-Grand Designs UK S22E03

Mind Over Stone
45 followers
23 Video Views·Nov 18, 2022
This is my house.
It's also your house.
Because whether the ownership of these great country homes
is in the hands of an individual or an aristocratic family
or the National Trust or English Heritage,
actually their history, good or bad, is part of our history.
It's part of our culture, just as much as football or shopping.
It even informs who we are and informs how we build now.
So if you want to mess with great buildings like this,
you risk messing with our shared culture.
You mess with me.
In the county of Perth and Kinross, 30 miles north of Edinburgh,
sits this wonderful Scottish estate
designed by the pre-eminent architect Sir Robert Lorimer in the 1890s.
Lorimer extended what was once a modest Georgian farmhouse,
transforming it into an arts and crafts version of a Scottish castle,
beautifully detailed.
It's wonderful.
What I like about the house is the kind of historical feeling that you have.
The whole idea of the arts and crafts movement
is that it was looking backwards.
It was looking backwards to an age before mass production.
It has that kind of sort of wistful character about it.
Other carefully positioned estate buildings
share the same architectural heritage.
The Gatehouse Lodge, a dainty two-storey pavilion,
and a farmhouse, all of which have since become private homes.
And among them is the jewel in the estate's crown,
a walled garden for growing fruit, vegetables and flowers,
with its own stone-built garden as shed or bothy.
And this jewel has just been sold to convert into a house.
We are very invested in how this is to be developed
and it's very important to us that it's done sympathetically.
We've had 40 years of living in a beautiful place with beautiful grounds.
Because we've lived there for so long, we're anxious.
You are but the temporary custodians of such a building,
but we'd like to know that it's gone on to good hands.
So, who would have the sympathetic eye, the vision,
to see the potential for a home in such a sensitive location?
Well, that would be Ian,
a young, ambitious architect who runs a small practice
based in Edinburgh, an hour's drive to the south.
We do want to make our mark, pushing clients to be a bit bolder.
There is a real fiery ambition.
We want to have a bit of a legacy, you know,
of really interesting buildings.
Ian's newest project is the remodelling of these Victorian arches
in Edinburgh's Old Town, a UNESCO heritage site,
with a new addition of gleaming steel and glass.
Some are going to love it, some are going to hate it, aren't they?
But I suppose that's part of the fun.
But for now, Ian has his sights firmly on the bossy and walled garden,
which he's going to transform into an audacious family home.
For him, his wife, Jenny, and their children, Archie and Emily,
who are living in a small rented bungalow nearby,
a world away from the heritage project they're about to start.
Family have come up to see it.
You know, like, how did you get this?
It does feel like something that has been kind of, you know,
handed down through families for generations.
This is the one for us.
Hello. Hi. Hello. Hi.
Jenny? Yes, hi.
Ian, how are you? Welcome to the bossy.
This is it. I mean, what is it? It looks like a garage.
It's an old gardener's bossy.
It's B-listed. Scottish word, bossy.
Yeah. Meaning little bottage.
Hut, shed, shed. Yeah.
You just said B-listed,
which, translating it for the rest of the UK means grade 2.
Almost exactly the same, isn't it, in terms of the... Pretty much.
It's not your average bossy, is it?
It's got a sort of charm, with an arts and crafts influence.
And beautiful end detailing and all that timber work
and that infill panel, and it's all together quite posh.
It's a posh bossy.
We've been reading a lot of Beatrix Potter to our kids
and it was a little bit Peter Rabbit-esque.
When it is, it's Mr McGregor's bossy. It is.
So, how much did you pay for it?
225. A good price for something that's already standing.
The bossy appears to be attached to that huge wall, is that right?
Yes, and on the other side of that is essentially
the old walled garden, which was the old kitchen garden
for the main house. Does it have an income?
I think, in all, it's about three quarters of an acre.
OK. Right. So, you're a bossy, but keen gardener?
No. Not yet.
Eager to learn. Yeah.
Can we get in? Oh, it's got a floor. It does.
And walls, and it's got timbers and a fireplace.
No-one's lived here? No.
I think they've sheltered fully from the weather,
but no-one's actually fully lived here. Wow.
A bit to do, mind. Through here is going to be...?
Bedrooms. Kids' bedrooms. It is?
Yeah, bedrooms.
And then this will be guest bedroom.
