Breaking news centers on a rapid legal clash between the Department of Justice and California election officials. The DOJ initially issued a 48-hour ultimatum to every county election registrar in the state, demanding they sequester the ballots of suspected non-citizens or face significant federal scrutiny. The Supreme Court rejected the DOJ’s emergency bid to set aside roughly 20,000 ballots, with a federal judge describing the government's effort as "unprecedented." The DOJ has since filed to dismiss its own lawsuit.
The U.S. Supreme Court and lower courts rejected the Department of Justice's attempt to sequester 20,000 ballots in California suspected of belonging to non-citizens. Despite federal raids and claims of systemic fraud, the courts found a lack of evidence and warned against disrupting election processes, reaffirming that states maintain primary authority over conducting their elections.
We have breaking news just in tonight.
The Department of Justice sending letters to
every county election registrar
in California demanding they help identify potential non-citizens.
The DOJ giving those registrars just 48 hours
to sequester the ballots of those suspected
non-citizens. Those registrars not complying by the deadline would risk
significant federal scrutiny, according to the DOJ.
Tonight, Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill
Assele posting on X, saying in part,
we obtained the registered voter list and told them
who we believe are non-citizens on their
rolls. We will hold election officials accountable.
No one is above the law.
If you interfere with our voters,
you will be prosecuted with a felony. If you tamper with
our ballots, you will face justice.
It doesn't matter who gave the order.
Meddling in California's election in California will come for you.
Breaking news centers on a rapid legal clash between
the Department of Justice and California election officials.
The DOJ initially issued a 48-hour ultimatum
to every county election registrar in the state,
demanding they sequester the ballots of suspected non-citizens
or face significant federal scrutiny.
The Supreme Court rejected the DOJ's emergency bid
to set aside roughly 20,000 ballots,
with a federal judge describing
the government's effort as unprecedented.
We examine what the government actually requested,
what the courts ultimately ruled,
and what the official legal record reveals beyond the headlines.
But tonight, local leaders are pushing back,
claiming the raid was intended to
intimidate people from voting
and that many of the defendants say the charges are false.
John Finolio live in the KTLA News Center with more on the bust
and the fallout tonight, John.
Sandra Micah, the Trump administration says it
is targeting large swaths of non-citizens
accused of illegally casting ballots.
But California leaders are calling the raids politically motivated
and that they're intended to intimidate voters.
They also say there is no threat of widespread voter fraud.
Before sunrise, federal agents moved in.
Photos obtained by the California Post show suspects being
arrested during a series of raids across California.
The operation, called Protect the Vote,
targeting 28 people the federal government has accused of registering
and voting in U.S. elections illegally.
These are not isolated instances. We are investigating thousands
of more similar cases throughout the nation.
But state and local leaders are rejecting Trump administration claims.
California Governor Gavin Newsom calling the operation a sad,
desperate attempt by Trump
to use his politicized Justice Department
to try to suppress California voters.
L.A. County Supervisor Janice Hahn saying this is voter intimidation.
And a blatant attempt to undermine trust in our midterm elections.
These arrests are being used to paint
a picture of widespread voter fraud
when we know that is not the case.
The dispute began on October 14th
when the Justice Department provided Los Angeles County
election officials and Secretary of State Shirley Weber with a list
of approximately 20,000 registered voters identified
as likely non-citizens.
The following day, federal prosecutors filed
a lawsuit demanding those ballots be sequestered
and left uncounted until citizenship could be verified.
The government argued this action
was necessary because once a ballot is processed,
it is impossible to retract.
The Los Angeles Times reporting several
of those arrested expressed confusion over the charges,
with some saying they had no recollection
of registering to vote as the Trump administration
has accused them of doing.
Loyola Law School professor and KTLA legal analyst Jessica Levinson
I think if the allegations against
these individuals are shown to be true,
then we still have a situation where voter fraud is exceedingly rare.
Over the summer, the Department
of Homeland Security had said they thought that there
were 120,000 people on California's voter rolls who were not eligible.
That number then changed last week, I believe, to about 20,000 people.
Now we see arrests and indictments of about two dozen people.
So is any amount of voter fraud too much?
Absolutely.
But the federal government has
been looking into this for quite a while.
And what we see here are allegations, again, about against 28 people.
I think if they had evidence of more widespread problematic behavior,
then we would have seen
more arrests and indictments.
