How Much Of Your Mental Health Is Physical?

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
Dr. K explores the profound connection between physical health and mental well-being, discussing how factors like sleep, breathing exercises, physical exercise, social interactions, and supplements such as omega-3 and vitamin D can significantly impact and reduce the severity of mental illness.
#MentalHealth #PhysicalHealth #HealthyGamerGG #DrK #SleepHygiene #ExerciseAndMentalHealth #Wellness #Psychiatry #SelfCare #BrainHealth
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
So here's what working on your body does.
It doesn't work in the same way as like psychotherapy.
Psychotherapy is like strengthening your mind,
using your mind to overcome your mind.
Disabling your mind. It's like some ninja move
to disable the anxiety, right? But you're still
fighting against it. What working on physical stuff does
is lowers the strength of the mental
illness in your mind. Today,
we're going to talk about why mental illness isn't really mental.
So I know this sounds kind of weird,
but when we think about mental illness, we assume
that it comes from the mind.
And we have a lot of evidence-based interventions
like psychotherapies at the top of the list
is the gold standard of mental illness treatment.
And psychotherapy works on the mind.
But what I've seen as a psychiatrist
is when I'm working with my patients
and we leverage the body,
we discover that this usually has very, very strong
positive effects on our mental illness.
And there's actually a ton of research
that is starting to support this.
And what I'd love to share with you all today
are the most important angles that I think
about as a psychiatrist for my patients and their physical health.
And the really cool thing that I found
is that the majority of these things actually
take very little time to implement.
So some of the stuff that we're talking about today,
you can do for like two to five minutes
a day, and on the upper end,
20 minutes or 30 minutes is actually like all you need to
get a significant benefit for your mental illness.
A lot of the things that we're going
to talk about today are really good at supporting
the evidence-based psychiatric
or psychological work that you may be doing with your therapist.
So let's start with the big one, sleep.
You should tell that to your therapist.
They'll *******, I don't have one.
I'm actually like, I solved all my problems
by getting good sleep.
So I learned something kind of interesting
when I was in residency and training to be a psychiatrist,
which is that I noticed that most mental illnesses
share one symptom.
So this is true of everything
except for personality disorders,
which is disturbances in sleep.
Mood disorder, disturbance in sleep
and major depressive disorder, huge disturbances in
sleep in bipolar disorder,
generalized anxiety disorder has disturbances in sleep, not so
much with trauma, I mean, a panic disorder,
trauma disorders, huge disturbances in sleep,
psychotic disorders, disturbances in sleep.
When I sort of noticed that basically one
of the most common pathways for
Mental illness is sleep.
I thought this was really interesting.
And the important thing to understand about this
is that sleep kind of goes both ways
when it comes to mental illness.
The first is that mental illness
causes disturbances in sleep.
So a good example of this is people
with major depressive disorder who are in a depressive
episode have a highly specific feature,
which is that they tend to have early morning awakening.
So they wake up around four to five to 6 a.m.,
even if they went to sleep at midnight or whatever,
they tend to abnormally wake up.
And usually when they wake up, their mind is in a very,
very unhealthy state. Either they wake up
and their mind is full of anxious or depressive thoughts
So we know...
That mental illness induces problems in sleep.
But the really interesting thing is that problems in sleep
also induce mental illness.
So one of the key things I learned in residency
was the best treatment for bipolar disorder is sleep.
That sleep is medicine.
And when we look at things like mood disorders
or trauma-related disorders,
a lot of our pharmacologic strategy has to do with fixing sleep.
So we'll prescribe things like prazosin in PTSD,
which prevents nightmares specifically
and helps people get a good night's sleep.
In situations like major depressive disorder,
we'll use medications like trazodone, which
are sedatives.
It's an antidepressant that you take late
at night, which helps you sleep.
And so this is the key thing to understand.
Sleep is when our body does a lot of repair, right?
So it's when it repairs injuries.
It's when we have a lot of memory consolidation
from our hippocampus so that we like store
things in our memory.
It's also a time for us to process emotions and calm ourselves down.
