and it's literally what he's doing.
And is this the ideal story that Number 10 wanted
to drop three days before the budget,
the budget which is supposedly going
to be about tackling the cost of living,
providing more support to people? Possibly not.
But as you say, also, a big sort
of gear shift from the man who said in May,
the last thing we should do right now is rerun those arguments.
I am not proposing that the UK considers rejoining the EU.
Now, the get-out from that, if you
were listening to Angela Rayner this morning,
is, oh, we're talking about not in this parliament.
And the heavy hint is, exactly as Andy Burnham did with social care,
what he's talking about is working up a proposal
that would likely be in a general election manifesto.
But a general election manifesto, when would that be?
We've got the polls this morning,
or last night, two opinion poll companies,
What's Ipsos, I think, and Opinium showing.
Labour, or suggesting that Labour
are eight points ahead of the other party.
The thing is though, this is an absolute gift for reform,
just at the moment when reform
were, you know, really been having a hard time.
Yes.
I mean, the thing is, this phrase, honest discussion,
this argument about Brexit was not categorised
in the honest discussion part of British public life.
It split families.
It split communities, it split the nations, the home nations.
Generated podcasts.
Generated podcasts, yes, yes, you did.
And Ben, whose scoop this is,
made the point that no British prime minister's gone there.
But it is, for me, fascinating as the general person in the room,
watching almost the manifesto being written in real time,
because all of these big ones, oh, the triple lock.
After the election.
Ah, free movement.
After the election.
But when Ben appeared on Radio 4 today,
I asked him for what he said about the mandate,
because he has said to you a referendum would be needed to rejoin,
but that anything short of rejoining does not require a referendum.
Am I paraphrasing you?
Yes, pretty much.
I said, look, just to be clear,
if you end up proposing Britain should go back into the EU,
should there be a second referendum?
And he said, yes, I think there should be.
And I said, well, what about if you propose?
Britain should go back into single market and customs union.
He said, oh, it's a bit too early for this discussion.
So he's not promising a referendum on those latter ones.
But as you were saying, all of this discussion
is pinned on the next manifesto.
So you would need to get a majority presumably
to implement whatever he proposes.
I mean, for me, the most fascinating thing overhanging all of this.
EU Brexit discussion is what is Burnham trying to do?
Is it a short-term tactic to unify the left?
Because if you look at polls, three quarters of Labour,
Lib Dem and Green voters want to go back
in. And if he's trying to grab all those votes behind him,
it's savvy politics. Or is it a
strategic move that he knows in his mind where he wants
to be at the end of next year? Maybe he is
sitting there thinking, I know I want to propose we rejoin.
year to make the argument to get the debate out there
and that's where I'm going to end up.
I don't know if that is where he is but that's
the kind of unknown hovering over all this.
Well it's interesting isn't it because
that's certainly that's how he operated in the run-up
to wanting to run as leader again right
so he all the time he would say oh I'm just making my point
about devolution or I'm just making
my point about the bond markets or I'm
just making my point about this and there were ups
and downs through all of that time.
But it did by the time that Keir Starmer was actually kind
of on his uppers, it created a sense of inevitability
that Andy Burnham was going to be the guy.
And that is a strategy in politics, isn't it?
As you say something, it sounds really shocking and people go,
oh, but then actually it settles.
And over time, it becomes something that kind of,
for your supporters at least.
It becomes a no-brainer.
Well, what was the reaction a year ago at a Labour conference
when he did all those interviews floating it?
He got slapped down by every cabinet minister,
all of Starmer's allies.
Oh, yeah, and they were delighted.
Back in his box.
And a year later, he's leader.
You're also in this slightly strange situation
where the Prime Minister is having to tiptoe around a document,
a 136-page document written a couple of years ago
with Keir Starmer's face on the front,
his signature on the back.
It's not just...
The tax commitments in the budget that John Healey is constrained by.
You were talking to Angela Rayner about leaseholds today.
You committed to sorting out that leasehold, as she called it.
It's sort of still not sorted.
