More than a million people a year stand on the sand in front of the Treasury at Petra, and every one of them is standing on the wrong floor. In this one I go through the tomb that radar found beneath their feet in 2024, twelve complete skeletons still lying where they were placed, one of them holding a ceramic vessel against its body. The part that gets me is why they survived at all, because almost every reachable tomb in Petra was emptied centuries ago, and these twelve were saved by the floods that buried the city. I will be honest, the detail I cannot shake is the Bedouin firing rifles up at the stone urn on top of the facade for hidden pharaoh's gold, when the real find was under their feet the whole time. The walls inside that chamber have also pulled back four centimetres in less than a century, not from desert weather but from people touching them.
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the summer of 2024,
a geophysicist named Richard Bates pushed a radar machine across
the sand in front of the most famous building in Jordan,
the treasury of Petra. More than a million
people stand on that sand every year.
Every single one of them
The ground the Nabataeans walked
on lies meters below their feet, buried.
is standing on the wrong floor.
Long ago, Bedouin herders believed
a pharaoh had hidden his gold inside the stone urn at
the very top of the treasury, so they fired their rifles at it.
The bullet marks are still there,
but they were aiming in the wrong direction.
When Bates looked at his screen,
the sand beneath the tourists was not solid. There were hollow
spaces down there. And what geologists learned
from the rock around them reveals what Petra
actually is. It is nothing like what you think.
Nobody digs in front of the treasury.
That has been the rule in Petra for as long as anyone can remember.
This is the most visited monument in Jordan
and the face on almost every poster of the country.
A single crack in that facade would be a national loss.
So, when an American archaeologist named Pierce Paul Creasman asked
to scan the ground beneath it,
he was asking for something almost nobody gets.
Creasman runs the American Center of Research in Amman.
His project was a joint Jordanian and American effort.
It was directed together with Fadi Balaawi
of Jordan's Department of Antiquities
and Fares Braizat, who heads the authority that runs Petra.
Every step needed their signature.
One mistake, and that view could be scarred for good.
And the request was not made on a whim.
The team had good reason to believe something was down there,
because it had happened before.
In 2003, Jordanian archaeologists led by Suleiman Farajat
dug into the forecourt on the left side of the treasury.
They did not find gold. They found tombs.
Chambers cut into the rock about six meters below the modern ground,
with steps carved down into them.
Inside were the broken remains of the dead.
Farajat had shown that the most famous building
in Petra had a lower level hidden under the sand.
Then the money ran out, the site was shut down,
the work stopped, and for more than 20 years
one simple question hung over that square.
If there were tombs on the left side of the treasury,
What was waiting on the right? That is where Richard Bates came in.
Bates is a professor of geophysics
at the University of St Andrews in Scotland.
His instrument is a ground-penetrating radar unit pushed along
the surface like a small cart.
As it rolls, it fires pulses of energy into the earth
and listens for the echo. It works
a little like a bat finding its way in the dark.
Solid rock sends back one kind of signal.
Packed sand sends back another,
and an empty space sends back something different again.
On the screen, it shows up as a dark shape where
the ground suddenly stops behaving like ground.
Bates ran his machine over the left side first,
over the tombs that were already known.
That gave him a fingerprint of what
a buried Nabataean tomb looks like on radar.
Then he crossed to the right side and did it all again.
The two pictures matched.
Creasman looked at the results and put it simply.
I think we have got something.
But knowing a room is there is one thing. Reaching it is another.
The hollow sat close to the base of the treasury itself.
Digging straight down would have meant
cutting through solid rock right beside
a monument that has stood for two thousand years.
Nobody was willing to risk that.
So, the team chose the slow road.
Instead of going down, they went sideways.
They started out in the open sand
and worked their way in toward the empty space by hand.
No heavy machines,
just trowels and brushes and buckets carried out one at a time.
Above them, the facade rose almost 40 meters into the sky.
The tourists kept coming, the camels waited patiently in the shade.
And every single day, the trench crept a little closer to the cliff.
Every bucket they lifted had been lying there for centuries.
Then the trowels struck bedrock.
And in the bedrock, there was an opening.
A gap leading into a chamber cut by human hands.
A space that had been closed off
in darkness since the age of the Nabataean kings.
The team pushed a light through.
Dust hung in the beam. For a moment, nobody spoke.
The walls had been cut straight and square,
and on the floor lay shapes that every archaeologist on
that dig recognized at once. Bones. Not scattered fragments.
Whole people, lying exactly where they
had been placed 2,000 years ago. Someone began to count.