So when you interfere with a human being's inability to sleep,
it increases the risk
or increases the severity of their mental illness.
Now, getting a good night's sleep is...
A big topic in and of itself.
We have a two-hour deep dive over on the membership side where we
really dive into how to get a good night's sleep.
Unfortunately, it is not something that I can
explain very simply, but there is a ton of evidence
that shows that if you are sleeping well,
then the likelihood that your mental illness improves is huge, right?
And some studies find actually
a gigantic effect size or a large effect size.
On sleep quality for basically every illness that we've talked about.
The key thing to remember about sleep.
So I'll kind of give you guys a quick TLDR of the two hour deep dive.
Sleeping is the natural complement to waking, right?
So our body has a cycle which involves a certain amount
of waking followed by a certain amount of sleep.
So the biggest thing that most people miss is that having
a good night's sleep does not start one hour before you go to bed.
It actually starts when you wake up.
So a couple of things that really help
with a good night's sleep are observing the dawn.
And there's a lot of evidence that shows that exposure to light has...
Positive effects.
This is another thing that you can do.
So just like wake up early in the morning,
you know, head outside and observe the sun
going up.
Natural light exposure is going to be really good.
Like this study shows, and it'll anchor your circadian rhythm.
This tells your biological clock, okay, it's time to wake up.
And when you observe the dawn, it'll be easier to go to bed at night.
The second thing that you want
to do is ideally observe sundown as well.
So this signals to your brain, okay,
now the day is ending and it activates a lot of physiologic
mechanisms that will help you go to sleep.
So good sleep is really, really, really important.
The third thing when we're talking about observing the dawn
and observing the dusk, and this could
be like five, 10 minutes spending them outside.
You can read a book, you can do whatever you want.
Don't be on your phone.
Don't be on a screen.
But the other effect that you gain ground with is nature exposure.
So there are studies that show
that nature exposure has basically a small to medium-sized
effect, more on the small side, on improving your mental health.
So this is where, like, just for five minutes a day,
waking up early, observing the dawn
can have a huge impact on your mental health over time.
Hey, y'all.
If y'all want to learn a little bit more,
by all means, watch another YouTube video.
If you guys are actually interested in finding
the practical tools to change on your own,
that's where Memberships comes in.
And if y'all are interested in getting some help
or achieving a particular milestone
four weeks, eight weeks, or 12 weeks from now, check out Coaching.
So if y'all are interested, check out
the link in the description below.
A couple of other things to keep in mind
when it comes to getting a good night's sleep.
In the deep dive, we also share other important
principles like how you spend your day will
determine how easy it is to go to sleep.
So it's not just about the circadian rhythm.
It's also that your brain has a mental
to-do list about what you should be accomplishing today, right?
So this is something that y'all should be aware of because
when you're like procrastinating during the day,
your brain is like, hey, we should be
doing this, we should be doing this.
And then we run into a problem, which is when we go to sleep at night,
if we have not done enough work during the day,
our brain is like, hey, we shouldn't really be going to bed yet.
And in fact, what a lot of people will experience
is a burst of motivation at bedtime.
And you're like, oh, my God, I'm going to do so much stuff.
I want to do so much stuff.
Where does that burst of motivation come from?
It comes from not doing your work during the day.
So what I find when I work with people
and for myself is when I have a productive day
that I spend doing the things that I should be doing,
I don't get this surge of motivation
at night.
In fact, what I feel is tired and exhausted
and spent in a really good way.
And that helps me sleep, okay?
So if you guys want a kind of a really good understanding
of sleep, check out the deep dive.
Second thing we're going to talk about.
Second thing we're going to talk about, breathing exercises.
But I do have to say that therapists are real doctors
because much like doctors these days.
Maybe I don't want to finish this bit,
but basically every time I went, she was like,
have you been doing your breathing exercises?
And I was like, lady, when are we going
to admit that that ---- does not work?
You got to teach me like a magical spell or something.
This breathing ---- is not getting the job done.