So much of his...
Daily challenges are due to that document
that he didn't have much of a hand in.
But that is what people voted for, right?
Let's not forget that.
That is what gave them this massive, massive majority.
Or was it because the Tories had had disaster
after disaster and that's why they won?
But I was interested this morning to see
and listen carefully to how Angela Rayner responded to these comments
and whether or not she was as willing
as Andy Burnham was to jump into this suggestion.
This is what she said.
I remember the Brexit debates
and I remember the promises that were made to the British people.
Leave the European Union,
more money coming into our NHS, better economy.
People haven't seen that realised.
So what the Prime Minister is saying now
and what I want is that we have an honest conversation
about the facts of what the trade-offs are to get
a best deal for Britain going forward.
And the frustration for me in the previous debate we had
when we had the referendum
is a lot of those facts didn't actually get the airtime.
What do you want to see in the future?
Should we return to freedom of movement?
I want to see the best deal for the people
of my constituency and for Britain.
So look, I just want to be the person to say that this country,
the United Kingdom, has been arguing about this for 60 years.
In the 1960s, we tried to join the European Economic Community
and the French said no.
Charles de Gaulle said, no,
we don't want those dreadful Anglo-Saxons messing up our club.
With their corduroy.
With their corduroy, he added.
Then we went in, and to our listener of 20, half of their life has
been spent with this argument about the people who are 22 miles away.
And I think that's why, you know what,
there are going to be a lot of Labour MPs
in constituencies where Brexit was overwhelmingly the choice.
Who are going to think, oh my god, we're not opening this up again.
Now that may not be the majority of the PLP,
because a lot of people in the Parliamentary
Labour Party will be really pleased about this.
But there will be many people who are not,
who've just said let's not go back there and there will
also be plenty of Labour politicians who given a few days,
journalists will have time to go through
all the archives of what they said, when they said it,
exactly what they said about going back to
freedom of movement or not,
and more clips and bits of tape will emerge where people said of
course we'd never go back to freedom of movement,
the most important thing yadda yadda but this
It's incredibly messy for Andy Burnham after what most people
in the Labour Party would agree has
been a broadly successful first couple of months.
And I think that's interesting about whether or not this creates
so much noise that it knocks him off course.
And Paddy's point about Brexit fatigue is fascinating.
I remember in 2019 when the Tories came up
with that slogan, get Brexit done.
I talked to Isaac Levita, who ran that campaign for the Tories,
and he said it wasn't just for the...
Eurosceptics. It was for that other chunk of the country
that just thought, look, the decision's done.
I may have voted Remain, but we're three years on now.
I just want to make it stop thinking about it.
So while the polls might show that people are kind of minded
to go back in when you tell when you actually ask them,
do you want the next one, two, three,
four years to be dominated by this issue?
I think you might get different. And I think
there's an interesting thing, Joe, about that.
Andy Burnham was not in parliament during
the height of all the Brexit wars.
Now, he was there at the time of the referendum.
But in those years, 17, 18, 19,
when it was like hue and cry every night,
when there were a hundred people screaming
and shouting at each other on College Green,
seeming to be this sort of impenetrable knot
of political grievance on all sides.
And Andy Burnham wasn't there.
He was in Manchester by that point.
So I just wonder if that is part of it.
He doesn't have the same institutional memory
as some of his colleagues.
Yeah, I mean, people were screaming and crying
and in tears and all those sorts of things.
I'm not suggesting that's a reason not to do it.
And clearly, we're not saying whether it's a good or a bad thing.
But I think there will be, or I wonder, I'm wondering aloud,
if there will be a different attitude to this.
From people who were there every single day during that time
and I just think also for opposition parties.
On the right, for the Tories and for reform,
this is really, really easy for them.
It's such a simple argument for him to make,
a sort of betrayal narrative.
And this morning, we're just going to play you a little montage
of the three different opposition politicians we spoke to this morning.
We had Jeremy Hunt, Daisy Cooper then from the Lib Dems,
who are up for it, and Robert Jenrick will come last.
