Mystery Files is back and the boys get to play with fire! Don't worry, the set is still intact.
Content Warnings: Fire related deaths
The first four episodes of MYSTERY FILES are airing now on WatcherTV! Use our 3-day free trial or get 30% off an annual subscription using the code HOTGHOULSUMMER30: https://www.watchertv.com/
No part of this video knowingly uses AI generated content or images. Though many industry-standard editing and post production programs have incorporated AI into their main workflows, Watcher is committed to paying our wonderful artists and minimizing the impact these tools have on our final content.
SFX by Audioblocks Watcher Logo Designed by Jennet Liaw
Welcome to Mystery Files, where we take a deep dive
into cases that span from the creepy to the truly bizarre
and everything in between.
I'm Ryan, and today I'll be forcing my colleague Shane
to hear all about the explosive phenomenon
that is spontaneous human combustion.
And in the end, you'll have to decide
if the mystery is solved or if it's simply a mystery.
Now, we've talked about spontaneous human combustion
before in our illustrious careers.
We have talked-
BuzzFeed Unsolved, back in the day.
We talked about a lady.
Named Mary Reeser.
I remember her.
And that was just one case,
a singular case of spontaneous human combustion.
Today, we're examining it at large,
from a macro level, if you will.
Boy, do we have some stuff in store for you.
Okay, I'm excited.
You don't look excited.
Yee!
And before we get into this, focus up here.
Shane, focus up.
Let's get those eyes open, ears open, mouth closed.
This one is a little disturbing.
There's gonna be some stuff in there that, you know,
just a little bit of a warning there.
People blowing up, I get it.
Yeah, so you might-
What do you think I'm gonna cry about it?
We're gonna blur things.
Oh, yeah.
Apologies to all the people watching this
who may be triggered,
who maybe have had family members blow up.
Well, I mean, we have at least four cases.
Well, hey, maybe they'll be watching.
Sorry if any of your family members spontaneously melted.
Case number one, Mary Reeser, a.k.a. The Cinder Lady.
In Tampa Bay, Florida, on July 2nd, 1951,
at about 5 a.m., 67-year-old Mary Reeser's landlord,
Pansy Carpenter, awoke to a loud thud.
Unable to find the source of the noise,
she went back to bed despite noticing an odd burning smell.
Later, when a telegram arrived for Mary,
Pansy decided to deliver the message herself,
perhaps using it as an excuse to check on her tenant
as she had been visibly upset the night before.
After Mary failed to answer, Pansy tried the doorknob.
To her surprise, it was hot to the touch.
When first responders arrived,
they broke down Mary's door
and rushed into the smoke-filled home.
To their abject horror,
against a backdrop of burnt walls,
melted electrical outlets,
and a mysterious grease-like substance on the rug,
investigators found what was left of Mary Reeser.
Her body had been reduced to a pile of ashes,
with her only remains being a single foot
still encased in the black slippers
she had been wearing the day before.
Did we see that ---- last?
Because that's a foot.
No, we did see it, but you're not seeing it now
because it's...
Because it's a foot.
Well, yeah, because it's a foot.
We don't want to show you a foot.
We have to pixelate that.
Yeah, but you can conjure it in your mind, a foot.
Yeah.
A bit of her burnt spine entangled
in the spring coils of her chair,
and what appeared to be Mary's skull,
shrunken by the extreme heat,
to the size of a small cup.
I forgot about that.
I like revisiting these cases
because I can laugh all over again.
You know, sorry it happened.
Objects surrounding the burn zone,
such as wax candles and plastic items, had melted.
But curiously, the fire was contained
to only the chair and its immediate vicinity,
which suggests that while the fire
was hot enough to cremate a body,
it didn't burn long enough to spread
to other flammable areas of the home.
Investigators were also unable
to find the cause of the fire.
To quote the FBI, quote,
an examination showed the presence
of no oxidizing chemical substances
used to initiate or accelerate combustion, end quote.
