Greg Maddux’s 76-pitch complete game is FAKE | Baseball Bits

ThinkGeek
6 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 18, 2022
The mainstream baseball media is lying to you about Greg Maddux.
He wasn't some soft tosser.
He didn't always pitch to contact.
You ever seen this?
It's not true, and MLB has the gall to say Greg Maddux threw a 76-pitch complete
game in 1997.
That's impossible, right?
It finally happened.
A few months ago, the aptly named YouTube channel This Is Where You Find Baseball uploaded
a VHS copy of Greg Maddux's complete game versus the Cubs from July 22, 1997.
Previously, the only clips from this two-hour masterpiece came from MLB's official page,
which somehow thought it was a good idea to condense a performance whose highlight is
the pitch count into a generic two-minute clip that provides no context for Maddux's
approach or rhythm.
The title claiming a 76-pitch complete game is doing the heavy lifting here, as it's
by far the most viewed Greg Maddux content on the official MLB channel.
But the video itself could come from any start.
You could accomplish the exact same thing with a couple strikeouts and groundouts from
Noah Syndergaard's 79-pitch complete game.
Of course, that one was 5 innings and then called for rain.
But there's a controversy.
The MLB clip claims 76 pitches, Baseball Reference, which uses scorecard data from RetroSheet,
claims 77, and the TBS broadcast of the game claims...
Put on your detective hat, kid.
We're gonna solve this case once and for all.
How many pitches did Greg Maddux throw versus the Cubs on that fateful day?
Along the way, we're gonna uncover a much larger conspiracy about his overall pitching
style.
Here's all the context you'd ever need.
It's Game 1 of a doubleheader, Eric Gregg is the home plate umpire so the strike zone
is gonna be huge, the wind in Wrigley is blowing in, Greg Maddux is going against his former
team the Cubs who had a weak lineup in 1997, and he's already retired their leadoff hitter
Doug Glanville with two pitches thanks to a slick defensive play.
Greg Maddux won 18 Gold Glove awards, the most in MLB history, but then again, in 1999
Rafael Palmeiro won the Gold Glove at first base after playing exactly 28 games at first
base.
Maddux had this otherworldly reputation with the leather, but what do the numbers say?
The biggest reason he won those awards is that his pitching style generated so many
chances.
The average pitcher from 1986-2008 attempted 1.8 defensive plays per 9 innings, but Maddux
did so at a rate of 3.1, meaning he somehow made 729 more defensive outs than the average
pitcher.
729 outs, that's equal to 27 complete games.
Because he was so active in the field, Maddux is the all-time leader in putouts among pitchers
by an enormous margin, and in 2008, the final year of his career, he led all pitchers in
assists at the age of 42.
There isn't a lot of sabermetric data on the value of pitcher defense, but any film
study makes it clear that Maddux's reputation as a wizard with the glove is earned.
He somehow made this play, and this play, and this play.
Okay, actually that last one was Mark Burley, I just wanted to show it.
Back to the game, he retires Sean Dunstan on one pitch, it's the first of several
at-bats that end on the first pitch, and he catches Mark Grace looking on a filthy sinker.
Mark Grace had over 9,000 plate appearances in his career.
He struck out looking only 204 times.
Now at the plate, Maddux battles with Cub starter Jeremy Gonzalez.
As the pitcher with the second most sack bunts in MLB history, he had better bat control
than most, and eventually coaxes an 8 pitch walk, meaning Gonzalez throws more pitches
to Maddux than Maddux threw to the Cubs in the first inning.
In the second, Maddux sets down the Cubs in order, Sammy Sosa grounds out on his 4th pitch,
Dave Clark swings and misses at his 4th pitch, and Ryan Sandberg grounds out to end a 1-2-3
inning in 11 pitches, bringing Maddux up to 18 total.
Keep an eye on Sandberg, the two Hall of Famers have an important matchup coming soon.
To start the third inning, Tyler Houston tries to counter Maddux by swinging at the first
pitch, and is rewarded with a single.
The strategy is sound, Maddux dominated the count throughout his career, batters often
found themselves down 0-2 if they didn't get aggressive.
Current Mariners manager Scott Service does the same, and shortstop Jeff Blauser makes
a nice play on the Baltimore chop.
Cubby pitcher Jeremy Gonzalez grounds out on the 3rd pitch of his at-bat, and Chicago's
lineup resets.
Leadoff hitter Doug Glanville strikes out on 4 pitches to end the inning.
In the 4th, Sean Dunstan sees the writing on the wall and swings at the first pitch,
a visibly frustrated Maddux laments just missing a fielding opportunity.