So breathing exercises are really fascinating
because some people swear by them and some
people are like, man, this stuff doesn't do anything.
So if we look at the research, we see some really interesting things.
So here's a study that looks at slow paced breathing
and basically tries to measure the
impact of anxiety.
And what the study finds is what a lot
of patients will report to me, which is that
breathing exercises like help while I'm doing them.
But the moment that I'm done doing them,
my anxiety just like comes right back.
And this is a study that basically finds the same thing,
that slow-paced breathing is effective.
For short-term anxiety and during the course of like
when you're doing the breathing exercises,
it lowers your experience of anxiety.
But what we find in this study is if you ask people
to rate their overall anxiety when
they're using a little bit of breathing practices here,
here, here, and here, their overall
average rate of anxiety does not go down.
And this study also looked at something called
perseverative cognition, which is basically
rumination, which on the whole doesn't appear to go down.
And then we also have studies like this, which are sort of
of like more technical.
So these are also very short term studies
where there's someone's like, okay, like we're
going to like brain scan you,
we're going to look at your alpha symmetry in the brain.
I don't know what kind of brain scan they're using.
I don't remember exactly,
but this is like a highly technical neuroscientific study.
And they're testing anxiety immediately before a breathing exercise
and immediately after the exercise.
So this is also a study looking at a very short-term time window
for whether breathing is effective.
And what they find is, yes, it is effective, but only short-term.
So if you guys...
Or new to the channel, you may not know this,
but I love breathing exercises.
And so I spent seven years studying to become a monk.
That's kind of where this stuff comes from.
And this is more cultural, but whatever.
And so then you guys may be wondering, like,
Dr. K, why do you do so many breathing exercises
if, like, the studies show that the breathing exercises don't work?
This is insane.
Not all breathing exercises are the same.
This is one of the stupidest things that modern mental health...
does. We talk about things like box breathing.
We talk about these random, like, slow-paced
breathing exercises.
But the science of the breath in the mind goes really deep.
And back when I was
faculty at Harvard Medical School,
before this happened, my focus was on developing
evidence-based protocols of breathing exercises
for particular mental illnesses.
So when I have patients with a major depressive disorder,
I do this set of practices.
When I have patients with bipolar disorder,
I use a different set of practices.
And these are practices like Nadi Shuddhi Pranayama,
which is this one, if you guys have seen this.
So it's called alternate nostril breathing.
Breathe in through this nose.
Hold.
Out.
In.
Switch.
Out.
So this is a very specific practice.
We can also look at studies on Nadi Shuddhi Pranayam.
It's one of the most studied breathing exercises in India.
And we see that it is effective for short-term anxiety.
So this is a study that looked at people who are about to,
nursing students who are about to take a test.
And Nadi Shuddhi Pranayam is effective for that.
But there are also studies
that are looking at more long-term things.
This is an 18-week study
where they asked people to do Nadi Shuddhi Pranayam.
And we see improvements in mental health.
We see improvements in physical symptoms.
So we see about 20% reductions in all kinds of stuff
that is more long-term, okay?
So here's the key thing to understand
is that specific breathing exercises
will be more effective
for certain mental illnesses than others.
We have.
A ton of breathing exercises that we teach all over
the channel, and I can't go over
all of them now, but I will explain a couple of the basic principles.
So first thing that you got to understand about
the body is we have homeostatic mechanisms.
What does that mean?
That means that our body has kind of like cycles that it goes through.
So a simple example of this is, let's say...
My sodium level is too high.
So I eat like a bag of chips.
Then what happens is my body detects, oh, sodium level is high.
And then it triggers a response, which is thirst.
So then I feel like drinking water.
I drink water.
My sodium levels go down
because now I'm diluting the sodium in my body with plain water.
And then I no longer feel thirsty, right?
So when I need calories, I feel hungry.
When I need water, I feel thirsty.
That's how it works.
And this also works with our breathing.
And one of the most important reciprocal relationships
is with emotion and breath.
So if I'm feeling a certain emotion, I will breathe a certain way.
