Sarah Cook, upphovsman till UnderReported China newsletter på Substack gästade NTD:s Steve Lance för att diskutera sin granskning om oetiska organtransplantationer i Kina.
Hennes rapport Red Flags, Compromised doctors lyfter fram en vetenskapligt granskad studie som visar att kinesiska läkare var inblandade i, eller hade kopplingar till, avrättningar av fångar – ofta samvetsfångar – genom organuttag.
Cook tar också upp den grundläggande ”Dead Donor Rule”, som kräver att donatorer förklaras hjärndöda innan organ kan transplanteras.
Hon påpekar att läkare i Kina inte är bundna av Hippokrates ed eller läkareden utan förblir lojala mot det kinesiska kommunistpartiet, och betonar att många av läkarna som utförde dessa oetiska transplantationer sedan dess har gjort karriär och fortsätter att leda transplantationsprogram.
Sarah Cook discusses a report on organ transplant abuses in China, revealing that many doctors linked to the \"execution by organ procurement\" of prisoners are still practicing. The report highlights the violation of the \"dead donor rule\" and the targeting of prisoners of conscience, while explaining how CCP control over the medical system ensures secrecy and a lack of accountability.
A new report raising concerns about organ transplant abuses in China.
The doctors linked to past cases
who are still practicing medicine today.
Joining us to discuss these findings of that report,
Sarah Cook, author of the Underreported China newsletter.
Sarah Cook, thank you so much for joining us.
My pleasure.
Sarah, you have a new report.
It details organ transplant abuse in China. You've been following
this issue closely for years.
Tell us about why this new report was necessary and what you have
discovered.
Sure. So this report is the second in a series
that I'm working on looking at what are any
indicators of ongoing transplant abuse in China today.
This particular report really actually
looked at kind of the legacy
and the ongoing footprint of very well-documented past abuses,
and in particular at where are some of the doctors now
that were found to have essentially
We've essentially been involved
or linked to the execution of prisoners via organ retrieval.
And so what we did for this report was there
was a peer-reviewed study a few years ago by two researchers,
one of them a transplant surgeon himself, that looked
at the papers that Chinese doctors had written and published.
And they found, based on the way the organ procurements were described,
That it became evident that as they said, the retrieval of the organs
and the procurement became the proximate cause of death for the donor.
So in other words, those who are involved
in these surgeries did not properly.
The person who was providing the organs was not actually brain dead
the way would be normal international standards.
And instead, that it was the organ retrieval
that contributed to the person's death,
they actually titled the paper Execution by Organ Procurement.
So that was how direct and stark what they found was.
Now, those papers were published from 1980 up until 2015.
So they're not necessarily evidence of things happening now,
but very clear evidence of what happened in the past.
What we looked at was they had listed hundreds of doctors
and others who had authored these papers.
Where are those people now?
And what we found is that many,
many of them are still practicing in China.
It's incredible.
I guess, talk to us about how unusual this is based on your research
and what that fact alone,
meaning the patient or the donor, unwilling or otherwise,
what does it say about who they are
and the condition they're in when this has happened?
Okay, so there's a very important
foundational rule for transplant medicine.
It's called the dead donor rule.
And it's basically the rule that means
that there's a very specific, it's very technical,
very specific process through
which a prospective donor is actually declared to be brain dead
and therefore being able to be a viable donor.
And it's what separates organ transplant surgery
from effectively killing.
Now, there's another layer of prohibition.
In fact, even in the many, some countries in Europe,
it's actually illegal for physicians
to participate in the execution of prisoners.
What seems to have happened here is that these doctors
and surgeons violated both of those
provisions.
And this 2022 study found that based
on the descriptions of the order in which and the
process through which the organ procurement
and the supposed brain death declaration had
That, in fact, it didn't meet international standards
and these people were not really
brain dead.
And therefore, that the organ procurement
itself had very likely caused their death.
And this was something, again,
one of the authors on this paper is himself a transplant
surgeon outside of China, a professional,
and he was shocked when his co-author who
speaks Chinese showed him these descriptions like,
wait, this can't be right.
I can't believe this.
This is completely wrong.
This is not how you go through the order
for the organ procurement.
And one of the things is that at the time these papers were published,
even the Chinese government admits that there
was no real voluntary donor system in China.
These only prisoners were being used for organs.
So that means that these the people who are supposedly,
you know, donating their organs, they weren't volunteers.
It wasn't someone in the ICU who got into a bad car accident or things
like that that we might see in other countries around the world.
These were prisoners. These were prisoners who were taken
and were killed and their organs were procured.
Now, one of the things, who are these prisoners?
Well, some of them were very likely people,
and this is what the Chinese government claims,
who were like on death row and things like that.
But in China, of course, there isn't real rule of law.
So even someone who's on death row may
not have actually even committed the crime they were accused of.
But, of course, there's also a lot
of evidence that during this period of time,
religious minorities and prisoners of conscience,
especially members of the Falun Gong spiritual group,
were being targeted and victims for organ harvesting.
