Exclusive
Is the CCP behind the US Election fraud? Why was General Flynn Targeted? - James Fanell

China Insights with Jenny
670 followers
80 Video Views·Nov 3, 2023
Hi, welcome to Focus Talk. Today we're going to interview Mr. James Fennell, a former
Naval Intelligence Officer specializing in Indo-Asia Pacific security affairs. His positions
included the Senior Intelligence Officer for China at the Office of Naval Intelligence and
the Chief of Intelligence for the U.S. Pacific Fleet. He retired in 2015, concluding a career
of nearly 30 years. Today, Mr. Fennell joins us via Skype from Europe.
Hi, Mr. Fennell. Thank you for coming on to our show.
Thank you, Jenny. It's my honor to be here. Thank you.
Thank you. So, there are a lot of things happening in U.S. today. Are you regretting
that you're not here, or are you glad you're not here during this special time period?
Well, as an American, I always miss being home in my home country.
Yeah, well, certainly there are a lot of big things happening in this country. And just yesterday,
President Trump gave what he called his most important speech on the election fraud. Did
you get a chance to watch it? And do you have any comments?
Yes, I did watch it live. And I think that, you know, we've been hearing since the election
about the irregularities and potential fraud in the election for the president on the 3rd of
November, and then the subsequent calls for evidence of this irregularity and fraud. And I
think yesterday, the president put forward very specific allegations and assessments that were
backed up by affidavits from many, many people. And so I think at this point, it's very simple
in some sense to be able to go and look at those allegations and those affidavits and have the
legislatures in the various states that he referenced, and have the politicians there
look at the data and say, yes, it's true that what he asserted is true or it is not. It seems that
it's very black and white at this point that he's laid out some specific allegations, given names,
given numbers of ballots, given specific actions. And it seems something that should be either to
be told yes or no. And I think the American people must know the answer to that question,
is what he said yesterday true or not? Because it gets to the very heart of the American Republic.
Yeah, we've certainly seen a lot of things in recent days, especially
with all those hearings going on in different states. So we'll talk more about election fraud
and the Justice Department's role in it a bit later. But first, I'd like to hear your thoughts
the pardon of General Flynn. President Trump granted General Flynn a full pardon just before
Thanksgiving. But, you know, back in May, the Justice Department already wanted to drop the
charge. However, one of the federal judges refused to do so. So what do you think of the pardon of
General Flynn? And why now and why not earlier? Well, I think the pardon of General Flynn is
a statement by the president that he is acknowledging that it's possible that he may not
continue to be president after January 20th. And so he wanted to make sure that he set the record
straight regarding General Flynn. Obviously, when the Justice Department in May, as you said,
recommended that his case be dropped, then it would be unprecedented in my knowledge
that a judge at that level would not say, OK, the case is dismissed. Yet the judge in the case
refused to drop the case and continued to hold General Flynn at risk. And as we now know that
General Flynn, while he was in this situation for the last four years, he had his passport taken
away from him. He was told that he had to report his location on a routine basis to lower level
officials in the government. He was forbidden to speak or write about his condition and essentially
in many ways was put under house arrest. And so I think President Trump also took this move in
order to basically give General Flynn and his family a happy Thanksgiving. But it is a sad
remark that a judge of this nature would refuse to drop a case, especially after all the new
evidence that came to light in 2020 when General Flynn was receiving new legal counsel and was
able to bring to light information that previously had not been revealed by the Department of Justice
and the FBI. Why do you think that they targeted General Flynn to start with? Well, General Flynn
was someone who was obviously high up in the intelligence community, the director of defense
intelligence. And he had a very clear and unconstrained view of what the intelligence
community should be doing. And he had written about it publicly, had spoken about it. And he
was someone that wanted to make sure that the intelligence community was not just going along
to get along, as we say, but was a community that was willing to break with the conventional wisdom
where the evidence showed. And that was his experience in the Middle East. I had similar
experiences in my time in the Pacific. And I had an experience where you speak truth to power.
