Mon analyse du film First Man qui est très bien réfléchis en terme d'image et de son au service du récit mais aussi pour faire vivre ce biopic de Neil Armstrong au spectateur ! Encore une masterclass de Damien Chazelle !
Pour m'aider à continuer lâche ton like et abonne toi ;)
First Man by Damien Chazelle is a film that mixes sound work and complex images to get us into the head of its character.
And that's of course what we're going to see today by first looking at the image, then the sound.
This whole scene on the moon represents this film and the end of Neil Armstrong's mourning.
I remind you that it is following the loss of his daughter that he totally drowns body and soul in the mission of Gemini.
As for the image, with an evolution of the means of capture, I mean the cameras used.
For the whole film, they used film to give the impression that what we are looking at is a documentary,
that these are in fact unpublished archives of NASA shot at the time.
Usually it will be 35mm, but also 16mm in the moments full of emotion to dirty the image as much as possible,
thus representing a distorted vision of Neil's reality, clouded by mourning.
They thus keep a pure film image, I mean pure in the sense that it is not reworked in post-production,
and therefore it keeps a lot of defects due to this format.
A lot of grains and vivid colors.
Through the image, it is the evolution of the character's mourning.
We also notice a lot of blurry shots.
A filmmaker will tell you that it is to better transcribe the disturbed thoughts of our character.
While in reality, it's just the technique, it's that when you shoot in film,
even today in 2023, we still don't have scopes that are accurate enough to avoid having blurry shots.
Quite simply because the scope is not in the same place as the film,
whereas in digital, what you see on your scope is the image that is transmitted by the sensor.
So what is filmed by the sensor is what you have on the scope, it's exactly the same thing.
Whereas in film, it's still two different things.
So in film, you inevitably have blurry shots.
We will notice in terms of colors that the color of its environment is yellow,
while that of space is blue.
And the black color is disappearance.
The image has thus been treated in two different ways depending on the places.
Everything that happens at NASA has been underexposed during filming and then overexposed during calibration,
to accentuate the grain and hardness of the image.
Our character is focused on his goal, but also hard on himself so as not to give in to his emotions.
And everything that happens in his house has been overexposed during filming and then underexposed during calibration.
Exactly the opposite of NASA, to make the image softer because our character is more relaxed.
It's an environment that appeases him.
But overexposure is there to remind us that it is also an environment that attacks him,
as it is here that he has all his memories with his daughter.
All this only by image.
And it's something else than Joker, where the image is dirty because our character sees everything in black.
We end the film with the totally crazy sequence in IMAX, 65mm horizontal.
Finally, a film that uses IMAX in a coherent way.
It impresses the viewer with the quality of the image,
but it is also a return to reality for Neil who mourns his daughter and gets out of his frame.
We are no longer on documentary with old archives, but on a quasi-human vision of this historical event.
The most interesting is what has not been done.
In fact, Damien Chazelle refused the demands of the Americans
who absolutely wanted the planting of the American flag to be put in the film,
because it is the ultimate victory against the Russians.
No, instead he keeps in mind that this film is there to follow the quest of our character
who says goodbye to his daughter through this very moving moment where he releases the bracelet,
which disappears in the darkness of the crater.
For info, this scene was shot in a quarry near Atlanta in the middle of the night
with a 200,000-watt light spot specially created to recreate the light of the sun with a 15-degree angle.
They were able to shoot with the same settings as the cameras that took the photos of the lunar surface.
But why shoot with the same settings as the cameras of the time?
Because these photos came from a collective imagination,
that is to say that the public expects the moon to be represented like that and not otherwise.
This is an important point because you should know that in photos, just like in cinema,
there are rules that must not be broken.
The representation of the sky, for example on Earth, must always be blue.
And the only way to get out of this rule is to tell the viewer that we are on another planet or that it is in a dream.
And it's not going to look bad like that, but I was a photographer for a long time
and I took a lot of artistic photos where I wanted to tweak the colors by making the sky purple or pink.
