#DonaldTrump#JDVance#IranWar Donald Trump and JD Vance are raising questions about the Iran war, MAGA, and the 2028 presidential election after Republicans' losses in the 2026 midterms. Is a political disagreement emerging between the president and his potential successor?
National Review's Rich Lowry examines why JD Vance blamed the Iran war for Republican losses while Trump continues to defend the military campaign. But was the war really responsible, or did inflation, tariffs, and the cost of living play a bigger role?
Rich explores what this disagreement could mean for Trump's political legacy, Vance's 2028 ambitions, and the future of MAGA.
Could the Iran war become JD Vance's biggest political challenge? Let us know what you think.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Rich Lowry analyzes the growing tension between Donald Trump and J.D. Vance over the war in Iran. While Vance claims the conflict was the primary cause of Republican midterm losses, Trump maintains the decision was a historical necessity. This ideological rift over foreign intervention signals a passive-aggressive struggle that could impact the future of the MAGA movement and the 2028 nomination.
Hey everyone, are J.D. Vance
and Donald Trump headed for a big crack-up?
Has J.D. Vance's comments about Iran,
questioning some of those messages,
has that impacted your relationship at all?
No, not at all, but a lot of people didn't like
his comments, but not me.
He was right. Other than one thing,
he should have made one other statement, one
statement that I think is very important.
If you had it to do again, would you do it again?
The answer is yes. I'm Rich Lowry of National Review.
And of course, that was the president
of the United States at the airport named
for himself in West Palm Beach, Florida,
talking to reporters about this.
J.D. Vance, ex-post from last week,
advancing Vance's theory for why Republicans got shellacked
in the midterms, largely because of the Iran war.
And I think this is worth dwelling on because
Trump and Vance, this is the most fraught,
interesting and important relationship in
Republican national politics at the moment,
arguably in national politics in toto. And what
we heard from Trump there, by no means is he blowing J.D. Vance out
of the water, but you can hear a little discontent.
And he says what he wants to hear from Vance in the future
on this is that if they had it to do over again,
it would be the right decision to bomb Iran once again.
So what I want to do in this video is to go back
to that J.D. Vance X post, which was so important and interesting,
and get to what was good about it,
what was bad about it, what makes sense, what doesn't.
Get to how it creates this potential fissure
with the president of the United States and how
that potentially could blow up their relationship
and change the whole 2028
Republican nomination battle.
So first, let's go to the J.D. Vance post. So the day after the
election, Vance posted this.
He said, actually, the Republican turnout wasn't so bad, but.
the problem was that former Trump Vance voters
from 2024 were voting for Democrats this time
around.
That's contested.
Turnout was a huge problem for Republicans,
but that's not the main issue here.
Then he goes on to say there'll be a lot
of infighting and arguing over what happened
and why that is.
One of the pollsters I really respect told me
that her economic messaging wasn't sharp
enough down the stretch.
Yeah, obvious, right?
But the real reason we lost is,
speaking of obvious, obvious to almost everyone.
Another pollster I trust said we're going to lose by 13 points.
That turned out to be right.
In his polling, he saw that a lot
of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote
for Democrats.
He asked those voters who had abandoned us
what would cause them to come back into the
fold.
Top four answers, end the war,
focus on the cost of living and inflation, put America
first, and change our relationship to Israel.
So if you look at just that portion of the post,
he's making a very particular claim.
There's this segment of voters that were key.
Trump 2024, Democrats 2026, this pollster asked them this question,
What would make you come back?
And he gets these answers. Now, I don't think Vance
is making this up, but we don't know who
the pollster is. We don't know what the margin
of error was on this poll. We don't know how
specifically how the question was asked. We don't know the methodology.
So it's kind of a black box there.
And Vance certainly wants this interpretation
to stand in for his broadest case for what
went wrong in the 2026 election.
And here, I think he's too simplistic, too monocausal.
So let's look at what happened
to Trump's approval ratings over time during his second
term.
All right, so this is a chart of the president's approval rating.
You look at the dark.
Red line there on the bottom. That's his approval rating going down.
And the key inflection point is a liberation day.
So he announces with great fanfare tariffs on nearly everyone.
Rationals all over the place.
This is unsustainable. He backs off in part.
But this is not a great moment for him. And he's going down ever.
Since I should stipulate right at the top here that every president's
approval rating goes down over time unless there's some enormous crisis
or enormous black swan event. So you expect you get elected.
You're kind of popular. You wouldn't get elected in the first place.
Then you start to do things and you go down.
And that's what's happening to Trump.
But the first inflection point is the tariffs.
