How Old is Life on Earth

David Butler
136 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 12, 2026
Here's the 'How Old is Life on Earth' video. It's the last chapter of the 'How Old Is It' video book. It starts with the Hadean Earth and the Oparin-Haldane Hypothesis. It covers several experiments like the Miller-Urey experiment and the Kensei Kobayashi Experiment. And finishes with some of the oldest fossilized microorganisms ever found.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the transition of early Earth from a molten state to a habitable world. It contrasts the classic Miller-Urey experiment with modern research, suggesting that proton bombardment from the young Sun's coronal mass ejections, rather than lightning, likely catalyzed the abiogenesis of organic molecules. It also explores early evidence of life and the lineage of LUCA.
Here's a table of the geologic periods in Earth's history. The Hadean lasted 540 million years.
In the previous chapter, How Old is the Earth-Moon System?, we marked the beginning of the Hadean
Eon, where the Earth was molten. There was no life at that time. We used uranium-lead zircon
crystal analyses to find the oldest solid Earth crust matter ever discovered at 4.356 billion
years old. Life cannot be older than this. From the early 20th century up through the 1980s,
geologists generally agreed that conditions during the Hadean period were utterly hostile to life.
The inability to find rock formations from the period led them to conclude that early Earth was
hellishly hot. They pictured the surface of the Earth as covered by a giant magma ocean.
This hellish perception began to change in the 1980s, when geologists discovered zircon crystals
with ages exceeding 4 billion years old, preserved in younger sandstones. In addition to the
radiometric dating techniques that revealed the ages of these ancient zircons, geologists used
other analytical techniques to extract information about the environment in which the crystals
formed, including the temperature and whether water was present. Since then, zircon studies
have revealed that the Hadean Earth at its end was not the uniformly hellish place previously
imagined, but near the end it possessed an established crust, cool enough for surface
water to form, possibly on the scale of oceans. Living organisms are made up of elements and
compounds and adhere to all the laws of physics and chemistry. In our current world, existing
living cells create the complex molecules needed for life, such as carbohydrates, proteins, and DNA.
Given the molecular makeup we have around us today, which includes plenty of oxygen,
there are no natural processes that can do this. The question this video addresses is how could
simple molecules in the late Hadean have converged into the giant complex molecules
needed for life? In order to understand the hypotheses and experiments covered in our analysis,
we need to understand how life's basic chemistry works. So we'll cover this chemistry in some
depth next in our first main chapter. If we look at the Earth we have today, we find an atmosphere
with 78% nitrogen and 21% oxygen, with traces of water, carbon dioxide, and methane. The seas
contain 96.5% water, 3.5% salt, and smaller amounts of other minerals like magnesium.
All the air compounds are also found dissolved in water. In addition, volcanoes spew large
amounts of matter into the air and water, including sulfur dioxide, phosphate, and more.
We also have lots of lightning, ultraviolet radiation, and solar storms impacting this mix
at irregular intervals. We also have living cells in large numbers in the air,
on the land, and in the sea. We see these cells creating the complex lipids, carbohydrates,
proteins, and nucleic acids needed for life. But there are no discernible processes that have the
simpler molecules evolving into monomers, evolving into polymers, evolving into macromolecules.
That is why, up to the early 1900s, it was generally understood that only living organisms
could produce these complex molecules of life. The study of these processes is called biogenesis.
Abiogenesis refers to the scientific hypothesis that life on Earth arose from non-living matter
through natural processes. In the 1920s, the British scientist J.B.S. Haldane and the Russian
biochemist Alexander Oparin independently published theories concerning the conditions
required for the origin of life on Earth. Combined, they are known as the Oparin-Haldane hypothesis.
