Our urban areas are expected to grow one and a half times by 2045, to over six billion city dwellers - with developed land projected to triple. With this in mind, how can we build healthy cities?
This video is part of the series “The Architecture of Place,” a collaboration between the ICAA, INTBAU, and The Prince's Foundation. Perhaps now more than ever before, we are all aware of the built environment that surrounds us, and of the impacts it has on the health of individuals, communities, and the planet. The Architecture of Place series brings together the established and emerging voices working to create a better built future. You can find more information on the full series here: https://www.classicist.org/the-architecture-of-place/
About the Course: The second event in the 'Architecture of Place' series was held on October 26, 2020, and featured a lecture from Dr. Shipra Narang Suri and Dr. David Howard.
Our urban areas are expected to grow one and a half times by 2045, to over six billion city dwellers - with developed land projected to triple. This rapid growth and urbanization is also set against the backdrop of natural resource depletion and climate change. In order to plan sustainable cities and communities within this context it is important to take an interdisciplinary approach – understanding that the way in which we design and build our cities impacts our public health, economy, environment, and our mental and physical wellbeing.
This talk explores the intersection between health and urbanisation, and what it means for how we plan and manage our cities. David Howard presents his research in urban design and health infrastructure, and Shipra Narang Suri presents on planning services and the role they play in creating healthy living environments. Their presentations are followed by a moderated panel discussion.
About the Speakers:
Dr. Shipra Narang Suri is an urban planner with a Ph.D. in Post-War Recovery Studies from the University of York, UK. She leads UN-Habitat’s Urban Practices Branch, which is the hub for UN-Habitat’s normative work and the home of its portfolio of global programmes. The work of the Branch covers all major areas of UN-Habitat’s work such as national urban policies; legislation and governance; urban planning and design; planning and health; public space; urban regeneration; land, housing and shelter; urban economy and finance; urban basic services; safer cities; human rights and social inclusion. Shipra is also the senior advisor within UN-Habitat for local governments and their networks.
Shipra has extensive experience in advising national and local governments, as well as private sector organisations and networks, on issues of urban planning and management, good urban governance and indicators, livability and sustainability of cities, urban safety, women and cities, as well as post-conflict/ post-disaster recovery. She has worked with the United Nations, specifically, UN-HABITAT, UNDP, and UNESCO, as well as international NGOs such as World Vision, and private sector organisations, for over two decades. She is a regular public speaker at national and international fora, and has several publications to her credit.
Dr. David Howard is an Associate Professor in Sustainable Urban Development at the University of Oxford, and a Fellow of Kellogg College, Oxford. He is Director of Studies for the Sustainable Urban Development Programme at the University of Oxford, which promotes lifelong learning for those with professional and personal interests in urban development. David is also Co-Director of the Global Centre on Healthcare and Urbanisation at Kellogg College. The Centre hosts public debates and promotes research on key urban issues affecting society today, with the aim to provoke discussion and constructive action, linking current best practice in related areas of research.
Sponsors: The ICAA would like to thank The Benton Family Foundation for its generous support of this lecture series, along with series sponsor McCrery Architects. Additional thanks to INTBAU's supporters for this series, Fairfax & Sammons, ADAM Architecture, and Size Group. Additional thanks to The Prince's Foundation's supporter, Mr. Paul Beirne.
About our channel: This course is presented by the Institute of Classical Architecture & Art, a national nonprofit promoting the practice, understanding, and appreciation of classical design. To watch more online classes like this one, or to become a member and support our educational mission, visit https://www.classicist.org/ .
Good afternoon. It's a great pleasure to be here and introducing this wonderful new series,
The Architecture of Place, a collaboration between the ICAA, INSBAO and the Prince's Foundation.
This series of talks is a collaboration between these three organizations and focuses
on the built environment and its impact on the health of individuals, communities and the planet.
Established and emerging voices will speak on their work to create a better built future,
something we can all look forward to. It is my pleasure to introduce the second lecture in the
series. The title of this lecture is Health and Urbanization, Creating Healthy Cities,
with Shipra Noorangsuri and David Howard. Urban areas are expected to grow one and a half times
by the year 2045 to over six billion city dwellers, with developed land projected to triple.
This growth is set against the backdrop of natural resource depletion and climate change. This talk
will discuss an interdisciplinary approach to planning sustainable cities and communities
and emphasizes understanding that the way in which we design and build our cities
impacts our public health, economy, environment and our mental and physical well-being.
