Is Justin Herbert Becoming a $262.5M Tua 2.0 Under Mike McDaniel?
5 Video Views·Oct 8, 2026
Seattle. Down a touchdown, no timeouts, the clock running out,
and former Charger Uchenna Nwosu comes free off the edge.
Strip sack. Game over. The Chargers are 0-4.
The man calling their plays, Mike McDaniel, made Tuatunga-Valleloa look elite.
Now he has a quarterback on a $262.5 million contract. Hold on to that number.
So here's the question. Is Justin Herbert becoming Tua 2.0?
Afterward, Jim Harbaugh was asked about McDaniel's job.
No, no, no. His job is not in jeopardy. He's a skilled coach, and we're gonna keep growing.
Here's how we'll answer it. What went wrong in Miami came in five steps,
and I'll show you each one, then show you where Los Angeles stands. Keep count.
Step 1. The Genius. Miami, February 2022. The Dolphins hire Mike McDaniel,
Kyle Shanahan's offensive coordinator in San Francisco, known for his run game ideas,
and NFL Network's Peter Schrager reports he's bullish on Tua.
Within weeks, McDaniel has Tyreek Hill, who becomes the highest paid receiver in the league.
The offense is built on speed, motion, and quick throws,
and CBS Sports calls it quick strike and motion heavy.
Notice one of the first calls he makes as head coach. It's to his quarterback.
My job is to coach you to get all that greatness out of you.
Now, Los Angeles. In January, Miami fired McDaniel,
and 18 days later, the Chargers announced him. People take longer to pick a couch.
Harbaugh had said what he wanted, a head coach of the offense.
At his introduction, McDaniel talked about Herbert.
He has it near the ceiling to what he's capable of. He can make every throw.
Step 1 is done, so put a check next to it. Same coach, same promise, new quarterback.
So does Herbert get the same ending?
Step 2, the honeymoon. September 2022, Baltimore.
Miami trails by three touchdowns in the fourth quarter, but Tua keeps throwing touchdowns,
and Waddle scores the winner with seconds left.
That year, Tua finishes with the best passer rating in the league.
The next fall, Miami drops 70 points on Denver,
and Tua goes on to lead the league in passing yards.
Remember how good that looked? The story writes itself.
McDaniel's system makes a quarterback look elite.
Now, Los Angeles. At the scouting combine,
general manager Joe Hortiz said McDaniel would build his offense around the players they have,
and then he made a prediction.
I think Justin's gonna take off in it.
Miami's honeymoon lasted about two seasons.
Take a guess how long Los Angeles got. Not even one game.
At home against Arizona, the Chargers were the biggest favorites on the board, and they lost.
That honeymoon was shorter than most wedding toasts.
Herbert was sacked on fourth and goal before halftime,
and a blocked punt set up an Arizona touchdown. Check. Sort of.
But is that a Herbert problem or an offense problem?
Hold that thought, because Step 3 tells us a lot.
Step 3, the blueprint.
Every great offense gets figured out, and Herbert's own team drew up the first blueprint.
December 2022, Sunday night.
Brandon Staley's Chargers press Miami's receivers at the line.
Right in their faces.
Tua can't get anything going.
Herbert, on the other side, carves Miami up, and the Chargers hold on.
ESPN's Dan Orlovsky calls it the blueprint to stop this Miami offense,
and it's one of five straight losses for Miami.
The best way to stop a genius, it turns out, is to stand very close to him.
It doesn't stop there.
The next year, Miami almost never beats a good team.
And then comes a playoff game at Kansas City, in cold that makes the record books.
Now, Los Angeles.
In Seattle, the Seahawks pressured Herbert on most of his dropbacks,
and this offense lives on quick throws.
The Athletic found that Tua got the ball out fast far more often in his best year
than Herbert did through three games.
Russell Wilson, on a CBS Sports podcast, pointed to what McDaniel had in Miami.
His verdict?
That's not really how Justin Herbert plays.
So here's the problem.
This offense runs on timing.
And when the protection breaks, the timing breaks.
You can't run Tua's offense with a quarterback who doesn't play like Tua.
Check.
With a caveat.
It's early.
But ask yourself this.
If the offense was built for Tua, who is it being built for now?
Step 4.
The turnovers.
October 2025.
Herbert's Chargers beat Miami.
Tua throws three interceptions, and then he points at his teammates.
We have guys showing up to player-only meetings late.
Guys not showing up to player-only meetings.
Days later, he apologizes.
Miami fires its general manager.
But McDaniel stays.