They proposed that molecules like water, hydrogen, methane, carbon dioxide, and ammonia in the
atmosphere could combine into more complex molecules as long as little to no oxygen was
present. For example, here we have been watching the endothermic chemical reaction that converts
water, methane, and ammonia into the amino acid glycine. They proposed that energy sources like
lightning and ultraviolet solar radiation provided the needed energy. They proposed that the created
compounds fell into the sea, making the sea a prebiotic soup containing large populations of
organic monomers and polymers. In our example, the glycine created in the atmosphere combines
with alanine, previously created in the atmosphere, to create a dipeptide. Further, they proposed that
groups of monomers and polymers acquired lipid membranes, and that further developments eventually
led to the first living cells. Another key part of their theory included the need for an atmosphere
with little to no oxygen, referred to as a reduced atmosphere. They pointed out that oxygen,
with its strong oxidizing capabilities, would turn the methane and ammonia into water and carbon
dioxide. No glycine or any of the amino acids and bases needed for carbohydrates, lipids, proteins,
and RNA formation would be created. This also explains why we cannot see any organic molecule
component formation in today's oxygen-rich atmosphere. The Operon-Haldane hypothesis had
a good deal of appeal, but without any experiments it was talked about, but not very well accepted.
The Miller-Urey experiment was a simulation conducted in the 1950s, designed to test the
Operon-Haldane hypothesis. Urey was the professor, and Miller was the graduate student. They attempted
to replicate the conditions of Earth's early atmosphere and oceans to see if organic molecules
could be created abiogenically, that is, formed from chemical reactions occurring between
inorganic molecules thought to be present at the time. They constructed an apparatus to simulate
early Earth's conditions. It had two large chambers. The lower chamber was filled with
water to simulate the oceans. The upper chamber was filled with gases to simulate the atmosphere.
They included methane, ammonia, water, and hydrogen gas. Note that this was a reduced
atmosphere with no oxygen. The water was boiled to produce water vapor, which ascended into the
large upper chamber. Additional tubing allowed material to descend from the upper chamber
through a condenser, where water vapor would condense into liquid and fall into a collection
trap slightly below the lower chamber. Periodically, samples could be taken from the trap.
In an early run of the experiment, Miller discovered that the energy produced from boiling
water was not enough at the point of contact between the basic molecules to drive the chemical
reactions expected by the theory. In a second version of the experiment, they added electrodes
to the upper chamber. After the water was boiled, the mix of gases circulated through the system,
past electrodes that discharged sparks which simulated lightning. The hope was that this
would be enough energy to enable the anticipated chemical reactions. This process ran continuously
for one week. After this period, the contents of the apparatus had visibly changed color.
A red and yellow colored solution had started to collect in the trap after running the experiment
for a few days, and became a broth of red and brown by the experiment's end. They discovered
two amino acids, glycine and alanine, which are used in the biosynthesis of protein.
Here's a photograph of the paper chromatogram revealing the presence of the two amino acids.
The experiment showed that amino acids, which are important components of proteins,
could have arisen from inorganic compounds during Earth's prebiotic phase between 4 billion
and 3.5 billion years ago. Shortly after Miller published his findings, Joan Oro,
a scientist in Spain, added hydrogen cyanide HCN to the atmosphere. He used ultraviolet light as
energy source and produced adenine, a base molecule found in DNA. These results demonstrated
that the first part of the Opran-Haldane hypothesis, that foundational molecules
needed to grow into lipids, carbohydrates, proteins and nucleic acids, could have originated
through chemical reactions among simple molecules in the atmosphere, is possible.
Miller, Urey and others assumed that the early Earth atmosphere was a reducing mixture of methane,
ammonia, water, hydrogen gas and hydrogen cyanide. More recent photochemical studies show that ammonia
would have been quickly destroyed by ultraviolet UV emissions from the young sun. These days,
scientists primarily reconstruct the Hadean atmosphere by studying ancient, nearly indestructible
zircon minerals. The resulting geochemical data supports the argument in favor of a water,
nitrogen, methane and carbon dioxide-dominated atmosphere driven by volcanic outgassing.
Breaking the bonds that hold these atmospheric molecules together is the first step in the
chemical reaction that forms the base molecules for life. Different atmospheric makeups have
significant implications for the energy source used for this first step. The Miller-Urey experiment
used simulated lightning. Lightning is an avalanche of electrons. And the electrons
are supplied by the molecules the lightning passes through. The weaker the molecular bonds
that held the molecules together, the easier it is for electrons to be stripped away. We see that
the bond strengths of the molecules in today's atmosphere are generally weaker than the bond
strengths of the molecules in the Hadean atmosphere. Studies show that the Hadean
atmosphere is 28% less likely to generate lightning than today's atmosphere. This would
not be enough energy to support the first step. A different energy source is needed.