And I know General Flynn had the same. And I think that any time that you come in and you're like
that, it upsets what they say, you know, in Asia, it breaks rice bowls. And many people get upset
and concerned that their area of control or their domain of expertise will be challenged.
And General Flynn was somebody that challenged conventional norms and did not take the answer
of, well, we've always done it this way, or we've always assessed it this way as being fact. And he
demanded excellence. And people sometimes don't like that, especially in the intelligence community.
And I think that background and that pattern of leadership that he had in the intelligence
community was threatening to people in the previous administration.
So in other words, he made some people unhappy.
Yes. He clearly threatened people in the previous administration, especially if you look into this,
what Attorney General Barr has just designated Mr. Durham as a special investigator to look into
what did the previous administration do to target and spy on the Trump campaign before the election
of 2016, and then even after he was elected. And so I think the fact that Mr. Barr, Attorney
General Barr, would designate Mr. Durham as a special investigator into that event clearly is,
in a way, a justification of what General Flynn was actually going to do when he was brought in.
And I think that's why the previous administration went after him.
So as a former intelligence officer, I think you probably feel, you can feel the obstacles and the
pressure General Flynn was facing when he was doing all the things that he was doing.
Yeah, I think at his level as a three-star general, the director of defense intelligence,
he was facing a huge amount of resistance from a cadre of people that may not have agreed with
his views, may have resisted him, may have thought that he was not an expert in the area that they
were an expert in. And many times people will fight back against that. I experienced similar
reactions in my career at a much smaller level. But when you challenge people's conventional
wisdom, either they are going to change and look at the evidence and say, I have new evidence and
I can make a new assessment, which is what you would hope and expect that an intelligence
professional would do, or you get people that dig in and say, I'm not going to change my view.
You know, after President Trump pardoned General Flynn, the media got mad. They said that this is
like an abuse of power. Do you think that this is a fair action for President Trump to pardon
General Flynn? Well, it's totally in his legal authority.
Obviously, General Flynn, if you go back and you look at what the evidence from the FBI said
in the initial investigation in 2016, at the end of 2016, after the election, and even before the
inauguration, and right after, the FBI's own records state that they didn't believe that
General Flynn was being disingenuous. So when it's said on the news that he lied to the FBI,
that's not exactly true if you look at the facts. And I think General Flynn,
his pardon was certainly warranted. But I think even worse is he should have been acquitted
as per the Department of Justice recommending that his case be dropped.
Yeah, it's sad. I think even in President Trump's speech yesterday, he mentioned something that
happened to him or happened to General Flynn should have never happened in this country.
So let's talk about the election. General Flynn actually, in his first interview after he was
pardoned, this past weekend, he gave his first interview along with his friend General McInerney.
In the interview, they talk about the election fraud, and they use the word treason or coup
to describe this 2020 U.S. election. General Flynn said it's a coup against President Trump
and that America is seeing theft with mailing ballots and theft with this Dominion system thing.
What do you think of their comments?
Well, I'm not an expert in the details of what happened with the election ballots using the
Dominion system. But from what I'm hearing in the testimonies, it seems clear that there was
irregularities in what occurred at these different locations and how the ballots were adjudicated.
I tend to focus on what happened in the six month period before November 3rd,
when many, many of the states, especially in these contested states or battleground states,
where legislation, not legislation, but lawsuits were brought to these states and said,
we want to make mail-in ballot more accessible. We want to get rid of the security protocols that
have normally been in place.
Lawsuits by whom?
These kinds of things that would ensure that the legitimacy of the election was maintained,
even with mail-in ballots. And these lawsuits essentially were brought by one party,
and they were brought to eliminate those protocols to allow more mail-in ballots to occur.
And these decisions, these lawsuits were largely adjudicated by the executive branch in those
states in contravention of the U.S. Constitution and even the state constitutions, which mandated
that state legislatures should be determining the change in voting protocols in their states.