And in fact, when you look at these doctors' papers,
75% of them were published after 1999
when the persecution of Falun Gong
by the Chinese Communist Party was launched.
So it's very likely.
That the supposed donors in these cases
that were killed via the organ procurement
were, in fact, prisoners of conscience
and not just necessarily death row prisoners.
And in your research,
you found that 100 of the 348 doctors who wrote these papers are still
practicing in China.
What does accountability look like? And is there any?
So that's what we wanted to look at.
Here you had this publicized study,
and there was an appendix with these names.
And the reason we started looking into this,
because as I got into working on this research,
you know, I started to become familiar with some
of the Chinese doctors and the leading
transplant surgeons' names.
And one day I had this idea, you know what,
let me see if they're in this appendix.
And I was shocked, because top heart and lung transplant doctors,
people now who are leading
major transplant centers in China,
are among the people that authored those papers.
Now, when you're listed as an author on a paper,
it's certainly at least one of those
people, and probably more than them, were in the actual operating room.
But even if they weren't, as soon as they
were reading the description, they had to
have been aware of what this practice meant,
that there was very problematic procurement
going on.
And yet they still put their name on the paper.
In fact, some of them put their names on two, four, six papers.
So these are people
who had a recurring link to problematic organ procurements.
That essentially were basically execution of prisoners.
So we looked at where they are now.
What we found was that over 100 of them
are still active in China at 40 hospitals in 16
provinces.
Within them, there's a subset of 39 who,
again, were authors of more than one paper.
Those people are concentrated.
In like five provinces, and a smaller number of hospitals,
but several of those hospitals are the same hospitals where
the abuses originally took place.
So you have this situation where you have institutions at which
this kind of horrific, problematic procurement occurred,
and those same doctors, those same personnel have advanced
in their careers and are still leading transplant programs.
To that point, Sarah, I think this issue for the international
community inside of the United States, it's such a...
difficult issue to kind of wrap our heads around
because of the civilized society that we live in.
It's almost unfathomable. What would your message
be to an American doctor who's encountering this
issue for the first time or may have heard about it?
But as it starts to come into the discourse
more and more, my colleague, Yania Kalik,
has written an excellent book called Killed to Order
that explores China's transplants, malpractices.
I think that's a light way to put it.
But what would you say to them
when this comes across their desk and they're just
trying to wrap their heads around this?
I think you have to understand how
different the system is in China.
And that's actually what the first report in the series
looked at. We actually looked at.
How the Chinese Communist Party controls the medical profession
and the transplant sector in China.
I think a lot of doctors outside would be like,
wow, how could Chinese doctors do this?
It violates the Hippocratic Oath.
But we looked at it.
Chinese doctors don't take the Hippocratic Oath.
They take a different oath that was introduced by the Ministry
of Education that prioritizes things like loving the motherland, right,
and that kind of CCP speak compared to what you would have
in the traditional medical oath of do no harm.
Many transplant doctors
are themselves Chinese Communist Party members, we discovered.
And that means they've taken another oath.
They've taken an oath to protect the party's secrets.
So when you see that there are no whistleblowers,
well, that's because some of the people running
these programs have given a vow to be secretive, to cover things up.
And...
One of the things, and then on top of that, of course,
there's the entire repressive apparatus of the party
that will just punish anybody whether they're a party member or not.
So for the first report, we were actually able to find a doctor
who's now in exile, not a transplant surgeon, but just someone
who had worked for 15 years in the medical system in China.
And we asked him, well, why don't people speak up if they're witnessing
or being forced, right, by the party apparatus
to even engage in these kinds of ethical violations?
And he said, well, everybody in China knows if you speak up,
you're going to be the next one to disappear.
So I think that fundamental difference
of what the incentives are and the culture is
of even the medical profession in China,
it's very technical, very technocratic.
There isn't this underlying ethical foundation
that's the same as you might find outside
of China.
And there aren't the institutions to ensure that.
Because what we also found is that all of these,
as part of their supposed reform, all
All of these supposed independent oversight bodies.
We just went one by one.
They're all controlled by the party.
They're all dominated by party members.
So it's entirely circular.
So you can't really know what's actually happening on the inside.
And of course, that has real implications
for the risk for ongoing abuses, because they
absolutely could be supplementing what
is a voluntary system that does exist in some
capacity and scale in China with ongoing organs from prisoners
or prisoners of conscience.
And nobody would know about it because it's entirely secret.
It's entirely enclosed.
And it's run by people who have been sworn to secrecy.
Sarah Cook, author of the Underreported China newsletter.
Great research.
Where can we find your work and sign up for your newsletter?
So you can go to Underreported China.
It's a Substack newsletter.
And you can find these reports on the website
of the International Coalition to End Transplant
Abuse in China.
They're the one who published this report.
And that's at endtransplantabuse.org.
Sarah Cook, really appreciate you joining us.
Thank you.