Where's your dining room, kitchen, bedroom, you know,
all the stuff for you? Stuff we need. Yeah.
In the walled garden.
Ian's come up with an in-your-face strong statement
for the bulk of the new house.
OK, so this is a new build as much as it is a restoration
stroke conversion job?
On this side of the wall, it's going to be the new build bit,
which is going to be essentially a big single-storey timber-clad
box that is kind of tucked behind the wall that you don't really
see as you approach the building from the other side.
So it's that kind of tardis element that you have to come through
the bothy or the wall to get to it.
And it's going to be in a bit of a contrast
because it's south-facing, there's going to be more light.
It's going to be, you know, timber-clad
and probably in a kind of black-stained timber.
The experience of coming through from these older spaces into this,
it's going to be quite... Yeah. ..strong, isn't it?
You're an architect, you want a bit of drama.
A little bit, if I can. Yeah.
Well, projects like this are never short of drama.
Planning permission dictates that from the outside,
the listed garden wall and Peter Rabbit bothy
must principally stay as they are,
although Ian and Jenny are allowed to replace
the wrought iron gate with a door.
But behind the wall, it's another story.
A large swathe of the beautiful garden will be supplanted
by a very big single-storey insulated timber block,
200 square metres in all,
that Ian optimistically calls the stealth box.
It'll be black-clad in timber with large, simple windows
overlooking what'll be a smaller garden,
adapted for family life with young children.
You'll enter the building via the bothy's tiny central room,
which is big enough to be a boot room,
and straight through a huge hole punched through
the stone-built garden wall.
That should deliver a dramatic enough entrance
to the new extension.
Because you'll find yourself immediately under a skylight,
stretching 13 metres along the old wall,
that'll lead to the generous, top-lit, open-plan kitchen,
living room and dining space,
with windows that give out onto the garden.
Next door, there'll be a snug with a log burner.
Back under the hallway skylight will sit a playroom,
an office for Ian, bathrooms,
and a main bedroom for Ian and Jenny.
The children's bedrooms will be on the other side of the garden wall,
back in the bothy, accessible via a second punctured hole.
Archie's rooms will be downstairs and Emily's upstairs.
At the far end of the bothy,
there'll be a guest bedroom with a bathroom above it.
I don't envy Ian's challenge here.
He has to somehow magically integrate the whimsical old bothy,
a bulky black box and an historical garden
into a satisfying hole.
All right under the noses of all the other residents
who live on and love this historic estate.
Ian and Jenny have burdened themselves
with an enormous duty to get this right.
Building as you are, where you are,
with half a dozen families around you, you know,
you've got a responsibility with this place.
You're making it bigger, you're imposing it
and you're pushing it out into this garden.
And there's a family kind of sort of type here, isn't there,
between all these buildings?
Are you mucking around with that?
A wee bit, yeah.
You know, we've got the wall to hide behind.
Yeah.
And that'll kind of hopefully kind of mask the big bit.
So when are you hoping to get the thing done then?
It's the kind of traditional in for...
Oh, no, no, no.
In some capacity, in for Christmas. Yeah.
At the same time, there's financial constraints
that we can't let it rattle on inevitably.
So if your programme's loose at the moment,
but with a hoped-for date, how hoped-for is the budget?
Budget's a bit tighter, probably.
You want to do it for what?
350.
And we can't go above that.
So 350 and that's it? You don't have any more cash?
No, that's it.
For 350, astonishing if you can do it.
I mean, if you can do it.
I reckon you'd need at least half a million pounds here
because the project is split and complex.
There's the Bothy Conversion,
where Ian has to conserve as much of the old place as he can.
A new modern home to construct against an historic wall.
And the remodelling of the remainder of the garden,
whose proportions will have been mucked around with.
It's not really one project at all, this house.
It's a sort of separate number of smaller, interrelated tasks,
each with their own agenda, each fighting for attention.
It's like dealing with a bunch of small children, really.
You know, it's going to demand a huge amount of creativity,
discipline and intellectual capacity from Ian and Jenny.
The first challenge is getting heavy machinery
onto such a restricted site.
Though Ian cannily got permission for his stone basin, Callum,
to open up a section of the listed stone wall.
It'll need to be rebuilt with great care later on.
Yeah, it's really unusual to have a wall carrying right through the property.
I haven't seen it before. A lot of buildings are kind of left to ruin.