Though it is worth noting that Mary Reeser
was a habitual smoker and had taken
at least two sleeping pills the night before.
Now I will say, we did an entire episode
on Buzzfeed Unsolved about this.
And after reading that, I think it's fairly easy
to surmise what happened here.
Yeah, it does seem like that would be what happened.
I know there's a lot of unexplained other factors
around it, like the weird gelatinous substance
or whatever it was.
The grease-like substance in the rug.
The grease-like substance.
But that could be human fat.
I don't know, you know.
Could be.
And the other thing is, have you ever seen
a video of like a controlled burn?
Like the, sometimes it'll just be like
a little garbage can that's on fire
and that can like catch the ceiling
and then the whole room just goes up.
So it's kind of weird that like just her body
would be on fire and nothing else.
And I don't know how that would necessarily happen,
but stranger things have happened, so.
It's like a controlled burn, right?
Oh, you got some, you're like a pastor at church.
Yeah.
Look at you.
How many of those do you have
and how often are you going to be using them
in this episode?
Only you will find out.
Okay.
Is that insensitive to perhaps do that
after we talked about a lady exploding?
Maybe.
Case number two.
Jean Lucille Jeannie Saffin.
In 1982, the 61-year-old North Londoner
was sitting in the kitchen with her father, Jack Saffin,
when according to Jack, she suddenly burst into flames.
He screamed for Jeannie's brother-in-law, Don Carroll,
to come and help.
The two used water to put out the flames
that engulfed Jeannie.
But sadly, she succumbed to her injuries eight days later,
with her official cause of death
being bronchopneumonia due to burns.
When questioned, Don insisted he saw flames
shoot out from Jeannie's mouth and midriff.
To quote,
she was roaring like a dragon.
Tough break for the cardigan.
Tough break for Jeannie as well.
I know, I just think it's funny that he was like,
cardigan was ruined though.
Cardigan melted.
We couldn't sell it.
Roared like a dragon.
This one's interesting because I feel like
a lot of the cases where we read about this,
they don't have a witness.
Yes, in this one they say it happened suddenly.
So, what happened?
Good question you just asked.
Thank you for asking it.
Let's go to case number three.
Case number three, Michael Faherty.
On December 22nd, 2010,
Faherty's burned remains were found
in front of his fireplace in Ballyban, Ireland.
Despite the placement of the 76-year-old's body
and the lit fireplace,
investigators ruled that the fireplace fire
wasn't the cause of Mr. Faherty's scorching demise.
Some details from this case mirror that of Mary Reeser's,
including the contained nature of the burn
and the lack of any clear point of ignition.
But unlike Mary Reeser, Faherty's body was still intact.
Coroner Dr. Kieran McLaughlin ruled the cause of death
to be spontaneous human combustion,
saying it's the first time in his 25-year tenure
that he'd recorded such a verdict.
However, many experts criticized the concept
of spontaneous human combustion.
Mike Green, retired professor of pathology,
maintained that a source of ignition,
such as a lit cigarette, needed to be present.
Thus, not being spontaneous in that sense.
There needs to be some source of ignition,
whether it's a cigarette, some sort of flame
that's not produced from within.
That makes sense.
However, this coroner said spontaneous human combustion.
So my thought is, how easy is it
for investigators, firefighters,
to go to the scene of a fire
and conclusively say there was no cigarette here?
The cigarette, little tiny thing, how you know?
I would assume that there would be some trace,
but I could be wrong.
I guess in this case, you do have the fireplace near there,
but they're saying it wasn't involved.
But also, could they be bad at their jobs?
It's possible.
These three cases are far from the only reports
of spontaneous human combustion throughout history,
with the earliest report of the phenomenon
dating back to 1641.
Dr. Bartholin noted in his medical catalog
an Italian knight who drank so much alcohol
that he started vomiting fire.
However, other entries in this catalog
also included things like childbirth by mouth
and conjoined triplets with animal heads.
