Espresso Distribution Which Tool or Technique works best

Cook Space
21 followers
Oct 28, 2022
When people first start making espresso they usually just grind the coffee,
tamp it and then move on with life blissfully unaware of the deep nerdy rabbit hole they just
avoided. Then one day they see someone performing some weird ritual on the coffee grounds and they
think they look like they know what they're doing. Maybe that's what I've been missing this
whole time. And just like that they have been sucked into the black hole that we call
Today we want to back it up and find out if you really need a special tool or a
certain technique to distribute the coffee. Let's see what we can find out right after this.
Hey it's Josh from the Coffee Science and Education Center. Today's video is a part of
a series where we answer the most common questions we get about science and the technique of espresso
coffee. Last time we covered questions about tamping but today we're going to take a close
look at what baristas call Distribution. Distribution is the process of preparing
the ground coffee before we compress it using a tamp. The thinking here is that if coffee isn't
evenly distributed throughout the basket then the water will work its way through the less dense
parts causing uneven extraction from that bed of coffee. In simple terms water is lazy and it
will always look for the path of least resistance through the coffee. Evenly distributing the
grounds is one of those ways that we try to make sure that water can't just take the easy option
out. Now there are a crazy number of tools and techniques to help baristas distribute coffee
so we wanted to see if we could find any evidence that one or more of these techniques
made a more significant difference than another. For the sake of time and our own sanity we could
not test every method or tool out there. Instead we limited our tests to the techniques and tools
most popular and used in today's cafes. These methods are collapsing the coffee bed vertically
like by tapping the handle on the forks of the grinder or the edge of the bench. Tapping the
side of the basket with your palm. We tested both a short version and a longer version of this method.
The stock fleck technique. A method that involves shifting the ground coffee in a circular motion
between your first finger and your thumb. The OCD distribution tool. That is a device which has a
designed to move the layers of coffee in a circular motion inside the basket.
And we also tested doing absolutely nothing at all. Now before we get carried away I should
clarify that these tests are not the final word on what's best. There are hundreds of variables
that go into making coffee that we cannot account for. Not to mention different taste preferences.
So your results may vary. Also things are about to get really nerdy really quick. So hang in there
and seriously are you ready for this? We got one of our chemical engineers Johnny to set up a
series of different tests which include measuring the differences in the espresso extraction time
and also the TDS. TDS means total dissolved solids and that is inside the liquid espresso.
This is essentially a measure of the overall strength of the espresso.
We do this by taking a small sample and measuring it with a device known as a refractometer.
Again the purpose of choosing these measurements was to see if a particular distribution technique
changed how the coffee extracted or the consistency of the shots over time. Of course we also tasted
the coffee but the results of our taste tests were inconclusive. So we won't muddy the waters
by commenting on taste this time around. Let's start with the extraction time. The simple palm
tap, the stock cleft, the OCD and undistributed method all extracted in very similar ranges of
time. The palm tap and the stock cleft methods were very ever so slightly more consistent than
the OCD or the undistributed method. But there were basically nothing in the split of the results.
What was more interesting was that both the vertical collapse and the longer palm tapping
technique took noticeably longer to pour in that extraction than the other methods used.
Our best guess is that the most aggressive downward force is causing some of those finer
particles to move downwards and choke the flow of water just a little. Now even though the water is
taking longer to flow through the coffee, the vertical collapse and the longer palm tapping
technique both extracted less than the undistributed method. That is to say the
coffee made using these methods was ever so slightly weaker than the control. Now at first
glance that seems like the opposite of what should happen. Most people would naturally assume
that a longer extraction time would result in more being extracted from the coffee. However
when we use these techniques the restricted flow seems to have limited the overall extraction from
the coffee. Another point to note here is that while the OCD didn't really change the extraction
time, the shots made using this device also had a slightly lower TDS than the undistributed grounds.
Now this seems like a little bit of an anomaly but it does line up with the previous research
done by the team at Socratic Coffee. They also saw a consistently lower extraction yield when
using the OCD while keeping the other variables the same. We'll link to their research in the
description if you want to look into this a little bit further. While we don't know why the shots made
with the OCD extracted less, I will point out that a lower TDS is not necessarily a bad thing for
flavor as not everything we extract from coffee has a positive impact on the final result. So while
the chart seems to show that these shots are worse, taste is a far more complex thing than
these numbers on their own would indicate. Before we wrap up this section and try to pull some
practical conclusions out of all of this, I'll make a quick note on consistency. While we really
didn't see a big difference between the average extraction between distributed grounds and
undistributed grounds, the undistributed method definitely had less consistency from shot to shot.
For that reason alone, we would recommend using some method of distributing the grounds rather
than just leaving it all to chance. It is also worth noting that we used a high-end commercial
espresso grinder, the Mythos 1 for these tests. This produces even and less clumpy grounds than
those smaller domestic grinders, so this may have an impact on how well the undistributed grounds
did perform in these tests. So what do we do with all of this information? Unlike our tests on
tamping, these results are just not so cut and dry. There is no obvious winner, as much as we
definitely would like to see one. The conclusion we came to is this, specific distribution techniques
do not actually make as much of a difference as we think. It matters more that you pick a technique
and use it consistently in your workflow. If you're going to start from scratch,
we recommend using the simplest method, which is that easy palm tapping technique.
We recommend it because it's quick, doesn't cost anything and it is as hygienic as possible,
because you don't need to interact with that coffee any more than necessary. And with that
in mind, here's the process we teach our students in our classes. First, we grind the coffee into
the basket directly, settling it just a little before we pull the handle from the grinder to
ensure we keep our mess on that bench to a minimum. You've got to keep your benches clean. Secondly,
we weigh our end dose to ensure that the correct amount of coffee is being used with our desired
recipe. Third, using our preferred quick and efficient method of distribution, it is to use
the heel of our palm and strike gently against the side of the basket to settle and level the
coffee grind. The fourth step is to tamp firmly and evenly, compressing the grind and removing any
potential air pockets. The fifth step is to wipe and swipe and keep the ridge of the basket and
those lugs clean and ensure that you have a good seal prior to the extraction. Finally,
lock that beast up and enjoy the good brew. What do you think? Did we get it wrong? Is distribution
really the holy grail of Perfect Espresso? You know what to do, let us know in the comments.
Next time, we're going to take a look at the effect of pressure. Is 9 bars really the ideal
brewing pressure to get those best results? We'll definitely try to find some answers for you soon.
