FULL EVENT: Governor DeSantis Addresses American Tort Reform Association Conference - 11/16/26

Breaking News
8 followers
54 Video Views·Nov 17, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker outlines Florida's strategic approach to legal and tort reform, emphasizing the shift toward a conservative judiciary to protect legislative changes. These efforts have successfully curbed excessive litigation, stabilized the property insurance market, and fostered significant economic growth and fiscal discipline, resulting in lower costs for consumers and a pro-business environment.
It's great to see you. Thanks for the introduction.
This is my second trip to Atlanta in about a month
and the previous trip was to see the
Florida Gators get administered a major league butt whooping
by the Georgia Bulldogs and that
was not fun to see that. That game's going to be in Tampa next year.
It's normally in Jacksonville
but they're renovating the stadium
so we kind of have this two-year period where you did Atlanta
this year, then you'll do Tampa next year. When I was first governor,
I had people from University of Florida come
to see me in the office and talking about
just general things to the university.
I said, Governor, just so you know,
we've run the numbers, and it's our belief that
if we were to change the Florida-Georgia game
from Jacksonville every year to home-and-home
Gainesville-Athens and rotate,
that the university could actually make more money doing that.
And I thought about it, and I said,
you know, I think you're probably right.
I think you probably could make more money.
There's only one problem.
Like, what's that?
Like, I am not going to be the governor that gives up
the world's largest outdoor cocktail party on my watch.
And so we never done that, and we were looking forward
to having it come back to Jacksonville.
I think about when I was running for governor,
particularly with respect to legal reform,
The one thing I realized,
the one way I knew we had a problem in Florida was,
I don't think you could drive a mile on the freeway without seeing
a billboard with plaintiff's lawyers on it.
And they're not doing that for their health.
They're doing that because that's a way for them to make money.
And you would see it in different types of...
rankings where we were so proud of Florida,
no income tax, and we thought we were just
so great in so many things,
but we were rated one of the worst for legal environments, and some
rankings had us as the absolute worst
in the entire United States of America. Well, that obviously is
not going to be advantageous to really building
a strong economy for the long haul. So I knew that
I knew that that was going to be an issue that needed to be addressed,
and it wasn't just because of...
The legal and statutes and the common law that Florida had developed,
which obviously, you know, was issues, but it's also the court system
and how the courts were effectively nullifying attempts
to actually rein in some of the excesses.
And in fact, when I got elected governor, the court was split.
Of the seven members,
we had four who were considered liberal judges and we had three
who were considered conservative judges.
Of the liberals,
three of those four were on the majority back in 2000 with the Bush
versus Gore fiasco that was happening.
And people forget about how crazy that process was.
The U.S. Supreme Court...
It was controversial, but they just put an end to it.
But the reason they had to do it was because you had
this court that would not apply the law.
And they were changing the law and saying,
you can recount here, but not there.
It was an embarrassment.
And the court really needed to change.
And so three of those four justices,
all of them were part of the Bush v Gore,
they had mandatory retirement.
The day I got sworn in, they were off the court.
So what kind of a gift is that to be able
to roll in and really make a difference?
So in my first couple weeks in office, I was able
to put three constitutionalist justices on the Florida Supreme Court.
And that took the split from four
to three against to six to one in favor.
Now, those two of those three I appointed in January 2019 eventually
were elevated by President Trump to the 11th Circuit,
so I backfilled those.
I have also backfilled other people who were on the court prior
to my tenure who have left and gone on to greener pastures.
And so right now we have six-to-one split,
six conservative justices were all appointed by me.
During my tenure, and so to go from arguably
the most liberal activist court in the country
to one of the most, if not the most conservative court
in the country is a huge, huge sea change.
And we see that across a lot of different issues.
But certainly on the issue of legal reform,
there were times, even though it was very
difficult to do, where there were reforms enacted in Florida.
And they would unwind those faster than you could.
You could pretty much set your clock to they were going to rule in
favor of the plaintiff's bar no matter really what the legislature did.
So that's just kind of what we were dealing with.
So I knew if you fix the court, and not just on these business issues,
but really on anything, if we do policy.
And the policy, unless it offends the Constitution,
the court is not a council of revision where
they just get to opine because they don't like it.
The only way they have an ability
to rule against you is because it actually violates
a provision of the Constitution.
And so we knew we'd move beyond
this idea where they were going to just try to trip
up conservative reforms just
because they were on the other side politically.
We knew the reforms would stick.
But the legislative reforms were not easy to...
And it's just the reality of how
these legislators get elected to office.
The plaintiff's bar in Florida has done a really,
really smart job of playing both sides of the aisle.
They get involved in some Republican primaries.