Okay, all right.
I don't know, maybe that journal,
I wouldn't call it a medical one.
No, I don't think so.
Imagine burping out a baby.
Oh, ah!
That's pretty crazy.
In 1725, Northeastern France,
Jeanne Lemaire drunkenly warmed her feet
by the kitchen fire, where her husband,
Jean Millet, later found her burnt body.
According to Dr. Claude-Nicolas Lecate,
based on secondhand accounts,
the blaze had burst forth from inside Jeanne.
From these testimonies,
Lecate concluded spontaneous combustion
as the cause of death.
Think about that.
I mean, if she's got her feet up against the fire,
he leaves the room, he comes back,
she's exploded, whatever.
Like, the most obvious thing
is that maybe she was wearing stockings
or something that caught fire and then burned her up.
Like, you usually say something like, my feet!
My feet, they're on fire.
Ow!
Yeah, like, my thought is the person investigating this
who is making this conclusion
is maybe not, like, good at their job.
It's weird for a doctor to be like,
she caught on fire from the inside.
And you're like, well, you're a doctor.
Tell me more about that.
And he's like, I don't know.
It beats me.
Boom.
Mr. Paul Rowley, a fellow of the Royal Society,
documented what remained of 62-year-old
Countess Cornelia Bondy, a known drunk,
after her death in 1731.
To quote, four feet distance from the bed
there was a heap of ashes, two legs untouched,
from the foot to the knee with their stockings on.
Between them was the lady's head,
whole brains, half of the back part of the skull,
and the whole chin were burnt to ashes,
amongst which were found three fingers, blackened, end quote.
Like the case of Mary Reeser,
the surrounding area was undamaged,
save for two melted wax candles.
Yeah, I wish people still wrote like this.
All the rest was ashes, which had this particular quality
that they left in hand when taking up
a greasy and stinking moisture.
Didn't even see that.
I feel like a human body would require,
you know, quite a bit of heat for it to,
because the body is a wet thing.
Yes.
Full of wet blood.
So for a human body to burn to the point of ashes,
you need so much, so much heat in a way that like,
something catching just by, you know,
maybe you got a cigarette or something
and it burns your clothes.
If your clothes burn,
I can't imagine it's just gonna burn your whole body.
Like you'll get burns on your body,
but it's not gonna reduce your body to ashes,
which is why I've always find this so fascinating.
The idea that it could just come from maybe a cigarette
or something in the environs is highly...
I mean, you know, maybe it could.
I don't know.
Fire is a wild thing, you know?
Let's learn more.
Let's go, and you know what?
Let's talk about some science.
How about that?
That's fine.
In 1998, the BBC program, QED,
conducted an experiment on air to find out
if the human body is even capable
of fueling a fire on its own.
They had the same question you did.
Same question you did.
On the show, a group of fire experts
used a dead pig to simulate a human body
as it has a similar fat content.
Look at me.
I'm a fire expert.
There's no name for that.
I guess it's just like...
I bet that exists.
They gotta learn about fires.
I mean, at a certain point,
they'll probably know all they need to know
because fire's not gonna get a software update, but...
Yeah, just looking at fire in a lab.
The dead pig was wrapped in cloth and doused in gasoline.
After about five hours of burning,
the pig exhibited similar burn damage
to the damage observed in human combustion victims.
But it was doused in gasoline.
It was doused in gasoline.
That's the tricky part, and here he goes again.
You know it's not doused in gasoline.
Look how exciting he is.
You know it's not doused in gasoline.
That's not doused in gasoline.
No, it's not doused in gasoline.
But what's gonna happen to it?
That just looks like a regular piece of paper to me.
This is just a regular piece of paper.
What could possibly happen here?
I don't know.
Whoa, yeah.
I gotta stop looking directly at that.
It's blinding me.
It's hard to not look at it, isn't it?
I know, yeah.
A more recent study in 2002,
also testing for human combustibility,
set amputated legs on fire,
published in the Journal of Forensics.
