Educator Misconduct Exposed: Rachel Hale & Aileen Blachowski Share Insights

The Texas Insider
6 followers
11 Video Views·Jan 29, 2025
In this episode, Rachel Hale and Aileen Blachowski from Texas Education 911 discuss their recent report on educator misconduct. We explore the scope of the issue, key findings from their research, how Texas compares nationally, and actionable strategies to protect students. Don’t miss this crucial conversation on accountability and prevention in education.
Everything in this system, from the beginning, from the pre-hiring and the pre-screening
of employees, all the way through to the final disposition of investigations, oh my gosh.
It's shocking how unsafe our children are at schools, despite the laws we've passed.
They're not working and they need to be fixed.
Now I know education is always a hot topic and there's a lot going on, discussion from
education reform to curriculum.
Now what you're talking about today is something completely different, but it's important it's
an overlooked topic.
I know there was a recent report done on educator misconduct that was done by Texas Education
911 and this report was released earlier this month.
What are some of the things and issues that this report goes over?
Well, we found a shocking number of reports out of the Texas Education Agency with regard
to school employee misconduct.
And so it's not just certified teachers, it's bus drivers, it's teachers, aides, and sometimes
it's the mechanic who works in the bus yard.
But I mean, it was alarming.
We had submitted public information requests to get this data and we found that there were
over 11,000 records of misconduct reported by school districts.
Almost 7,000 of them were regarding physical and sexual assaults of students by taxpayer-funded
employees.
And that set off alarm bells for us and we just knew we had to dig into those numbers
and get them reported and get this out in the eye of the public so we could start solving
some of the problems.
Texas alone we're talking about.
Yeah, and those 11,000 reports were from September of 21 through March of 2024, or current March
of 2024, or June, was it June?
It was July.
July, I think.
So from September 2021 to July 24, that's where that 11,000 number came from.
And now I know this report was done from parent advocates of Texas Education 911.
What are some of the other issues?
I know you have sexual abuse, actual physical abuse.
What other types of things do they find?
Well, there are a number of categories of abuse that can be reported to the Texas Education
Agency.
They can include anything from drug offenses, alcohol, theft, miscellaneous misconduct,
other crimes committed outside of school sometimes show up too.
And so, you know, sometimes you see some of those things as well.
We also see contract violations, honestly, show up in the same reporting system.
And so we put our focus specifically on the sex and violence because, well, we were concerned
about sex crimes against students because, again, this is happening on our tax dollars.
These are employees that we pay to care for our kids.
Parents send their kids to school thinking that it's a safe environment and that the
adults were looking out for their best interest.
This alarming number of reports is raising a lot of eyebrows.
And frankly, we just thought that was the most important thing to look at.
But when we got all the data and we saw that the violence claims were, I mean, three or
four times the amount of sexual misconduct, we said, Texas has to know about this.
Probably got brought out into the open.
And what were some of the other key findings in this report?
Well, I think what is most alarming is, well, there were a number of things.
The advocates of Texas 911 live all across the state.
And so this started as a very just boots on the ground what's happening in your school district.
I live in Prosper ISD, and in 2022, a bus driver molested two young sisters aged five
and seven for an entire year.
And no one else who had children on that bus were aware of that until three months later
when a federal lawsuit was filed by the victim's families.
And so all of these victim families whose kids may have been affected, they never heard of anything.
And so we started looking into what happens.
Nobody lost their job.
Nobody was fired except for the bus driver who later died in police custody.
And so everybody felt like there was no justice done.
And so we just started looking at what's happened in my district.
And somebody would say, I'm going to ask for that information in my district.
And soon enough, we started asking for information for districts all over the state
until the Texas Education Agency delivered the entire portal database.
And when we looked at that, we found there were issues from the reporting itself,
the timeliness of the reporting.
The Texas Education Agency wasn't inputting those reports when they received them.
Whatever date is in the system is the date they actually
keyed in the report, not when it happened.
Sometimes things were left uninvestigated for a very long time.
A very high number of reports were coded as did not open,
like there was never an investigation opened.
We don't really know what that means.
We really don't know.
And when parents come to us with problems and they tell us what they've experienced,
it doesn't match up with what the TEA is saying that they do internally for their
investigative process.
So we found process problems.
We found reporting and timeline problems.
We found failure to report serious violence and sex crimes against children.
We also found that investigations are kind of botched up, frankly,
and a lot of times parents are even stopped from moving forward.