Introduce our speakers, Shipra Noorangsuri. Dr. Shipra Noorangsuri is an urban planner with a
PhD in post-war recovery studies from the University of York in the UK. She leads the
UN's Habitat Urban Practices Branch, which covers all major areas of the UN's habitats work,
such as national urban policies, urban planning and design, human rights and social inclusion,
and much more. Shipra is also the senior advisor within the UN Habitat for local governments
and their networks. She is the former co-chair of the World Urban Campaign, a platform that
brings together a large array of global organizations to advocate for sustainable
urbanization and a former vice president for the General Assembly of Partners, a platform
established to bring stakeholder voices to Habitat 3 in the drafting of a new urban agenda.
Dr. David Howard is an associate professor in sustainable urban development at the University
of Oxford and a fellow of Kellogg College at Oxford. He is director of studies for the sustainable
urban development program at the University of Oxford, which promotes lifelong learning
for those with professional and personal interests in urban development. David is also
co-director of the Global Centre on Healthcare and Urbanization at Kellogg College. Welcome
David Howard and Shipra Noorangsuri for the lecture. Thank you. Hello, I'm David. Thank you
very much indeed for the introduction. It's a pleasure to be with you at this moment. Yes,
I work in Oxford and I work particularly in sustainable development, but over the last year
or so I've been working closely with colleagues in evidence-based healthcare. So my 10 minutes or so
talk will be really looking at that work we've been doing and a systematic review that I've done
over the last few months to really look at the link between urban development, healthcare and
pointing towards elements for a green recovery, particularly how to link urban design with
providing healthcare and building healthcare into the urban environment. So I'll have a few
slides. Great, well it's a pleasure to be here in this series on Architectural Place and we've
been asked to address what is a healthy city. I'll be focusing really on that relationship between
humans, built environment, nature society relations and to some extent looking at this
in the context of a post or unfortunately mid-COVID-19 society. So my background as I
said is within sustainable urban development in Oxford. I work with the Sustainable Urban
Development Programme. We work with urban practitioners who want to continue their
studies in the field of sustainable development either as masters or a PhD programmes. That by
its very nature is interdisciplinary. We've worked very closely with the Prince's Foundation and set
the course up 10 years ago with the Prince's Foundation. So that is one element that has
really been integral to trying to understand how cities work or don't work. Another aspect I'm
involved with is the Global Centre on Healthcare and Urbanisation. This was set up in September
last year without any idea that COVID-19 was going to happen. But that centre was set up on
the basis of working with a whole series of colleagues in sustainable urban development
at Kellogg College Oxford but also with colleagues also connected with the college and the University
of Oxford at large who were working in evidence-based healthcare. We realised that although
we're spending many meetings together and passing each other in the corridor or sending emails,
we rarely sat down just to realise the integral link between urban design and healthcare and
really going back to some of the basics of urban planning to provide healthy spaces. So the centre
was set up as I said in September 2019, supported again by the Prince's Foundation. We've done a
series of public engagement events etc up until COVID-19 to really look at that link between
urban design, healthy cities and healthcare provision. One of the aspects of that that's
evolved during the COVID-19 crisis is to set up an evidence-based service out of the University
of Oxford that tries to look at this cross-disciplinary inter-practice or inter-practitioner
response to COVID-19. The website itself had over 15 million viewers in the first month in March
of this year and it just showed the interest I think in that need really for evidence-based
knowledge from members of government, public, fellow researchers etc. So this is really the
basis for my thoughts on healthy cities really and how COVID-19 is affecting them. I think this
really comes to root really one of the interests that I've had between nature, technology and cities.
A great book by Brian Arthur who looks at the nature of technology and he argues that we are
tuned in the deepest parts of our being to nature, to our original soundings and our original
conditioning to humankind. We have a familiarity with nature, a reliance on it that comes from three
million years of at-homes with it. We trust nature. When we happen upon a technology such as stem cell
regenerative therapy we experience hope. We also immediately ask how natural this technology is
and so we're caught between two huge and unconscious forces. Our deepest hope as human
lies in technology but our deepest trust lies in nature. These forces are like tectonic plates
grinding excorably into each other in one long slow collision. I think this relationship between
technology, if you will, urban development and nature has come to the forefront in many respects
over the last six months globally and it feeds into some earlier work over the last decade or so
of ecologicalizing the city. Those keen urban geographers amongst you and sociologists
will recognize the work of the Chicago school in 1930s that looked at urban ecology but more
recently the notion of bringing in our understanding of the biophysical world into the
way cities are planned and built etc has been key and Carvone and Evans and Van Heer have said well if
we are using resilience as a way to understand the world then perhaps an adaptive management
approach provides a better way of its operational delivery. In particular learning from the natural
world from the biosphere around us and arguably urban development is just a series of experiments
and one hopes that one experiment is better than the last but learning from ecological biological
principles for example found in water energy and forms of biodiversity are one ways we can apply
this to understanding how cities work and so there's a notion that we have experimental green
cities of testbeds for sustainability and also recognize a new series of stakeholders involved
in these urban experiments can also be the animal world around there's trees plants etc
