This creamy Southern baked mac and cheese brings three cheeses together with a golden baked topping. Add it to your Thanksgiving menu or serve it alongside your favorite Sunday dinner!
Today, I’m making baked mac and cheese with sharp cheddar, Colby, and Monterey Jack. Evaporated milk and sour cream bring richness to the sauce, while that cheesy topping finishes everything off in the oven.
We’re making the sauce, mixing in the pasta, and baking it until the edges bubble and the top turns golden. If mac and cheese always gets a spot on your holiday plate, this recipe belongs on your menu.
"Subscribe and hit the bell for new recipe alerts!"
Online YouTube Store - https: //shorturl.at/hmpX6
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ►►
PERKS for YOUTUBE MEMBERS: For just $5, become a Smokin’ and Grillin’ wit AB YouTube Member and unlock exclusive perks, including bi-weekly recipes, private live streams, member-only content, and a special credit in our videos.
Join Smokin’ and Grillin’ wit AB today and be part of the family. Thank you in advance for your support!
DISCLAIMER: This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission.
AI Generated·May contain errors
All right, folks, look, we're back at it again, right?
So listen, you'd already seen the thumbnail,
so I'm going to go ahead and just read what it is.
Now, check this out.
This is a creamy southern baked three cheese mac and cheese, right?
Super simple.
And if you guys pay attention to these ingredients right here, look,
it's not a whole lot to it.
Now, if you guys go to my website,
which is smokingandgrillingwithab.com,
and that's W-I-T-A-B.com, that will show you.
Look, I took the time to make all of these recipes.
It's the holiday time.
I want you guys to go there.
And then there's, listen.
If you pay attention and you look
on the right-hand side of any recipe that you pick,
there's a little save button right there.
Go ahead and hit that for all of the recipes that you like,
right? So if you're doing some type of, uh, what is that?
If you're doing some type of,
let's see, if you're doing a holiday, you know,
if you're doing a holiday, you know, playlist,
and you just want to have all your recipes
right there, when you actually click that,
then when you hit it, you'll see everything that you saved
and any other website that you go to.
And again, that's Smoking
and Grilling with ab.com and that's w-r-i-t-a-b.com.
All right, so first thing we're going to do is,
which I'm going to start off by telling you now,
because this recipe goes kind of quick.
Please don't let the simplicity or the lack of a whole
thousand ingredients make you think this is not going to be,
you know, fire. This will actually
be on my table and it's probably on thousands of other people's,
you know, Thanksgiving table also,
right? So before I do that, I want to make sure
that I let you guys know you want to preheat your
oven to 350 degrees. So go ahead and get that going.
Now we're going to talk about the elbows,
You guys can use any pasta noodle that you guys would like to use,
but here's going to be the trick.
You got to be able to read this on the back and find out.
Let's just say, I'm going to give you an example.
Let's just say eight minutes,
10 minutes. Let's just go with 10 minutes.
Ah, eight minutes would be more realistic.
If it's eight minutes to be al dente,
no matter what noodle that you use,
whatever pasta you put in there,
whether it's macaroni, elbows,
or whatever shape, size, or whatever,
if it say eight minutes,
I want you to take them out, right?
Listen to me.
You take them out two minutes prior to.
Now, come on.
Now, the particular brand of pasta noodle,
it say this is gonna be done in six minutes, right?
By al dente.
I want you guys, come on in here right now.
Look at this.
What I'm gonna do is,
I'm gonna go ahead and give this
a couple of pinches of salt.
you want it to have some flavor
and you want your pasta to you know taste like
you know some seasoned water yes i said seasoning even
though we just put salt in there
right so now i'm gonna come grab my spatula i got
that we're just gonna do this now this is
already boiling you see it we ready
to go remember i said mine says this package right
here says six minutes i'm gonna set a timer
as soon as i drop this in there for four minutes
All right so look while we on the stove right I'm letting
that work I got that four minute timer
going I'm gonna go ahead and take this normally I have
my stick of butter you know I'll peel it
back a little bit and do it
but what I'm gonna do now is I'm gonna go ahead and just grease this
right now you guys can use non-stick spray
if that's what you want to use you know
I think butter give you
the best flavor you know I just actually had this
this was already in my refrigerator that's why I'm doing it this way.