So if I'm feeling angry, fast, deep breaths.
If I'm feeling lustful, right?
So this is going to be slow inhalation,
deep inhalation, but rapid exhalation.
So there's a lot of specificity
and nuance around certain emotions and certain breathing
patterns.
Then we have anxious, right?
This is faster, shallower breath,
shallow inhalation, shallow exhalation.
And we sort of know this, right?
People will say like, okay, if you're really,
really panicking, take a deep breath.
So we know that altering
our breathing patterns will alter our mental state.
Even after doing this small amount of breathing,
you guys may have noticed that my energy,
My energy, my tone, my volume.
The speed at which I'm speaking has naturally gone down.
So there are very effective breathing exercises,
but I think that the science of breathing exercises
is so deep and so specific
that not everyone really understands that.
So if you guys really learn good pranayama practices
or good qigong practices,
or even things like, you know,
people have found that things like holotropic breath work
can even do things like induce psychedelic states.
There's a whole...
science behind that that we explore elsewhere on the channel,
but that breathing practices are,
in my opinion, incredibly effective.
You can do them for about five minutes at a time. Some studies
show that if you do them for about 18 minutes,
that's when you start to see hormonal changes in
your body. And once you start changing your hormones,
you'll see more long-term, not really
permanent, but you'll see like long-term changes, okay?
So about 18 minutes is how long it takes to
Next big one, big thing that you can do.
Exercise.
And
so
And so if you're like part of the manosphere,
you'll see like a lot of gym bros talking about,
yeah, like we don't need therapy, bro.
Like just lift. Like after you get dumped,
after you have some kind of setback, just lift, bro.
And this is where like they're not wrong.
So I'm a huge fan of therapy. I think you guys should
do therapy if you're not doing well
But...
Don't let it substitute for physical exercise.
And it's not just the gym, bro.
So here's a study that just came out that showed
that there is a large effect specifically
in women for resistance training
when we're talking about symptoms of depression and anxiety.
There's even some mild evidence that resistance training and just lift,
bro, is arguably even
more efficacious for women than it is for men.
So this is where doing some amount
of exercise is going to help you a ton.
And this is a great meta-analysis
that actually compares what kind of exercise you should do.
At the top of the list is yoga,
followed by high-intensity interval training, followed
by medium-intensity cardiovascular training, okay?
So what are these three things and how do they work?
First, let's understand yoga.
So yoga is not about becoming a human pretzel.
It's not about flexibility.
The real goal of yoga is to bring your mind to the present.
It is to induce a state of one-pointed focus.
Now, people will try to meditate, right?
And when we meditate, we're trying to focus our mind.
We're trying to create a one-pointed mind, but it's hard.
So the yogis figured out something really cool.
They're like, hey, you can do this automatically.
You don't even have to try to focus your mind.
We're going to develop a practice
that automatically focuses your mind, and that is yoga.
So here's how yoga works.
When you adopt a posture, what'll happen is as you do the posture,
if you do it at the right
intensity, and that's the key thing about yoga,
it's not about maximum stretch. It's about
achieving a certain level of stretch that requires
your concentration to maintain. Okay.
So if you're bending down and touching your toes,
what you'll find is that there is a certain level
That you go down, where you really,
at the beginning, you may not have to concentrate,
but as you hold the pose, it requires your concentration to maintain.
So you'll start to shake, you'll start to quiver,
and then like kind of hold it, hold
it, hold it, hold it, hold it.
And this does some really cool things.
So if we look at most mental illness,
most mental illness is thoughts that are not one
pointed.
So when I have depression, I'm
not thinking the same thought technically.
I'm thinking, oh, I'm terrible because of this reason.
I'm terrible because of this reason.
These people don't like me.
These people don't like me.
I'm going to screw this up.
It's a lot of different thoughts.
If we look at anxiety, it's also tied to rumination.
What is rumination?
It's thinking thoughts over and over and over and over and over again.
Then we get to things like mania,
which is thinking a ton of thoughts really fast in
a disorganized way, right?
So basically most, if not all mental illnesses have a lot of thought.
