EdSource: Schools report positive changes from cell phone law

Fox-KTVU
32 followers
1 Video View·Nov 21, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCalifornia school districts are reporting positive outcomes following the Phone Free Schools Act. Educators observe reduced bullying, lower student anxiety, and improved social interaction and academic performance. While policies vary significantly across districts, the general consensus is that limiting phone use is a positive step toward a healthier learning environment.
Welcome back. Teachers and administrators
at California school districts say when it comes
to cell phones and students on campus,
they have noticed some positive changes in the last year.
It comes almost two years after the state
of California passed the Phone Free Schools Act,
which required all public
and charter schools to set policies that in some way limit the use
of cell phones on campuses.
Zadie Stavely is a senior reporter at EdSource. She joins us in
the studio to talk about her reporting.
You spoke to a lot of school districts about how these
cell phone policies are going.
Thank you for coming on to the show to tell us about it. What
were the big takeaways in your reporting
that you learned from schools about how this policy is
going? So we've talked to people
in several different districts all over the state and
people in general, teachers
and administrators told us that kids are feeling better.
They're less fighting, there's less bullying,
kids are feeling less anxious.
Apparently before, kids
were feeling nervous about getting photos taken of them and social
media bullying.
And that would inhibit their social interactions?
Yeah, and so that was a big takeaway.
Also, some said that they have already seen kids doing better
in school, especially schools
that had already implemented a policy the year before.
There was one high school principal told us that kids are doing more,
playing more together during recess.
I mean, high schoolers were playing hacky sack again,
playing Uno games, and he said that they just feel, they seem younger.
So overall, the consensus seems
to be this is a step in the right direction.
A positive step.
Okay.
But it is just a step.
And some of the shortcomings
of this cell phone-free act is that it doesn't say what
kinds of policies districts have to make.
They just have to do it, limit it in some way.
Correct.
And so there's a huge variety of policies.
Some schools allow kids to have their phones,
even during class, as long as the teacher
has to enforce it.
Don't use your phone during class.
And then a teacher has to figure out how to make that happen.
Some schools allow the kids to have them during
or use them during lunch or in between classes.
And others tell them that they have to put them away all day
or lock them away all day.
Right.
There's some Bay Area school districts that do that.
I think not West Contra Costa, Mount Diablo.
Oakland Unified actually,
their policy on paper says that they have to lock them away
In those Yonder pouches, right?
Yeah, or in like a lockbox.
Okay.
And then.
And then some schools have
those pouches where kids have to put them in.
Thank
And, you know, others, there's one school district,
West Sonoma County Union High School District,
that actually has something called geofencing where...
All the kids have to download an app on their phone,
and then they can't actually access
anything other than phone calls or texts during the day.
And so they can have their phones with them,
you.
but they can't actually access anything else,
no matter if they're on Wi-Fi or on cell phone data.
That's interesting.
You mentioned Sonoma, the West Sonoma School District,
Bay Area School District you spoke
with, also West Contra Costa County, Unified.
What are they doing?
They have a policy that a lot of school districts...
Thank
you.
It seems like a great job getting kids
to not use their phones during class, but it
really depends on him, right?
And so one of the things that the folks
in West Sonoma County said in Sebastopol was
that kids, when they had a policy in the past where it
was up to teachers, teachers were
telling kids constantly to put away their phone.
They were spending a lot of time.
They were doing all the policing.
Yes, and it was like every five minutes.
And now, since they can't get on...
their phones. Basically, they can't use their phones.
It's not really an issue anymore.
And the teachers are occasionally telling a kid
to put away their phone, but it's like once a day
rather than every five minutes.
So the school district says it looks like these policies are
working in some way. If you could look down the line,
based on what you heard in the next two to
three years, do you think there will
be more strict policies put in place given what's happened so
far? Maybe. I mean, a lot of students told us
that they're figuring out ways to get around the
Especially when it's like, put the phone in the yonder pouch.
Some kids said that they put deodorant sticks in there
or different kinds of things to get around the policy.
And so there are always kind of ways around that.
And so I think it's possible
that school districts will come up with stricter policies.
Or in some cases, they might figure out a way
to convince the kids that this is not actually healthy.
One of the things that was really interesting to me
is that students apparently...
Privately, publicly will tell you that they don't like.
The school, the phone policy,
especially around their friends, but when they're spoken to
privately, both by school administrators or to our reporters,
they said that they actually
appreciate them. Interesting. Zadie Stavely with EdSource.
Thanks so much for sharing your
reporting and coming to talk to us about it.
It's really insightful and this is an issue I'm sure
we'll be talking about a lot in the years ahead.
Thanks for having me. Of course. We'll send it
over to you, Rosemary. All right. Thank you so much.
Ladies, giving you a look here over Santa
Santa Cruz, clouds.