They find folks who are going to be in leadership, and they do.
And then those folks tend to be.
More reflective of that perspective,
of the litigation perspective, rather than what a lot
of the small businesses were saying, for example.
So that's just the reality that you have to deal with.
We would do some legal reform my first year.
We did some stuff here and there, which was good,
but it wasn't necessarily moving heaven and earth.
And the reality is, is because we didn't have enough support
in the legislature to do it.
And then what happened was, November 22...
We won the biggest victory any Republican has ever won
in a governor's race in the history of the state of Florida.
We won by a million and a half votes.
We carried 62 of 67 counties,
including Miami-Dade by double digits, Palm Beach.
First time anyone in 40 years carried that as a Republican,
and we haven't carried it since.
So we had so much momentum.
On the heels of that election,
that we were able to do a special session
and do the litigation reforms with respect to property insurance.
And then in the regular session in March of 2023,
we were able to do the full Monty
of really serious litigation reform that's made a big difference.
So that was a moment in time where you had a lot of the stars align,
and then we were able to get these things through.
But there was a lot of opposition, obviously, to doing that.
What then has happened since then?
Well, one, we saw the trial bar fund.
So the architect, I don't know if the architect's the right word,
but the sponsor of the tort reform legislation in the House
of Representatives in Florida was running for Florida Senate in 2024.
And they recruited a primary challenger against the candidate.
And I was supporting our candidate who had been in the House,
and I had known him, he did a good job.
So they recruit this former sheriff in the area,
who's, you know, you're well-known as sheriffs.
Sheriffs are very popular.
In in their jurisdictions, a little less so in Florida,
because they came out against our property tax initiative
and it still passed overwhelmingly.
So some of their core supporters, like hey man, I need the relief
You guys have your budgets have gone up across the board.
Let's let's let's kind of come to Jesus a little bit
on this and start looking out for taxpayers.
So you did see that. But but the bottom line
is they're very popular overall.
So they did that.
They got President, now this was, he was running for his election
in 24, so he wasn't president, but he had been president,
and they got President Trump to endorse their candidate
in the Republican primary, and they ended up raising about 20 million,
this is a state senate seat,
massive amounts of money that they're pouring into that.
And our guy ended up winning by about 20 points.
And so that was a huge, huge loss for them
to have really tried to align the stars
as good as you can with all that
and then still have a really, really difficult defeat.
So that was, I think, just important because if he lost,
it would have sent the message to legislators,
don't do that, you're not going to have any support.
He did have support and was able to win.
Then what happened?
...was you actually had in the beginning of 2025
a movement by the then Speaker of the Florida House.
Again, these are Republicans.
In fact, we had the biggest Republican supermajority we've ever had
in the history of Florida.
And what do they do?
They try to undo the reforms that we did.
In 22 and 23, and I'll get to the substance
of why it obviously didn't make sense
because the results speak for
themselves, but they're trying to do this.
And, you know, they put their members
in a lot of really difficult spots.
You've got a lot of these small business
leaders are calling their reps,
saying, what are you doing?
Why are you doing this?
This is paying dividends.
It's working.
So they tried to effectively reverse the reforms that we did.
And, look, I said I was going to veto it.
The Senate wouldn't even take it up.
And so it kind of crashed and burned.
But doesn't that show you something?
This was something that Republicans
in Florida have been trying to do for 20 years.
We finally got it done.
We already saw good results, and I'll talk a little bit about more.
And yet there still was an effort to do that.
That is not the actions of someone
who's just trying to do good policy for their constituents.
That's the actions of somebody
who is in bed with the opposing industry.
That's just the reality of what we had to deal with.
So we were able to beat back that attempt.
Now, what has happened since then?
2022-23, we did the reforms.
2024.
Florida had the lowest increase
in property insurance rates in the country.
2025, we had the lowest increase in the country.
And in fact, now we have a net decrease.
One of the only states in the country that has seen a net decrease.
We have over 20 new companies have come into Florida's market
to write policies for homeowners insurance.
And here's just why that's important.
Because it's like, you know, you have some of these candidates
who just won elections across the country in this massive, and it was,
it was a massive blue wave, we just got to acknowledge that,
very, very devastating for Republicans.
You know, some of these folks are like, oh,
I'm going to come in, I'm going to demand they lower rates,
I'm going to freeze this, I'm going to do that.
Well, wait a minute, that is not going to work.
The way you lower rates is you have
a competitive market where people are putting capital in
and then you as the consumer will get a statement.
And you say, wait a minute, maybe I can do better.
And then you go look in the three
or four other companies who are offering,
and then you pick the one that's the best fit in terms of cost for you.
And guess what?
The other companies will have to work to match that.