Several of those arrested today appeared in federal court.
The judge ordered them to be immediately released
on their own recognizance.
They're due back in court for a preliminary hearing November 9th.
Reports indicate the Department of Homeland Security compiled this list
by comparing California's voter rolls against government records
and a commercial database.
While it is an official federal list,
it does not represent a confirmed count of non-citizens,
cast ballots, or illegal votes.
First, we have some breaking news. A federal judge has denied
the federal government's request
to block 20,000 mail-in ballots it claims belong to non-citizens.
The judge warns it would wreak havoc on midterm elections.
State election leaders
California and Los Angeles
County immediately pushed back,
calling the federal list unreliable
and arguing that segregating ballots mid-election
was logistically impossible.
When local officials actually checked the data,
they found many people on the list weren't
actively registered and were never even mailed a ballot.
A subsequent UCLA study revealed that 42%
of the flagged names didn't appear on the current
voter roll at all, and that the list
mistakenly included naturalized citizens.
Late today, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected
a request from the Trump administration to weigh
in on its effort to sideline those thousands
of mail-in ballots here in California. Earlier today,
the administration filed an emergency appeal after
a divided appeals court rejected a request to set
Set aside 20,000 ballots from people
the federal government claims are likely non-citizens.
citizens. California officials say
the administration's list is highly unreliable
and likely includes many people who are U.S. citizens.
The Supreme Court did not give a
reason for declining to weigh in on the issue this afternoon.
Okay, so let's talk more about
all of this with Professor David Levine
from UC College of the Law in San Francisco. David,
nice to see you. Good to see you both.
So boy, the Supreme Court really moving quickly on this.
Why do you think they did move so fast
and what does it say about the administration's case here?
They move fast because they know that tomorrow's election day.
Okay.
Now, the administration moved quickly
because they lost the case just the other day at the
Ninth Circuit for the second time, and just this morning,
they filed their emergency motion.
So what was interesting is what happened internally
in the court is because this was a case coming
from the Ninth Circuit,
Justice Kagan got the papers first because every justice is
responsible for these kind of motions in different circuits.
So she got it first.
She could have acted.
on her own, but instead she referred it to the entire court,
which strikes me that that
was the right thing to do, given the provenance of the case.
And then nobody...
Wanted to touch it.
What was interesting to me is that the order
from the Supreme Court is one sentence and
no recorded dissents at all,
given that the Ninth Circuit had one judge who kept saying,
no, no, the administration has a case.
I kind of thought that two or three of the justices might say,
wait a minute, we should
look at this some more, but no recorded dissents.
So they moved quickly, knowing it is election day coming up,
knowing that the vote is going
on and that this case from the administration just
was never going to happen.
However, the government disputed those findings.
A senior federal immigration official told the court
his office reviewed the names flagged by the county
and found none were U.S. born,
though he acknowledged four might have a claim
to citizenship.
With both sets of numbers before a judge,
the court would ultimately rule the government's
allegations unproven.
Going anywhere.
How unusual is it for the Supreme Court
to rule on an application like this from the
administration without even asking for responses from the two sides?
Well, a lot of times with emergency motions, they will just say no.
That's pretty common.
But the administration has had such good luck
with the Supreme Court that
It's maybe a little bit surprising, again,
that they didn't get any bites from any justices.
We didn't see a Justice Alito or Justice Thomas saying,
wait a minute, we're going too fast.
One reason might have been that there's just
not enough time with the election going, with
tomorrow being election day, with the vote underway.
To go through the rigmarole of some...
Was it just about the timing, you think,
or were they looking at what, you know,
the evidence that the administration was putting forth
about these contested ballots?
I suspect it's the timing as much as anything because they move
so quickly and because we didn't get any recorded dissent.
It was just we're in the midst of it now.
It's too late to really to interfere.
Now, the administration's remedy.
There is a remedy, which is a couple of different ways.
One is that if, in fact, some noncitizens voted.
That's recorded. The administration can come back in,
and they could indict people, and it's only a misdemeanor,
but they could indict people for this after the fact,
because the envelopes will be maintained,
the voting records will be maintained,
and if they really were serious, they could go after people.
The other alternative is,
as the Ninth Circuit judges were saying, is...
Go to Congress,
and if you want to require a higher level of proof that people who are
voting are citizens, you go to Congress,
and they can change the regulations and statutes
for federal elections.