One, then another, then more. There were 12
of them. But before we step inside,
there is a question that bothered the geologists even more
More than the bodies.
Why does the ground in front of the treasury sit meters higher than
the ground the Nabataeans actually walked on?
Something raised that floor.
And the answer begins with the crack in the mountain
that every visitor walks through to get here.
Walk into Petra today and the first thing you meet is the Siq,
a narrow passage that winds for
about 1.2 kilometers between walls of rock.
In places, it is only a few meters wide. Above you,
the cliffs climb as high as 180 meters.
Most visitors assume a river carved it, water cutting
slowly through stone over millions of years.
It is a reasonable guess. It is also wrong.
Geologists have shown that the Siq
was not cut by water at all. It was torn open.
Tectonic forces deep in the earth pulled
the mountain apart along a fault and split it in two.
Only later did water find its way into the crack
and smooth the sharp edges into curves.
Petra's front door is not a canyon.
It is a wound in the crust of the earth.
And the rock on either side of that wound is extraordinary.
Petra is carved into a sandstone called the Umm Ishrin formation.
It was laid down roughly half a billion years ago,
long before the first dinosaurs,
long before the very first trees.
Then it was buried deep underground. Down there,
water rich in dissolved iron
and manganese seeped slowly through the stone. As it moved,
it left its minerals behind in rhythmic bands.
Red, purple, yellow, almost white.
When the land was finally pushed back up to the surface,
those bands came with it.
That is why the walls of the Siq look painted.
Run your hand along them and the stripes swirl
like marble. Nobody painted them.
The colors were placed there by underground water long before
any human being existed to see them.
But a city built inside a crack has a problem.
Cracks collect water. The hills above Petra drain a huge area of land.
When a winter storm breaks over those hills,
the rain has nowhere to go but down.
Around 55 square kilometers of hillside all drain toward one point,
and the lowest path down
runs straight through the Siq.
A dry gorge can become a roaring river in minutes.
Boulders, mud, uprooted trees,
all of it funneled into a passage only a few meters wide.
Anyone caught inside has nowhere to climb and nowhere to run.
The Nabataeans understood this better than anyone,
so they did something remarkable.
In the first century BC,
they built a dam right across the mouth of the Siq.
Then they cut a tunnel through solid rock beside it,
almost 90 meters long and taller than a three-story house.
When the floods came,
the dam turned them aside.
The water roared through the tunnel and away down another valley.
From there, it was guided into channels, cisterns, and reservoirs.
The Siq stayed dry.
The same storms that could have destroyed
the city became its water supply.
It was flood control and plumbing in a single design.
But it only worked as long as someone kept it clear.
Eventually, nobody did.
Over the centuries, the dam crumbled and the tunnel filled with debris.
And the floods found their old road again.
In April 1963, a group of French tourists was walking through the Siq
when the rain began.
Within minutes, a wall of brown water came down the gorge.
22 tourists and their Jordanian guide were killed.
Jordan responded by looking backward.
Engineers rebuilt the dam on top of the old Nabataean one
and cleared the ancient tunnel.
2,000 year old engineering was put back to work.
Today, sirens stand ready to warn of rising water.
In December 2022, they were needed again.
Flash floods poured through Petra and around 1,700
visitors had to be evacuated.
Now picture all of that happening not once, but over and over for
more than a thousand years with no dam at all.
Every flood that roared through the Siq carried
mud and gravel and stone. And where does the Siq end?
Right in front of the Treasury.
That open square is where the water finally slowed down
and dropped what it was carrying,
layer upon layer, storm after storm.
Geologists believe this is how the ground in front of the
treasury rose meters above the floor
the Nabataeans once walked on. The city's own
floods buried it. But the same mud that buried the doorway
also sealed whatever was behind it,
And behind it, 12 people have been waiting in the dark for 2,000 years.
The chamber was not large.
Richard Bates estimated it at roughly 5.5 meters on each side
and almost three meters high, about the size of a small living room.
You could cross it in five
or six steps. The walls had been cut straight into the bedrock,
and lying inside that room
were 12 human beings.
Not a pile of loose bones, not a few teeth and a scrap of skull,
12 complete skeletons.
Each one still lying where it had been laid to rest.
To understand why that stopped the team in their tracks,
you need to know something about Petra.
There are hundreds of tombs carved into these cliffs.
Grand facades, columns, doorways cut high into the rock,
and almost all of them are empty.
Over 2,000 years,
every tomb that could be reached was reached.
Robbers took the offerings. Floods washed through the chambers.
Animals and wind and time did the rest.
Bates put it plainly. In all the other tombs around Petra,
only a few have ever held human remains at all.