And so I think in terms of constitutionality, I think there are cases to be made in these states
to say, why were these rules changed in the last six months before the November 3rd election?
And how many ballots were actually falsified or changed because of that?
So in that sense, I think there was some concerted effort by the other party
to change the rules to get more ballots in a mail-in environment with the virus.
Well, they have a good reason. They said it's because COVID-19.
Right. That was the rationale that was used to do that. But that still does not invalidate the
requirement for validation of ballots. It still requires, even with mail-in, that you have to
prove who you are. And we have many examples now that are being brought up, even in this last week,
where you have testimonies, affidavits filed where people are saying, I have no idea who voted here.
There was no security envelope used. There was no signature validation. There were duplicate
ballots produced that were exactly the same. We have a story today about some tens of thousands,
maybe 40,000 people that voted in Nevada twice. So there's a lot of questions about the validity
of these elections across numbers of states. And that cannot be allowed to stand. America cannot
continue to operate when we have ballots that are not trustworthy.
From all these hearings in these states in recent weeks, I feel, I don't know if a lot of people
feel the same way, but I do feel that there is a similar pattern, a pattern of election fraud,
voter fraud in different states. And even the timing, like when they stop counting the ballots,
even the timing is almost exactly the same time. So it does seem like there's some kind of a
coordinated efforts behind all of this. Do you think it merits the word
coup or, I don't know, treason? Are these words too harsh or too strong?
I think at this point, the word coup is something that I would just not even get around to using at
this point. First, we have to establish the fact that these irregularities did occur.
And when we established the fact that there was all these irregularities,
which have been alleged and filed, sworn affidavits, when those have been reviewed
and judged to be true, and if they are, then you can now say, well, how is it possible that this
happened in every one of the battleground states and occurred at the roughly the same times,
in the same fashion, with the same numbers of percentages for one candidate or another?
And when you have all that together, I think then people will start to say,
maybe this was a coup. But at this point, let's just do one step at a time and establish
validity of the facts. And right now the facts are on the table and they need to be reviewed.
And state legislatures going into recess for the Christmas holiday is unacceptable.
Fair enough. General Flynn also said in an interview that he believed the Chinese Communist
Party is behind this. Now, you were a former naval intelligence officer in the Indo-Pacific
area. You know China and you know the Communist Party's tactics very well. Do you agree with his
assessment? What's your take on CCP's role in this whole thing?
There's no question in my mind that the Chinese Communist Party wanted
candidate Joseph Biden to be president. They've stated that over and over and over again
in their open source publications, in their press from China Daily, People's Daily, Xinhua,
Global Times, and the PLA Daily. On a daily basis, they make reference to Mr. Biden and
derogatory reference to Mr. Trump for the last year. So that's a fact. The other fact is we
know that the Chinese government hasn't been happy about having President Trump, who has reversed
40 years of what Secretary Pompeo called blind engagement. I have called it the
engagement school or the Kissinger school of engagement, which I call unaccountable and
unconstrained engagement. We just seem to—40 years of unconstrained engagement. We just preached that
if we just engage, things will get better. For 40 years, we did that. America engaged with China
at the military level, at the economic level, at the diplomatic level, at the people-to-people
level, in social settings, in the NBA, and all sorts of areas. We engaged with China for 40
years. Yet China continues daily to threaten Taiwan's existence. They threatened Japan and
the Senkakus. They murdered Indian soldiers this June on the line of actual control. They built
seven artificial islands in the South China Sea, three of which are the size of Pearl Harbor.
They stole the Scarborough Shoal from the Republic of the Philippines, all while we were engaging.
They got to come to Hawaii for the Rim of the Pacific exercises. We did everything with them.
Yet they spurned our goodwill, and they continue to advance their agenda of the
rejuvenation of China, which is to become the world's global dominant power.