Law enforcement doesn't talk to schools and schools don't play well with outside law
enforcement.
And essentially, no matter what happens in this system,
the parents and the child victims don't get justice.
Because of Texas's laws, they're not allowed to sue a school district.
We have probably the strictest sovereign immunity protections for school employees
in the nation.
And even if your child is sexually abused at school, it's almost impossible to get a lawsuit
going unless you do that through the federal courts.
So we found a number of problems.
And the high number of uninvestigated claims was probably, in my mind, the most shocking.
That's amazing.
And this is all different grade levels.
This is, like, from your elementary school to high school.
Yeah, that would be K through 12.
The little thing, the school superintendent and the principals, it's a state jail felony
if they fail to report and to TEA.
But yet, when they're not doing the intake dates, you don't know what the intake date
is when the report was filed.
So there could be all these state jail felonies, but it's hard to prove because we don't know
when they actually got the report to the TEA versus when they put it in.
And there's a seven-day window of when they have to report that.
Another thing that was shocking is that in the last legislative session, Texas spent
$1.4 billion on school safety.
So we're literally protecting the kids from the outside, but we're not protecting them
on the inside.
Yeah, just preventing who's coming in.
And you have the people, like you're saying.
Because, I mean, another part of it is, I know it was kind of brought up in the report,
is people who, you know, might seek to do harm to children, they're going to go work
in places that have children and they have access.
So this is something that's a big part of this issue as well, because they want to have
close access to victims.
Right.
And it is true that schools do do background checks before they hire individuals.
But what we found, again, more shocking failures in the system, is that the state requires
the schools to use what they call NASDAQ.
And it's a long acronym that is basically a national database for educators so that you
can see, you know, if they have any flags in their background, if they move from state
to state.
However, it's a voluntary association, and we're not all mandated.
All states are not all mandated to participate or to report to it.
So it's full of holes.
And then we talked to education researchers who told us, all you see is a flag, but you
don't know what it's for.
And so it's inadequate in really helping schools deter criminals from schools.
And everything in this system, from the beginning, from the pre-hiring and the pre-screening
of employees, all the way through to the final disposition of investigations.
Oh, my gosh, it's shocking how unsafe our children are at schools, despite the laws
we've passed.
They're not working and they need to be fixed.
And I know we were talking about, well, we were talking about some of the percentages,
but how prevalent is this, you know, as far as children being, you know, prone to receiving
misconduct from an employee in a school?
Well, out of the 11,000, more than 11,000 reports that we received in that time frame,
I can tell you that 1,028 of those, so just under 10% of those, were sexual misconduct
perpetrated in school.
And let's see, and violence, the violence claims, so this would be a school employee
who committed an act of violence against a student, 4,144 claims during that time period.
When we look at the way the cases are coded, 74% of those were coded as they did not open
an investigation.
This is just shocking.
If you look at the number of educators who actually had an inappropriate relationship
with a student, right, so these are teachers sexually perping on students, 1,412 cases
of those reported.
Every one of these numbers represents a child, a child who is, you know, and these are trusted
adults in school, and they're taking advantage of their situation, being able to get close
to kids, and they're perpetrating these crimes against our kids.
It's just simply unacceptable.
And a lot of these people, too, because there is a very, it's a big lack of reporting and
being able to keep track of these incidents, so they are probably going from place to place
and doing it again.
So there are repeat offenders, a lot of these people.
They are repeat offenders sometimes, and then what we've seen, and this is a phenomenon
we saw across the country, post-COVID, there was a massive teacher shortage, and that teacher
shortage, I mean, by state, you know, I'm sure every state's handling it in their own
way, but I think across the board, you can say we've had to make a lot of exceptions
and create unique programs to fast-track getting bodies into classrooms to cover, you know,
to cover the classrooms.
I don't know, they're not all certified.
A lot of them were emergency certified, and they're being brought in, and I don't know
how well you can do vetting when you have 200 or 400 positions to fill.
That's for the schools to answer.
What we can tell you is that since 2021, we've seen this incredible rise in these cases,
and so we believe it is part of the problem.
We have tracked a few individuals where we can tell you that they went from school district
to school district to school district, and we can find records of that before they're
actually fired or arrested.
We pass laws to try and help don't pass the trash.
They have largely been ineffective, and they lack teeth that make them effective and really
keep kids safe.