Let's have a listen.
Well, if I'd had any cornflakes this
morning, I would have choked on them.
I was absolutely astonished.
I mean, we have a million people not in employment,
education or training, young people.
And the government says it's serious about getting them back into work.
And to suddenly say that you are prepared to negotiate allowing people
from all over Europe to come and take those jobs,
I think it will be a hammer blow to those plans
to get people off welfare and into work.
We Liberal Democrats have been calling on...
On this government, to make sure we can join a single market,
join the customs union and get a really good defence pact.
If we can do all of that, and that includes free movement,
we can grow our economy, we can be safer, stronger and more prosperous.
Andy Burnham is proposing to open
our borders to another 450 million people
over whom we'd have no control whatsoever.
What would this do?
Undercut the wages of British workers, put more pressure on housing.
On the NHS, on doctors, on dentists, more challenges
for our communities and sense of unity and cohesion in this country.
And it's such a dishonest position, Laura,
because it was only a few months ago when he was on the stump
in Makerfield where he said he didn't want to open this whole debate.
What's he doing? Precisely the opposite of what he said a few days ago.
It's also a rare part of...
foreign policy that Andy Burnham wants to talk about.
I thought one quote that was really
interesting in your long read, Ben,
was when you asked the Prime Minister about the most
frustrating aspect of the office.
And he said the extent to which foreign affairs comes into
the day job. Now, immediately after saying that,
it reads like he slightly caught himself.
And tried to qualify and contextualise that answer.
But this is a man who really is interested in domestic politics,
not foreign affairs.
And he, I suppose, Brexit and the EU is one slight exception to that.
Yeah, maybe he spotted my eyebrows being
raised when he gave that response.
But yes, I said, oh, give me an example of what you mean.
And he said, this was, we were speaking
just after the Labour conference,
he said a couple of weekends ago, I'd marked out a load of time
Thank
focus and craft and write this speech
and my aides were coming in saying oh the details of
the Greenland deal between Denmark
and the US are just dropping can you get across those.
you
Now he quickly said that's the job I'm
not complaining Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer said
very
the same thing but yeah clearly instinctively he wants
to be focusing on domestic things more so
I think than Keir Starmer.
Also the Europe is changing we will look back at 2026 as a watershed
much.
A shared moment, really.
because there's a big election coming in many European countries,
including France, where Howard...
Sir Howard Davis was on my programme this morning on Radio 4
predicting Marine Le Pen of the far right
is going to win the presidential election,
saying he's going to have to get ready
for one of the big parent countries of Europe, which is France,
which would then be run by someone who's sceptical of Brussels herself.
Yeah, completely.
And what we often forget, and we did in the Brexit years,
there's a tendency in the British sort of chatterati...
To talk about the EU as if Britain can get what it wants
or as if it's all about what the UK is up to.
And actually, of course, what we saw time and time
and time and time and time again is the EU
is very capable of saying, well, I'm terribly sorry.
Off you trot.
You know, this is not all about what Andy Burnham wants.
It's not all about what Labour wants.
It's not all about what the UK does or doesn't want
in terms of a new relationship with Europe.
It's about what the European Union is willing to counter.
And it is pretty clear from their point of view,
whatever is going on with Mark Carney's
sort of special new friendship
that seems to be being forged as we speak.
The middle powers.
The middle power.
It sounds like something from Lord of the Rings, doesn't it?
Um
At the end of the day,
The European Union is the one that would have
the whip hand in any of these negotiations, right?
Not the UK. We couldn't dictate terms.
And interesting that Angela Rayner, on your programme, Laura,
did not want to engage really on her opinion
on freedom of movement at all.
But she did have an argument that she was setting out,
you.
which some other ministers,
publicly and privately, are also setting out,
which is about...
Why Brexit hasn't worked.
They argue the economy has suffered.
Look at the growth numbers.
Look at what this has done to food and farming.
She had some sort of clear bullet points
that she was trying to get out and communicate.
