Home Buying: The Most (and Least) Affordable Metros in the U.S.
#Low mortgage rates and limited inventory have generally made things super competitive for first-time home buyers across the United States, but your search will vary based on where you live. Home prices can vary a lot from one metro area to another and across metro. But to really understand what buyers on the ground are seeing in locations across the country, data analyst Liz Renter looked at pricing and supply data from some of the largest metros from July to Sept. 2020.
If you pay any attention to the buying and selling of homes,
you probably already know that it's been an interesting year
for first-time home buyers.
Low mortgage rates paired with a limited number of homes
on the market have made things super competitive.
But to really understand what buyers on the ground
are seeing in locations across the country,
I looked at pricing and supply data
from some of the largest metros from July to September.
In this video, I'll go over what I learned
to help you plan ahead in case you're hoping
to take the plunge into home ownership.
First, let's talk about California.
California is notorious for being an expensive place
to buy a home.
The houses in your price range
are often the houses you don't wanna live in.
And my analysis found that the five most expensive
metro areas for first-time home buyers
were indeed in California.
Los Angeles, San Diego, San Jose,
San Francisco, and Sacramento.
In Los Angeles, for example,
median income for first-time buyers was about $82,000
and list prices were close to one million.
That means homes were listed at about 12 times
the median first-time buyer income.
For reference, the general rule of thumb
is to find a home listed at three times your income.
And though we saw the number of homes on the market
increase in a few of these metros
from the second quarter to the third,
supply is down across the board
when compared to this period last year.
Now moving on to the East Coast.
Some of the most affordable markets for first-time buyers
were on the East Coast this quarter,
but that doesn't mean buyers there aren't seeing high prices.
Pittsburgh is the most affordable
for the second quarter running,
even though homes there were listed 23% higher
in the third quarter of 2020
than they were last year at the same time.
Still, with a median income of $76,000 for first-time buyers
and homes listed at about $250,000,
it's a relatively affordable market.
Other East Coast metros that are relatively affordable
include Buffalo, New York, and Hartford, Connecticut,
where homes are listed at 3.6 times first-time buyer income.
Clearly, not all East Coast metros are affordable.
Far from it.
New York and Boston have homes priced six times more
than first-timers have to spend.
So if you're considering an East Coast move
and your heart isn't set on New York,
you're not without affordable options.
There are plenty of choices where your money can go further.
If you're not committed to living on the coast,
there are many choices in the middle of the country.
Several real affordable metros for first-time buyers.
If you can tolerate the cold, Cleveland is one,
where first-time buyer income is $62,000
and list prices are about $228,000.
St. Louis is another option,
where typical first-time buyer income is $75,000
and homes are listed at about $250,000.
And if you're curious about Texas,
most metros there are about average affordability
and homes are listed at about 4.5 to 5 times
what first-timers have to spend.
So don't overlook the landlocked areas.
There are several midsize metros
where your money can go further.
Now let's zoom out.
Across the board and across the nation,
active listings are down, way down.
So buyers aren't seeing nearly as many homes
when they browse real estate apps.
This means competition is fierce
and buyers are more likely to pay list price
or even more to get under contract.
For example, in Salt Lake City,
where supply fell the furthest,
listings are down 57%
when compared to the same period last year.
Indianapolis is down 53%,
Denver is down 37%.
As a matter of fact, across all metros analyzed,
supply is down 38% on average.
There are just fewer available homes everywhere you look.
As you start thinking about where to buy,
it's important to note that affordability
can vary a lot from one metro to another
and even across a single metro.
A metro area isn't just the city center,
but also surrounding areas.
So averages across metros are a broad simplification,
but a good starting point.
Also, as people have the opportunity
to work remotely long-term,
we may see some leave expensive metros for greener pastures.
In fact, despite supply being down year over year
across the board,
we actually saw the number of homes for sale increase
quarter over quarter in San Francisco,
New York, Seattle, and San Jose,
four of the most unaffordable metros.
Long-term, however, city living will remain popular
for large segments,
and we'll have to just wait and see
how pandemic-era migration
might affect affordability over time.
Also worth noting, would-be buyers
who hope to wait out the scarcity
may find themselves waiting a while.
The flip side of that, the longer you wait,
the bigger a down payment you can save up.
I'm Elizabeth Renter, data analyst at NerdWallet,
and I just put my home on the market this week,
so I'm doing what I can to contribute to the supply
here in the Raleigh, North Carolina metro area.
If you have any questions, leave a comment and subscribe.