Oh, what's on the docket today?
Oh, got a big pile of legs here.
Yeah, we're gonna set them on fire.
All right.
I'm just imagining someone approving the budget
for this lab after time being like,
all right, look at this line item here.
It looks like you have a pile of legs.
Are you making a witch's brew?
My hope is that if I donate my body to science,
they'll be testing like what happens to the human body
if it gets like sucked into an airplane turbine, you know?
Yeah, just like, pull!
Holy ----.
That big guy went boom.
All right.
Published in the Journal of Forensic Sciences
by Angie Christensen, MA,
the study found that osteoporotic bones
suffered more burn damage than healthy bones,
which could explain why spontaneous human combustion victims
tend to be seniors.
The study also confirmed that a human-fueled burning event
would produce a low heat fire
that would be unlikely to spread.
However, it's important to note that both these experiments
require the use of an outside source of ignition.
And in the case of this particular experiment,
an accelerant was also used.
Remember, neither an outside ignition source nor accelerant
were detected in any of our mentioned cases.
As for the low heat fire explanation,
the legs in the experiment were never burnt to ash
like Mary Reeser or Countess Cornelia's remains.
So kind of how you talked about earlier,
it takes a lot to burn something to ash.
Yeah.
And add on that,
that there is no outside source of ignition detected
or at least figured out.
You know, I mean, I guess in Mary Reeser's case,
maybe the cigarette.
I don't know.
Is it the fat?
Is it like the human fat?
Does that fuel it?
Supposedly.
But both of those are problems
that don't have clear answers in all these cases.
Right.
While science may lack consensus
with regard to spontaneous human combustion,
other kinds of organic matter such as coal,
compost piles and haystacks
have been known to spontaneously combust.
Tracked heat generated through the oxidation process
and or fungal and bacterial activity
can cause heaps of these organic materials
to suddenly burst into flames.
In the case of haystacks,
water can actually increase the odds of a sudden inferno
as the additional moisture can create more insulation,
thereby trapping more heat.
Once the temperature through an exothermic reaction
reaches 400 degrees Fahrenheit,
boom goes the dynamite.
You gotta be on that.
Shit.
You're not...
Hold on, hold on, hold on.
This would have worked if you had...
I just forgot where I put my papers.
Boom goes the...
Boom goes...
Boom...
Boom goes...
Ha ha!
Boom...
One more time.
Once the temperature through an exothermic reaction
reaches 400 degrees Fahrenheit,
boom goes the dynamite.
I gotta stop looking at it.
That being said,
let's jump into the theories
of what could have caused these people
to suddenly burst into flame.
And as promised, before we get to the cork board,
I'll let you set one off.
Do we have scissors?
I wanna make a little, like a person shape.
That was pretty impressive how quickly you did that.
Okay, this is a little person smoking a cigarette.
Ha ha!
Here we go.
Oh no!
Just like that.
Theory one, the wick effect.
Proposed in the 1960s by English forensic scientists,
this theory is the most commonly used explanation
for how a human body is able to completely burn
without spreading to nearby flammable materials.
The theory posits that the victim's clothing
serves as a wick, with the fat in the body
serving as a kind of wax in a candle-like effect,
thereby allowing it to smolder for hours.
Both the BBC and Angie Christensen's experiments
prove that while this might be a reasonable explanation,
in some cases, it falls short for others.
For one, the person would have to already be dead
or at least extremely incapacitated,
which might have been the case for Mary Reser,
as the grease-like substance in her rug
was later found to be human fat.
But this was not the case for Jeanne Safin
or any of the other cases in which the victim
was known to be alive while burning.
Also, the theory falls short on explaining
how ignition would be able to occur
as there would need to be an opening
for the fire to meet the fat for the effect to take place.
Yeah, this feels hard to square with, you know,
the reports of this happening somewhat quickly.
Yes.