But California was following its own perfectly legal...
process of verifying signatures,
verifying that people are citizens who are voting,
and all the studies that have been done is that it
is an infinitesimal problem of non-citizens
voting. They don't want to get in trouble.
And it's just across the board. We hear a lot of
noise about it, but the reality is it almost never, never.
On October 28th, U.S. District
Judge David Carter, a Clinton appointee,
denied the government's request for emergency relief.
In a 26-page ruling, he found no legal basis for the demand,
questioned the list's reliability,
and warned of potential disenfranchisement.
In his words, once a vote is segregated,
lasting harm has occurred.
He noted the DOJ still had a remedy after the fact prosecuting
anyone who votes unlawfully. The DOJ immediately appealed.
Okay, so what do you expect after today?
I mean, what's next? Do you believe the
administration will say, will cut its losses and say,
okay, we're forgetting about this issue?
No. What they're going to do, I suspect, is, you know,
what we've seen is we've seen the Alaska case, we've seen a little bit
in Washington, we've seen a little bit in the state of Washington,
a little bit in Washington, D.C., this case coming out of Los Angeles,
all trying to create the narrative that there are problems.
And so what I expect,
what we're going to see is a lot of noise Tuesday night.
Wednesday, we told you, this is the administration,
we told you there were problems, and look
at those results.
We've got to look at this further.
So the real issue is going to be what happens
when the administration, who has been very
aggressive so far, continues to be aggressive,
whether it's in the courts or when things
turn to certifications in the states,
and then when all those records go, or those results
go to Congress, what will happen there.
So the story is not over.
However, it's just we're just changing to another locale.
Yeah.
So, yeah, you think all these legal challenges kind
of more so about laying the groundwork
potentially for challenges after the election.
Yeah.
This is all about the politics and less about the law
because these cases have been so dreadful.
And again, the proof is in the pudding within
a matter of hours today, nine, nothing, not
one Supreme Court justice could say there's anything here,
even the most friendly justices
To the administration, they said, uh-uh, not today.
A divided Ninth Circuit panel ultimately
refused to sequester the ballots.
The majority comprising one Trump-appointed judge
and one Biden-appointed judge
ruled that such a move risked disenfranchisement
and could jeopardize the county's entire election.
They based their decision on the state's
inherent authority to run elections,
as well as the legal precedent against
altering election rules at the 11th hour.
The Supreme Court now shutting down
a last-ditch effort by the Trump administration
to force California to set aside thousands
of ballots from alleged non-citizens.
You may remember last month,
the DOJ sent a letter to state election officials
that included a list of 20,000 registered voters.
It claimed those folks are not U.S. citizens,
but still received a mail-in ballot.
California contested and a federal judge sided with the state.
Yesterday, the Supreme Court rejected
the Trump administration's appeal.
With Election Day here, the DOJ announced this morning that election
monitors will be in all 50 states for the first time in U.S. history.
So what does this mean?
Well, we've got CBS News election law
expert David Becker with us at the table.
He's also executive director for the Center
for Election Innovation and Research.
That's a nonprofit focused on increasing trust in U.S. elections.
So, David, good morning. Welcome. Happy Election Day to you.
The Supreme Court gave a very quick, almost single line ruling
on avoiding the appeal from the Trump administration.
Does that mean this case is over?
This case is essentially over at this point.
DOJ had offered very flimsy evidence with regard
to these 20,000 alleged non-citizens on the voter
list. And in fact, a lawyer in a separate case yesterday
for the DOJ stood up in court and
basically admitted that there's a very high error rate on that list.
The Supreme Court rejected this
no notable dissents, didn't even invite briefing,
which is very, very rare. And I think in doing so,
they sent a clear signal, stop with all of this.
Let the election continue under the Constitution.
The states get to run elections.
Let the states continue to do their work.
To run this election, I think that's going
to bode very well for future litigation as well.
It's the same thing you have repeated.
States run their own elections and they're pretty good at it.
But despite that message from the Supreme Court,
the DOJ yesterday announced dozens
of arrests involving alleged voter fraud.
A third judge, also a Trump appointee, dissented.
Then on Monday, November 2nd, the day before Election Day,
the Justice Department petitioned the Supreme Court to intervene.
Within hours, the court rejected the request
with a single unsigned sentence and no explanation.
Crucially, this action meant
the justices only denied the emergency injunction.
