How the NBA continues to make scoring easier

First Athletic
21 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 27, 2022
Yes, you heard that correctly.
Back in 1970, this was an offensive foul for leaning into the defender.
A few decades later, a more aggressive version of the very same play had become a defensive
foul.
How did we go from punishing the offense for initiating contact to rewarding it?
Why was this play called a travel back in 1990 on Charles Barkley?
But in last year's playoffs, this Al Horford hop-skip-and-a-jump netted two points without
a whistle.
And how in the name of basketball have we somehow ended up with plays like this leading
to free throws for the offense?
A number of major rule changes have helped the NBA evolve.
The implementation of the shot clock sped up the sport, the widening of the lane stopped
big men from camping out under the basket, and of course, the three-point shot led to
today's pace-and-space revolution.
League-wide offensive efficiency steadily improved in the 1960s and 70s until the implementation
of the three-point line in 1980, where efficiency leveled off for about two decades before defenses
pushed it back down at the turn of the century.
We'll talk about why in a second.
In the 2000s, offenses improved again, and in the last five years, we've seen an offensive
explosion.
These changes are often credited to strategic improvements like cutting out long two-point
shots or an expansion of the talent pool that now features more international stars.
But the rules, and sometimes just the enforcement of rules, has morphed in a way that makes
life easier for the offense.
Take something as basic as dribbling.
We probably take it for granted today, but ball-handling rules were more strictly enforced
in the earlier days of the league, which made it impossible to dribble the way most players
do now.
Originally, they were supposed to dribble with their hand on top of the ball, and they
couldn't let the ball sit up and rest in their palm, which slowed down or paused the
dribble.
Versions of these limitations are still in the official rulebook today, although the
language now allows a player to put his hand under the rock as long as he doesn't carry
it.
Here's a slick in-and-out crossover from 1973, notice the right hand facing down, and
then the left hand comes under the ball on the last dribble, and that's a carrying
violation.
Here's another carry from 1978, where Julius Irving seems to just fumble the ball, but
those were stricter times.
Since pausing and cupping the ball is easier, players have been pushing the boundaries for
decades.
Here, the hand is just slightly on the side of the ball with a minor wrist turn, and Irving
gets away with a similar technique, turning the ball from its side before detonating on
some redhead.
By the 80s, this slight cupping and rotating of the wrist was no longer called a violation.
That meant the hand could sneak lower and even under the ball occasionally for better
control, which meant that players could sometimes carry it without a whistle, in this case pushing
the ball mid-flight to execute the crossover.
By the end of the 80s, the best dribblers were able to get underneath and turn the ball
like this for maximum control, and so normal dribbling in the 90s involved more of this
turning and controlling of the ball, sometimes even cupping it.
With the hand underneath it, players could pause the dribble a little more.
Chauncey Billups actually scoops the ball upwards after restarting his dribble, then
pauses it on the hesitation before carrying it across his body with the crossover, which
would have been a whistle in prior eras.
Some additional cupping and pushing has been normalized in recent years, and now most players
dribble with their hand underneath the ball to turn it and control it, and those plays
are becoming more common without being called for a violation.
So we've gone from this to this in about half a century without the actual rules really
changing.
Many of these dribbles are in violation of the rulebook, but in effect, they're legal
today because the whistle is never blown.
This has also happened with traveling, where players used to be held to two strict steps
after releasing their last dribble.
But today, things are a little different.
In the 70s, there were traveling calls that don't look like travels anymore.
They were so militant about travels that even in slow motion, it's hard to see them.
Magic Johnson's right foot takes a step, then his left, then I guess his right moves
three inches, and I think the replay officials at the time would have said it was the right
call.
Here's a play from 1972 that isn't a travel under any interpretation, but it was called
nonetheless, and even in the 80s, certain spin moves were endangered of being whistled
for a walk.
The earliest full-on Euro step I found was from 1982, and that long, decelerated stride
was instantly called illegal.
And many of these plays were whistled because there was no gather step back then.
The count used to start on the last dribble, so at best, this was one, two, three steps
and a turnover.