In the last four years, you had an administration that broke from that thinking,
challenged the conventional wisdom, and said, no, this is not good, and we need to stand up
and challenge what China's doing. Otherwise, we're all going to be living under a system
that we see in China, with a social credit system that tells us when we can leave our hotels and
our houses, when we can cross the sidewalk, when we can go to the hospital, when we can go to a
grocery store, when we can get on a plane and fly, a system that does organ harvesting that
has been documented by independent tribunals in England. We have information about a million-plus
people in concentration camps in Xinjiang. We have what's gone on in Tibet for the last 40 years.
So we have more than enough evidence to suggest that the 40 years of the Kissinger School of
Engagement failed. Now, people in Washington, D.C., and the think tanks like Brookings and other
places and Harvard, they don't like to hear this. And they are now pushing back because they believe
that they're going to come back into power. And they are already calling it the Restoration 2020
program. And they're going to restore the program that was in place during the Obama years with
virtually the same people that were in the Obama administration will now be in the Biden
administration dealing with China and telling us that we need to cooperate. And even today,
we had Mr. Bill Ovalt say we should collaborate with China. We should collaborate with them.
Well, so, yeah, I think the Chinese Communist Party regime certainly doesn't like Trump
administration. And they certainly have the motivation to interfere in the election. But
in terms of a direct intervention, lately I saw news that Dominion System,
or at least the company that owns Dominion Voting System, they received a $400 million
injection of money from a Swiss bank that has close ties to Chinese government. So I think
there's some maybe direct evidence there. I don't know if you have heard of the news.
I saw that report. While I live in Switzerland, I'm not associated with that bank. But what I
would say is all these reports that come up, they demand congressional investigation.
We cannot just allow this to come about. And let's just be honest. Over this 40 years of
the engagement school, we have built up a cadre of what they call China hands,
the experts on China. And these people have deep connections with Chinese authorities,
with the Chinese Communist Party, with their think tanks in the PRC. And they have an
arrangement where they go there and they go to conferences, and they get put up in nice hotels,
and they get to go around and meet people. And they then come back and they write these
dissertations and theses and articles for foreign affairs and foreign policy,
and tell us how much they know about what China's really doing and how we should follow their guide.
Well, that is a form of influence campaign. It's called psychological warfare. It's political
warfare that the PRC has been engaging upon the United States elites for the last 40 years.
So even if we don't even take into account the details that you've mentioned about the
Dominion system and the infusion of money, and those allegations which we need to look into,
let's just put that aside. And let's talk about the influence that China has had on the academics
and the elites in America, and how they've shaped our views of what's happened. We're told that
it's a myth that America lost manufacturing jobs to China. That was said today and written in a
report, that China's, the myth that China stole our manufacturing jobs is not true. Really? That's
a fault. Why are we accepting that from elites in America and Washington, D.C., when we have
so many people that are unemployed? Or what about the deaths from opioid overdoses and fentanyl
that's been brought into this nation from China? You know, in terms of talking about the influence,
this influence campaign, I think a lot of people from China actually
knows very well what Chinese Communist Party are doing to the Western elites and Western
politicians. But I remember once you told me a story about your personal experience. Is this
something that you could share with us? Is this the story about when I was in Hawaii?
Yes. Yeah, just a brief story. When I was still in uniform, I attended a briefing with the former
or the late Senator Daniel Inouye, and he received a military intelligence briefing
about what was going on in the Pacific theater. It was very much focused on military
activities and developments and capabilities and things of that nature. And at the end of
the briefing, he turned to the senior officer in the audience and he said,
I have this one question. In the previous year, how many congressional U.S. delegations have gone
to the PRC and how many have gone to Taiwan? And after some silence, because it wasn't related to
the briefing, Senator Inouye stepped in and said, the answer is there were about 10 to 1 to the PRC
versus to Taiwan, and it's been that way for years. And so what Senator Inouye was essentially
intimating in a very nuanced way, which is the Chinese Communist Party is influencing even our
government and our congressional leaders by trips to the PRC and shopping excursions in Beijing
at a rate of 10 to 1 compared to what we even hear from Taiwan. And so it doesn't take a rocket
scientist to understand that over years that has an influencing effect on the way our government
thinks and acts towards the PRC. Yeah. So there are certainly tons of things that warrant
investigation. But just on Tuesday, we heard from Attorney General Barr. In the interview he gave,
he indicated that they have not seen evidence of large scale election fraud that would change the
election result. But Trump's legal team, they said that, they pointed out that the DOJ has not
interviewed any witness from their side. So what's your thoughts on whether DOJ has done enough
investigation to reach this conclusion? Well, I think even the Department of Justice came out
after Mr. Barr's statement was kind of cherry picked out of his statement to the Associated
Press. And they said, no, we haven't looked into everything yet either. So I think what you have
is an understanding right now is that the Department of Justice hasn't really received
all of these allegations. And I think what's happening this week is they're now starting to
say, OK, here's specific, detailed affidavit information, and they have to look at it.