And there's a competition to try to get your business.
When you meddle around with the market
and try to do command and control,
companies leave, and then people have one choice.
Well, guess what?
You have one choice.
You're at the mercy of effectively a monopoly,
and you're going to end up paying a lot more.
So the way you drive down rates is through competition.
People are not going to want to do business in a jurisdiction
if you have really bad rules
and a lot of costs are imposed unnecessarily.
So that's what we address.
And think about this.
When we did our reforms for just on the property insurance piece,
because they had a provision in law that, you know,
if I sue you and win, you had to pay my attorney's fees.
But if I sue you and lose.
I don't have to pay your attorneys.
He says, well, guess what that does?
That incentivizes a sue first, ask question later mentality.
And the proof was in the pudding.
On the eve of us doing the reforms,
Florida accounted for 8% of property insurance claims nationwide,
but accounted for 78% of litigation nationwide.
Which is a really serious thing, really out of kilter.
Obviously, there's a problem with that,
but it gets even better or worse.
Of all of that property litigation costs,
property insurance litigation costs,
the vast, vast majority was in three counties,
Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach.
Now, those are populous counties, so you think,
okay, well, maybe they would have a little bit more.
But the problem is...
None of those counties had had a hurricane in the past 15 years.
You know, Irma may have hit a little bit of Dade County,
but nothing Broward, nothing Palm Beach.
They didn't have anything in the lead up
to these reforms, Ian, any of that.
So no major events.
And yet they're driving massive amounts
of litigation over these homeowners insurance claims.
Well, guess what?
Those costs are going to be borne somehow.
They're not just going to eat it, the companies.
They're going to socialize that across their rate payers
and their customers.
And that's exactly what happened.
So when you're dealing with an issue like that.
There are certain things you just can't control.
I can't control the fact that Florida
is a peninsula in the middle of a tropical climate.
We are going to have more hurricane risk.
That's just the reality.
We're never going to have less risk than Ohio.
It's just not the way God intended this.
So you know that's the case, right?
That's just what you have to deal with.
And so,
And so there was the other thing we couldn't control.
This decade has witnessed the worst run of inflation since the 1970s.
Now, there's reasons for that in terms of the borrowing and spending
and the Federal Reserve and all these things
that have happened out of Washington.
But the notion that somehow we would
not be affected by that in every aspect,
including on insurance and especially auto insurance,
of course that was going to happen.
Property values, there's all these factors.
The one thing we could control, though,
Is are we going to have a stable market that has reasonable rules
and reasonable litigation exposure
and not excessive litigation and excessive exposure?
So that's what we fixed.
So now what's happened is you've seen the amount
of lawsuits have gone down dramatically.
Companies know that they have an ability to come in and offer policies,
Thank you.
Finally, for the first time, you know,
the last couple years, they've been overdue.
We just had this past year 20% reduction in reinsurance.
That trickles down to what the average customer will pay.
So the rate filings that are coming in are all coming in with
reductions pretty much without exception, overwhelmingly, for sure.
If not 100%, almost all of them are doing that.
If we had not done that reform,
Given that we've had however many hurricanes we've had in my era,
given all the inflation that was going on,
if you continued to add really draconian,
excessive litigation on top of that,
the market would have just completely collapsed.
You would have had no market.
So now you have a market that people didn't think could be rescued.
Didn't think, you go back three years, they didn't think that you'd
be in a situation where there were 20 companies, 25 companies doing it.
No one thought that was possible,
and that was the reform that really helped do it.
And auto insurance has been another thing
that has gone down in Florida.
Again, there's certain things I can't control.
I can't control.
The demographic mix of a state where you will have some daredevil
in Miami driving next to some 90-year-old who's going pretty slow.
It's just the reality of what we have.
And you are going to have a little bit of issues there.
You're going to have some other issues with kind of the mix
and the risk and the damage.
So I can't do that.
I also just couldn't control the fact
that of all the items this decade,
auto insurance nationwide has been one of the most inflationary.
And there's reasons for that.
The inflation contributed to that.
Just generally how these cars get fixed now are a lot more expensive.
You know, these cars are basically like mobile computers now.
You know, I used to, like, you go back, you could, like, work on a car.
Like, when I was a kid, now you need a computer programmer
to go in there and try to figure it out.
Well, that just adds cost.
So there's different reasons for that.
But one of the reasons we had was we had
a litigation-friendly culture in Florida that was driving up costs.
Since we've done the reforms, you have almost,
not only do they have a lowered rate,
Most of the insurance companies have issued rebates.
To their current policyholders,
because the projection was you'd have a certain amount of costs
because of litigation, and then you ended up didn't have that much,
so they have, you know, which is quote, you know, excess money
that's there under Florida statutes, so then they're sending back,
and you're talking about billions of dollars.