And it gets worse anyway.
Miami benches Tua, the league leader in interceptions at that point,
for a late-round rookie.
And McDaniel explains.
I think Quinn gives this team the best chance to win.
That's Miami's side of Step 4.
Now, Los Angeles.
Against the Raiders, fumble after fumble.
At Buffalo, the Chargers force five turnovers and still lose
after a Herbert goal-line throw is intercepted.
Tom Brady, on the broadcast, criticized the red zone calls.
You don't deserve to win if you can't punch it in.
Before the Seattle game, McDaniel met reporters.
I'm not living in hope.
I'm living in reality.
That may be the least-spun sentence of the season.
Then came Seattle.
Herbert throws an interception on the first play, and another before halftime.
A muffed punt.
A strip-sack.
And the Chargers keep finding new ways to hand the ball away.
Through four games, he's the first Chargers quarterback since Ryan Leaf,
with that many interceptions and sacks.
Take a guess where he ranks in passer rating among qualifying quarterbacks.
Last?
Close.
Second to last.
After the loss, Herbert had every chance to point a finger.
You'd think he would, right?
I think Mike is the greatest, and I want to make him proud.
I gotta go make plays out there, and haven't done that.
Think about that.
Tua pointed at his teammates, but Herbert points at himself,
and at the coach he wants to make proud.
That's a real difference.
The turnovers, though?
They look the same.
Step four?
Check.
Which leaves the step that costs money, and the question of who ends up paying.
Step five.
The bill.
And Miami has already paid it.
Miami fires McDaniel.
Owner Steven Ross calls him an incredibly creative football mind,
and says the team needs comprehensive change.
Then Miami announces it's releasing Tua.
Remember this number.
$99.2 million.
That's an NFL record for dead cap.
Money Miami eats for a quarterback who is gone.
And Miami still pays Tua $54 million this season,
while Atlanta pays him the veteran minimum.
He got hurt before week one, and now he's Michael Pennix Jr.'s backup.
As of the latest reports, he hasn't thrown a regular season pass for the Falcons.
Lessons are expensive, and this one came with a record.
Now imagine Los Angeles in that spot.
It hasn't reached step five yet, but look at the playoffs.
Herbert is 0-3.
At Houston, he threw more interceptions in one game than in the entire regular season.
I let the team down, and you can't turn over the ball like that
A year later at New England, the Chargers scored only a field goal.
Asked about winning a playoff game, Herbert said this.
Yeah, I don't know.
I haven't figured it out yet, and it hasn't happened.
Meanwhile, the bill keeps growing.
Herbert's cap hit rises past $71 million.
So here's your count.
Genius hire?
Check.
Honeymoon?
Sort of.
Blueprint?
Early, but check.
Turnovers?
Check.
Call it four of five, with an asterisk.
The fifth is the bill, and Los Angeles' starts from a bigger number.
But let's be fair, because there's a real case that Herbert is not Tua.
Start with the arm.
Herbert has thrown for more than 5,000 yards in a season,
and last year, he played through a broken hand.
His left, not his throwing hand.
Then, the line.
ESPN counted four rookies on it at once in Seattle,
and Joe Alt, Rashawn Slater, and Trevor Penning all left hurt.
And Tua had help.
ESPN's Dan Graziano points out that Tua had Hill, Waddle, and A-chain.
Herbert doesn't have that.
Harbaugh made the case for his quarterback, too,
saying there's no player he's ever coached that he respects more.
One of the real grittiest performances I've been associated with from a quarterback.
Here's where I land.
I don't think Herbert is finished.
And I don't think it's Tua 2.0, case closed.
Herbert isn't Tua.
He has more arm, more size, more upside.
And that's hardly a hot take.
The Chargers made him one of the highest-paid players in the league for a reason.
But he's in McDaniel's system, getting the kind of results Tua got at the end.
And so far, the system hasn't bent to him.
That's the scary part.
So the real question isn't whether Herbert is Tua.
It's whether McDaniel can build something that isn't.
The lesson Miami learned?
A quarterback and a system have to fit.
And a big contract doesn't make them fit.
Miami signed a $212 million contract to learn that lesson.
And Los Angeles has $262.5 million riding on the same test.
The difference is that Miami only found out at the end.
Los Angeles still has time to change the ending.
History says it's possible, but barely.
The 1992 Chargers are the only team in NFL history
to make the playoffs after an 0-4 start.
So, is Justin Herbert the problem, or is it McDaniel's system?
Is this Tua 2.0?
Tell us in the comments.