but I think increasingly so we recognize that the needs for health care and preventative health care
is a key aspect of designing cities and I think one of the things we could to do is challenge
some of those buzzwords if you will those taken for granted concepts that we may use every day
Raymond Williams I think in 1968 wrote a book called Keywords where he sort of looked at some
of the words that kind of shape in whatever language the way humans understand the world
around them and he argued that words such as culture were one of the most complicated
words in human language because it encompassed so many ideas that one felt were obvious and
intrinsic but actually when you start drilling down if you will and picking what certain key
terms mean then they can make extremely complex and I think nature is clearly one of those buzzwords
and urban and you might say land as well some terms that we use quite readily and maybe uncritically
but one of the key things that the current pandemic has brought into line is to try to
understand what is the relationship between nature our use of land and the urban world around us
so to some extent I think it's interesting look at revaluation of nature society relations
not least because the Ankara scene in which we are involved is the first time
writers of such a farrier argue that humans project a future of dystopia beforehand maybe
humans wrote about the great progress enlightenment the renaissance of human existence
now increasingly we're imagining a world that unless we do something then end of humanity is
there before us and I think one of the ways of bringing together nature society and human
existence in the built environment is maybe to take up scott and torpor's idea of seeing the
urban as intrinsic a part of human existence as nature to recognizing that humans by and large do
live in groups and this notion of creating an urban environment of what of a scale is a key
part of our existence so after last few months I've been doing a systematic review of the impact
of COVID-19 or pandemics in general in terms of urban development and one of the things I've been
focusing on is this notion of nature within the built environment and a very if you will quick
and look at some ways we portray nature say this case in smart urbanism smart cities is often quite
glib in many ways almost cartoonish that we'll put a tree in there a few birds maybe some solar
wind turbines and that says that's how we're working with nature but arguably as I mentioned
really digging into what do you really mean by nature society relationships where do humans
place themselves in that link or disconnection if you will from the biosphere and arguably some of
the critiques of smart urbanism have been that humans become if you will digital points on a
otherwise apolitical landscape or nature too arguably could be maybe monitored and measured
but how much do we take into account natural rights or the rights of nature into our urban
design and I think many have written about the importance of parks and green spaces and
increasingly so literally around green infrastructure has been recognized very
much so amongst those working in all aspects of urban development over the last few decades
and Kuntzler who writes about 19th century parks he says will there be a return to nature and this
was written in 2001 and arguably I think people's experience of lockdown or confinement in some ways
has made us reflect upon humans relationship with a natural world around us in order to create those
healthy urban environments so Kuntzler argued or wrote the 19th century park throughout the western
world was a monument to the landscape was being lost in a rush to modernization an attempt to
embed an artifact remnant of the rural countryside within the overwhelming denatured fabric of the
expanding industrial city so my work over summer really tried to look at that relationship between
citizen nature particularly looking at the more recent evidence-based analyses of human experience
in cities during COVID-19 were reviewed through 384 studies to try and work out what were the
leading themes if you will on current research and how humans were dealing with not only COVID-19 but
dealing with current urban existence and I think a series of studies have showed
that residents in urban areas have been more aware of in brackets sort of in commas
nature the idea of recognizing the entrance if you will or the someone say encroachment
but let's say the sharing of urban spaces by wildlife otherwise animals that would not be
within the city sphere does this recognition of human relationship with nature will that spur on
to greater awareness of climate change or environmental concerns and unfortunately some
of the initial studies will say well no that doesn't seem a great link at this present time
between recognizing human condition and the condition of nature in city environments and
actually active changing of behavior or attitude towards environmental matters or climate change
but quite clearly studies are showing that green infrastructure and health care are integral to
creating healthy cities so that enmeshing not only of urban design and health care but of
recognizing human relationship to nature are key in a way forward so I've just got three slides I
think just to show some of the evidence base of the valuing nature within the city so in 1984
Ulrich and co-workers showed that actually not only an active engagement with urban green spaces
but just the visual viewing nature improved health and speeded up recovery so in the hospital in the
US the team had 23 surgical patients who had a view onto a natural scene the landscape the garden
and showed that actually comparing 23 patients with similar ailments that the 23 who had a
view on nature by and large had a shorter stay in hospital recovered quicker had lower levels
of depression or downtime should we say and their medication was more effective but what I'm trying
to show in the next couple of slides is there is a lot of information that's shown from previous
studies the importance of developing urban areas developing a built environment in the context of
biosphere and natural world around us so parks again have been brought to the fore really during
this post-covid era especially urban settlements and just one study by Jackson and colleagues just
showed that high density neighborhoods access to public buildings open spaces mixed land use
pedestrian walkways greenery both visual in terms of them to move through green areas and effective
urban infrastructure provided opportunities for increased physical exercise and enhanced
civic life so that combining of active commuting active city living not only in physical ways but