That has been sent back to consumers, and why is it going?
Because people now know if Progressive isn't going to lower their rate,
they can look to AAA, they can look to Allstate,
they can look to USAA and probably find a better deal.
So that's good momentum in favor of the consumer.
So in both of those instances,
we've seen really, really positive results.
As I mentioned, I do think you're going to see reductions in property.
If you have 20% reduction in reinsurance, that it's just lower cost now
for folks, they're going to be able to offer lower,
they're going to be able to try to get more business,
and that ends up benefiting the consumer.
So just right then and there you've seen.
We also had to beat back other attempts
to unwind things like medical liability reform,
which would absolutely cause costs to go up.
It isn't like health care is cheap in this country.
It is incredibly expensive.
It's an incredibly inefficient system.
But removing or repealing reforms that have been done in the past
to try to stop some of the bleeding
that we've had in Florida in the past
with some of the malpractice and premiums, that's not going to help.
Health care costs, that's going to make health care costs get worse.
So we're happy to have made sure that we've improved
Florida's litigation climate in a really, really big way.
And now, and just think about what we can now say
with the overall economy.
When I became governor, we had a little over a trillion dollars in GDP.
Now we're $1.9 trillion in GDP.
If you look at the amount of money that's moved into Florida,
income, more into Florida.
During my tenure than has ever moved into any other American state
in the entire history of our country over a similar period of time.
Adjusted for inflation, anything,
and no one's even close if you look at that.
You look at what we've been able to do with our budget.
Obviously, we run big surpluses,
but we've been able to reduce our budget four years in a row,
and we have the lowest per capita budget in the country.
We took all the debt Florida's accumulated,
and I've paid off, we've paid off.
Fifty-three percent of it just in my almost eight years as governor,
and we now have the lowest per capita debt of any state in the United
States of America, and we've also reduced the size of government.
We have fewer people working as state government workers today than
the day I took office, and we have the smallest government
per capita of any state in the United States of America.
That all leads to...
A state that leads the nation in new business formations,
and as we've had capital migrate to Florida.
We haven't had as many massive corporations like that
have moved to Texas, but I think what we've had is
we've had a lot more small businesses move to Florida.
A lot more small businesses start in Florida,
and they're going to continue to have success
because of the environment that we've been able to create.
We also did the property tax, so we're going to be implementing that.
It's going to give people huge relief on that,
and it's going to restrain the runaway local government budgets
because, you know, as people are flooding to Florida,
Home prices go up, they increase assessments, and people are paying all
this money, which you pay today for a house 10 years ago,
you're paying twice as much for the same house as you did 10 years ago.
So that was an inequity, and we've been able to do that.
So all in all, I think we've shown that these reforms work,
the state is doing very, very well, and I've got...
I've got a couple months left.
I'm not counting or anything.
And I'm going to be a free man soon.
But did you leave it better than you found it?
Better economy than what we found, better budget that we found,
better education than what we found,
better environmental restoration with what we did in the Everglades.
On and on it goes.
We've made a real difference.
We've exercised leadership, and we've shown it could be done.
So I appreciate what you guys are doing.
And at the end of the day.
Look, there's going to be companies,
unfortunately, that try to take a shortcut.
There can be companies that harm people.
There are companies who are exercising negligence.
And people have a right to be compensated if they're harmed.
I think the problem with the modern litigation
is so many of these cases are lawyer-driven cases.
They're not meritorious,
but they know that it costs more to defend the case than it would
To just simply cut a settlement check and so even though you're totally
not liable, even though you didn't do anything wrong,
you're staring at potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars in costs
and sometimes even more just
because someone filed a lawsuit that wasn't meritorious.
But the courts never impose the sanctions like they're supposed to.
When lawyers are doing it, because it's like
these lawyers take care of each other.
And ultimately, a judge is still going
to be more partial to the legal profession.
So that's really what we've tried to get over in Florida.
Look, there's going to be time for people to use the legal system 100%.
And unfortunately, people do get harmed,
not just from companies, but from individuals.
But our property and auto claims show with how
so many of those have tried.
The minute you took away the goodies for the lawyers...
Then all of a sudden, a lot of these claims,
if all of these claims were really strong
claims, the lawyer would take it on a contingency fee
and they'd still make a fortune by bringing
these and bringing in big settlements or big jury verdicts.
The fact that the cases are drying up
is a recognition that these are not likely to
be successful cases.
And so therefore, knowing that they can't
get attorney's fees on the ones they win,
they are deciding not to do it anymore.
So I'm happy to be here, I'm happy to take some questions,
and it's just good to be back in Atlanta.