And I think time is very short before the Electoral College gets formulated here in mid-December.
But I think it's incumbent upon the Department of Justice to look into these allegations.
And if they find something that they need to raise the flag and say,
we can't go forward until we know more about this.
Well, at least many people just feel that way. OK, I don't know if it's true or not,
but they do feel that DOJ and FBI have been largely staying put. They haven't really actively
stepped in to investigate things, especially with so many serious allegations by all these
witnesses. And I'm sure Trump's legal team probably provided them with a lot of things.
Even Attorney Sidney Powell said yesterday that he will present with DOJ the evidence
she collected, but she does have concerns. Do you think DOJ and FBI may have been playing
both sides of the election fraud issue? Do you think they should have done more?
Well, I have a colleague of mine, a retired Marine Colonel Grant Newsham,
and he has done some investigation into elections in South Korea. And he's been
making commentary about this election. One of the things that he said this week is that
it appears that the Department of Justice and the FBI have no formal tasking, standing statutory
tasking to look into election fraud or voter fraud. And it's not in one of their primary
mission areas. I don't know if that's true, but it seems to be something that we need to look at.
And Congress should be asking the executive branch, let us see the formal tasking,
the formal statutory missions that are levied upon the Department of Justice and the FBI to
make sure that there is some authority to look into election fraud in our nation. Because if
the FBI and the DOJ are not tasked with doing that, and we're left to each, who will be doing
it is exactly right. Someone has to do this. And we can't afford as a nation to allow these things
just to go along without some kind of oversight. The concern on the other hand is that if you put
this into writing, obviously then you risk at some point in the future that some centralized
federal authority would come in and try to take over the results of elections. So I understand
the counter to that. But there has to be in the face of so much evidence, there should be some
kind of mechanism that kicks in that unleashes a task force that says, go look at these things.
Yeah, yeah, that's very, very true. There has to be a mechanism. So I think in general,
people are losing trust in some of these agencies. Even Matthew Whitaker, a former acting AG,
he said in an interview that FBI needs to enhance its credibility. So what's your
thoughts on this issue? Are these agencies being too politicized in recent years?
I think the appearance of politicization is certainly there. There's been polls out this
last week that said six out of ten Americans, to include Republicans and Democrats, say that the
results of this election, they're not trustworthy. So I think it's on both sides of the aisle.
And I would certainly would expect that if Mr. Biden has won, that he and his followers would
want to not come into power with a large majority of the population saying, I don't think you're
a valid leader. No one wants to lead that way. So it seems to me that it's in everybody's interest
to get to the truth and have transparency on what happened.
Yep. And I think American people have the right to demand the investigation and to regain the
trust, I guess, the trust in this fair and transparency and integrity of our election
system. I agree.
So one last thing I just want to quickly get your thoughts on is an interesting thing,
because we were talking about all this engagement policy and Henry Kissinger,
and he recently got removed from the Defense Department's Defense Policy Board. I didn't
know he was on that board. But yeah, a lot of Chinese people are very familiar with Kissinger.