And those remains were fragments. This one held 12 whole people.
For archaeologists, that is like finding
a library after spending two centuries reading torn pages.
And the dead had not gone into the dark alone.
Around them, the team found objects placed there
on purpose. Pieces of bronze, pieces of iron,
pottery, far more than anyone expected to find.
Offerings left by people who loved them. Small things, ordinary things,
things a family might choose to send
with someone on their final journey.
None of it was gold, none of it was the kind
of treasure the Bedouin had been shooting at,
but to the people standing in that chamber it was worth far more,
because it was all still
exactly where it had been left.
Then came the moment that went around the world. One of the
skeletons was holding something.
Its hands were wrapped around a ceramic vessel, a cup.
pressed against its body as if it had been holding it for 2,000 years.
Now remember where this tomb is, directly in front of the treasury.
In 1989, that same facade
appeared on cinema screens across the world in Indiana Jones
and the Last Crusade.
In the film, the Treasury is the hiding place of the Holy Grail,
and here, beneath it,
was a skeleton clutching what looked like a chalice.
Josh Gates, who was filming the excavation for television,
said that when they saw it, all of them just froze.
You can understand why. Life had just copied a Hollywood script.
But the cup was not a chalice.
When specialists studied it closely,
they found it was the top part of a broken jug.
Just a neck and a rim, with the body long snapped away.
And yet, that broken jug turned out
to be far more valuable than any movie prop.
Because it could be dated.
The style of the pottery points to the first century BC.
And that gave the team something Petra has never really had.
Clock.
For 200 years, scholars have argued about when the treasury was carved.
Some said the first century BC.
Others said the first century AD.
Nobody could prove it.
There were no inscriptions on the facade,
no dedication, no builder's name.
Every date in the guidebooks was a careful guess.
Buried sediment is different.
It can be measured.
Now the team had sealed layers of soil and pottery
and ancient plant remains
all sitting undisturbed at the foot of the monument.
Tim Kinnaird, an environmental scientist at St. Andrews,
explained what that meant.
Until now, he said, they had worked on assumptions and conjectures.
A firm date would be a monumental achievement.
The early results are already narrowing it down.
The walls inside the tomb were
built somewhere between the middle of the 1st century BC
and the early 2nd century AD.
The tomb and the treasury above it belong
to the same golden age of Petra,
the age when this desert city
was at the height of its wealth and power.
So now we know when, but that only sharpens the bigger questions.
Who were these 12 people?
Were they kings and queens laid at the feet of a royal monument?
Or ordinary families with no idea how famous
their resting place would become?
And why is a building that every guidebook calls
the Treasury standing on top of a cemetery?
Start with the name. The Nabataeans never called
this building the Treasury.
That name came much later from the Bedouin who lived among the ruins.
In Arabic, they called it Khaznat Fir'aun, the Treasury of the Pharaoh.
Their stories said an Egyptian pharaoh had hidden
his riches somewhere inside it,
and the obvious hiding place
was the great stone urn carved high on the top of the facade.
So, in the 19th century,
men climbed into position below it and opened fire.
Again and again, hoping the urn would crack open
and pour gold onto the ground.
The urn did not break.
You can still see the scars from their bullets today.
Hold on to that picture of men aiming their rifles at the sky.
We will come back to it.
So who really built this place?
The Nabataeans were Arabs.
They began as wandering herders moving sheep
and goats across the desert.
But they learned something that made them rich.
They learned how to cross that desert better than anyone else.
Where to find water, which routes were safe,
how to keep a caravan alive.
Frankincense and myrrh
and spices moved from southern Arabia toward the markets of the
Mediterranean, and much of that trade passed through Nabataean hands.
They charged for protection,
they charged for water, they charged for passage.
And slowly, the herders became merchants,
and the merchants became a kingdom.
Their capital was this hidden valley.
They called it Raqmu. The Greeks later called it Petra,
which simply means rock,
a city named after the very stone it was cut from.
For centuries, the Nabataean kingdom thrived. Then, in the year 106 AD,
Rome absorbed it into its empire.
Petra was no longer the capital of an independent kingdom.
And at the height of that kingdom,
someone ordered the treasury cut from the cliff.
The facade is about 25 meters wide and nearly 40 meters tall.
Every column, every figure, every line
was carved downward from the top out of a single face of living rock.
There was no room for mistakes.
A wrong cut could not be undone.
Most scholars now believe it was a royal tomb, a mausoleum.
Many link it to King Aretas IV, who ruled from around 9 BC until 40 AD.
Others think it is older
and belongs to an earlier king named Aretas III.