I guess in emotional and social ways so a clearly strong public health arguments for incorporating
greenery green infrastructure natural light and visual and physical access to open space
in all aspects of our unbuilt environment and I think just a couple of final slides just to
show the importance of trees so a study by Swinbourne and Rosenwax in 2017 reviewed 500
studies and just showed that greater street calipy in urban areas reduced urban heat reduced the
costs of maintenance in urban areas and increased property values which may or may not be good
depending on your access to those properties but in Melbourne there are 70 000 trees and it's
estimated if there were 28 percent induction and heat related deaths in Melbourne if the city's
tree canopy was doubled to 140 000 trees and similarly in the city of Brisbane it was estimated
that the value of trees in terms of improving air quality capturing rain and storing carbon
was estimated at just under 1.7 million Australian dollars and the final study I'm very happy to give
these full links to the audience if they're interested Vandenberg and colleagues did a
systematic review the first systematic review of epidemiological studies examining the relationship
between green space and health and from reviewing the series of studies evidence clearly showed that
living in greener environments is associated with better mental health and lower all-cause mortality
so therefore it's in conclusion handing over to Shipra an urban design really should focus
more on quality than the quantity of green space and the greening of living environments is a
promising tool for enhancing public health. Thank you that was great and I'm just going to
exactly take off where David left off and talk about how do you create healthy cities by
integrating health and urban and territorial planning. I work for UN Habitat which is the
United Nations Agency for Human Settlements aiming to develop towards a sustainable urban future
my work really encompasses as the dean very kindly said everything ranging from housing basic
services of planning and design land human rights social inclusion public space so I'd be happy to
share some thoughts and some examples from our work at the UN. I want to start with actually we
were asked the question what makes a healthy city I want to start with what makes an unhealthy city
and COVID of course has shown us cities being the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic with over 90
now some are saying even 95 percent of all cases in urban areas that there is something to be said
about the relationship between health and the type of urbanization that we see across the world today
and the type is the key word here but also what makes an unhealthy city is air quality huge huge
factors the biggest single largest environmental risk to health with an estimated 7 million premature
deaths every year globally from air pollution about four and a half million of those from
outdoor air pollution physical activity the way cities are planned and designed David was talking
about compactness and walkability but a worldwide one in four adults and three and four adolescents
do not currently meet the global recommendations for physical activity and the costs of that are
huge both in direct health care as well as large productivity and finally what makes an unhealthy
city is also the very very poor nutritional health of its residents linked to physical
inactivity but also linked to the type of food we eat or the type of nutrition we get etc so
there's a lot to be said on health and cities and unhealthy cities but what are the spatial
factors and I'm basically I'm elaborating on what David just talked about what are the spatial
factors that are linked to public health when you look at planning and I'm a planner by training
you look at the use of resources you look at land use you could have informed and design
look at transport mobility movement networks look at green blue and public open spaces and
you can see that they can protect you from harm in terms of air pollution noise exposure to risk
they can promote health and they can provide services and access to services which basically
can enhance our physical and mental health as well as health equity which is really
access to health care services planning for healthy cities results in co-benefits across
a wide range of SDGs those of you who know the sustainable development goals adopted in
2015 as part of the agenda 2017 goals with 169 targets and one of them of course relates to
good health and well-being that's the SDG3 but health is linked to all of the 17 sustainable
development goals these are goals that were adopted by all member states of the United
Nations committed to by all member states of the United Nations related to poverty hunger
sustainable and resilient human settlements gender education energy life on water climate change
life on earth life underwater peace justice and you can see that health is a factor
which really is connected to all of those goals it's not just scope it's also the range of
non-communicable diseases that threaten the resilience and sustainability of cities and
of human settlements so what do we do what are we doing about it at UN Habitat our objectives are
threefold when you talk about planning for healthy cities and territories
one is the importance of building up the knowledge among local actors upon local national
regional leaders among health and planning professionals building up the knowledge
giving them the indicators the guidance the tools to integrate health and well-being into their
urban development decision making exactly what David was just saying taking an interdisciplinary
a cross-disciplinary kind of approach in fact planning was a profession that was rooted in
public health came about because of the need for public health improvements and really building up
that understanding and giving the tools and the resources to local actors to integrate
health into all urban development decision making the second is to support countries or partners
and on implementing and localizing and applying the knowledge you know that is available globally
and localizing and the third is to support the monitoring and assessment of health and
well-being in cities and territories very often people come to us and say I don't know what to do
or that I know I'm doing something but I don't know if I'm on the right track
I don't know how to monitor it I don't know what the impact of my work is and is going to be which
is where we assist them both in terms of the indicator sets but also using those indicators
and building up capacities to use them and there are a number of global frameworks that guide us