Right? So I let it come out, sit out, might as well use it.
Right? And you want it to get
room temperature so that it spray up just like
you see what I'm doing. It's old school folks.
A lot of times you guys see me using that PAM
or that extra virgin olive oil in the spray.
Sometime I use avocado spray, but you know what?
We pulling out all of the stops. Now my timer
just went all right. Let me, I turned this off just four minutes.
That's what it calls for here.
So I'm going to hurry up and get that out of there
because we want to stop that cooking.
So let me give me a couple of potholders, right?
I'm going to show you guys a little heads up.
Before I take that out, I want you to come here
and take a look at this. Look, I put myself a bowl
here and I put the collard over the top.
This is what we're getting ready to do. I'm going to take
this, bring this right here like this.
So what that does is it captures my starchy water. That's
always a plus, right? So I just picked this up, right?
I'm going to move this up out of the way.
That's my starchy water.
Now, I'm going to hurry, put this cold water in here
and shock it because we want to stop it.
The reason being, this is going in the oven, folks.
So when you put it in the oven, then
it's going to cook the rest of the way.
If you overcook it, you know how like the end,
look, let me show you guys here.
You see that?
Those are collapsed.
You don't want them to be collapsed.
You want them to stay, you know, in a round circle at the end, right?
So I'm going to leave it just like this.
I'm not getting ready to add no butter to it,
no olive oil or nothing like that.
This is enough.
Make sure I can feel it. It's cool now.
This is al dente. Okay, so look, now let's go ahead and
shred, right? Now this right here is sharp cheddar, right?
I'm gonna go ahead and get this going.
I mean, you know what? I see everybody saying that now.
When I first started,
and I'm not saying I started that,
but so many people was using shredded cheese out of the,
you know, the package. As soon as I started saying that,
it looked like everybody named
mama was a cheese expert. But they all speaking of facts.
If you shred your own cheese, it doesn't
have that little waxy film.
That waxy film that they put on pre-shredded cheese is to keep it
from sticking. Why? Because if you take this,
just imagine this, look how that clumped up.
Can you imagine that being handled in that bag without
that anti-sticking agent? You know what
I mean? So that's why, right? So we just shred this down, right?
And then we move on to the next one.
All right, so I'm just going to put this in a bowl.
We got to get it all mixed. I had a glass
bowl on the counter, but we need to have enough room,
you know, to go ahead and just to mix it
properly, right? So here we got Colby jack
and over here we got mozzarella jack, excuse me.
Monterey Jack, right?
So we got these two.
I'm going to do the exact same thing.
You guys know we pre-shredding everything ourselves
from a fresh block, right?
And you know where the recipe is.
It's on my website.
That's smokingandgrillingwithab.com and that's W-I-T-A-B.com.
All right, so this was my starchy water, right?
So I'm going to go ahead.
This is just one cup, right?
I just get myself about that much, right?
I'll set this here.
And I'm going to set this off to the side back here,
just in case I leave more.
If I wanted more, I could have used my two cup and I got a four cup.
I use a starchy water that helps the cheese adhere,
you know, to the actual pasta.
And then when we're making it, if it get too thick,
you can always thin it out with that.
That's a must save, folks.
Now, look, we got this here.
I'm going to go ahead and put a fire underneath the bottom of my...
My pot, you guys can use a saucepan if you got one big enough.
Anything that'll hold it,
all of your cheese, right?
So I want this on super low. We don't want a brown,
no butter, nothing like that.
So we just put a little heat on the bottom.
Now remember, we already pre-measured everything
because I gave you guys the ingredients.
I put that in there and now I'll let
that heat just work it nice and slow.
Let me go ahead and catch up on my dishes.
