Evidence for Dating the Great Pyramid of Egypt: Does Wooden Relic Change Things?

mysterious nature
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello everybody
and welcome
to Ancient Architects.
Please subscribe to the channel
for regular content on ancient architecture
as well as all of the latest news from the world of archaeology.
Back in 2020 an astonishing discovery was made,
well an astonishing rediscovery.
As the missing Dixon relic,
a wooden rod found inside the Great Pyramid in 1872
turned up at the University of Aberdeen in Scotland.
It was one of three objects found inside
the Queen's Chamber Northern Channel,
a channel that was closed at both ends until 1872,
when structural engineer
Wayman Dixon and his friend James Grant,
a physician and adventurer smashed through
the north wall to reveal a narrow channel.
Inside was this copper hook and this stone ball,
both of which are now kept in the British Museum
and there was also this length of cedar wood.
Whether these relics somehow work together
or whether they're just random objects left by
workers inside the northern channel we don't know.
But one thing is for certain.
They date to the time of the pyramids construction.
Because at the northern high end of this channel there's a closed door.
The channel does not reach the outside edge of the pyramid
and so there is no way into it from the outside.
And before 1872 the bottom end was also closed by not one
but two giant limestone blocks,
both of which are load-bearing
and they make up part of the northern wall of the queen's chamber.
The channel has no signs of damage by ancient tomb robbers.
There's no breach that could mean that these objects are intrusive
after the pyramid's construction.
And no, this broken channel block I showed
in a video a few years ago does not lead to another adjoining channel.
I've recently been shown another view of this broken block
which sadly I'm not allowed to publish
but I know for sure it is merely a broken piece of limestone
and nothing but masonry is beyond it. Yes, I was disappointed as well.
So the relics can only date to the time of the pyramid's construction,
estimated to be between 2580
and 2560 BC,
because they were trapped in a narrow channel with no way inside.
But on its rediscovery in 2020,
the piece of wood was radiocarbon dated and the results
really were quite a shock,
having a date range between 3341 and 3094 BC.
Yes, at a minimum, it was around 500 years older than
the conventional date of the pyramid.
But how can this be? Is the pyramid older than we're led to believe?
Does it imply the Great Pyramid was in fact built in the pre-dynastic
or early dynastic
or is there another explanation?
Well, in this video, I'll be trying to find out the answers.
Whilst investigating the Queen's Chamber,
Wayman Dixon and James Grant noticed specific cracks
in the south wall of the chamber.
Dixon probed a nearby joint with a wire
and he found out he could keep pushing it through
for quite some distance without meeting any resistance.
There must have been a void and so
the two men decided to excavate the wall and no, not very neatly.
But they did reveal the
southern channel and they scrawled the opening date
on the wall right next to it and above it.
Knowing the King's Chamber had two opposing air channels inside,
Dixon and Grant made the
logical assumption the same was likely
for the Queen's Chamber as well, and so they turned
their attention to the North Wall.
And yes, concealed behind the joint between two wall
blocks was another small channel heading off northwards
into the Pyramid's core masonry.
The discovery was published in the journal Nature on December 26th 1872
and it's in this article where we first learn about
the so-called Dixon Relics.
To see some fantastic high resolution pictures
and to learn more about two of the three objects,
visit the website of the British Museum
on the links I've left in the description below.
They described the stone ball
as a spherical dolerite pounder with a diameter ranging from
6.5 to 7.6 centimetres and weighing 540 grams.
The hook that was found is made of copper and
is described by the British Museum as a copper forked implement.
The presence of organic
material on the object suggests it
was originally fitted with a wooden or bone handle.
Its height is 4.55 centimetres,
its width is 5.19 and it's 1.09 centimetres in thickness.
But the third item is missing from the collection in the British Museum
and it had been missing for decades.
James Grant had kept the wooden rod until his death in 1895.
It was inherited by his daughter and she kept it until 1946,
when she donated it to the University of Aberdeen in Scotland.
The object was never properly catalogued in the university's archive
and although people have been searching for it in the past,
the small wooden rod was not found. Well, not until the year 2020,
when curatorial assistant Abir Eladani came across it,
74 years after it was donated.