But, yeah, they're taking it on. It's a big challenge.
We'll then rebuild that at a later date.
As history is swept away,
so the march of progress is accompanied by the sound of diesel-driven machines
that belong to Ian's contractor, Angus.
His team will install new foundations.
We have allowed eight weeks to carry out our work,
so the foundations are draining.
That's fingers and toes crossed.
Just as well that Ian's figured out a way to dispose of 40 tonnes of earth
that would otherwise cost £10,000 to remove.
He's dumping it in the middle of the carefully proportioned garden
to make a bog-standard lawn.
Have you seen the big dump of spoil round the side?
No. OK, we'll see that in a second.
Rather incredibly, this means that mature plants and topiaries used
that have been nurtured over the years will need to be uprooted and moved.
We're going to have to lose this corner one.
Oh, no! It's pretty, though.
I know, it's going.
And then we're going to have to lose this guy, unfortunately.
And then all of this is going to get lost in here.
So we'll probably lose that bush in the middle at the back.
I'd rather not lose stuff unless we really, really have to.
Get rid of it.
See this tree here? Can we just lose that?
I know I like it.
We'll get a shot of it.
We can always take it out later if we have to, but please don't take it out now.
No, it's a pain in the butt. It's safe to take it out later.
I feel like I'm being bullied into it. I really like that tree.
We're basically taking a really mature garden,
an established garden, and having to turn it into a building site.
We have to really make it a lot worse first
before we start to put it all back together.
Oh, dear.
Ian's interventions seem painful and almost destructive.
Next up, the listed bothy is rudely awakened
as the builders start to saw through the garden wall into it.
To make sure the whole bothy doesn't fall down at the same time,
Ian's structural engineer, Jonathan, is wisely on hand.
We don't know exactly how the stone wall is going to react
to having large holes knocked through it.
The risk here is really the unknown nature and make-up of the wall itself.
We've done the cuts to mark out where the opening's going.
From there, we'll then work on the outside.
We'll start taking out the stonework.
We need to make sure that we've got all the stonework propped
and everything that the stone wall supports on the inside,
which carries the roof and it carries the suspended first floor there.
We need to watch nothing collapses above us.
In truth, it is their care and patience which wins.
It took a bit of time, but, yeah, we're through.
But suddenly, Ian and Jenny's ambitious 11-month schedule
is thrown into disarray by Covid.
The site is forced to shut down for ten weeks.
Five months on, the groundworks are still underway.
Christmas was the obvious deadline,
so to then have a quarter of that essentially removed almost overnight
and there's nothing you can do about it, it's a bit tough.
And they have rent payments due every month,
so every delay places more pressure on Ian and Jenny's already tight finances.
Come July, the project gets a boost
with the arrival of the insulated panels
and the steel that will make up the stilt box.
These prefabricated components for the box cost £62,000
and were factory made in Perthshire,
although manhandled the last difficult 40 yards onto site.
It's quite uncommon for us to fit SIPs to existing buildings.
This is unique in that, essentially,
it is a full new build attached to an old build.
Planning requires that the new structure is no taller
than the rickety garden wall that varies in height all along its length.
And with the roof still to go on, Ian's starting to fret.
See where we've got the pinch point now? Yeah.
For our planning, we want the house to be hidden behind the wall.
It's kind of the whole point of the project.
If the frame does project above, there's a real chance
it could be getting our knuckles wrapped by the planning department
and, yeah, I'd be pretty gutted.
No-one wants to redesign and remake a factory-built structure on site.
No-one wants the headache, delay or expense.
It's the last thing Ian and Jenny need.
In this once beautifully laid-out walled garden in Kinross
sits an enormous pile of earth and an enormous black box,
the roof of which, mercifully, sits just below the top of the wall.
So this was the pinch point we were a little bit worried about,
but still got another, I think, 70mm insulation to go in this.
So, yeah, it's a bit of a relief,
but it looks like it's going to tie in OK.
Six months in to an 11-month project, Ian and Jenny are on a roll.
Just days after the structure's completed,
nine sections of glazing that will overlook the garden arrive.
They're worth £20,000.
And to get these big panes onto site a little bit more easily,
Ian's arranged for them to use a neighbour's gate.
Because of the length of the frame, it's going to be particularly tricky,
so we've got a straight run through, so hopefully it'll be OK.