Hey, and I didn't even say nothing.
I got to really say this now because especially
we cooking out here for the holidays or whenever
you're really cooking, you always want
to make sure you got your hot soapy water.
That's it right here. So I got all kinds of things going on.
This is what I was using
earlier for my pasta. We wash, we rinse,
we dry, and we keep everything at the ready.
Okay, so now that we have everything completely melted before I
start adding my ingredients. I want you guys to pay attention
This is what makes everything simple.
This is why I say you guys need a recipe, right?
This is why I take the time to do it.
I'll line it out how I'm gonna need it.
I'm gonna need flour, evaporated milk, whole milk,
and then sour cream, right?
Then we got everything when it comes to the dry ingredients,
when I introduce them, notice how I got these three together
and I got this one separated
because that one right there, which is the paprika,
that's the one I'm only gonna put
half of the paprika in right now, right?
So we got that. I'm gonna start off with
using my spatula, but the only real two
tools you're gonna need is your spatula,
And you know your whisk, right?
So now, come in here and let's look in the bowl, right?
So we got that going.
Now I'm going to start introducing the flour.
Just notice how I keep moving this around.
We don't want to brown it, right?
So that's why I still got everything on super low.
What we want to do is get that powdery,
you know, flour taste out of everything, right?
So I got it all in here.
We had enough butter.
The spasser allows us to get up against the edge to get it all,
you know, hooked up, right?
So we're going to let that heat cook it a little bit.
We probably move this around by one minute.
All right, now you're gonna get a little color,
you know what I mean, but we just don't want it to brown.
And remember, I'm still on that super low, gotta do it.
All right, so now we finna switch our tools.
All right, so now my evaporated milk, we start adding that.
I know it gets a little noisy
because I'm using a metal whisk,
but you know, I'm using Hexclad pots, right?
Pots and pans.
This right here is not a coating,
it's a design that keeps everything to be non-stick, right?
So you can go ahead and use metal utensils.
For those of you guys that don't have these,
You know what I mean?
You can always use,
you gotta use something like a bamboo,
you know, wooden spoon, rubber,
things of that nature,
so that you don't knock off that coating.
Now I'm finna get here and look underneath the bottom,
and now we gonna get it up like this.
We just wanna have a low flame underneath the bottom,
cause we gonna need a little heat
by the time we get to that cheese.
Now, I'm gonna add
my whole milk.
Now the key with this whole thing
about making any type of sauce,
especially when you're using cheese is,
If you knew you got to trust the process, meaning we're going
to start off low, eventually we'll get there, right?
We just leave it.
You know, we want to keep working it.
That's what this whisk is for, you know, just to keep it going, right?
It should look smooth, just like what you guys see right there.
Now, I'm going to stop and do a rinse, and then I'm going to go ahead
and catch up on these dishes, but I'm on low.
We don't worry about that.
We just want to make sure everything come up
to the right, proper temperature.
Okay, so now, if you look,
I'm going to have all three of these seasonings.
You know, we just start adding that there.
Now we just continue
to whisk.
That smells good.
All right.
Now just a little bit
of the paprika,
not a little bit, just half. That's it.
Now I'm going to look at my fire. I'm going to turn this
down low, back down to like super low.
This starts to thicken up automatically on its own, but you
want to make sure you got everything incorporated in here.
Right? Look at that. Now we're going to
add a little bit of this. I'm going to get it all done.
Now we're going to add a little pepper.
I always put fresh cracked black in everything.
I'm at super low. I'm getting ready to turn my
fire off. And then I'm going
to add myself just a pinch of sauce.
All right. Now that I have that
going, now we're going to go ahead and add,
you know, about a half a cup of this sour cream.
Now I just turned the heat off.
We don't want this sauce to break. This right here, we right
there. This is perfect. Right?
So I say we need a half a cup. So I'm going to go in here.
This is a quarter cups. That's a quarter. And that equals a half.
Right? Now, off it here. I don't know if you guys didn't know,
but I like to try to be neat, you know?