When the forecourt was dug in 2003,
the excavators also found bowls that once held incense,
which suggests that people came here not only
to bury the dead, but to honor them.
So, were the 12 people below the treasury royalty?
That is the obvious guess.
But Pierce Paul Creasman has been careful about it.
From the Nabataean tombs found so far,
he says there does not seem
to be a huge difference between royal burials and ordinary ones.
The kings were not buried in gold
while everyone else was thrown in a pit. So the team cannot yet
say who these 12 were. Princes? Priests?
Servants? Or simply families who wanted to
rest close to the most important monument in their city.
The bones will have to answer that.
And Bones can say a great deal more than most people imagine.
And here is something most of the headlines left out.
This tomb was not a complete surprise.
When Suleiman Farajat
and his colleague Sami Nawafleh dug the forecourt in 2003,
they found more than they had time to explore.
One tomb was spotted but never fully opened.
The team cleared the tombs beside it instead.
When they returned in 2005,
they recovered the remains of at least 11 people.
Some of the objects went on display in the Petra Museum.
But the full results were never published.
Richard Bates says the signs of this very tomb
were already there around 2003.
Then the funding dried up and the dig was shut down.
The American Center of Research itself describes
the 2024 excavation as a continuation of that
unfinished Jordanian work.
The door had been glimpsed long ago. It simply waited
more than 20 years for someone to walk through it.
Think about that for a moment.
A tomb with 12 complete people inside sat under
the most photographed spot in Jordan for 2000 years.
Millions of people walked over it. Almost nobody knew.
So what is lying under the parts
of Petra that nobody photographs at all?
In 2016, two archaeologists went looking for the answer from space.
Sarah Parkak specializes in finding ancient sites in satellite images.
Christopher Tuttle had worked at Petra for years.
Together, they studied high-resolution pictures
of the land just south of the city center.
One shape kept catching Parkak's eye.
A large rectangle in an area everyone had walked past
for two centuries.
At first, she dismissed it.
Then, they sent up a drone.
Then, they went and stood on it.
What they found was a massive stone platform about 56 meters long
and 49 meters wide.
That is roughly as long as an Olympic swimming pool and twice as wide.
Inside it sat a second
platform, once paved with flagstones.
One side was lined with columns. A grand staircase led up to it.
Pottery scattered across the surface suggests it was built
when Petra was still young.
Perhaps as early as the middle of the 2nd century BC,
and it has no match anywhere else in the city.
Tuttle admitted that many archaeologists had
probably walked right over it for years without
realizing what was under their boots.
So why not dig it up? Why not uncover the whole thing
and show it to the world?
Because Petra has a problem that has nothing to do with money
or permission. Tuttle explained it in a single line.
The moment you uncover something,
It starts to disintegrate.
He called that Petra's number one problem.
To understand why, you need a geologist
who has spent most of his career
measuring disappearing stone.
Thomas Paradise of the University of Arkansas
began studying Petra in 1990.
His idea was simple.
Petra is a perfect laboratory.
Its monuments were carved at known times.
They have never been moved,
and they are all made from the same kind of sandstone.
So if you measure how much stone has vanished from a surface,
you can work out how fast Petra is wearing away.
His team measured thousands of points across the Roman theater,
and the treasury, and the quarries above the city.
The answer was sobering.
Depending on the rock, the surfaces
are shrinking by somewhere between about
one and a half and seven centimeters every thousand years.
That may not sound like much,
but on a carved face or a delicate column, it is the difference
between a sculpture and a smooth lump.
And the rock is not all equal. Here the colors from earlier
come back into the story.
The red and purple bands get their color from iron. Paradise found that
where the iron content climbs above about four or five percent,
the stone barely weathers at all.
In those iron-rich layers, you can still see
the original chisel marks left by Nabataean stonemasons.
Fine lines. The strokes of a tool that was set down 2,000 years ago,
as if the workmen
had only just walked away.
The paler stone, with less iron, crumbles far faster.
So the same mineral water
that painted Petra underground half a billion years ago
is now deciding which parts of it survive.
But nature is not the biggest threat inside the treasury.
We are.
When Paradise and his students measured the inner chamber,
they found the walls had pulled back by as much
as four centimeters in less than a century.
Not from wind.
Not from floods.
From people.
Visitors touching the walls, leaning against them,
rubbing the soft stone with their hands and their clothes,
breath and sweat raising the humidity in a closed room.
2,000 years of desert barely scratched those walls.
A few decades of tourism did more.
Today, visitors are no longer allowed inside.
Then there is the strangest finding of all.