But not all the neighbours are so accepting
of Ian and Jenny's works in the walled garden.
Fred recently moved from the main estate house
to a new self-built home nearby.
Hi, Fred.
Ah, Kevin. You were in the big house?
We lived there for 40 years, yes.
40? Yeah.
We moved there as a group of three families.
We bought the house in 1977,
and we were known as the hippie house.
We were long-haired and drove Volkswagen buses and things.
Did you grow vegetables in the garden?
Yes, all that sort of thing. Yeah, yeah, good.
And then it gradually took over our lives.
25 years of...
Just 25 years of work gone.
Of work and knowledge that's put into it.
It's been quite reshaped, hasn't it?
Well, I was hoping that they would keep most of the planting
and the shape of the garden.
My wife, who's an expert and enthusiastic gardener,
is a bit disappointed with the state of it at the moment.
No, I just hope that they will get to grips with the garden
and put it back to somewhat what it was before.
Yeah.
But there's no turning back now.
A mere two weeks ago, there were just foundations in the garden.
Now the new extension is nearly watertight,
save for the giant roof lights that are yet to arrive.
So what's it like?
How are you guys doing? Hi. Good, thanks.
Well, you've trashed the garden,
you've put a bloody great black lump in it.
We're still at the breaking egg stage.
We're not quite making the omelette yet.
Big black thing.
You've always been very keen that it was black,
and I kind of was more sort of erring towards
kind of timbery, larch sort of fading.
Because, I mean, it is very long and very low.
You were worried it was going to look a bit like a static caravan.
I was a bit, yeah.
The question in my mind was whether or not the presence of it
in the garden was going to alter the garden.
And the answer is, yes, absolutely, it does.
Yeah.
Because suddenly the garden becomes its garden.
Yeah, I mean, obviously it's impacting it.
Yeah.
It's kind of bigger than I thought, actually.
Do you know what I love?
It's that six inches that's just set down and in, just enough.
Yeah, it would have been nice maybe to have higher ceilings,
but we had to keep below the...
It would have been rather catastrophic, actually, wouldn't it?
Do you know what I mean?
Because you'd have had planning round and your neighbours.
If there's going to be a cock-up, that's going to be a pretty bad one.
It ain't over yet. No. No.
It's still quite a long way to go.
There sure is.
The transformation of the bothy into three bedrooms and a bathroom
has hardly started.
Not to mention the resurrection of the cultivated walled garden
ought to be done for £200,000.
But there is a more fundamental question that hangs over this scheme.
So the most exquisite thing about this project is where it is.
It's in the middle of an estate that once was much bigger than it is now.
Over there is the big house,
which was designed, actually remodelled, by Robert Lorimer,
the great Scottish architect at the end of the 19th century.
And while he was doing that,
he also built a beautiful little banqueting house.
And over there, the farm, which could be very functional,
but actually has been turned into a kind of an eccentric delight
with the remains of a fake tower
and some really crazy gable ends over the window.
And right in the middle of this project
was carefully placed this productive walled garden.
And it was accompanied, of course,
by our favourite little bothy sitting here.
Now, this suite of buildings, this group of buildings,
are all highly decorative.
They're all beautifully detailed and carefully thought about.
And they are now accompanied by this great lump.
So you have to ask, don't you, what is it doing here?
Because these other things, these glorious objects in the landscape,
they're embodied, if you like, by one word, which is whimsy.
The quality which is entirely missing from this place.
Of course, that's not to say
modern architecture in a heritage location can't work.
This is the Basildon Park Estate in Berkshire,
designed by John Carr in the 1780s.
There is here another walled garden
with another new house built as part of its walls
by the architect John Pardee.
You see, this house doesn't sit inside the wall of the garden here.
It is on the wall of the garden.
It floats.
It's as though that wooden box has just been suspended
on the very margin between inside and outside.
And not only that, when you look at this,
you can see inside the rooms in that wooden box,
and yet when you look at the ground floor,
the views are so cleverly organised through the glazing
that what you're seeing is the garden beyond.
It's as though literally that wooden box has been suspended in air
and what you can see beneath it
is the continuation of the landscape beyond.
That is magic.
I mean, proper magic.
But head through the garden wall and the illusion is broken.
You see, there is a house.
From this side, almost no house.
House, no house, house.
It's brilliant.