And on the networks, I got ripped off because people didn't understand the concept that it's art and that we do absolutely what we want.
No, no, no, they told me that my photo was shit because the sky wasn't blue.
It really disturbed a lot of people that the sky wasn't blue.
And here I can quote the representation of Mars.
In movies, it's always the red planet.
In all movies, it's like that because the viewer expects to see that.
While technically, Mars is not red but rather brown.
And NASA understood that by systematically applying a red filter on all the photos it reveals to the public.
Which I think is pretty crazy.
Let's go back to our character.
His goal is to realize his daughter's big dream and not meet the requirements of the government of the time.
And this is quoted when he says his historical sentence,
but that he is hidden by the sunshade of his helmet and in addition he is in the shadow of the Lem.
And that for once it's really realistic.
Yes, he is the first man to walk on the moon,
but it is above all a very small wheel of a huge machine
where hundreds of people worked for 10 years to accomplish this feat.
That's why he almost never did an interview when he returned from the moon.
He didn't want to be erected as a hero of the nation,
which would have eclipsed the work of all the engineers in the background.
Even if it was still the case.
Now let's move on to the sound stage.
To make the spectator feel the anguish,
it is customary to have a very specific music theme
which comes back and which is quite repetitive,
but which comes back to the sequence where the spectator must feel the anguish.
The Teeth of the Sea is the perfect example
since its musical theme of the shark changed the whole film.
During the test screening, there was no music yet
and the spectators found the film boring.
Very quickly, the studio directors were convinced
that The Teeth of the Sea would be the next big flop of the year.
And John Williams' music changed everything in the film's fate.
A little anecdote that I discovered
is that the theme of The Teeth of the Sea was remixed
to create that of TF1's JT.
Listen carefully.
You will of course find the video in the description.
For First Man, they used the theremin,
an instrument that uses radio waves,
which gives the film a strange aspect
as we are not used to hearing it.
And it also gives a very organic side to the whole.
Besides, I find that it looks a lot like 2001's music.
In any case, it gives the same disturbing atmosphere of moving towards the unknown.
You know, the music that comes back all the time with the monolith.
But Zerg uses this instrument a lot and I love what he does.
So that's the music, but there is also a second possibility,
quite simply, its absence.
To no longer have only sound effects,
so to give a realistic side,
to really make the viewer feel what the character feels.
Gemini 8's takeoff uses this style completely
with the whole sequence taking place in a capsule,
with some shots from Neil's point of view
to accentuate the feeling of oppression of such a small capsule
and with only sound effects.
In 2001, I think of the great scene
where we just have the breaths in the suit
while he unplugs Hal.
In First Man, the opening scene uses the same logic,
as well as at the end.
It starts without music and almost without sound effects,
to be totally focused on the image.
It is only when the bracelet is released that the music resumes.
For info, they rebuilt the two capsules almost the same size.
Almost, because they were slightly enlarged
because Rylan Gosling is taller than Neil Armstrong.
And then I find this ending a bit disappointing,
because if we compare it with all those with Gemini 8,
which is really crazy,
well, this one...
Well, they came to the moon,
he took care of his daughter,
they came back, they made a pizza, and that's it.
On the other hand, that's what happened,
there were few problems, so it's less captivating.
Even if the image is beautiful and all, and it's incredible, but...
I don't know, it falls a bit like...
The whole movie teases us about that, and in the end,
they go there, it goes well, they come back, and...
And that's it.
To finish, it's a role that sticks to Rylan Gosling's skin,
since he plays an emotionless character, so he's fine with it.
While the whole movie plays dead on the emotional side to try to raise all that.
And yes, he plays the calmest man in the world.
You know the moment when he has an accident and has to eject?
Well, in reality, Neil Armstrong's tension only went up to 12.
His colleagues were even surprised to see him 10 minutes later in his office,
quiet, writing his report.
If you liked it, your like and the welcome, it helps the channel a lot.
Don't forget to also activate the bell to be notified of all the releases of my next videos.
And I'll see you later!