He then engages in battle with Mark Grace, who was the Cubs' best hitter at the time,
Dunstan steals second base.
And on pitch number 3, Grace grounds out to the right side, advancing the runner in a
productive at-bat.
That brings up Sammy Sosa with a chance to drive in a run.
The first pitch is just a bit outside, but as for his second offering, this has been
a certified 90 strike zone moment.
But Chief Sosa has the last laugh, he's rewarded with a sacrifice after hitting a
ball straight into the dirt.
Maddux tries to deke Dunstan, but to no avail, he scores.
Dave Clark then strikes out on a front door sinker to end the inning.
We're at 38 pitches through 4.
The professor leaned heavily on his two-seamer throughout his career, and he of course had
the reputation of being a soft tosser.
In 2008, his final and only season played in the pitch-tracking era, he averaged less
than 85 miles per hour on the sinker.
But then again, the man was 42 years old.
A 1999 broadcast of a matchup between the Braves and Cardinals featured Maddux destroying
Maguire with 90 mile per hour sinkers.
This was when velocity readings on broadcasts were coming into fashion, but given the differences
in readings between the commonly used radar guns, those can't always be taken at face
value.
Look, if I had a time machine, I'd do what anyone else would do, I'd go back to April
20th, 1889, and accurately measure the velocity of John Clarkson's fastball, then compare
it to Walter Johnson, Bob Feller, Satchel Paige, Nolan Ryan, etc.
It's a shame that any figure stated before 2008 has to be taken with a few hundred grains
of salt.
And yet, if Prime Maddux was indeed in the 89-90 range, it should be noted that the league
average velocity of starting pitchers throwing sinkers in 2008 was 90.5 miles per hour.
And that was after a decade of league advancement.
Maddux is really only a velocity outlier among the generational power pitchers of his time.
He didn't throw with the heat of Clemens, Martinez, or Johnson, but hardly anyone did
back in the 90s.
In his prime, his velocity was average, or maybe even above average compared to the rest
of his peers.
Maddux starts off the 5th by coaxing a Ryan Sandberg groundout on the very first pitch.
Their next matchup will be far more important.
That brings up Tyler Houston, who jumped on Maddux's first offering in the 3rd inning.
He's looking for the sinker in the zone again, but instead whiffs on 3 changeups.
That'll show him.
Next up is catcher Scott Service.
When Maddux gets the outside strike on his first pitch, the rest of the at-bat becomes
a formality.
Service is sent down in 3 pitches, bringing the count up to 46 through 5.
It's the type of inning that shows just how nasty Maddux could be.
His breaking and off-speed stuff generated 5 swings and misses versus Houston and Service,
which complimented his sinker, a particularly deceptive pitch when thrown front door to
lefties like Dave Clark and Mark Grace.
And although the ball moves, the catcher's glove never has to.
It's time to face the facts.
Greg Maddux ruined multiple generations of baseball dads.
They saw what the skinny, supposedly noodle-armed kid became and projected it on their own sons.
Just throw strikes is solid advice, but it becomes much more effective when paired with
filthy movement and generational command.
Maddux was more of a strikeout pitcher than you probably think.
The logic is simple.
If you throw a lot of strikes, eventually you'll throw 3 strikes to the same batter.
For his career, Maddux struck out 16.5% of batters faced, compared to 16.1% for the league
average during those seasons.
But that career total is skewed by the many late career years he pitched with diminished
stuff.
In his Cy Young seasons of 1992-1995, he was 10th among all MLB starters in strikeout rate
and relatively close to power pitchers like Smoltz and Clemens.
The equivalent starter in today's game would be Brandon Woodruff.
In fact, the active starting pitcher most compared to Maddux is Kyle Hendricks, who
has averaged a fastball velocity and strikeout rate well below league averages throughout
his career.
But that's not Maddux.
Not really.
In the 6th inning, pitcher Jeremy Gonzalez gets his revenge with a single on the 3rd
pitch.
But it's quickly erased by leadoff hitter Doug Glanville, who provides Maddux with the
perfect double play ball.
That's generally how Maddux operated.
You'd get pitches to hit, resulting in a baserunner, but that baserunner would become
susceptible to the double play.
Maddux coaxed 20 or more ground balls in 18 games.
18 games, 20 or more ground balls.
All active pitchers in MLB right now have combined for 10 such games.
Sean Dunstan ends a 7 pitch 6th with a shallow flyout.
The pitch count sits at 53.
For all the game outcome enjoyers out there, Atlanta right fielder Michael Tucker homers
in the top of the 7th to give the Braves a 4-1 lead.
In the bottom of the inning, we get a glimpse at HIGH right before Maddux throws absolute
filth to Mark Grace.