And they could so easily just have instead just dropped that wooden box
straight down behind the wall
and surrounded it with these flint walls here.
But no, instead the brilliant thing was to lift it up, put it on show,
but actually position it over the wall so that it sort of just hovers.
Inside, the dual aspect makes for some wonderfully light spaces
and extraordinary views out.
An Asian-inspired courtyard garden to the south,
the walled garden to the north.
So there's absolutely no doubt in my mind
about the brilliance of this place.
The delicate arrangement. I mean, what shall we call it?
The composition of new architecture resting on old wall,
all working as one.
Not just artfully, but also playfully, you know, with joy and delight.
So all Ian and Jenny have got to do is this.
For about a third of the budget, Ian and Jenny have just £350,000.
But as the pandemic rolls on and with Ian and Jenny holding down busy jobs
and doing the homeschooling, the family are at their lowest ebb yet.
It's been a lot of plate spinning
and you can't really afford to drop any of them.
We've got family that are obviously a priority.
We've got our home that we're building, which is a priority,
so there's a lot of things that can't really be allowed to drop.
Yeah, it's been tough.
I mean, tiredness is one thing, but I think the stress levels
have been a bit tricky to deal with.
I'd love to say that I kind of don't get stressed that easily,
it's just the accumulation of things.
I think he probably doesn't share some of the more stressful stuff with me
because I'm not going to be able to really help.
Running a business and having your own business is a big deal,
you know, it's a big stress,
and then I think having this build on top of it is obviously huge.
Summer fades to autumn and the Bothy, looking rather sorry for itself,
finally gets some much-needed attention.
Although one element of it, one that lends it so much charm and authenticity,
the roof is being ripped away and the slates replaced.
The old ones apparently can't be reused.
A little bit sad. We're obviously trying to hold on to it as much as we can,
but, yeah, they were just in not great shape.
It's a dreadful shame, one I hope they don't regret.
I'm just sort of hoping that the new slate doesn't look too sort of spanking new
and it doesn't lose some of the kind of old charm that we fell in love with.
Yet the Bothy still has the potential to inflict revenge on Ian and Jenny.
So we're hoping we're not going to find any rotten timbers.
Hopefully it'll just be some kind of reasonably minor repairs here and there.
Doesn't look too bad.
We'll get a better look once the guys have stripped it all
and then get in and get a proper close look to it.
God, it's all gone. That was quick.
It gives their contractor, Angus, the chance to inspect the wooden sarking boards,
and the omens aren't good.
Yeah, so that's just totally rotted away there.
Definitely a bit there to replace.
It doesn't bode well for the state of the timber structure,
the rafters and the purlins beneath.
We just want to check these kind of structural timbers here
that come down on the hip, and we'll need to check the ridge as well.
Hopefully not a whole new roof.
To replace the whole roof would cost thousands of pounds,
which Ian and Jenny don't have in their budget.
The hip rafter is definitely quite rotted away.
See, a new hip rafter.
And the end of this hip rafter, that's just rotten.
That's already two of the four hip rafters that are rotten.
Right, next bit.
See, that hip rafter is shot as well.
Again, there is rot there on the top.
So we've checked four of the hips, and the two at that end are pretty bad.
The two at this end, it's the kind of same story.
It would be nice if the ridge was dry and in good condition.
If the ridge purlin, the largest bee running across the top, is also rotten,
the whole roof will need to be rebuilt.
That doesn't look good.
All the way along there, rotted away.
Balls.
In Kinross, it's mid-autumn
before the Bothy's rotten timber roof is rebuilt.
Just two months before Ian and Jenny hoped to move in.
You're looking a bit...
Downtrodden.
You've been feeling it, I think, this week a lot.
You've been a bit grumpy.
The fuse has got a wee bit shorter. Yeah.
So, listen, the slates, which were beautiful, of course, exquisite...
Yeah. ..are all going.
It was better to have a whole new roof.
I think it's the bit that keeps you dry.
Is it not better to conserve as much of the building as you can?
Do you see this as a conservation test that you've failed?
No, because we're still using, you know, a natural slate.
We've gone for a smaller slate that's more akin to what was on there before.
But it will look like a new slate roof.
And the new slates are from...?
Spain. OK.
If we had a kind of unlimited budget, then, yeah, to be honest,
we probably would have been able to do something else.