the most recent of these is the source book that we've developed you and Habitat has developed
with WHO which is about integrating health in urban and territorial planning it doesn't stand
on its own it builds on the SDG 11 it builds on the international guidelines in urban territorial
planning builds on the new urban agenda that was adopted in 2016 by member states and various
global commitments this is a source for you and Habitat and WHO have been working on for the last
couple of years perversely launched this year had nothing to do with COVID till COVID came along
of course this source book really details why health needs to be part of urban development
and urban practice and how can we make it happen how can we make it happen through housing through
access to basic services through water sanitation through public space through mobility through
compact urban form through better building design etc and it really connects planning and health
approaches and brings together about a very large number of existing resources and tools in this
area interestingly it has different kinds of entry points which is important because very often you
get put off when you look at a resource because it's got nothing to do with your type of work or
the entry points that you're familiar with so for those that work on urban planning or
urban design there are a number of entry points in terms of you know whether you can enhance
or integrate health into cities through public space through movement corridors
through green and blue networks through amenities through better design of housing and various kinds
of estates or by outcome or by principle you know are you in the business of road safety are you in
the business of social environmental justice are you talking about healthy cities more generally
and you can take various kinds of entry points or through sectors what is the relationship of
the housing sector with health what is the relationship of local economy with health
this relation of transport and health so it gives different entry points and allows people to use it
in different ways i want to talk this is very very dear to my heart and i do want to talk about the
because planning is really a fundamentally integrating profession it's by definition
interdisciplinary you cannot do planning without a very large variety of disciplines
but planners are not just technocrats planners are also mobilizers planners are also advocates
planners are also community leaders planners are also visionaries planners are also political
leaders and their role is really to bring public health voices into decision-making processes
spatial decision-making processes but also take the spatial element into the public health profession
that's very important to be able to speak the language that both sides understand and the
other role of planning is also as i said before to develop monitoring systems that can ensure
that whatever proposal you're developing whatever project you're proving actually you're able to
model its impact on health as well as health equity equitable access to health the third
their role is really to promote and support the health of all citizens by enabling
you know the full exercise of their rights to city services to urban amenities to basic
infrastructure and and to opportunities sometimes there are people are located way too far to be
able to access what cities have to offer and there's a very very large proportion that gets
completely left out and exists at the fringe of the urban fabric and of urban society the role
of planners is really to bring those in from the fringe into the mainstream. I also want to share
a couple of case studies on what we've done to promote healthy cities in different ways using
different entry points. The first of these is some work we've done recently in Nairobi which is our
home the UN Habitat is headquartered in Nairobi and I'm based in Nairobi it's our home for a lot
of what we do and we've recently launched a city-wide public space inventory and assessment
and I know David said the quality of public space is much more important than the quantity and I
would say David adding to that the quality the distribution nobody having one large city park
and no other green space anywhere else as well as the access to that public space is absolutely
fundamental it's not about how many square kilometers you have or how many square meters
you have in the public space but how well is it distributed across the city who has access to it
how is it maintained is it green is it not green what kind of amenities does it include you know
a street is also public space technically a highway also comes into public space that's
not what we're looking for right so really it's what are we looking for is the distribution the
access and the quality of public spaces and this is something we've assisted Nairobi with
and now we're working with them to actually convert a lot of their unused public spaces
potential public spaces into usable connected public spaces a network of public spaces across
the city a second example I want to give is really about we've talked we've talked a little bit about
climate change not much but really talking about cities and cities being both the generators of
greenhouse gas emissions but also the main sufferers from the impacts of climate change
now they bear the vast chunk of consequences of climate change and one of those consequences
is also the heat island and we've seen we're working in Sharjah in the UAE we're looking at
nature-based solutions we're looking at areas with green coverage mapping areas with green coverage
and seeing how there is a heat island effect and how that heat island effect can be
reduced through enhancing green cover so we've mapped out the whole city and we're looking at
per capita green area and different parts of the city and how that can be enhanced so that's the
other small example I wanted to give and it's out in Cameroon where we are doing exactly what was
just talked about just really building a coalition of actors for a healthy urban and a healthy
planning system talking about you know bringing in participants from different stakeholders and
actors together to talk about planning to talk about policy making talking governance
integrating health and planning a health-focused planning system assessment which is quite unique
really a new element of the work we do. Now coming to COVID-19 in conclusion it's interesting
and again for Wesley COVID-19 has been the advertisement for good planning and really
that is something it is the advertisement for adequate housing we have been talking about it
the right to decent quality housing what you've mentioned David about you know ventilated housing