They did not issue a ruling on the citizenship
status of any voter on the list.
They are processing the ballots as we speak,
which means they're removing the ballots from
the envelope.
When the ballot is removed from the envelope, it's done.
There's no way to ever reconnect that ballot to that envelope,
which is why we're asking
the Supreme Court today to at least stop the bleeding
and at least, at this point moving
forward, to put those envelopes in a separate pile.
So we can adjudicate this issue before
those ballots get co-mingled with all the other ballots,
which makes it impossible to adjudicate this.
So, yeah, I mean, you're not wrong by in a couple of weeks.
This, our issue, our lawsuit will basically be moot
because all the ballots will have been
commingled with together
and there'll be no way for us to ever untangle that. So it's a real
problem. This is no exception.
Any election that has a federal candidate on it, we do monitor and
we look for fraud. And there's no question there
is fraud in every election. The question is how
much fraud? We know that California,
there's been many people prosecuted for illegally registering
a vote or not being qualified to vote.
And the response is always, it's not widespread. And the
With California, to be frank, our system sucks.
It really does.
We have universal vote-by-mail.
We have no voter ID, and that is a recipe for fraud,
and it makes it almost impossible to know
how many people are eligible to vote in California.
We've tried hard to audit the voter rolls.
We have sued the state of California.
The federal government's entitled to review those voter rolls,
and they have stonewalled us.
That case is before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
The DOJ informed the court
that its requested relief was no longer viable.
By the time a special master was scheduled
to evaluate the federal list at a November 13th
hearing, California would have already commingled
the challenged ballots with the general pool.
At that point, the state had processed
approximately 9 million ballots with nearly
5 million remaining.
Bill Essily, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles,
stated his goal simply, we want to stop the illegal voting.
Check that for us. How common is voter fraud in the first place?
We know how much voter fraud there
is in the United States, and it's not zero,
but it's really close to zero. It's very, very rare.
We have a really good sense of
how many non-citizens are on voter lists.
Sometimes they get on as a result of an
administrative error, but it's extremely rare.
The numbers are very small. And over the course
of nearly two years trying to investigate voter fraud,
non-citizens voting, et cetera,
this Department of Justice has only arrested
Several dozen people out
of well over 200 million registered voters in the United States.
It's also important to note the DOJ is violating its own rules here.
The DOJ has very clear rules.
I'm a former DOJ voting section attorney myself that say you
do not do not bring investigations or litigation that could influence
or interfere with the election close to an election by even making
these arrests, which could have been made tomorrow.
They're clearly violating their own rules.
So our viewers should keep that in mind
as we watch poll results come in today.
We don't know if they'll come in quickly,
if they'll trickle in, if some states we can
call tonight or tomorrow.
What should people keep in mind
as they perhaps hear different things from different government
entities?
Yeah, it's almost certain that we're going
to hear losing candidates or losing parties
claim the election was rigged and bring up false
and debunked claims about the election
in the aftermath.
They're likely to try to leverage the period
of time where we're still waiting for the
winner to be announced by the media,
by us here at CBS, because elections are going to
be really close around the nation today.
And as margins get smaller, as the elections get closer,
including in places we're not
used to seeing close elections,
we just heard about Texas, for instance, and other places
we might be waiting for more ballots to be reported in.
And it could take hours or even days until
we have enough information in those really,
really close races.
Tune out the noise.
Be patient. As hard as it is, I'm also impatient.
But just wait for the election officials, your neighbors
who are working in their county offices to count all those ballots.
They're going to be working through the night to get those out
to all of us. And the results may change as they come
in because different locations will be. That's exactly right.
They're just counting those ballots. But the point you made there,
your neighbors are the ones helping. Right.
What does this dismissal
actually settle?
The legal record establishes only
that two lower courts rejected the government's request
based on the evidence presented,
and the Supreme Court chose not to intervene.
Crucially, the dismissal does not establish
that 20,000 people voted illegally,
nor does it certify the accuracy of the federal list.
The DOJ maintains it is evaluating ways to protect the vote
while navigating ongoing litigation over its use of the database.
Meanwhile, in a separate effort, state prosecutors have arrested
more than 30 individuals for alleged illegal registration,
and election clerks have received grand jury subpoenas,
though the specific targets remain unclear.
This specific ballot fight is over,
but the debate over federal reach into state elections is not.