He's pretty much the architect of this so-called engagement policy. So how do you
decipher the message sent by this action? Why now that the Pentagon removed these senior advisors,
including Henry Kissinger?
Well, this engagement school, as I call it, the Kissinger Engagement School,
it's not just in academia, and it's not just in the State Department, or it's not just in
think tanks, but it is also in the Department of Defense. And I experienced it in my career.
There were people that were very strong advocates for engagement inside the Department of Defense.
And I think with the shakeups in the department in the last month, I think you're starting to
see this administration recognize that it's time that we follow through as much as we can and get
a new blood in of people that aren't encumbered with this baggage of engagement. I mean,
obviously, Dr. Kissinger has financial interests in the People's Republic of China,
that's a known fact. I'm not saying he's on the payroll of the Chinese Communist Party,
but he has financial interests in China. And that by itself should disqualify him
from having representation on a board like the Defense Policy Board.
Now, I know some will criticize that. I've heard the criticism, which is to say,
well, if you don't have anybody on your boards of this nature that know China or have experienced
China, then how can you have a policy with China? Well, the fact of the matter is,
there's a lot of ways you can understand and know about the People's Republic of China
without having had extensive 50, 60 year integration or collaboration with China.
And so I think that it's appropriate that this was done. I wish it would have been done on day
one of the administration. There's a lot of people that were on that list. And as we discussed
previously, a lot of this, many of these changes that were announced could have just been the
regular timing of four or five or six year appointments to that board. So I don't know
those details, but whatever it is, I think I'm personally happy to see people that have had
the engagement school as their guiding principle on boards like the Defense Policy Board removed.
And let's get in new people with new thoughts about how to protect America's national security
and those of our allies and friends. Do you think, in terms of the timing of this,
do you think it has, may have something to do with the election situation in that it could be a mean,
a way to prevent classified information from leaking to President Trump's adversary, so to speak?
No, there's many other ways that an incoming administration is going to have access to
classified material. So I don't think it's so much about limiting the Biden administration,
if they were to come into power, from having access to classified information as much as it is
about the Defense Policy Board's purpose is to provide forward-thinking, out-of-the-box
assessment for America's national security. And when I looked at the list of people that were
on that board that were being removed, what I saw was they were the establishment. They were
the 40 years of engagement school. And I don't know why they were there after four years of
Trump administration, but it's not bad that they've been removed to bring in people that
are going to look at China with a different view than the conventional wisdom. Because, as I said,
the conventional wisdom has not put us in a better place. Asia is not more secure and safe today
than it was before these engagers started engaging. Things are worse today. If you're
living in Taiwan today, you're under the threat. I mean, we just had Taiwan Minister of Defense
Wu come out this week and say he's very concerned about a potential invasion from China.
That's very serious. And we should all stop and say, is China getting ready to invade Taiwan?
And what are the implications from such an act on America's position in Asia? And what does that
mean for alliances like the Quad and other things? And what does it mean to the global economy?
And what does it mean for our security of our people in America and our allies in Japan and
other places? And that's all been brought about by 40 years of engaging with China.
So if we're going to continue just to keep doing the same thing and let China continue down their
path towards their great rejuvenation, then fine. Then let's keep those people on that board. But
then you might as well get rid of the Seventh Fleet and the Fifth Air Force and the Seventh
Air Force and let's bring all of our military back to California and let's truly be isolationists,
if that's what they want. Otherwise, we need to stand firm and stand up for our core principles
and values of freedom and liberty and free access to markets and freedom of navigation
and equal opportunity for all nations. Yeah, I think we should have some true forward-looking
people, experts on that board who really understand the true nature of the Chinese
Communist Party. And I agree that probably this action should have happened earlier.
But thank you so much, Mr. Fennell, for sharing your insights on these important issues.
It's been really a pleasure talking to you. Thank you very much. It's been my honor.
Thank you. Have a good one. Well, that was our interview with Mr. James Fennell, a former
Naval Intelligence Officer. Thank you so much for watching our program. We'll see you next time.