Scottie Pippen got away with the gather step a ton in the 90s, but it still wasn't honored
in many situations.
This would never be called a travel today, but in 1996, it was too many dance steps on
the last dribble.
Fast forward 10 or 15 years, when the gather was unofficially accepted, and this Manu Ginobili
sorcery was viewed as a legal two-step play instead of a four-step travel.
In 2019, the NBA officially added the gather step to the rulebook, paving the road for
all kinds of step-back moves and new-age baleic Euros that would have been illegal in the
olden times.
Modern players have way more leeway starting their dribble as well.
Back in the day, you couldn't lift your pivot foot before releasing the ball, although this
has been inconsistently called forever, and you certainly couldn't just jog and plan
a move after receiving a pass.
This led to some incredible travels, like this zero-step shot without a dribble and
this half-step travel by Henry Bibby in the 1977 Finals.
If you bobbled the ball, forget about it.
That was an immediate travel for a number of years.
Even in the 80s, remnants of the illegal bobble travel can be found, before the refs realize
that to travel, it might make sense for the player to successfully possess the ball in
the first place.
Here's a hesitation on the catch from 1963, but that little pause draws a traveling call,
whereas today we see players set up shots with multiple steps without ever starting
a dribble.
This is a nice perk for today's offensive attackers, who don't have to worry about
dribbling instantly when they catch the ball.
These looser and looser interpretations of ball-handling tactics not only help offensive
players, but they make the missed calls even more extreme, sometimes leading to three-step
or even four-step travels without a whistle being blown.
The loose interpretations don't stop there, though.
The entire concept of in-the-act-of-shooting has expanded a ton over the years.
On this post-up, Bill Walton is fouled as he's turning into his shot, but it's 1977,
so sometimes this was a non-shooting foul.
In the 90s, these plays could go either way.
Scottie Pippen's bumped here, and he instinctively launches it at the basket and is rewarded
with free throws.
Yet in the very next game, Clyde Drexler's hit is he's about to jump, and it's called
a foul on the floor.
Today's players are given an extremely liberal definition of in-the-act-of-shooting, where
they feel some contact on the perimeter and then flail the shot toward the basket and
are being rewarded with free throws.
Ironically, the league put out a video in 2017 explaining exactly what constitutes in-the-act,
declaring that on drives in this area, the act of shooting starts after the gather, and
on outside shots, it starts on the upward shooting motion.
Even with that, players are repeatedly fouled on the floor and then receive free throws
for gathering and shooting after that contact.
In essence, these calls take what used to be a side-out-of-bounds and replace it with
an 80% shot.
So without changing many rules, interpreting them differently over the years has been a
huge boon for offenses, and we haven't even touched, arguably, the single biggest interpretation
change of them all.
There were some quirky old NBA rules that are wild to look back on, like awarding three
free throws in order to make two on-shooting fouls in the bonus.
Before 1970, putbacks off missed free throws only counted as a single point, and that point
went to the free throw shooter, not the rebounder.
And, among other oddities, pinning the ball against the backboard was actually goaltending
for some period of time.
I have no idea when this stopped, but it apparently didn't fly back at the beginning of the 70s.
Perhaps the biggest shift of all is how physical contact has been officiated, and specifically
who has been rewarded or punished for initiating contact.
This is an offensive foul because the attacker lowers his shoulder into the defender, even
if there isn't a ton of contact.
In the 60s and 70s, offensive players didn't even have to make contact, just the act of
leaning in or jumping into a defender could draw an offensive foul.
That meant it was common for offensive fouls to be called when defenders slid in front
of the ball without falling over.
Today, this would be a no-call, but in 1971, Walt Hazard was whistled for dipping his shoulder
into the defender, who beat him to the spot.
It didn't matter if the defender kept moving or even jumped, there was simply little tolerance
for the offense jumping into defenders and initiating contact.
This might not look like a defensive foul, but that's because there was less physicality
in general during that era.
Defenders would arm bar and hand check, but the slightest nudge or bump could be called
a foul.
The 60s has this reputation for being tough and rugged, but there wasn't much contact
allowed in space and with the ball.