And as you said, Paddy, on your programme today,
Andy Burnham and his ministers
are flexing their muscles on Brussels.
I did say that.
I did say that.
Lovely line.
There's also, probably said by somebody else,
probably said by Laura.
But the thing is as well,
is that there is a tantalising theory
That the way for Brussels to respond is not with the muscles
that we saw when they dealt with it before,
but to give us the same entry as we exited on,
i.e. no euro, a veto, a rebate.
Well, you get the veto anyway.
Keep the rebate, stay out of Schengen.
So actually, a generous Brussels deal would
be seen as a huge win for Andy Burnham
if that's the mood that Brussels can get itself into,
which is you're rightly saying.
Who can predict that?
But there are other things,
though, when you look at the economy, right,
that could be really problematic.
So what does the government say all the time they want to do?
They want to get the economy growing.
They want to take advantages of AI.
That's a bigger and bigger part of the economy,
a bigger and bigger part of our world.
Look at the difference between how AI is regulated in this country
and in Europe, in the European Union, and then in America.
The regulation in Europe on that particular part of the economy
is incredibly strict in comparison to where it is the US.
I only mention this because
There are bits and pieces of the UK's economy
or the UK's position in the world
that have, post-Brexit,
allowed the UK to basically build a niche, right?
To be the sort of in-between, you know, the kind of in-between lands.
Well, this is...
Other Lord of the Rings sounding kind of things.
This is an argument put forward very forcefully by Jeremy Hunt.
I don't know if he made it this morning on your programme.
I couldn't watch it, but...
What were you doing?
I was doing something else.
But the thing is, he said I was a Remainer.
Yes.
But now that we're out, I prefer to be out.
And he gave his reasons why.
And there will be some people who voted for Brexit
who didn't actually mind the four freedoms.
They might have wanted just to push off Brussels.
You've got mission creep.
But I don't mind trading across an open border.
I don't mind going to France when I'm 20.
Though it could be that not every Brexit voter
is triggered by the four freedoms.
But on the other hand, this argument, as Ben put it,
it's just where no politician has gone.
And it gets so much trickier
when you begin to look at actually the specifics of
what you're going to propose.
So right now we're having this loose conversation about
maybe we'll get a bit closer if you're like
okay should we go back into the customs union
well that means ripping up every single
trade deal you've done since leaving.
the EU and I think generally that seems
to be a reasonably popular thing to be
doing striking trade deals with Australia and New Zealand in America or
if it's going back in the single market
okay free movement but also we're back
to the bendy bananas that Boris Johnson
endlessly banged on about you you are a
rule taker is that really what Britain wants to be again so when you
As we're going to next year, I think,
begin to dive down into the specifics, it does get rather naughty.
It gets very naughty.
Whereas what Keir Starmer was trying to do, which he,
in a very Keir Starmer way, described as, in not very exciting words,
like, we can look for more strategic alignment,
said nobody ever around our kitchen table.
But he was talking about things like,
can you just sort out the arrangements between vets?
On different sides of the channel.
So that a vet in Dover and a vet in Dieppe
is going to do the same thing to this animal
that turns up with it.
It's
We're talking Yvette Cooper, what must Shabana Mahmood in the Home
Office be thinking when they saw your front page drop last night?
All this work that Shabana Mahmood has been doing,
some of it largely successfully, even if, you know, Angela Rayner
and Mhairi Black don't seem to agree with all of her sort of plans.
I mean, what must they be thinking of basically ripping
up what they'd argue is their hard work and Yvette?
Hard work in recent years.
Yes, and on which point, actually,
and I don't know if either of you have heard this,
because I can't get anybody to do that useful thing
and actually say publicly that this is happening,
but I hear that the crunch meeting
between Andy Burnham and Shabana Mahmood,
the Home Secretary,
to decide what to do about the immigration reforms
is this week at some point.
Maybe they'll even try and have it on Wednesday
when everyone's concentrating on the budget.
As I say, nobody would...
And rudely, nobody would delightfully say,
yes, of course, that's correct, and say it publicly.