Yeah, it does seem, like you said,
it would take hours for this to occur.
It would take a long time.
And also, like, I guess maybe if you took sleeping pills
you wouldn't, but if you fell asleep
and started catching on fire,
you'd probably be like,
ooh, you can move around and such.
Yeah.
I would think so.
Stop, drop, and roll.
Don't forget about that one.
And it's probably been a while since you heard that.
Theory two, static electricity.
Supernatural balls of lightning have been theorized
to be the cause of some spontaneous human combustion cases.
These bolts from the blue could theoretically occur
in clear weather conditions
and could perhaps even be attracted
by certain individuals who radiate higher levels
of static electrical fields than normal.
In 1934, a woman in Italy named Anna Monaro
reportedly generated such a high level
of static electricity while sleeping
that she was said to glow blue at night.
In the 1980s, a woman named Jacqueline Priestman
claimed to suffer a constant barrage
of electrical phenomena with appliances
like televisions and sparking electrical outlets.
Though, neither woman has been known
to spontaneously combust themselves.
Even at normal levels, Professor Robin Beach
from the Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute
has claimed that collecting the right amount
of static electricity could theoretically
cause a combustible material to suddenly catch fire,
meaning that it is not outside the realm of possibility
that a static shock could serve
as an unlikely but possible catalyst.
But then you would need something very flammable, right?
I mean, yeah, extremely flammable at that point, yeah.
You ever do that thing where it's like it's night
and you're under like a fleece blanket
and you like wiggle around a bunch
and then you can see all the little
staticky sparks everywhere?
Shocks, yeah, it's pretty cool.
And that's why I wanna see that lady.
Did you explode?
I mean, I'm here.
Theory three, alcohol.
As far back as the 18th century,
medical science believed that spontaneous combustion
could be a direct result of an overindulgence in alcohol.
There was even an implication
that overweight and lazy women
were the most likely to succumb
and that a sudden burning of the inside out
might be a direct reflection on one's moral character.
Well, that's shitty.
You know, this is back in the day.
They didn't know what the **** they were talking about.
I think they exploded because they were ugly women.
While the amount of alcohol required
to make one's body flammable would absolutely end your life
long before you'd suddenly catch fire,
there might be something to be said
about alcohol's propensity to physically impair
one's judgment around an open flame.
And it is possible that certain spirits
could serve as an accelerant.
Would there be anything to, if you had,
like, let's say you had a Everclear or a 151
in your tum-tum.
Yeah, oof.
You make a bad decision.
You're drunk, you fall asleep by a fire.
Would that, being in your bladder,
by the time it burned up to that,
would that, would it just be like,
would you go up, would you explode?
I don't know.
I don't know, maybe.
I'm gonna say maybe, because I don't know.
Theory four, bacteria.
As stated earlier, bacteria in haystacks and compost piles
can generate heat when given enough water,
oxygen, and insulation.
Is it possible that a sudden outbreak of bacteria
inside the human body could do the same
under the exact right conditions?
Seeing as, in most cases, a high concentration
of bacteria in the body typically leads to infection,
like fevers and, you know, death,
this probably is not the most likely explanation
for a human to go up in flames.
But given what we know about non-human organic combustion,
it could perhaps be not impossible.
This is kind of similar to what you were saying before,
and it would be bacteria, but like I said,
you probably would get sick more so than explode.
Bacteria would be crazy, yeah.
Theory four, bacteria be crazy.
Theory five, a phosphinic fart.
Eggs.
What is this graphic?
That poor woman, she's probably just a lady
who went to some stock photo company,
and they were like, oh, just, you know,
she was, we'll pay you 60 bucks, just stand like this.
And she was like, oh, sure, that'll help me
put aside some money for my grandkids for the holidays.
And then we take her image, we've Photoshopped.
An atomic fart blasting out of her ass cheeks,
and her bending over going, oh.
How do you not know that we actually,
that wasn't the intent to begin with?