open spaces windows a clean air both indoor and outdoor air quality but also just the basics
having access to water and sanitation and toilets and solid waste management it's been the biggest
possible advertisement for some of the most basic human rights cities and communities need and this
is something that we've talked about a lot in our support to cities bonding to COVID as well as
recovering from COVID said but you need to get the basics right. COVID is spreading in dense overcrowded
settlements which means there is a problem with dense overcrowded settlements in the first place
you tell people to isolate where will they isolate you tell people to keep social distance where are
they going to keep social distance you tell them to wash their hands 10 times a day when they don't
have to drink so how are those parameters of containing COVID going to work in cities which
are not built for a healthy life. This is data that most people would know but 95 percent of
global cases are in urban areas maybe you wouldn't know that 1500 cities in 200 territories
have been affected by COVID-19. A billion people live in informal settlements and slums
similar number another 1 billion live in homelessness or in not in slums but in other
types of overcrowded housing. Two and a half billion people lack access to safe water and sanitation
how are we going to control this pandemic in these situations only by looking at building
back better and therefore I would just like to conclude by saying COVID is a reminder is the
advertisement we needed desperately needed probably to build back better by going back to the basics
decent and adequate shelter clean water clean air effective waste collection management affordable
and efficient public services mixed land use you know we've all been in lockdown
you can't commute long distances and people who are in working in the informal sector who have to
go far away to buy their wares can no longer do so and are losing their livelihoods we're talking
about well-distributed accessible public in green space talking about accessible public transport
and we talk about proximity economies because there are a number of people that have moved back
from urban to rural areas the migration the patterns the disruption of supply chains
has shown us that the model that we are working with doesn't work and I'd like to just conclude
by saying like David said it's not the quantity of the urban of the public space or it's the quality
I'd like to say it's not cities and urbanization per se the quality of urbanization that really
determines whether it will be a healthy city or it will not. Thank you both that was a fascinating
discussion I could have listened to much more of it but I thought I would just continue the
conversation I've got a few questions that came up as you were speaking starting off really
straightforward where you left off which was this idea about the right type of urban spaces and not
urban spaces inherently and I think one of the things that I think we all saw in the midst of
COVID is that a lot of the conversations around health and urbanization have been trending towards
a sort of potentially anti-urban sentiment that there's something inherently flawed with our
urban areas that create ill health and one of the things I guess I suppose is how do we switch that
narrative how do cities become places that are actually instigators of good health so maybe a
question for you both Shivra since you raised the theme maybe I'll leave that one with you first.
Okay thanks no this is true this is so true you know the whole discussion about let's all leave
our apartments in the city and move to you know encourage sprawl and move to the suburbs and have
single family homes with large gardens and five bedrooms because we all need to work from home and
we all need to isolate that sort of discourse is one that has been very very damaging the other
very damaging discourse has been because cities don't have I don't have space in my flat so that's
part of it the other damaging discourse has been let's not use public transport let's all go back
to using our cars because it's so unsafe and we're all going to get infected if we get into the
tube or the metro or the bus you know let's also not go out into public space you don't know who
you meet you don't know how you're going to engage with those people and the whole point
about the whole counter argument that we've been talking about is constantly saying yes but if we
had adequate public space well distributed public space in the hearts of cities we could have used
it in this time we could have used it effectively the problem with public transport is not public
transport per se but the fact that we don't have enough of it that we have you know a matatu
which should take 22 or 21 passengers usually takes about 49 because you don't have enough of
it right and similarly when you talk about housing you talk about you know we don't have well
ventilated housing or apartments the fact of the matter is that we have built too close we have
built too dense and nobody ever said that you know density will solve everything there is an
optimum density that's all stuff and then beyond that DACA is not optimum density you know so
really we have to flip the narrative by saying yes but what kind of urbanization are we talking
about and the other point is really that just because COVID has come the climate problem hasn't
gone away and we cannot afford to lose the very minimal gains we've made in the last five years
about you know not using cars about future public transport about more dense more compact
urban settlements about reducing sprawl reducing single car use so a lot of that really has to
go hand in hand it's not COVID or climate it's not COVID or sustainable development
David very rightly said COVID is a symptom of our unsustainable patterns is a reflection of
sustainable patterns of development which makes the Paris agreement the sustainable development
world's new urban agenda sustainable urbanization more important than ever before rather than less
important than that's the narrative we need to really capture and give it over to David to
kick off from there thanks very much I think if some of the early studies coming out in cities
high level you mentioned that 95 percent of cases of COVID case of urban areas
but it's not as much the density it's off the scale of the urban area so high density urban
living is not directly lead per se to high levels of pandemic and or unhealthiness if you will in
whatever context so it's been found that actually the large cities would then need people to travel
across larger distances had higher rates of COVID-19 where density alone actually in many