But that's what I hear.
So I think that is moving.
And that's...
I don't know if that means they'll announce it this week,
but the immigration reforms are meant to be coming
really soon.
And the important thing about that for us,
for people like me not following every jot and tittle,
is that it's thought that Andy Burnham may try and loosen
or water down Shabana Mahmood's stricter immigration proposal.
Yeah, and I mean, I think I may turn out to be wrong.
Often happens, I'm happy to say so.
I wouldn't be at all surprised,
and I think the signs have been there actually since July
when we first sat down with Andy Burnham,
that they're likely to do a carve-out for care workers.
But other than that, broadly speaking,
the reforms will be, broadly speaking, sort of untouched.
But I may well be wrong. I don't know what you would expect.
Well, Shabana, the Home Secretary in a Labour conference
speech stressed the need for fairness in the rules.
And that was widely seen as a kind of hint
that she will water them down in some way.
I mean, the most controversial bit is this retrospective bit.
Yes.
So it's all about indefinite leave to remain,
which is the point currently five years that...
If you're a foreigner living here, you're told,
okay, you can stay here forever and
therefore you get access to benefits and things.
Shabana has proposed putting up to 10 years,
maybe 15 years to some people, but it's the
retrospective that is really becoming
the point of tension with Labour MPs.
I do wonder whether she's still going to try
and keep some of the retrospectiveness, even
if they carve out just social care workers.
Because her argument, Jo, was that if you don't change...
There was such a significant influx of people
when Boris Johnson was the Prime Minister
that if you don't change it retrospectively,
there's going to be a very significant number of people
who will be allowed to stay here forever and who may,
as many, many people do, who may end up
They're receiving more from the government's coffers than they
do putting in in terms of their tax payments.
So she was exercised. I think it's
a £10 billion estimate, something like that.
Yeah, that was the number floating around.
Yeah, she was worried. I think she gave us
that figure actually in an interview about this.
She said, we have to do this now because
or else it's going to cost us loads and loads and loads of money.
And Robert Jenrick, who obviously has strong views
on immigration, was talking about...
Who used to be a Remainer, let's just say.
You did point that out to him.
Yeah, although he said,
I'd never thought freedom of movement was a good idea.
I like your question when you said, what, were you crossing
your fingers behind your back when you were supposed to remain?
Are there any former colleagues of Robert Jenrick who might ever
have discussed freedom of movement with him in the years gone by?
He was, though, making that point about the impact of immigration
on public services, on, he'd argue, depressing wages.
And, of course, on the benefits bill that the Conservatives
and Reform UK think the government needs to tackle.
And of course, they've said they want to and...
Will do, but we don't have much detail
of Andy Burnham's plans on that yet.
I just wanted to raise something which is a bit trivial,
but also quite important for British people who've been on holiday
about relations with the EU, which is this entry and exit system.
And is it really going to destroy the European project
to allow British passport holders with a biometric passport,
which is the same technologies they're using over there,
is it really going to destroy the Treaty of Rome?
To let Madge from Macclesfield go to Majorca through an E-Gate.
You know, what is the problem with getting British people
to use the European EES system?
I don't know. Maybe if you had your fingerprints done,
you don't want to feel like a burglar.
Well, no, but you get your fingerprints.
We've all been giving our fingerprints as we've been travelling.
Have you given your fingerprints over?
Yes, I have.
Actually, weirdly,
on the way out, because I failed to do it on the way in.
But, yeah, I have, yeah.
Yeah, because we asked listeners about their experience of it,
and it's just basically, it's like you
just give away three hours of your holiday
because they've got this delay trying to get into the thing.
So I wonder if there's something for Andy Burnham, an easy win,
when he does this meeting with the Europeans.
I think it's next month, isn't it?
Yes, November 20th. But I mean, the point the Europeans would say is,
why should the Brits get any special treatment?
I mean, you're outside the bloc. You're free to do other things.
Why should we give you a carve-out when all
the other countries need to show their fingerprints are outside?
It's a powerful reminder.