How do we not know that that was the stock photo
and we just cut it out?
I don't know.
You don't know that, do you?
Yes, we did.
Ma'am, if you're out there, chime off in the comments.
You know, if you know this lady,
let her know what's going on with her work these days.
Oh, it blew my scarf off.
Oh, Jonathan!
Phosphine is a gas generated during decomposition
that can spontaneously ignite when exposed to oxygen.
One theory suggests that naturally occurring phosphine
in the human body could,
through some abnormal digestive process,
escape in a victim's fart,
and become trapped within their clothing,
leading to combustion, which, as you can see,
can produce the Hadouken that's coming out of her asshole.
A mega fart, if you will.
While this theory is completely unproven,
it remains a silent but deadly possibility.
Nasty little piece of ----.
Get out of here.
Boo!
What do you think about this fart theory?
Oh, this one's interesting.
That's what she's saying.
That's what she said.
Oh!
I don't know.
I certainly can't rule it out
because you can light a fart on fire, right?
Yes, but isn't there the danger of it
going back up the tube?
I feel like when they do it,
they have the flame like right, you know,
they're usually sort of like-
Can you demonstrate?
All the way up there.
And they've usually got the lighter like right by it
because I think the gas has to be
like really concentrated, right?
Yeah.
So for it to fill up whatever sort of garment they're wearing
at that point I feel like it's kind of diluted
and then for it to then sort of linger there
on the off chance that fire
eventually comes into contact with it
feels a little bit of a fart.
I mean, it would have to be a pretty gnarly fart too.
It would be.
I don't really even want to imagine the sound of that.
What do you think about all these theories?
Which one stands out to you?
I think the ones that stand out to me
are the wick effect and alcohol.
And this has happened so infrequently throughout history
that it seems like it's maybe just not one thing
that's going on here.
I feel like each of these cases
is some sort of rare freak set of circumstances
that is hard to pin down.
Let me ask you this though.
Yes.
Do you think human spontaneous combustion is real?
I don't think it is.
Okay.
I think if it was real,
we'd probably have a better handle on it scientifically.
We'd also see it more probably.
Right.
That would be unfortunate.
While science may provide evidence
for how a human body can sustain a slow and contained burn,
there is no single satisfying explanation
with the power to extinguish the possibility
that a person is capable
of spontaneously going up in flames.
Who's to say that although rare,
the exact perfect conditions
couldn't somehow suddenly ignite
inside an unwitting victim.
But for now, we must accept that the frightening phenomenon
of a spontaneous human combustion
will perhaps forever remain a mystery.
So we officially don't know if it's not true.
Yeah.
But I would say it probably isn't.
I mean, yeah, it's happened so infrequently.
It makes me wonder if there are conditions
that are just so wildly rare that it could happen.
It could happen as some sort of freak accident.
Yeah.
Five times.
I mean, I lean on the side of it's not possible.
Yeah, because even in my opinion,
all of these cases,
they were near fire sources for the most part.
What if somebody murdered someone
and then just set them on fire?
It's possible.
But then they would still have to burn them to ash, which-
It seems like a lot of them were.
What I'm saying is that would be hard to do
without the proper heating conditions.
I don't know.
I guess that's why it's a mystery.
I guess that's why this show is called Mystery Files.
Thanks for watching.
We'll see you next time.
Now, perhaps to end this, we'll do a big one.
Let's do a big one.
I'm gonna let you do it
because it's frightening to me.
I'm gonna hold it right in front of my face.
I don't think you should do that.
I'm not gonna do that.
All right, you ready?
Look at this.
Yeah, that's nice, right?
It's a big piece.
We'll see you next time, everybody,
here on Mystery Files.
Oh!
It did burn my pants a little bit.
Why didn't that one go as fast?
We'll see you next time, everybody.
Is there something different about you?
I've been putting on numbers, you know, at the gym,
putting up those big numbers.
That's what it is.
I think that's what it is.
I've been working out.
That's what it is.