So, we want to let this heat, just the residual heat in here,
because we offer the fire, right?
You can see the color.
As it mixes, you'll see if it's not mixed properly.
Look at that right there. Yes, sir.
Now, I'm going to bring that cheese.
Now, we're going to put about a handful of this in at a time, right?
Notice how I'm doing this, and I'm constantly, you know, whisking.
Yes, sir. Just like you guys see.
We're making that sauce now, folks. And I don't add no more
sauce until I see all of this cheese that I just pre-shredded.
You know what I mean? We want to
make sure that that just, you know, melts.
You know, it should look like that. No screen should
be holding with it or nothing like that. Look at that.
Now, you want to reserve yourself about a
third of this cheese that you have. You know what I mean?
Because we're going to need that. You don't
put it all in right now. You know what I mean?
It takes about three handfuls. I guess it really
It really depends on how big your hands are.
You know what I mean?
But if I put another,
Handful like that in here after this completely melts.
Look at that.
That's now it's becoming.
Ooh, look at that right there.
I love it when I do the cheese right.
All right, so when you see it, you see that right there?
Look how smooth that is.
You got to control that heat folks.
I didn't give it to you the best way I know how.
You know what I mean? It's pretty,
pretty simple because you don't want it to break. If you guys
ever had problems with making a cheese sauce,
it was really, it was too hot. You got to just get
your timing right. But if you follow this video the way I got it,
I think you guys will be just
fine. You know what I mean? And plus everybody gonna ask you,
have you taken this to somebody's house?
Just be prepared.
You'll be bringing mac and cheese
to everybody's house from here on out.
Right?
So now, I'm going to go ahead
and just start adding my elbow mac in here.
I put a little bit in there at a time.
You know what I mean?
And then look.
Come on in here.
This is the part you guys wanted to see.
So you want to get in here and look at this?
Look.
Yes, sir.
Now, your oven should have been already up to 350.
But I just want to get this in here like that.
You see?
Now, we bring this like this.
And don't forget, every day I'm posting something,
you know what I mean, that we're
going to put on the table. You pick it.
If you're cooking by yourself, go back and look through
these comments. People will tell you they've
been making these recipes, you know, for the last,
I've been on YouTube for nine and a half years, folks.
You know what I mean? But look at this
right here. Yes, sir. Did I say this is going to be a creamy mac?
All right, so you remember we said we held back just
a little bit of the pasta water.
You can see this right here.
You know like this is cool, but I just want to show you if you want it
and plus this got the sticking agent in it.
It's got the starch. It's the starch water. I just add
this a little bit in here and I'm gonna make sure I got
this incorporated everywhere. I'm keep giving
this a stir. It loosens it up just a little bit.
Remember that song just a touch a loving
A little bit.
Y'all remember that?
I guess I'm speaking my age right now,
but y'all let me know down in the comment section below.
Do you know that song?
All right, so that right there,
you can hear my tone and all of that.
I'm gonna pop my collar,
because when it's right, it's right.
Like Cardi B say, when it's up, it's up.
Oh yeah.
All right, so now we nice and creamy.
You remember we greased this right here, right?
So now I'm gonna take this,
and now we finna add it, right?
Look, I just put this in here like this.
You guys did it right.
You know what I mean?
Let's get it all in there.
If for some odd reason you guys have a casserole dish
that is not as deep, this one's actually
shallow. I was a little worried myself.
I just like the color, you know what I mean? I could
have used a deeper one, you know what I mean?
But I didn't want to do just straight white,
right? I could do a better job,
but I got enough of that in there. And don't forget,
we reserved a little cheese, right?
So we get it all, we just want it to spread like this.
And you know what we're going to do with the rest,
folks. We're going to go ahead and
Sprinkle this cheese over the top, right?