Ella Darney was reviewing items for the university's Asia collection
when she found the wooden rod.
Now in a number of pieces and inside an old cigar box
and this was marked with Egypt's former flag.
I have to say it is pretty cool that although
the relic has been in Scotland for many decades
it was rediscovered by an Egyptian. It's almost poetic.
But anyway, after its rediscovery, the wooden rod was radiocarbon dated
and the results of which surprised everyone.
Because the date range was outside of Khufu's reign
and outside of Egypt's Old Kingdom.
The piece of wood had a date range from 3341 to 3094 BC,
and that's at least 500 years older
than the reign of King Khufu,
the supposed builder of the Great Pyramid.
In the past five years,
some people have been using this discrepancy as evidence the Great
Pyramid was not built for King Khufu, because well,
we now have hard evidence right here.
You surely can't argue with the scientific data.
It does sound like compelling evidence against
the mainstream view for the age of the Great Pyramid
and for me personally I was forced to delve deeper into the science
and find out what specifically was being dated.
Radiocarbon dating a piece of wood does not give you the date
when the tree was cut down.
It also does not tell you when the specific wooden object was made
or even the age it was last used.
It gives you the age of the tree ring the wooden object is made from.
And what do we know about cedar wood
that was used in Old Kingdom Egypt?
It was imported from Lebanon,
a country that's always been famous for its enormous cedar trees.
Lebanese cedars can grow up to 40 meters
or 130 feet in height with trunks up to 2.5 meters or
8 foot 2 inches in diameter.
Some examples have been found to be even bigger.
And they live for hundreds and hundreds of years.
Some ancient cedars are thought to be over 1,000 years old
and some sources even say they can live
to between 2,000 and 3,000 years.
Cedars are slow growing trees.
Cultivation goes all the way back at least 3,200 years
when the Hittite Empire established two populations in northern Turkey.
They first came to Britain in 1638 by Edward Pocock
and now nearly 400 years later,
one particular tree is still going strong.
And if you're cutting down cedar trees to export the wood,
logically you don't use young trees.
The trees you'd cut down are old and established.
So, to clarify, if you cut down, say,
a 700 year old cedar tree, the oldest central tree
ring would give you a radiocarbon date 700 years older than
the date it was cut down,
because the tree lives for so long.
So now, all of a sudden,
a piece of wood found inside the Great Pyramid,
dated to at least 500 years older than the structure,
doesn't actually seem that out of place.
Especially if the wood comes from the inside
of a very old Lebanese cedar.
And we know from studying the famous Palermo Stone,
that in the Fourth Dynasty of ancient Egypt,
great quantities of cedar wood were imported.
In the reign of Sneferu, the father of King Khufu,
40 shiploads of cedar timbers were imported for his
building projects. And maybe Khufu did the same,
or maybe there was wood left over from his father's
reign, or there were wooden objects that were reused by Khufu.
In ancient Egypt, quality wood
was scarce, so objects could well have been recycled
for as long as the wood remained intact.
Whatever the origins of this small piece of wood
that was found inside the Great Pyramid,
the fact is, it isn't strong enough evidence
to date the Great Pyramid all by itself.
Because yes, you could argue it came from a young tree,
and so yes, the pyramid could predate the reign of Khufu.
But on the flip side,
you could also argue that it comes from the inside of an old tree,
and so the pyramid is perfectly dated to the reign of Khufu.
By itself you can't date or re-date the Great Pyramid.
It can only be used as supporting evidence in a much larger dataset.
But at the very least, it does tell us
the Great Pyramid can't be any older than 3341 BC.
And that's because of where it was found.
In a sealed channel in the core masonry of the pyramid.
Whatever the truth, this small cigar box containing splinters
of wood is an important rediscovery.
It's one of only three artefacts ever discovered inside
the Great Pyramid
and these objects were left in situ ever since it was built.
And so, however it is interpreted,
it's something that pyramid enthusiasts must consider,
and the data from radiocarbon dating is something that can't simply be
dismissed or forgotten.
Thank you very much for watching this episode of Ancient Architects.
If you enjoyed the video, please subscribe to the channel,
Please like the video and please leave a comment below.
Thank you very much.