Then you look at it. It's.
Pretty much straight down, but we have another
inflection point, arguably here with the Iran
war, seems to go down a little bit more.
But if you squint and look at this, if you didn't know
any of these events were happening, you just say it's going down.
So this is all counterfactual,
but my guess is without the Iran war,
his approval rating would have plateaued at some
higher level. You have to consider the Iran war, it was a war.
of discretion, at least at a certain level.
There's no reason the president had to launch it
specifically on February 28th. And he hasn't won it.
At least he hasn't won it yet. So you just
you launch a war of choice. You don't win it.
That's not going to go over well. And then on
top of that, of course, you have the disruption
and the Strait of Hormuz. So you get gas prices
going up, diesel prices going up, fertilizer prices going up.
In the months prior to midterm
election, that's not going to be great for you anyway.
Obviously, that is going to hurt.
at a certain level. Another way to quantify
this is to look at polling showing what people said
they cared about during the election.
So this is a post from my friend Byron York over the
Washington Examiner pointing out the percentage of voters
who told exit polls that they ranked
a particular issue as crucial
or major in terms of determining their vote. You have 90%
It's a government corruption. 56% of those voted Democratic.
You have 89% who say cost of living, 58% of those vote Democratic.
You have 74% who say Iran, and 63% of those vote Democrat.
So you look at that, there's no doubt that Iran
was a major issue and hurt Republicans,
but it wasn't the only issue.
Corruption was a huge issue.
Cost of living, a big issue.
And Vance doesn't want to talk about
these or doesn't want to dwell on them as much
because obviously corruption.
is uncomfortable for him,
not because he's corrupt or people around him are corrupt,
but he's in the midst of this Trump family
and their allies who are all making money
hand over fist. Doesn't want to talk about that one.
And cost of living does include the Iran war,
but it's not exclusively Iran war.
It also includes tariffs. And this is an issue that
J.D. Vance is ideologically committed to.
So he doesn't want to point to that either. So he wants
He wants to make it all about the Iran war.
I think the
Best way to look at this is how some
political analysts have described it.
It was going to be a terrible night for Republicans regardless.
But then you have the Iran war coming in and making it that much.
But let's go back to the Vance Post.
Here's more further down in what he wrote.
The reason we lost is the war.
The president himself said so last night.
If you'd like to argue it was worth it,
that losing the Senate for the next six years was
worth it, then do so.
Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay.
Agree or disagree.
That's at least honest.
Skipping down.
I remain hopeful about our country.
To the people who are pissed off
and want to say I told you so, you're right.
You did tell us so.
Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview.
So you see there, Vice President, very categorical.
The reason we lost was the war, and that just goes too far.
It's too simplistic.
It's too monocausal, too convenient for his point of view,
by the way, and just wrong.
And then you get this passage where he's...
Kind of derisively challenging anyone to say this was worth it.
And clearly he has pro-war pundits in mind when he's saying that.
But you know who he's also basically directing that to,
if you read it literally, is the
president of the United States who was happy to defend it
and say it was worth the price.
More from Trump on the tarmac.
I can tell you if I had it to do again,
this historically for history will go down as one
One of the best things we ever did because
If they ever had a nuclear weapon, they would blow up the world.
You know why? Because they're
crazy. Thank you very much, everybody.
Let me pause right here, by the way,
and urge you to subscribe to the National Review channel
if you like videos like this.
If you're not going to do it for the substance,
do it for my magnetic personality.
But whatever the reason, we urge you,
please, to hit the subscribe button.
So there you hear Trump taking on the implicit challenge and saying,
Damn right, this was the right thing to do,
and history is going to say this was the right thing
to do. Now, there's also a very notable moment I went over just
a minute ago in that Vance post
near the end, where he says, you know what,
if you're sitting there saying, I told you so
about this war and the disaster it would be,
that's implicit, you were right, and just channel
your energy in a positive way to help Republicans.
But this is, again, a huge implicit rebuke
of the essential decision that was made to go to war in Iran.
And by the way, this is an
element of this post that's catering potentially
to some of the president's now
most vociferous ideological opponents on the right.
People like Tucker Carlson,
who think Trump has totally betrayed MAGA,
Marjorie Taylor Greene, and the rest of them.
How is Trump thinking about it?
Well, he emphasized it again in his very notable interview
with Ross Douthat of 60 Minutes.
A couple days ago, your vice president,
J.D. Vance, wrote a social media post where
he says, the reason we lost is the war, meaning Iran.
And he said things in that post- I don't disagree with it.
About Israel, yeah, so you agree with his analysis?