By the 80s, hand fighting and physical contact was more commonly allowed on drives like this,
and in the 90s they let plenty go as well.
That's a solid push to the shoulder that goes uncalled there.
Physicality probably peaked in the early 2000s, where there was a ton of contact away from
the ball at times, and some of these contests felt like rugby matches instead of a basketball
game.
There was plenty of contact allowed on the ball as well.
After this ruggedness ground scoring to a halt, the league made a concerted effort to
give perimeter players more freedom of movement, but in most areas, the game is still far more
physical than it was in the 60s and 70s.
This kind of hand fighting probably wouldn't be permitted back then, and there was no foul
at the end of this play despite contact.
So because there was less contact in general, especially out in space on drives like this,
initiating contact was frequently whistled as a foul on the offense.
This started to balance out a little more in the 80s as the game became more physical.
A little lean in by Isaiah Thomas was a defensive foul here, but in the very same half, this
little bump on a post up was called on the offense.
The physicality of the 80s was famously on display in the classic wars between the Celtics
and Lakers, Celtics and Pistons, and really the Celtics and anyone.
But by the middle of the decade, leaning in like this could still be called on the offense
like it was here, it could be a no call like this Isaiah lean in, note the defender thought
he was the one fouled, and those little shoulder drops could even be defensive fouls if the
angles weren't so clear cut.
By the 2000s, it was common for these plays to be non-calls, and by 2010, we started to
see the defense regularly called for fouls when the offense barreled into them.
That prompted this prescient quote from Jeff Van Gundy during the 2008 playoffs.
When the offense is allowed more contact than the defense, it's wrong, it's like if you're
In recent years, fouls are now regularly called on the defense after the offense initiates
that contact.
This happens a lot on drives, dropping a shoulder into the defender to create contact, and often
earn the offense free throws.
Sometimes this comes in the form of veering back into the defender running alongside the
ball handler, although the league made it a point of emphasis to call these offensive
fouls in 2022.
But there were no shortage of defensive fouls this year for offensive players leaning in
while running alongside defenders.
Another popular way to create contact is upfaking and then jumping into defenders.
Again, the league made it a point to revert these back to being called offensive fouls
shooters were essentially throwing defenders off balance and then launching themselves
into them like they had a bullseye on their chest.
Even after those points of emphasis, we still saw a ton of plays where the offense hurled
itself into the defense and then earned free throws, and dribblers can still target a moving
defender in space and bounce into him and head to the charity stripe.
Compared to prior decades, this is still a massive philosophical shift, where the offense
is rewarded for dropping the shoulder into the chest of the defender.
A play like this probably is an offensive foul in the 1980s when Joellen B. drops his
shoulder and then discards the defender with the off-arm, and there might have been a second
foul dipping into his chest, but Grant Williams is so freakishly strong that he just holds
his ground, and in today's game, this is called a defensive foul.
Using that off-arm on the defender is a major part of this story.
Devin Booker karate chops the defender's arm out of the way here before driving into him
for a foul.
But this used to be called an offensive foul.
Watch the swipe with the left hand here that's called on the ball handler.
Officials were incredibly quick to whistle offensive fouls on any advantage with that
off-arm.
Phil Jackson's right arm was called for clearing space on this hook shot, and even just briefly
extending an arm to hold off a defender could be called an offensive foul in the 1970s.
In the 80s and even 90s, officials were still on the lookout for off-arm techniques, but
at some point in the 2000s, as more physicality was allowed, offensive players could do more
with their off-arm without having it called.
Watch Steve Nash's right arm keep the defender at bay here, and instead of a foul, it's a
layup.
By 2022, the scales had tipped enough for this play to be called a defensive foul on
the defender's face.
And no, there was no whistle on that little body bump beforehand, and yes, this call was
upheld on replay.
Compare that to Milwaukee's other MVP, who was immediately whistled for an offensive
foul on an almost identical play a half century earlier.
Today, little shoves and whatnot are frequently let go, whereas in the 90s, it was more common
to see an off-arm foul called on the ball handler.