Another team of geologists took small cubes of Petra sandstone
into the laboratory and soaked them in salt water again and again
to imitate centuries of weathering.
Then they squeezed some of the cubes under heavy pressure.
The cubes under the most stress decayed the slowest.
Weight was protecting them. Rock that carries a load holds together.
Rock with nothing pressing on it falls away.
And when they let sharp shapes erode,
they slowly turned into rounded forms that look remarkably
like Petra's oldest weathered tombs. The mountain is sculpting itself.
But the most violent force ever to strike Petra did not come from salt
or wind or tourists.
It came from deep underground,
from the same restless fault that split the Siq.
On the night of the 19th of May in the year 363,
the ground beneath Petra began to move.
The Dead Sea Fault runs only about 17 kilometers
to the west of the city. It is part of the same
great break in the earth that tore open the Siq.
That night, it slipped. A letter written soon
Soon afterward, lists the towns that were hit.
Among them is a name written as RQM.
The same letter says it struck in the dark hours of the night
when most families would
have been asleep. Ancient sources say a third
of the city was destroyed, and when archaeologists
dug into Petra's great buildings,
they found that claim written in the stone. The main theater was
shattered. Columns of the great temple lay where they had toppled.
One of the city's grandest
temples was never rebuilt at all.
The city that had been carved so carefully out of the rock
was shaken apart in a single night.
But the worst damage was the kind you could not see at first.
The earthquake also broke Petra's defenses against water.
The channels and barriers that had kept
the winter floods under control for centuries
were cracked and blocked, and this time nobody fully repaired them.
Petra was already past its prime. The money and the manpower were gone.
Archaeologists studying the old city center found the result.
Year after year, flood water carried mud
and gravel down into the streets and left it there.
People built small shops out of broken pieces
of older buildings along the edges of the main road,
and the ground kept rising around them.
The story we followed through the Siq
was happening across the whole city.
Petra was being buried by its own valley.
Slowly, the people drifted away.
Trade had already moved toward the sea,
where ships could carry more goods for less.
Without its caravans and without its water system,
Petra had little left to hold anyone.
By around the year 700, only a few people still lived among the ruins.
The local Bedouin knew the valley,
but to the outside world, it vanished.
Then, in 1812, a Swiss traveler named Johann Ludwig Burckhardt
talked his way into the valley in disguise,
and Europe suddenly remembered that Petra existed.
So now, we can finally answer the question
this whole story has been building toward.
What is Petra actually?
We have been taught to see it as a city carved into a mountain.
That is only the surface. And
the surface is exactly what has fooled us for 200 years.
Petra is a city built inside a crack
in the crust of the earth.
It sits at the edge of a fault that is still moving today.
Its walls are a sandstone painted half
a billion years ago by water running through rock deep
underground. Its front door is a split
that funnels every storm for miles straight toward
its most famous monument.
And the city we photograph is only the top floor. The ground
the Nabataeans actually walked on lies meters below
the feet of today's visitors, buried by
floods that their own engineering once held back.
The geologists did not just find a tomb.
They found that much of the real Petra is still underground,
and the team says there are still
many voids beneath the treasury that nobody has explored.
Now remember those men at the start of
this story. The Bedouin with their rifles aimed at the sky.
They believed the treasure of Petra
was hidden in the urn at the top of the treasury.
They fired again and again. But that urn is solid
sandstone. There was never anything inside it.
They were aiming in the wrong direction.
The real treasure was beneath their feet the whole time.
Every bullet they fired went up. The answer
was down. Twelve complete people with their offerings beside them.
And here is the final
twist. The very disaster that buried Petra is what saved them.
Almost every tomb people could
reach was emptied centuries ago.
The tombs the floods covered were the ones that survived.
The mud that ended the city protected its dead,
and the work is not finished. The 12 have been found,
the chamber has been recorded,
but their bones have not yet told their story.
Inside those bones is a record
that could reveal where these people came from
and how they lived. So the next time you see
a photograph of the treasury, remember what you
are really looking at. Not a bank, not a palace,
a grave marker standing over a buried cemetery.
Richard Bates says the next step is to raise
the money to properly lift at least one of the twelve
and study it in full, then all of them.
Their teeth can show what they ate. Their bones can
show how hard they worked and how they lived.
For the first time, we may meet the Nabataeans
almost face to face. Who do you think these twelve people were?
And somewhere beneath
that famous square,
the radar is still showing dark shapes that nobody has opened.
Spaces that have not seen light in 2,000 years.
Petra has been giving up its secrets slowly for two centuries.
The next one is already down there, waiting under the sand.