And so those are some of the things that we want to try and address in the next legislative
session because kids are...they're in schools that are fortified like Fort Knox from the
outside, from outside predators, but they're locked inside.
With predators that we haven't been paying attention to.
I know that was one of the other things the report goes over is what are some of the solutions
that are being discussed?
Well, we have three main solutions for the problem that we would love to see.
We've talked to lawyers who are fighting these cases in federal courts.
We've talked to individuals who have worked inside the TEA in investigations and adjudicating
these issues, and we've come up with three systemic solutions, if you will.
The first one is we're calling for an independent Office of Inspector General for Education.
In the Texas state budget, education is the largest spending light item.
So there's no oversight over that.
And when we looked at what's happening here in investigations, we said, you know what,
this has to be pulled out of here.
We need to move this function to an agency or an office that we can trust will only have
this on their mind.
And so we'd love to see the investigative authority be removed from local school districts
and the TEA and place that in that independent Office of Inspector General so that we know
that they're operating with a specific investigative standard and that they're a neutral third
party that can work in the best interest of the victim.
And then they'd also have the ability to investigate waste and fraud as well.
And so that's a big one.
We're getting a lot of traction on that one.
It is something everybody recognizes is a solution that's very much needed.
It's novel.
And I think it's time for that one.
The next solution we have is to exempt violent sex misconduct against students from the sovereign
immunity that we talked about.
We think that it will begin to deter these crimes and put a stop to them if school districts
and the offending employees know they're going to be responsible for the simple penalties
for the damages they cause to the children they harm.
And then the third one is to abolish taxpayer funded lobbying specifically in education
because there are large statewide and regional lobby groups who are literally driving the
bus for Texas education.
And they just, you know, they serve the vendors and they serve the unions and they serve the
interests of special interests, but not the students who should come first in education.
So we'd love to see that abolished as well.
I wanted to say, too, on those two solutions, the inspector general and the sovereign immunity,
we're literally operating under education under a two-tiered system of justice.
If you or I go out and we perp on a child, we're absolutely going to get thrown under
the jailhouse.
Yet in education, they are often allowed to voluntarily surrender their license, their
certificate in lieu of any kind of civil or criminal penalty.
And it's only the certified teachers.
So we're not talking about your uncertified teachers or your bus drivers or aides or whatever.
They don't have a certificate necessarily to relinquish, but they're allowing the educators
to do that.
Another key thing that we have found is the majority of the people that are being arrested,
that is when somebody goes and makes the report to outside law enforcement and they immediately
get them, the command there is to immediately get the child before a child advocacy center
investigator to interview them.
And so that is where we are seeing when they go in-house and the parent goes directly to
the school district, the majority of those are not ending up in arrest.
So there is, yeah.
So it's not like it's never being brought up by being pushed under the rug and not really
being, nothing's being done about it.
So then they can just go on.
It's going to happen again.
TEA is never referred to outside law enforcement.
Whereas outside law enforcement, Department of Family Services, they all, when they get
a case, they do report that to TEA, but that's not reciprocated by the TEA to outside law
enforcement.
And that's a problem.
Yeah, definitely.
What is that session coming up that you're going to be talking some more about this and
January 14th, this Tuesday, they gavel in it?
Yeah.
Coming up.
And so this is going to be the key topics that you're going to be discussing and where
will it go from there?
There are already some bills out there that we are looking at, several bill authors, and
we are working with them and offering amendments.
And honestly, to be quite frank, we're looking for a bill that's actually going to have teeth
and enforcement, and it's going to do what it's designed to do.
We are no longer going to accept half measures and band-aids.
Our Texas children are too important and too valuable for that.
So we're looking for something to get in there and really create the enforcement that is
necessary to protect Texas children.
And make those.
And this is not going anywhere with school choice and stuff like that.
And we don't weigh in on school choice.
However, we absolutely want to fix public education.
The majority of children, there's 5.5 million students in Texas.
And so we've got to protect them.
Absolutely.
And if people want to know now, can parents or the community, how would they get involved
and want more information?
Where would they look?
We welcome people to join us.
We'll be training up parents.
Lots of parents have issues.
So we want to hear their stories, number one, because they only reiterate the fact that
we need these solutions.
And so we highly encourage teachers, aides, anybody else who's working in a school district,
we hear from them now.
It's shocking.
So if you're a parent or a teacher working in a school and you want to help solve these
problems, share your stories.