Because there were some pretty major interventions into this.
You cut some big holes in the walls, new roof, it's kind of like,
whoa, whoa, how much more can the old girl take?
And how much is it all going to cost?
The new roof structure was unexpected,
and their budget was always relatively modest at £350,000.
How far have you chewed into your money?
We've spent about £250,000.
How much have you got left?
Just over £100,000. OK. Enough to finish?
I think we may need to borrow an extra £50,000.
And yet there's still so much more to be done
to get this project over the line.
It's got to take this garden, which was once much bigger,
which has been encroached on and which now sort of doesn't make sense anymore,
it's got to take the bossy of building from another age,
it's got to join them all together in one big conversation,
it's got to make sense of all of that.
It's got to do that in a way that says,
no, I haven't always been here, but I was always meant to be here.
I'd say Ian's professional reputation depends on that.
With the Scottish winter approaching,
the priority is to get the project completely watertight.
In the minimalist stealth box,
the installation of that extraordinary 13-metre-long skylight
takes just one day.
How much weight is in each of these?
That itself is 225.
The crane is at its limit there.
While for the bossy, the rotten windows and doors
are all being carefully reproduced by Ian and Jenny's local joiner, Billy,
at a cost of £12,000.
You need a strong heart when you're taking on these projects.
It was a gardener's bossy.
It's not been a lived-in property, if you like,
so everything was absolutely at the end of its life.
And as it's going to be a property that's lived in now,
it needs to be brought up to current standards.
I pretty much would look at it and say,
I'm glad it's not me that's paying for it, type of thing.
Each to their own.
A new house is a lot more cost-effective
than renovating an old property.
Of course, Ian and Jenny are doing both.
By December, the month when they wanted to be all finished,
the bothy interior is still being skinned out with timber and insulation
to modernise it into habitable bedrooms for the children and guests.
But Jenny's starting to worry that the already small rooms
are going to be even smaller.
Just trying to think about the bed location.
Yeah, the bed will fit.
Like, the walls have sort of come in, you know,
quite significantly on either side,
and they weren't massive rooms anyways.
Right, where are you going to put your bed?
As a result, the six-year-old arches decided
he doesn't want his bedroom in the small, dark bothy as planned,
but in the roomier, brighter extension.
He wants a sofa in his room.
Do you think there's going to be enough room for all that?
As the bothy chews up more resources,
it seems it's becoming less practical than planned.
Less of a bothy and more of a folly.
We do want it to feel like one home,
but then we're also very aware that there's the two separate
but linked entities.
There's a lot of time spent trying to make sure
we get the details right, to make sure that it feels like one unit,
but that we're also being true to the bothy bit as well.
The bothy is definitely more expensive per square metre to do.
Come late winter, they're still not moved in
and the buildings are frozen.
And the epic task of transforming the walled garden is yet to start.
Last time I was here, this place looked absolutely trashed.
Yeah. Yeah.
The only difference now is it's covered in snow.
Yeah, it's probably a good thing. Covering up a little bit.
You're really pleased, aren't you?
It's covering a multitude of muddy sins.
Yeah, I mean, this is just mud, essentially.
Yeah, frozen mud. Frozen mud.
This is the low point and now it starts to get better.
So how much have you got to spend on this garden?
We don't want to spend more than probably £10,000, to be honest.
You could spend it on plants if you're not careful.
We could. Just plants and some soil.
Yeah.
Hardly are some to do justice to this once-magnificent garden.
But every budget runs out sooner or later.
Which is why, come the end of March,
the family moves into a building site.
Right.
It just sort of made sense to be up here
and then we weren't paying rent, there's more space.
And it's kind of nice just to be here.
The Newville site actually isn't too bad,
but this site, there's so much to do.
Like, there's a lot. There's a lot of graft.
As there is in the garden,
where an ad hoc DIY approach is the only option for landscaping.
With the central swathe now lawned over,
Ian sets about building a retaining wall with his friend, Gus.
I think this one's destined for the back of the wall.
He's a lot kind of handier than I am,
so if you're going to do something like this,
do it with one of your best pals.
I wanted it to be rustic.
Some would maybe say that's a bit too...
That's at the far end of the scale.
There's a couple of wee bits I might have to revisit,
especially now that Gus has done this bit and it looks way better.