ways it had many more benefits it wasn't directly related with high rates of COVID high density
urban areas allow active travel it allowed people to cycle to work the 15-20 minute case so 15-20
minute city has gone in the space of I think from you know 12 months from being this oh this utopian
idea to be a major strategy for the mayor of Paris and being re-elected so I think density is not the
evil neither is urban neither is high levels of urban density but actually having manageable
cities 15-minute cities where you can have mixed land use you can commute actively if you're able
to that's the answer per se so you know city groups such as city 40 alliance are you know very
keen on promoting the green recovery and in for urban areas and I'd say there's probably a
recognition I wouldn't say anti-urban in many ways there's quite a lot of pro-urban
pro the right type of urban development linking to what you said I think the problem what you
said about manageable and the challenge is really alongside urban planning good planning
it's also good urban management and it's also good urban governance and I think you see where
the response has worked and where the promise of green recovery is highest is where cities
which are seeing good governance I think that also is very much a factor and must be talked
about as such as a factor in terms of building back better and actually I think that leads
really nicely into a couple of questions that have come through from those who are watching
and I think one person sort of asked about the negative impacts of automobiles and how do you
reduce those impacts but I think someone else is sort of referencing that a lot of our emotional
health is challenged by the stress of urban living so congestion noise crime whatever it may be and
other things that we can do beyond some of say the more sort of sticking plasters on type of
initiatives like planting more trees or living within well-designed housing which is obviously
important but I suppose coming on to I suppose I think urban governance things like that are the
things that we can do on a more holistic scale uh to address some of these sort of our emotional
and I suppose physical well that shipper is doing in the larger organizations is that change the
mainstream ideas about healthy living and what you know active travel now being something you
choose to do it's also about the classic idea of being an environmental citizen or a citizen
world that actually realistic if government's telling you something you have to do something
like recycling is a classic example if you're told to do it the chances are you might do it
um because your neighbors are doing it uh you might be getting some 10 cents back for a bottle
but as soon as those initiatives are taken away unless there's a definite emotional sort of
engagement to change and that's really any way you can have a sustainable path for the future
going back to the point about a holistic approach and about governance
what makes city living easy and comfortable and not stressful is also the ability to make your
own choices to be able to walk to be able to choose your mode of transport to be able to
choose where you live and work many other factors involved including the cost of housing
the availability of infrastructure to walk or cycle the proximity you have to your place of work
and simple stuff such as the street lighting so there are many factors that actually
some of them seem cosmetic but have a very as David in one of his slides was talking about
the impact of trees it seems cosmetic but it has a very strong proven health impact now there's a
lot of research around it similarly street lights seems like a you know like what but talk about a
woman wanting to walk from the bus stop in the evening to her home on a dark street and what is
her biggest stress factor is the fact that there is no light on that route that she takes every day
you know so all of those can be resolved through a better obviously a better approach to urban
governance to more transparent more accountable governance but also through very basic
environmental design very very basic environmental design can take care of a lot of those parameters
I think that makes a lot of sense I think that also brings something that both of you really
touched on in your talks and I think that was the idea that this is a very interdisciplinary
subject so this is something that inherently cuts across a range of subject areas a range of
disciplines a range of practices and I think a question obviously quite interesting and close
to my heart what is the role of education within that and I think that is true of both the education
of practitioners and the education of the public and how do we create sort of that next generation
who are taking a more integrated interdisciplinary approach to addressing some of these things
I think well I think that's key and in terms of having multi-disciplinary courses and short
courses accessible as well for people who have or interested in urban matters who are
practitioners so you can have architects engineers finance folks sitting around the same table and
discussing matters in a sort of a in an atmosphere that's not competitive so the program I work with
it's quite interesting how we have workshops and we'll have a room of mixed urban practitioners
sitting down and many say it's quite nice to be able to talk about architecture without having
to represent my firm I can discuss engineering issues or financial issues and we're not sort
of out in a project ongoing to be competitive or just have to protect their corner and there's a
great survey just completed by the institute of commonwealth architects and engineers that
has come out recognizes the shortage of certain key skill areas in this case commonwealth
countries I think you can look well beyond the commonwealth but not only this short is some key
training areas but the in many cases there are too many planners in some areas and too few in
others so I think the redistribution of those skills are key but also to have a situation where
you do speak across the various disciplines and practices and I think shipper is far more qualified
to talk about that than me because I spend most my time in a classroom or on a field site etc but
that interdisciplinarity is key and talking across languages if you will or professions
no absolutely and in fact I want to pick up on an example from my former academic life
where I was teaching a course I won't say where I was teaching a master's in urban design course
I was taking a small course on international frameworks for sustainable urban development
and I asked there were 18 students in the class in my first class I said how many of you have