Again, offensive players today are initiating this contact and using it to create space.
There's no call on this one, although officials are definitely calling some of these backhanded
shoves offensive fouls as well.
James Harden, in particular, uses a bent off-arm to drive into defenders and create space,
and he almost never straightens the arm when extending and pushing away from defenders.
That serves as a kind of shield, again, initiating the contact and sometimes pushing off.
Here's a great view of the technique, where he's delivering a blow with the bent arm,
and this one was actually called on Harden.
But, most of the time, keeping the arm bent and pushing the defender is uncalled.
Which brings us to the most extreme version of initiating contact the sport has ever seen,
in the 86-foot jump shot.
Some elements of the 80s and 90s are probably never coming back.
Long 2s don't make much sense anymore, many teams created space through the illegal defense
and there was a brutality to the era that has been washed out of today's game.
No suspensions were handed out here.
Back in the 80s, hard and dirty in-game fouls weren't always called flagrant.
This one was a common foul, and this famous incident in the 1987 Eastern Finals wasn't
even a foul, just nothing, although Robert Parrish was suspended for a game.
By the early 90s, the league had cracked down on fighting and overtly dangerous fouls.
This one was an ejection, and in the very next game, this was called a flagrant.
But there was a ton of physicality from possession to possession, especially down in the post.
This kind of wrestling for position and hand-fighting wasn't really part of the game before the
three-point line.
Watch Kareem move through the lane here.
That little bump was called a defensive foul, that's all it took, and there just simply
wasn't a ton of jostling or powerful seals in the 60s and 70s off the ball.
It was common to see post-ups from players where defenders gave them space instead of
leaning on them or driving them off their spots.
In the mid-70s, there might be a forearm to the back to keep an offensive player stationary,
but they weren't leaning all their weight into each other in a battle for paint position
like we'd seen in later decades.
Listen to the broadcasters marvel at how physical Walt Bellamy is back in Abdul-Jabbar's first game.
Wilt Chamberlain was actually called for an offensive foul for backing down here, but
in the 90s and 2000s, the power backdown was a staple for the strongest players in the
sport like Shaquille O'Neal.
Methodically backing down defenders was so common that in 2000, the league added a five-second
count making it a violation to back down defenders for longer than that.
So if you're wondering how the 90s and 2000s featured a bunch of giant stiff big men who
couldn't shoot or dribble, it's partly because there was a ton of contact allowed down in
the trenches, and size and strength were really important for winning the battle down there.
But something you didn't see in any of these positional battles was flopping.
This 1993 post-up was an offensive foul, and the defender doesn't even fall down to draw
the whistle.
There were a few actors who certainly accentuated contact at that point in time, but falling
down wasn't really a tactic, and most players just kept on playing through the physicality,
which is slightly different than how things are today.
Flopping really started to take off in the 2000s, where players would yell and flail
in order to accentuate a possible foul, and that ushered in foul-baiting techniques like
the head snap to draw attention to even the slightest contact.
All that has snowballed to where we are today, with players constantly trying to trick the
officials into calling fouls that don't exist.
This manipulation has manifested itself in a number of ways.
For instance, constantly falling down after shooting to draw fouls when there's no reason
to be falling down other than to draw phantom fouls.
The falldown is a cousin of the leg kick, where a shooter splays his legs out to contact
a defender, so yes, the defender can be called for a foul.
The earliest leg kick I've seen was from Doug Collins in 1978, but its popularity has taken
off in the last few seasons, and combined with the falldown, has earned countless free
In 2022, the league said these leg kicks would now be offensive fouls because, you know,
the offensive player is doing the kicking.
But players still tried this technique in the season, and some even still argued with
officials after they were no longer called on the defense.
One reason players are falling like rocks is the landing space foul, which was magnified
after Kawhi Leonard's ankle injury in the 2017 Western Finals.
Older versions of this actually required banging into a shooter with the body, while sliding
under a shooter's feet without any other contact was almost never called a foul during the
20th century.
Still, of all the tricks to draw fouls, the so-called rip-through might be the most mind-boggling.