The project is now in its horticultural battle phase,
so the non-gardeners, Ian and Jenny,
have hired the former gardeners, Alicia and Jane, for backup.
It's going to be a battle for hearts and minds too.
I feel quite sad about it, really.
It deteriorated so quickly.
It really had.
But it is hard to stand by and watch something get really messy and horrid
when it's always been really immaculate and, you know, it's a shame.
That it is.
And if Ian and Jenny don't quite get the garden right,
the entire project will be found maunting.
18 months since Ian and Jenny began building at the heart
of this glorious and historic country estate in Kinross,
I wonder whether their new home has made its peace with its setting.
The project was always controversial.
It slammed a big black modern box into a traditional walled garden,
slicing through historic stonework.
It aggressively modernised a charming gardener's bothy.
So?
Well, there's actually a hint of a sort of secret garden through the glass.
And as for the bothy, well, there's more than a hint of quality about that.
That is quite beautiful.
Ian and Jenny have left just enough ivy and moss
and all the old characterful lime pointing on these walls.
The brand-new Spanish slates may not be Scottish,
but they are gifted character by the crafted leadwork,
and there's more great craftsmanship in the new gable-end joinery.
Oh, hi. Hi, welcome.
Thank you very much. Thank you. I'm well. How are you?
Good, thank you. We're still talking to each other.
We are. Just. Most of the time.
This is so pretty.
It's romantic.
The whole thing is looking exquisite.
It sort of seems lighter and brighter and cleaner
and altogether more loved.
I know the leadwork's new because it looks new,
but it's also beautifully crafted.
And this end, to my mind, is the old one, but it's not, is it?
Because that was cruddy and falling apart.
Yeah, it was all rotten and stuff.
The whole thing is a sort of faithful reproduction,
dimensionally, everything about it.
It vindicates the process of doing it properly.
Yeah, it's been a bit of a labour of love for Billy the carpenter.
But it's a shame that the Spanish slates are not...
They don't have the same personality. They don't.
But they're lifted by the leadwork and the detail.
It's a wee bit of a compromise.
How long have you been living here?
We've been living here almost three months,
so it feels like home now.
It's good to get to this stage where we can take a bit of a breath
and start to enjoy it. Yeah.
Where do I go in? If you want the journey, you go in.
Oh, yeah, I want to. Come on.
The way in to Ian and Jenny's home is via the botty's middle room.
This colour will be known as botty green.
Botty green, yeah.
In you go.
Oh, this is charming.
It's a relief to see the original terracotta floor tiles relayed.
The old fireplace is still here.
And so is the tiny window that once overlooked the walled garden.
It's got a lot of bothiness about it. It's really lovely.
And good old Billy strakes again with all the handmade units.
Beautiful.
From here, one of those new openings in the garden wall...
Into the light.
..delivers you into the skylit corridor
between the new extension and the old botty wall.
For me, this is kind of a seminal moment in the building, you know?
Because this is the old wall of the building meeting embedded in,
joined to and as part of the new stuff.
Yeah. Bothy on one side, new house on the other.
But what is so brilliant is this glass roof.
Because if I look up, what I see is a garden wall in the sky.
You know, that purity of that simple idea is still there.
Off the corridor are to be found the main bedroom for Ian and Jenny,
a family bathroom, a study and Archie's bedroom.
These rooms all feed off the light that drenches the adjacent corridor.
A brilliant idea in every way.
Oh, wow.
And there is more top-lit brilliance in the kitchen living room,
although the snub next door is more intimately lit.
Wow.
You see, standing underneath this skylight,
it feels as though I'm about to be transported up, you know?
From my spaceship kitchen designed by Stanley Kubrick, you know?
The 2001 A Space Odyssey is pretty glorious.
I think there's an element of acceptance that it's new,
so don't try and make it something it's not.
I'm always got this kind of fear that something becomes a bit pastiche.
You try too hard, exactly, to make it something it's not.
From where I'm standing, all I see is greenery.
It's teasing. The whole thing is pulling you forward, you know?
It's quite clever. It wants to draw me.
It's not delivering everything in one hit.
The question is, you know, when I get there, will the garden be any good?
Let's face it.
The success of this project was always going to come down
to the relationship between new and old,
where the old was so brutally and so recently spoilt.
And the moment you come out, wow, yes!
This is so pretty.
The garden is still divided into three separate areas.