And if you want it, we need something in return,
which is very good at that.
All the clichés are going to come back, aren't they? No cherry-picking.
No, whatever, not the customs union, a customs union.
The EEA, is it more like the EEA
or is it more like the Norway or Canada?
Are you Norway or Canada?
It's Ben's fault.
It's Ben's fault.
No, my fault.
Amelia Cumberbatch.
Was there anything else spending some time
with Andy Burnham that stood out to you?
Because it's not, we should say, you know,
it's a great, this freedom of movement thing,
it's a great talking point, it's a really important story
that came out of your interviews,
but it's not that often that us humble hacks get to spend,
you know, quite a lot of time
over a period of time with a new prime minister.
Was he different?
Between your first one and your last one
because they happened over a period of time didn't they?
He wasn't especially different.
What was different is somehow trying to get time in his diary so we
kind of proposed the idea around the time he
was doing the Makerfield by-election.
We ended up having a coffee talking
about it before he agreed to say yes.
And then when you get to the Prime Minister slot,
as you'll know full well, Laura, you're literally negotiating about,
oh, we want to do a clip with him on camera.
Is it 90 seconds? Is it 120 seconds?
You know, he becomes so busy. So that's certainly true.
I think one thing that didn't change and is actually quite significant
to how he's approaching the premiership is he's determined to try
and be authentic and keep his voice.
Because he said in 2015, when he ran for the second time
as Labour leader and he was the front runner.
And he said, I felt like Westminster got hold of me
rather than me getting hold of Westminster.
And he got contorted, ended up kind of abstaining
on whether to support Tory benefit cuts or not.
Jeremy Corbyn got on the ballot, electrified the base, won.
And he was very burned by that.
And so I think he's determined this time to make sure
he speaks, he trusts his instincts
and he speaks in his own voice.
It's interesting, there's a line he says,
something like, I believe I've got powerful instincts.
Yeah.
And it's interesting because his whole style,
you see, in a different politician's voice,
a lot of people might read that or listen to that and say,
oh my God, that sounds so arrogant.
I must trust my own very powerful instincts.
But for Andy Burnham, somehow in terms
of his relationship with the Labour Party right now.
There is a little bit of a kind of, oh, it's all about Andy.
There is a little bit of that, isn't there?
But beyond that, he does seem
to have struck a connection with his party
because they think he's struck a connection with the public.
Yeah, and I think in a world where authenticity is everything,
Mm-hmm.
He is, I mean, the sort of change of position on the EU
is maybe an argument against the consistency point, of course.
But I suppose he's now back to where he was at the start on the EU.
He is, I suppose, in some way, people would argue, authentic.
But that comes with some sort of issues and problems.
And of course, yes, he says, I want to remain true to myself.
But he has had various missteps
on things like his response to Man City.
Thank
an issue in terms of football
in the north west of England
where you think he would
understand
if someone's found guilty
they're found guilty
yeah you think
his instincts would be
slightly separate
and on this
maybe he is being honest
and having
an open conversation
honest conversation
but also politically
this is maybe
you.
Be, um...
Well, it's a difficult debate
that he has suddenly pushed his party into.
I'll tell you what was interesting in one of the interviews.
We were talking about this,
and he explicitly made the comparison with Donald Trump.
And he said, look, obviously I don't agree with him on lots of things.
He essentially said the communication style of the president,
where he shoots from the hip, he makes lots of problems.
But he feels like he's speaking in his own voice.
There is possibly something other politicians can learn from that.
Well, and it's a confidence, right?
Right. And actually, do you have a choice between maybe British
voters have a choice between authentic politicians who.
And what is interesting,
three days out
from the budget, even
though we've not seen that
much of John Healey,
things are going this year far better than the absolute
I don't know how you say it in BBC terms,
but it was the stramash of last year
where you had loads of leaks,
pitch rolling on perhaps changes to income tax
and the manifesto commitment being dropped
and then sort of rowing back in a different way.
You can't blame Rachel Reeves and her team
for what happened around the leaking of the budget
by the OBR accidentally on the morning of the budget.