I don't disagree with it.
Did you know he was gonna write that post?
He asked me, what do I think?
I said- Write what you feel.
By the way, what are you gonna write?
The only thing I wish he would have said there.
If he felt it and you'd have to ask him about that,
but if you had it to do again, would
you do it?
It is part of a decision making process.
And my answer is an emphatic yes,
because you can't let Iran have a nuclear weapon.
I think historically, this will be a very good decision.
Is it a good decision for today and tomorrow?
Maybe not.
But I have to go with what's right for our country.
If they had a nuclear weapon during my term,
I would be excoriated, far worse.
So there's Trump once again, like on the tarmac saying,
well, I hope JD says that this was
the right decision.
Also want to throw in this clip from,
I believe the day after the election when Trump is touring
the ballroom.
Of course, what else would he be doing?
And he's asked about the Vance X post.
Did you know the vice president was going to post that X message?
Talking so much about the results of the war and how it impacted it.
Well, I knew the war was going to impact it,
but whether it impacted or not,
Iran can't have a nuclear weapon.
No, but the vice president wrote a very lengthy post about
how the war impacted the results.
Well, I knew he was, I know how he feels about it.
I think it was, I think it was fine.
I thought it was good.
We knew that.
I know that.
I knew that when I went in.
And we stopped them from having a nuclear weapon,
and they will never have a nuclear weapon.
Have you spoken to Vice President Vance?
Yeah, I've spoken to him about a lot of things,
but I mean, we'll see what happens.
Everybody, I mean, you don't know who's talking about running.
You can have people running.
You can have a lot of people, maybe a lot of people running.
Maybe nobody's going to run.
He won't run. I don't know who's going to run.
So I count at least four major passive-aggressive rifts
in all that Trump has said addressing this Vance post.
First of all, when he's talking to Ross Douthat,
he says, oh, yeah, sure, say whatever you want.
But what is it? Clearly he wants to know.
Then at the construction site, he's saying,
oh, I saw that. Well, it was fine.
Then he catches himself. No, it was actually good.
Then he says on the tarmac, a lot of people don't like what he wrote.
I'm fine with it, but a lot of people didn't like it.
And then also at the construction sites,
well, he might not run for president.
So all of these things speak to a grumbling,
kind of rumbling, low level of discontent
with where the vice president is on this,
or at least what he's saying about it publicly.
And who knows, right?
Someone else might run for president.
All right, so the crux of this dispute
is not the way you might think on the superficial level
Well, what role did the Iran war play
in the midterm drubbing Republicans got?
Maybe it was 90 percent.
Maybe it was 50 percent.
Whatever it was, it was a big deal.
And everyone, Vance, Trump, others all agree it played a role.
The crux of the question is whether the decision
to go to war with Iran was the right one or
not.
And you have Trump showing no daylight there,
absolutely certain, yes, it was the right
thing to do.
History will judge me generously over this,
and if we had to do it again, same circumstances
replayed, knowing what we know now, yes,
we would do it again, and J.D. Vance should say
that.
Now, that puts Vance in a very awkward position,
given he's signaling, I don't like this,
I wasn't on board this.
Credible reporting suggests
in the internal deliberations, he actually said, sir, I don't
support this military.
Operation. So how is he going to say what Trump wants him to say
if Trump really insists on it? Now, Vance is a very deft communicator,
a very shrewd guy, a deft maneuverer.
So maybe he finds a way around this. He can just say, look,
he's president United States is president United States for a reason.
He made this call for the right reasons.
And it's my job as vice president United States to support
and implement whatever he does. But that's.
Could feel kind of insincere,
given he's signaling to everyone, no, I wasn't on board
this, it needs to end, the critics were right,
and will be disappointing to the people that
he considers a key element of his constituency,
the isolationists or restrainers or whatever
you want to call them,
who have been excoriating about this decision and about Donald Trump
because he made this decision.
So, look, it wasn't going to be easy.
Easy for anyone to try to be the successor to Donald Trump.
Vice President Vance, you'd think,
is still lined up best because he's the veep.
He has big name ID.
He's in that room and kind of can hopefully,
for his purposes, cater to Donald Trump and
knows the internal dynamics.
But here, very early on, you know,
we're a couple of days into the 2028 primary season,
if you consider the midterms kind of the starting gun here.
And there's already turbulent.
Waters for J.D. Vance with perhaps more to come.
Hey, curious what you make of this one.
Please leave a comment.
If you like this video, you've watched it
this long, just click the like button.
And once more, humbly beseech you to subscribe.
I'm Rich Lowry, over and out.