We can keep you anonymous.
Go to our website at texased911.com and share your story or submit your story.
We would love to hear from you.
We'll follow up with you and see what we can do to help.
And hopefully give you an opportunity to elevate and expand your voice.
Give you a platform to speak in front of legislators so that they can hear about how important
what you've experienced and how they can help solve your problem.
And then you can also sign up on our website to get action alerts.
And we'll let you know when bills are coming up and they need a little push or some encouragement
to be passed.
And of course, we are all volunteer and mostly self-funded.
There are dozens of us in this network, but some of us are spending 10, 12 hours a day,
six days a week doing this work.
We are unpaid and fully volunteer.
And if anyone would be willing to support our work and give us a donation, you can find
our donation link also on our website.
And we would just be so grateful.
It would help us cover mileage, copying expenses, and, you know, give those hardworking parent
advocates of Texas 9-1-1 an extra boost of caffeine on the days that we're hitting the
halls of the Capitol.
Right.
And so the more people that get involved, the better, you know, the chances of change.
And that's what's going to be important.
Absolutely.
You know what?
Rachel said it perfectly.
We can't take out any more half measures.
The time for passing those sort of beauty bills that don't actually provide the appropriate
oversight and accountability, we can't have that anymore.
Kids are being harmed in Texas schools.
We thought very carefully about the title of this report, and we called it sponsored
child abuse for a reason, because tax dollars are paying for this to happen.
Systems are in place.
They are not doing their job to protect children.
And until the legislature and the state agency is responsible for keeping kids safe to actually
do that, we'll continue to call out the state sponsored child abuse that's happening.
No, I'm very, I'm glad that you joined us today.
And it's something that really needs to be, you know, out there and highlighted more people,
parents, you know, the community has to get involved to try to make changes happen.
And that, you know, make more rules and regulations that are not being followed.
So I really appreciate you being with us today.
Thank you so much.
And hopefully we can get you back after the session and see what, you know, if anything
is kind of moving along.
I'd love to hear more about what's where it's at in another month from now.
We would love that.
I will say last session, we gathered like 31 or 32 stories and we called on Champion
a Child.
And we found stories for each basically senator's district and started giving them, are you
going to be a hero in these child's lives?
And we need them to step up and to be a hero this session.
And so we're very proud of that work.
And we, as parent advocates, we go hand in hand.
We, you know, all will attend meetings and with parents.
I will say this isn't anything that we've touched on in our report, but the educator
misconduct is just scratching the surface.
There is a huge rise in child-on-child sexual assault.
It really is.
And, you know, you asked in your explainer, you know, what does this look like on a national
level?
And what we have learned from talking to education researchers is that we haven't collected
data on this on a national level in over a decade.
And so the last statistic that we have is that about 1 in 10, 17 to 20, yeah, it was
a little over, it's a little over 1 in 10, 1 in 17 out of 100, I think it was 17% of
students nationwide report having had some unwanted sexual interaction with an educator.
We know that we're looking at the trend data in Texas and we're seeing a pretty significant
rise.
It's about a 20% rise in all misconduct reports year over year.
That's all reports.
And so we know the data needs to be updated.
It's a significant problem and Texas educates 10% of the nation's students.
So we need to lead on this and, you know, we need to put a stop to this now.
Hopefully others will follow and take the lead after we take, oh, if we take the lead.
Yeah, other states are already looking at Texas and they all talk about our don't pass
the trash bill and some other legislation that has been done.
But the fact of the matter is, is that it hasn't gone far enough and the enforcement
in it had no teeth essentially.
And so they are looking at us and they are looking to Texas to what we have been able
to figure out and put together.
We've actually tracked educators that were fired and left Texas schools and they've
crossed over the line and gone into Oklahoma to further be educators.
Another thing we haven't talked about, when they're allowed to surrender their certificate
and their license, there's nothing stopping them from going to another school district
and saying, oh, I just want to be a substitute.
And then if they say that, then they're not even looking to see if they've ever had a
certification or whatever.
And so other states are absolutely looking to Texas to solve this problem.
You have to be the example to kind of lead the way.
Well, like I said, I hope you definitely get some headway in this next session.
And I want to follow up and see where this where this ends.
And I hope it's, you know, in a better way for the children, you know, the ones that
are being harmed in the situation.
So I appreciate you coming today.
And thank you so much.
Thanks for having us.