Tim Duncan had a more primitive rip-through, whipping his arms up into the defender, knowing
he would draw contact and free throws.
And Kobe Bryant was one of the first players to overtly use the technique.
Notice how he targets the defender's arm instead of rising up in his normal motion.
The rip-through epitomizes this philosophical shift that rewards offensive players for initiating
the contact instead of punishing them.
The entire idea behind the move is that instead of trying to shoot, the offensive player tries
to swing his arms into the defender's often stationary arm.
And at this point, the arm can really be anywhere.
This play was a defensive foul.
Trey Young feels the defender getting close, so he just rips and flails to draw a call.
This was actually turned into a non-call on review, and in a Hall of Fame-level sequence,
Joel Embiid tries the rip-through multiple times and ends up throwing the ball off the defender.
All this ripping through has spawned the off-arm hook, where the offensive player hooks the
defender's arm instead of gathering the ball in a natural motion.
And again, this was being called a defensive foul until 2022, although this year we still
saw some of the most incredible fouls in league history.
Harden trips and rips into the defender while falling over, and ladies and gentlemen, that
earned him two free throws.
To say we've come a long way from the days where this was called an offensive foul feels
like an understatement.
Players are now playing with their hands literally clasped behind their back to take away the
target of the rip-through.
If we look at shooting fouls per 100 two-point shot attempts, we see a big jump in 2005,
when the league relaxed contact on the perimeter, and then a fairly steady ratio until the 2020
season, when shooting fouls spiked in the bubble and have remained incredibly high.
Meanwhile, the dribbling and traveling changes have helped suppress turnovers.
Yes, strategy and skill development play a role in this entire story, but the rules also
make it easier to maintain possession now compared to the 80s or 60s.
It was far more common then to see teams apply pressure to force shaky ball handlers into
turnovers, and one easy way to help dribblers in those spots is by setting a screen.
Screens originally had to be set well before the defender arrived.
That last-second hop was a moving screen, and even though this screen was set, the little
turn was enough to draw a moving screen call in the 1970s.
In the 90s, screeners started to use their arms more and lean into defenders, and that
evolved into something akin to blocking for the quarterback.
Karl Malone pushes and then slides with the defender here, helping John Stockton send
the Jazz to the 97 Finals.
In the 80s, it was hard to get away with flipping a screen on top of the defender like this
without giving him space, and you couldn't just slide into a defender's path at the
last second without drawing a call.
By the 2000s, it was far more common for screeners to kind of move through a defender's path
while rolling, and players could have way more movement on their screens without being
fully set.
Today, you're supposed to give a defender the chance to change directions, but blocking
tactics like this are rarely called on the screener.
The big advantages screeners have now is they can often move into players' bodies to pick
them like this instead of waiting for them in their path.
They can move at the last second, sometimes repeatedly, to flip or reset a screen that
originally won't connect.
And they can even get away with turning and driving through players like an NFL lineman.
A huge number of screens in any given game now would have been illegal in 1972, and the
same can be said for many other types of plays.
A play like this in a prior era could have been called a travel, then an offensive foul
for pushing off, then a travel for shuffling the feet, then an offensive foul for jumping
into the defender.
This play could have stopped with an illegal dribble, then maybe an offensive foul for
leaning in, possibly a travel, and continuation wouldn't have been awarded by a number of
old officials.
The big takeaway here, at least for me, is that the game has evolved and continues to
evolve even when changes aren't formally made to the rulebook.
Some of these changes have made the game far more entertaining, and for my money, some
have gone too far to cripple defenders and reward players for manipulating refs.
So yes, strategy and training tactics have improved, the talent pool is deeper than ever,
but the way the game is officiated also plays a big part in this story, and it's one reason
why we're living in the friendliest offensive environment the NBA has ever seen.
To support this channel, check out patreon.com slash thinkingbasketball.
We have additional content, a ton of historical stats, and a discord community that is well-versed
in league history.
A huge thanks to everyone for watching this one all the way through, it was a bit different
so I hope you found it valuable, and as always, I really hope you're having a great day.