Real simple. You know I mean I see a lot
of these recipes everybody doing a whole lot
for something that grandma used to make back
in the day that was just right. You know I mean she
didn't always need my grandma didn't need five
cheese you know what I'm saying. But anyway I'm
gonna go ahead and do this like this and you guys let me know down
in the comment section below how
did this turn out for you. Some of y'all probably want
to taste this right now especially if you
If you knew, you don't know who I am or whatever,
go ahead and make this pre.
What they say, we're going to pre-game it
and then what they say, oh, by the way,
check this out. My cameraman just told me it's not up.
It's not when it's up, it's up. They told me
when it's up, it's stuck. You know what I mean?
Hey, these youngsters. Okay, so now you remember
that little paprika that we had left over?
You know what I mean? It wasn't a whole lot, right?
So you hold your hand up
and you just sprinkle this on here just like what I'm doing, right?
Now I'm going to put this in the oven,
probably for about 25 to 30 minutes,
but this is going to be the key. I'm going to take a look at it again
at 20 minutes just to see where we're at.
And then I want to say this part,
did you guys notice I didn't pat that down
and make it like a condensed layer? You know what I
mean? You wanted to have these ups and downs
and valleys and it stays a little airy in the inside.
Why? Because that gives it character.
And just when I come in here and I pick it up,
you'll see why. With that being said,
we're in the oven. I'll see y'all in 20.
Okay, so look, my timer went out at 20 minutes.
Let's take a look at it. Ah, yeah, nah, I'm not
going
no further.
You see that
right there?
Yes, sir.
Look at that.
Okay, so now you
got to get a
chance to look at it, you know,
without all of the ooh and the ahs and all of that. If you look
right here, look, this is what I mean when I say it's creamy.
You got your, you know, your cheese
on top. This is where, you know, it sits in there,
it bubbles up, turns brown a little bit, and we
And we put a little bit of that.
Smoked paprika on there to give it
a little bit of flavor and a little color.
But if you guys can see right here,
you can see the cheddar, the Monterey.
You know what I mean?
You can see it all right there.
I got it.
Some of you guys like to use all those different cheeses,
but I can promise you, don't let
this, you know, fool you.
This right here is fire.
It's deserving to be on anybody's Thanksgiving,
you know, table, Christmas table.
You know what?
Weeknight table.
Hey, with that being said, I'm going to go in here
and just get me a little bit of this.
Oh my goodness.
You guys let me know down in the comment section below.
Do you like to have that, you know,
that crusty top? Now look, I got some, I got so many,
I've probably made this 10 or 11 times.
So when you guys go to my website,
which is smokingandgrillingwithab.com and that's w-i-t-a-b.com
you pick it. You can go baked. We can go baked and creamy.
You know what I mean? I got a baked
one right now that the edges on there are so crunchy and ooh,
I got it no matter how you want
it, but I don't want to over-talk it like I'm doing right now.
So check this out. Bon Appetit
The flavor there.
Let me get that.
Yes, sir.
Yes, sir.
Now remember this, remember we talked about al dente
two minutes before we put it in there,
it'll come out right?
Mm-hmm.
You gotta let me know down in the comment section below.
You gotta come back and tap in with me and let me know.
After you followed this, you know,
all the way down to the T, did it come out like that?
These positives right here is right.
Yay.
This is right. It's flavorful. It's cheesy.
The top, you know, that little crust gives you what
you need. Now, I got to ask you guys, you got to take,
you know, make it like this, taste it,
and tell me what would you guys do differently.
I need to read it. Now, I got a couple of more
mac and cheese that I'm going to do, you know,
between now and the end of the year. You know
what I mean? They're going to be fire,
but this next one I'm going to do is really going to turn
the mac and cheese world upside down.
So, with that being said, let me know what you would do
I'm going to do extra and...
If you're new to my channel, let me just take
this time to say thank you for watching this video.
Don't forget to like, smash that subscribe button,
and tell everybody out there.
There's a channel out here that's simplifying these recipes
and taking the mystery out of cooking.
You guys can't wait to see what I'm going to do.
I promise you.
With that being said, I'm out.
Peace.