And when you are calm, you are having fewer thoughts.
Like when I'm watching, I'm relaxing at the beach
and I'm just watching the sunset.
Sometimes my mind is completely empty
and that's what feels so good.
Also why heroin is so damn addictive.
Empties people's brains, right?
So one of the key things that the yogis learned
is that like, okay, one pointedness of the mind
is calming, is relieving.
Emptiness of the mind is very relieving,
which is why we all love sleep.
And fentanyl zombies are fentanyl zombies.
So yoga, when done correctly,
will train your mind to be in a one-pointed state.
And the cool thing is, the longer you are in that one-pointed state,
two things will happen.
One is your brain gets used to the one-pointed state,
understands what it is,
understands how to make it, we're artificially making it,
and then can do it again later more automatically.
So when people do yoga,
Their control over things like rumination
and things like that tend to improve.
This is my clinical experience, okay?
Second thing that yoga does is it teaches people how
to shut off the cyclic thoughts
in their brain, because now we're like literally like taking
a break from that for some period
of time.
So if you go to like an hour-long yoga class,
like you'll be in a relatively one-pointed
state for that whole hour, which is a huge amount of relief, okay?
But even five to seven minutes a day of yoga
can have a profound effect on people's mental health.
Second thing is high intensity interval training.
The way that this stuff works
in medium intensity cardiovascular training
is kind of interesting.
So when we stress our body,
when we rapidly increase our heart rate,
when we're breathing really hard,
where like, let's say you go running
for as hard as you can for like three minutes.
Afterward you will be exhausted and as you like lay down
and you collapse a lot of restful
So a lot of restful mechanisms activate, right?
So when I run really, really, really, really,
really fast, heart rate shoots up, blood pressure
shoots up, and then my body's like, okay, we got to relax.
Then I'm exhausted.
My mind slows down, right?
So no one, like when I had patients
who would have panic attacks in my office, one thing
that I would do, depending on how ill they were,
is we'd go outside to Commonwealth Avenue,
which is this street on Boston where there's
this beautiful stretch of basically park.
And like, I would run with them.
We'd run for 60 seconds.
And then we're both exhausted.
We sit down on a park bench,
we're like, and then the thoughts just kind of calm down.
So exercise also does all kinds of things,
physiologically, hormonally, improves blood flow.
So like flushes out all the bad thoughts in your brain
from an evidence-based perspective is very, very helpful.
Next one is really interesting.
Chit chat with strangers.
So a lot of people are struggling with loneliness
and a lot of the common dialogue,
a lot of the research is about deep connections, right?
Do you have people that you can rely on
when you're in a crisis?
Like we used to have six really close connections
and now we've dropped down to three.
Some men have zero.
And so deep connections are really, really, really fantastic.
But if you look at how human brains are organized,
we're actually used to a lot of
lightweight physical interaction.
So this is what's one of the most interesting.
interventions,
because it is so low lift and seems to have a significant impact, which
is just saying hello to people.
Like some amount of brief social interaction, as simple as hello,
can actually have an impact on your mental health.
This is a lesson that I learned.
I had a patient who was acutely suicidal,
was literally thinking about killing themselves that day.
And she said one thing.
She was like, OK, before I die, I'm going
to just have my favorite candy bar.
So they went to a grocery store and they got they wanted to have
their favorite candy bar one last time before they end their life.
And like the the person who is checking them out,
like was like, oh, like that's really
like I've never tried that flavor, but I like that brand.
How is it?
And they had this brief, really simple,
brief interaction where the person who's checking
out was like, you know, haven't I say I hope you enjoy it.
And then like that was enough for this person to rally a little bit,
protected them from
that suicidal impulse in that moment.
So small social interactions seem to have a pretty big impact,
a disproportionately
big impact.
And what I love about small social interactions,
which is just nodding to people on the street,
like I like the bro nod, right?
So like you see, bro, you can do the up nod
or you can do the down nod, like nod, nod, whatever.
Saying hello, making small talk in the elevator,
just asking people, how are you doing today?