In the middle, a new lawn is a breathing space for the new house,
flanked on either side by beauty.
How romantic!
We are standing on what was a quagmire of mud.
This is where you deposited all your spoil to save money,
to stop removing it from...
I mean, I thought, what a crackpot decision.
I'd rather see it go from sight and preserve the topography of the garden,
but not you.
No. No, it allowed the house to sit down a little bit.
And it provides a sort of central anchor for the two wings,
both of which are far more worked, far more ornamental,
far more elaborate, in a way.
Those haven't really been touched, to be honest.
We've started to put some stuff in,
cos we want to put our own mark on it.
I say we, you say me. We, Jane. Jane and Alicia.
And they've gardened this garden for years, so they know.
They've been a massive help.
Are you becoming gardeners?
Yeah, slowly. I mean, they're being very patient.
I feel like a small child following them around sometimes,
asking annoying questions, but...
Things like, you know, deadheading, pruning,
and when to intervene and when not.
Yeah, yeah.
Which is what architects learn to do with buildings, actually.
In fact, Ian's dramatic big black intervention here
turns out to be much subtler than I expected.
The black-painted cladding performs as if just a shadow among the bushes.
The glass mirrors the greenery.
And in the bossy,
Ian's taken care to preserve just enough original character
in both Emily's bedroom and the guest rooms.
I love the feel of this room and the light,
especially in the evening as it comes round.
It's just lovely.
You provide enough of the old building, preserve the romance of it.
Yeah. I mean, this was, the whole time,
the bothy was providing the kind of original character
that we were after in that kind of wish list
when we were looking for something.
It was important that it felt like the bothy.
Yeah, I think it achieves what we set out to do.
There is, thank goodness, plenty of playfulness here
and a remarkable degree of whimsy too.
I'm very surprised at just how established and appropriate
and charming it all feels.
Hang on, though, what do the neighbours think?
What they've done, how they have landscaped to speak to the house,
it's fantastic, and that's a big achievement on their part.
I think it's a tremendous success.
I really admire what they've done
in terms of relating very modern extension.
The way they've blended it in with the walled garden,
I think, is a real triumph, actually.
So, yeah, I think hats off to them.
Wow, that's praise enough,
especially since they finished the building works in a year,
once the lockdown closures accounted for.
Tell me about the cost.
How much did you want to spend?
I think we were about £350 initially,
and we ended up just over £400, I think.
And you've got a heritage garden, you've got history,
you've got, hey, you've got the house of your dreams.
You've got a lot. You've got a lot for that, haven't you?
Yeah. You really do. Yeah.
That's quite good value.
And you were converting the bothy for that as well,
which, being an old building, of course,
was capable of swallowing all of that.
Was it a big hassle in the end, all of this?
It was quite a lot of pressure.
I think probably my optimism
maybe gave me a false sense of security
that I could handle it all really well.
And there were times where it felt like a huge pressure,
and I just thought, I'm going to crack here.
But that's where I had to kind of open up to Jenny a little bit
and calm me down.
I think they knew it was bad, because normally you're so positive.
But, you know, you did, you kept it going.
You know, I think you need to take a bit of credit,
but you're not very good at that.
A bit awkward, a bit Scottish about it.
I'm very proud of Ian. He's done a brilliant job.
We've come out the other side. Yeah.
This is definitely home.
Ian and Jenny took on an almighty risk with this place.
It's been one enormous balancing act.
There was always a question hanging over this project,
and it was whether this brave new house
would somehow knock all the old buildings here out of kilter,
strip them of their meaning, meddle with history.
And actually what happened is that this building
gave the Bothy and that wall a kind of new meaning.
It revitalised them, gave them purpose.
But there was a second question here to do with the gardens,
the setting, and whether in building this,
Ian and Jenny would somehow destroy the beauty of this place,
actually meddle with the historical value of it.
And, boy, did they trash it.
But they did so with a purpose,
to rearrange this garden,
to reinvigorate it too.
It goes to show that with a single, strong, contemporary idea,
you can spring the past alive.
Ray passed away very suddenly.
He knew it was right to come back.
We're so lucky to have Gret with us.
I feel very responsible for her.
I've never constructed a house.
We are running against time.
A change like this could really ruin the design.
He will guard his design like a pit bull terrier.
You hope that we won't have any fallings out.
It looks gorgeous.
It looks terrible.