Coronal mass ejections, CMS for short, have been proposed as a candidate replacement for
lightning as an energy source in the Hadean epoch. These are powerful explosions that eject protons,
electrons and a magnetic field into space. They can eject billions of tons of coronal material
at speeds ranging up to 3,000 kilometers per second. That's 1,864 miles per second.
The overwhelming bulk of this mass comes from the protons, typically around 1 billion trillion
trillion protons in each one. That's why this is often referred to as proton bombardment.
One to three CMEs reach the Earth per month. That would not be enough energy to break the chemical
bonds needed to support the first step in creating the basic life-building blocks.
E.K. Draconis is a young star about 112 light-years away. It's between 50 and 125
million years old. That's the age our Sun was during the Hadean Eon. It's 90% of the Sun's mass
and shows intense magnetic activity like CMEs, star spots and solar-like rotation cycles.
This makes it an excellent proxy for the early Sun and offers crucial insights into the early
Sun's potential to impact the early Earth's atmosphere. Studies show that it produces CMEs
with 10 to 100 times more energy in protons than our Sun does and they occur roughly once every
4.5 days. This would be enough energy to break the bonds holding the Hadean atmospheric molecules
together. In 2023, a team of Japanese scientists led by Kensei Kobayashi updated the Miller-Urey
experiment by starting with a more Hadean-like atmosphere and simulating coronal mass ejections
with proton bombardment. They filled a glass container with a mixture of carbon dioxide,
methane, nitrogen and water. The container included a Havar non-magnetic high-strength
cobalt-based alloy foil window that lets protons in but does not allow molecules in the container
to get out. Protons were produced by accelerating negative hydrogen ions, that's hydrogen atoms with
an extra electron, from an ion source toward a positively charged 3 million electron volt
central terminal. Once the ions reach the center terminal, they pass through a device
that strips the electrons away, turning the ions into bare protons. Because the central terminal
is positive, the newly formed positive protons are repelled by the terminal and accelerate away
from it. By reversing the polarity of the particle in the middle, a 3 million electron volt terminal
actually imparts 6 million electron volts of energy to the protons. The energy of the protons decreased
to 1.58 million electron volts after passing the Havar foil. This input proton flux is comparable
with the proton flux associated with coronal mass ejections. The proton irradiation time was
about 1 to 2 hours. After irradiation, the liquid was analyzed. They found glycine and
alanine just like Miller-Urey found in their experiments. The scientists concluded that
coronal mass ejection driven energetic protons are the most promising energy source for the
prebiotic production of bioorganic compounds in the Hadean atmosphere. The oldest life forms
ever discovered are fossilized microorganisms found in 3.48 billion year old rocks in Western
Australia. These multi-layered sheet of tiny living things are mostly bacteria and archaea
that grow stuck together on moist surfaces. The oldest potential evidence of life ever discovered
was within a 4.1 billion year old zircon crystal. This graphite has a low ratio of heavy to light
carbon atoms which is consistent with the isotopic signature of organic matter, potentially indicating
a biological origin. While not conclusive proof, the presence of this graphite within the zircon
is a strong indicator of early life on Earth. Here's Darwin's tree of life. Complex organisms
like plants and animals are relative late comers, appearing roughly 1.8 billion years ago.
The two main branches of the tree of life, bacteria and archaea, diverged about 3.5 billion
years ago. Tracing it back further, researchers estimate that the last universal common ancestor,
Leuka, a hypothetical single cell that all life on Earth is derived from, probably lived around
4.5 billion years ago. That's the answer to our initial question, How old is life on Earth?
And it concludes our entire How Old Is It? video book. Thanks for watching.
Here's the list of sources I used to put together the How Old Is Life on Earth? video.
These articles, videos and websites also represent resources you can use to do additional research
into areas touched on in this video. And don't forget, every video has a document
on the HowFarAwayIsIt.com website containing all the text, links, pictures and other additional
information. Download and translate as needed. And thanks for watching.