Or if someone holds the door for you,
you say, thank you, have a nice day.
Like even these small, simple social interactions,
which human beings have evolved.
In these community, tribal sort of situations seems
to have a disproportionately large impact
on mental health.
Last thing that we're going to talk about are supplements.
And basically, there's one that beats out all
of the others, which is omega-3.
So this is important to understand.
Omega-3 is a fatty acid that our brain can't,
our body can't produce, but our brain really
needs in order to be healthy.
So as our diet has changed,
as we've entered a more processed diet, things like that,
our brain requires omega-3 for the health of neurons
and astrocytes and glial cells and all
this kind of stuff, right?
So our brain needs it, but we can't produce it, which means you have to
get it out of the diet. And if you're not getting out of your diet,
supplementation becomes really
important. So omega-3 is like the one thing,
if you're like, there's one thing you want to take,
like omega-3 is at the top of the list,
definitely talk to your doctor about it.
And the really interesting thing is you can even get like...
Pretty specific with it,
where there are some studies that suggest that a certain type of
omega-3 or a certain ratio of omega-3 is more helpful
in depression versus there is a different
ratio that may be more helpful in anxiety.
A couple of other really,
really important ones for mental health are vitamin D.
So if you're vitamin D deficient,
one of the standard things for the workup of depression
as a medical doctor is I check everybody's vitamin D levels.
Because if you're low,
then we can supplement vitamin D and you'd be amazed at what kind of
impact it has on your mental health. It can be huge.
It improves energy, things like that.
The other thing to check is something
like thyroid hormone. So thyroid hormone,
when it's really low, can cause depression.
And when it's really high, it can cause anxiety.
So there are a couple of like really simple things that, you know,
there are so many patients I've worked with who struggle.
Like they go to psychotherapy, they do all these kinds of things.
And it's like, they have this really like tough mental illness
and you check their vitamin
D level, you realize it's low,
you supplement it and their life becomes so much easier.
And this is kind of the key point that I want
y'all to understand when it comes to the body
and mental illness.
When you are struggling with mental illness,
let's understand what the struggle is.
So your mind is telling you, oh my God, I'm so tired,
or your mind is telling you these people
don't like you, or your mind is telling you don't bother,
you're going to fail anyway. And so if you
look at most people who struggle with mental illness,
the struggle is actually fighting
against their own mind.
And the problem is as the mental illness becomes bad,
The strength of the mind increases.
And so you guys may have found this
where like, if you're struggling against it,
there are some days you win
and some days you lose, fair enough.
But you're exhausted either way
because you have to climb this high mountain.
You have to work so hard to convince your mind
to do the right thing.
You know what the right thing is.
It's just the mind just doesn't listen.
You're so anxious.
You're like, calm down, bro.
They like you.
They're your friends.
They invited you.
But the mind is like, no, they don't.
They invited us just because they feel guilty,
just because we're around, just because,
but they don't really want us there.
And so you have to fight against yourself and it's so exhausting.
So here's what working on your body does.
It doesn't work in the same way as like psychotherapy.
Psychotherapy is like strengthening your mind,
using your mind to overcome your mind.
Disabling your mind.
It's like some ninja move to disable the anxiety, right?
But you're still fighting against it.
What working on physical stuff does is lowers
the strength of the mental illness in your
mind.
When we supplement vitamin D,
like if you're one of the lucky people for whom it's like
very curative, which I've absolutely seen, right?
Takes the wind, it reduces Mount Everest to like an anthill,
but usually something in between.
It makes the mental illness that you're fighting,
it really weakens it because you're leveraging all kinds of physiologic
and anatomical mechanisms to strengthen, I mean,
to weaken the mental illness so that it is easier to overcome.
And a great place to start with this is once again,
getting your sleep in order.
This probably has the largest effect size for the most mental
illnesses. And we've got this two hour deep dive.
You guys can check out the link in the
description below. You guys can sign up for the free trial
and watch that video if y'all want.
So check it out. It's really one of our most useful videos.