When his at bat ends in a short pop up, he tosses the bat in frustration.
Sammy Sosa gets a hold of one, but the wind blowing in at Wrigley knocks it down.
That's why they call it the Big Apple.
Chances are, you've come across this at some point in your baseball internet life.
It's always making the rounds.
Greg Maddux faced over 20,000 batters, only 310 saw a 3-0 count, and 177 of those were
intentional.
As impressive as it sounds, it's not true.
310 is the approximate number of plate appearances that ENDED on a 3-0 count.
But in terms of REACHING a 3-0 count, that number is actually 643.
I had to re-record this part.
Still incredible.
Also, that level of pitch-by-pitch data is only consistently available starting in 1988,
meaning Maddux's first 32 starts aren't accounted for in that total.
So here are some 100% factual stats.
At the conclusion of his 1997 campaign, Maddux had the second best strikeout-to-walk ratio
in the season in MLB history.
In the summer of 2001, he went 72 innings without issuing a base on balls, and he had
12 seasons with less than 1.5 walks per 9, by far the most in the live ball era.
Okay, pay attention to this at bat.
Ryan Sandberg takes Ball 1 to start the 8th inning, and then hits a single to left.
Did you see it?
We'll discuss later.
Tyler Houston hits a weak line-out to centerfielder Andrew Jones on an 0-2 count, and he nearly
doubles up Sandberg.
As for Scott Service?
This has been a certified 90-strike-zone moment.
He also lines out to Jones for the second out of the inning, and after a first pitch
strike, pinch-hitter Jose Hernandez hits a comebacker which is handled by Maddux.
He makes the play look routine thanks to his ready position after completing his pitching
motion.
Going into the 9th, Maddux has thrown 70 pitches.
In the top of the 9th, Maddux tries to hide his smirk when the Cubs make a pitching change
right before his turn to bat.
He eventually draws another walk.
Entering the bottom of the 9th, both the broadcast and I have Maddux at 70 pitches.
No. 71 is taken by Doug Glanville for strike 1, and he's retired on pitch 72 after Braves
first baseman Ryan Klesko makes a snag in foul territory.
After a first pitch strike, Sean Dunstan makes the second out of the inning on pitch 74.
If Greg Maddux retires Mark Grace on 2 pitches, that'll end the game at 76, meaning the
MLB YouTube title is correct.
If it takes 3 pitches, that'll be 77, meaning the retro sheet data on baseball reference
is correct.
Why is Mark Wohler's warming up?
Grace takes ball 1 on the 75th pitch of the day, and then he fouls off Maddux's 76th
offering.
But he's not done playing spoiler yet.
On the 77th pitch, he hammers the ball.
It sails over the head of right fielder Michael Tucker and bounces off the ivy-covered wall.
Grace slides headfirst into 2nd with the double.
The game continues.
Maddux will have to throw at least one more pitch.
And that's all he does.
Sammy Sosa hits a weak ground out to Mark Lemke and ends it.
Greg Maddux has thrown a complete game in 78 pitches.
It technically doesn't qualify as a Maddux, a stat reserved for shutouts, but it's as
Maddux-y as any performance could be.
Where MLB got 76 pitches from?
Not so sure.
But baseball reference's 77 is a result of a scorecard filled by someone in attendance
and submitted to the retro sheet game database.
Here's the discrepancy.
Maddux's 8th inning matchup vs. Ryan Sandberg is described as Sandberg hitting a single
on the first pitch.
But the video shows he took ball one and singled on the second pitch.
We've just changed baseball history in the most minuscule of ways.
How will this affect Greg Maddux's legacy?
They'll probably have to add a post-it note to his Hall of Fame plaque.
Heck, do the same for Ryan Sandberg.
Greg Maddux had a career that's easy to paint in broad strokes.
He didn't throw hard, he didn't strike guys out, but he used pinpoint accuracy to
generate weak contact.
The more accurate description of Maddux's approach and skillset requires an adjustment
in perspective.
His velocity and strikeout rates were normal compared to the average pitcher of the 80s,
90s, and 2000s, yet Maddux was anything but average in terms of his proficiency on the
mound.
So by not standing out among the crowd of pitchers he overlapped careers with, he paradoxically
stands out the most among his inner circle Hall of Fame peers.
The only thing special about him is that he wins over and over and over and over.
Ask yourself right now, who's the greatest pitcher of all time?
Chances are you'll answer with either option A, one of the many imposing outlier power
pitchers over the last 100 plus years of professional baseball, or option B, the man, the myth,
the Maddux.
Thank you to my newest patrons.
You can support my work at patreon.com slash foolish baseball.