But the run-up...
It was almost a textbook example,
and some in Labour now observe it as a textbook example
of how not to brief and prepare in public for a budget.
And John Healey has avoided that,
even if the actual final product may not be to everyone's taste.
I was talking to somebody in the Treasury a couple of weeks ago
who said they don't want to blow the doors off with this budget.
They don't want what Robert Jenrick has done,
a term, the triple whammy of tax rises.
Everybody remembers Rachel Reeves' first budget.
A few weeks after getting in,
jacked up NI insurance for employers, big tax rise.
Didn't want to come back for the second year,
did come back with another big tax rise.
Andy Burnham and John Healey, it seems to me,
talking to people around them,
are desperate not to have the narrative being,
oh, it's another huge tax rise after a new PM's come in.
I think that's absolutely right.
But a budget, by its very nature,
is unusual if it feels like a small event.
And it's interesting,
some people in the Treasury are actually a bit annoyed
that there's been a lot of briefing from...
Various places saying, oh, there'll be nothing to see here.
It's still our budget.
Just if you missed it, yesterday, Baroness Katie Martin,
who was Rachel Reeves' Chief of Staff and Business Advisor,
would tell you off for saying what you just said, Jo,
and she was with us yesterday and she explained actually
how that sort of chaotic run-up to the budget wasn't really their fault
because they were stuck in a trap.
Where they didn't want to deny anything,
where they didn't want to confirm anything.
It's amazing.
They did decide to wait seven weeks
after the party conferences to do the fundraiser.
They did.
And I'm not justifying it,
but it's worth a listen
because she tells it,
she talked about that yesterday.
And they also had that very early morning,
that sort of 8am, 8.30am.
A breakfast press conference
with the Chancellor before the...
I think, to be fair, there were loads of traps last year,
perhaps more than there are for John Healey this year,
but he seems to be tiptoeing around them,
even though his team, as we saw in the newscast before,
are aware that a lot of voters don't really know who he is.
They have very little sense of him or his politics
because he's sort of suddenly appeared.
And even though he's been a big part of Labour politics for decades,
he's not as sharp-elbowed
or as self-promoting as some in politics, they argue.
And therefore, I suppose Wednesday will partly be about
Trying to maybe explain a bit more who he is,
as well as his sort of wider plan.
And I'm sure the sort of personal story of him may be part
of the narrative they try and strike around this budget.
Well, after all the drama on Wednesday,
we'll have John Healey with us next weekend,
trying to work out what it all meant.
Because often after the budget, there's a kind of Wednesday story.
And then Thursday, everybody gets their cash,
had time to get their calculators out and go,
You what?!
So sometimes, actually, as was changed by Rachel Reeves' team,
now the Chancellor does a big weekend
interview after the budget, not before,
so we don't have the silly dance of saying, I'm not going to tell you.
So we say, Ben, congratulations. Thank you very much indeed.
Thank you so much for having me.
Just before we go, and the editor has asked for this specifically,
and newscasters are demanding this specifically,
Paddy, I feel that you have been leading me on
with the promise of learning how to do a stir fry before Tuesday,
and I would like a cast iron guarantee.
A cast iron what?
That you're going to do it before Andy Byrne passes
his 100 days in office.
Yeah, I mean, I'll do it, but it's not going to be very good
because it's the point of this endless story about the stir fry
is that I find it very difficult.
They're very mushy.
They're not properly stirred.
But look, yesterday we even gave you the...
Flipping rice wine so that you could make it nice.
Okay, yes, I will be sending you some kind of evidence, yes.
Right, so video evidence?
Yeah, evidence of a recording.
We'll do that.
Well, what you're not allowed to do,
but actually now I've just given you the idea,
is get a delivery.
For real.
Put it in a wok.
Put it in a wok or a bowl
and then take a picture and send it to me.
That's very tempting.
Up with that, we will not put.
Thank you very much for pushing me on that and goodbye.
Goodbye.
Bye-bye.