heard of the SDGs to how many of you know something about the Paris agreement one and I said what are
your aspirations what do you want to do and most of them wanted to open their own private architectural
urban design firm this that so I said do you realize that with the next building you build
you will single-handedly be responsible for destroying the climate you're like what what's
it got to do with me you know and you realize the lack of interdisciplinarity in many many a vast
majority there's very few like Dawson today but also some of the others it's very few which
actually even teach about forget about interdisciplinarity which actually even teach
about the major problems facing the planet today whether it is poverty whether it is inequality
whether it is informality whether it is climate change whether it is biodiversity loss whether
it is you know health inequity I think several years ago about 10 years ago there was this survey
also by by one of the commonwealth organizations I think cap or or one of those
commonwealth association planners which actually said that less than five percent of planning
courses in the world taught anything about time arguably this was 10 years ago but still so it's
an example that is changing that is changing of course you're in academia we support a lot
of work around continuing education with planning associations with networks and we've just launched
something which says you know as part of your continuing with the APA for example the American
Planning Association part of your continuing education you have to take credits every few
years and you have to take at least four courses in climate related stuff before you can get your
credits you know so suddenly they're tied to something new so both in terms of education
graduate and postgraduate education also school education starting with you know starting very
young continuing education the stuff that we do which is capacity development of professionals
through practice you know on the ground all of that has to take a harmonized approach a consciously
interdisciplinary multidisciplinary approach we don't do that we will never come to those
sustainable solutions we're looking for we'll not come to that transformative change that we're looking for
and probably David you and I need to have an offline conversation where we're going to take
this conversation forward but those are the kinds of things we need to do I'd like to join that
conversation no I think I think what you're pointing to is sort of this almost virtuous
circle between learning and teaching and how it's constantly sort of reinforcing we're going to end
with one final question I'm afraid uh just for the sake of time but take one from one of the people
watching Lisa who I think it's a really interesting question and states that when COVID began
Seattle shut down all the urban parks to discourage gatherings it was deemed okay to walk but
gathering was discouraged they've since reopened the parks in full do you find it interesting how
our health recommendations are constantly evolving throughout the crisis as we learn more about the
virus and how the urban environment is set up to respond uh I think a really interesting and
timely question to leave us on and Shifra I don't know if you want to take that one first
no indeed we didn't know enough about the virus we still don't know enough about the virus
but the one thing they say the one thing that's constantly strange the one thing that we
do know is we're going to have to learn to live with any promises of a vaccine being available
mass-produced and for you know every man woman and child on this planet it's not a real proposition
so we are learning uh we are talking about people being able to use spaces with a certain density
and with a certain distance with certain time distribution again public health officials
and city officials whose guidelines have evolved have actually fared better than those who have
been very rigid from the beginning because the social consequences of a rigid lockdown
the mental health consequences but also the social consequences of a very rigid lockdown in
a lot of the world are equally disruptive and equally um devastating and traumatic we do have
to evolve and in fact cities that have evolved and changed and adapted their responses as more
and more knowledge has emerged about the virus and about how it spreads you know the use of opening
parks is a political as well as a science-led response and science evolves and what we know
changes on a rapid basis so rules will change as as our scientific knowledge changes quite rapidly
um but it also comes down you know whole idea of urban governance that's really to have a
create a healthy city it's looking at you know what the uh experts or researchers in
health care are saying and also relating that in terms of forms of effective governance
I think one of the key aspects I think that's coming through is the almost competitive nature
between countries but it's almost like I have no idea how many variations are but let's say there
is COVID-19 how each country and in some ways each cities are sort of responding in different ways
and I think that is probably something that I find of interest that it's all like each on our own
against a global virus which you know raises questions. No there is a lot of peer learning
going on at this point between cities between local governments there are many learning networks
I mean okay we're all webinared out a little bit but there are many many learning networks and they
have shown that you know as you said we're not dealing with this in isolation there's a lot of
experience exchange there's a lot of uh good practice exchange there's a lot of exchange
around this didn't work for us don't go there kind of thing and a lot of thematic exchange
around issues around migration and COVID issues around food systems and COVID issues around
public health systems and COVID of course issues around women and their livelihoods and COVID
women's safety and COVID violence and I mean so there's a lot of semantics which have come out
which have actually helped going back to the last question with this interdisciplinarity and
connecting the dots that people see that these things are not divorced from each other they don't
exist independent of each other this is all connected. Absolutely fascinating well I think
we could probably all sit here and listen to a lot more of these questions and I'm sorry to everyone
that we didn't get to all of them there's some great questions out there um but hopefully this
is just the beginning of the conversation um and I just want to thank again thank you both David
Thank you Simon.