This educational history video lays out the fundamental challenges modern scholars face when studying the first few centuries of Rome's existence, traditionally known as the regal period (753–509 BCE). The narrator explains that because the early Romans lacked a native genre of history writing, their oldest records function more as a mythology heavily entangled with political stakes, which only began taking full literary shape after encountering Greek historians during 4th and 3rd-century expansions. The video explores how later Roman figures, facing institutional strain in the Late Republic, constantly refashioned these bare traditions to claim authority, a practice that culminated during the reign of Augustus when historians like Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Livy produced what became the official, yet heavily condensed and idealized, accounts of Rome's foundational roots. #RomanHistory#EarlyRome#RegalPeriod#AncientHistory#Historiography#Livy#AugustanAge#HistoricalMethods#ThersitesTheHistorian#AncientRome
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lecture explores the challenges of reconstructing Rome's early history (the Regal Period, 753–509 BCE). Because early Romans lacked a formal tradition of history writing, much of this era is a blend of mythology and fragmented records. The speaker examines how later Romans used these ambiguous origins to justify their institutions and political shifts, particularly during the era of Augustus.
Despite the crucial role of the Romans in both the history of the West
and the larger history
of the world, we know surprisingly little about
the first few centuries of Rome's existence.
Traditionally known as the Regal Period and dated from 753 to 509 BCE,
a good deal of what we know about this time
is much more akin to mythology than history.
In this short series, I will introduce
and explain the challenges and problems that
studying the early years of Rome presents.
Along the way, I will also show that despite
the ambiguity of this period even to the Romans themselves,
they still viewed these early centuries
as being absolutely critical to their cultural
and institutional development. This lecture
will lay out the problem of early Rome
and set up subsequent lectures on the Greek tradition of Rome,
The Roman tradition of Rome
And what modern scholars tend to think about the subject.
Traditionally founded in the year 753 BCE,
Rome had a long history by the time
that historians began to take notice.
However, much of that history has been lost to time
because the Romans themselves did not have a genre
of history writing the way that the Greeks did.
Really, in many ways, you could argue that Roman history,
in the proper literary sense,
only begins when the Romans encountered the Greeks.
A full encounter between the Romans
and the Greeks occurred in the 4th century, but especially
in the early 3rd century,
when the Romans had expanded into southern Italy and were
now threatening the independence
of the Greek states in the south of Italy.
At that time, the Greek cities of the area called
for Pyrrhus of Epirus to come in, and
they fought three major battles.
And effectively, this really put the Romans
on the map for the entire Greek-speaking world
as Greek historians really sort of take
a very strong interest in the Romans
who were clearly a rising power on the international scene.
It was only around this time when we really start
to see Greek historians write about Rome in any detail.
All of the Greek histories of this early period,
that is sort of the first half of the 3rd century,
...are now nothing but names to us,
but we do know some of the names thanks to Dionysius of Halicarnassus
and Livy, both of whom cite earlier authors.
After the Greeks began to write about Rome, the Romans themselves
decided that they should get in on the act and write about themselves.
However, early Roman historians also wrote their histories in Greek,
and the reason for that is that Greek
was the international language of intellectual endeavor.
Both the elite in Rome
and Carthage decided to write most of their work in Greek rather
than in their native tongues.
And only around 200
and possibly even a little later did the Romans decide to try to write
history in their native language, Latin.
Cato the Elder, pictured here,
wrote a work called the Roman Antiquities around the year 150.
And this was sort of a constitutional history
of all the various cities of Italy, including Rome.
This was very much modeled on previous Greek works,
but this was a fully Latin language endeavor.
So interestingly enough, you might think
that the Romans would have a pretty clear grasp of their history
and be the masters of their own tradition going
into the Second Punic War,
when Rome was already a major power,
having defeated Carthage in the First Punic War.
But actually, it was only after the Second Punic War,
a generation after the Battle of Cannae,
that the Romans really decided that they needed to start producing
full-length histories of their own people in their native tongue.
By the time that the Romans began to take
the task of history writing seriously,
they were in the midst of unprecedented expansion beyond
the bounds of the Italian peninsula.
As Rome's power and wealth expanded,
it struggled to adapt its institutions to accommodate its
ever-growing empire,
and the Romans began to feel a yearning to better understand themselves
so that they could explain their success to their new subjects.
By the time that the late Republic began,
Rome was beginning to experience severe institutional strain
and political turmoil.
This caused a number of prominent Romans to seek political solutions.
In Rome, tradition and received authority always carried
a great deal of cultural cachet,
and so the Romans looked to their earlier history,
seeking answers and examples from
virtuous ancestors that they could emulate. Unfortunately, as we know,
the history of the early republic was rather bare.
Roman reformers would always cite
Tradition, and claimed to be going back to an earlier,
or truer, or more pure form of
what Rome was supposed to be.
So many of the battles over Rome
were not so much reform versus not reform, it was differing
interpretations of tradition,
and that's something that we will discuss later in this course.
The Romans believed that their greatness
was built on their foundations, but the question
then becomes, what were those foundations?
Because certainly the historical record
is not altogether clear about that.
If we look at Rome's early history, we see
that this traditional history in many ways is more of a mythology.
And one of the useful features of that,
which helped to speak to the concerns of the present,
was that this history slash mythology features a number of kings.
By the time that what you might call the definitive versions
of both the Greek and Roman tradition of Rome emerge,
Rome once again has reverted to monarchy under Augustus,
so suddenly the regal period, the
early period of Rome's history,
had regained a great deal of relevance after years of being
little more than a curiosity,
a time when Rome probably did some important things culturally,
but when ultimately the big takeaway was that monarchy was bad
because it impinged upon
upon the rights of the Senate.
So now things have come full circle in a way,
and it would be during this period, the period of Augustus,
when two of his contemporaries, Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Livy,
would write sort of the definitive,
if not altogether compatible, accounts of Rome's early history.
By the Augustan era, the early history of Rome was a subject
which had legitimate political stakes.
For the Romans, their early history explained
not only how the Romans had evolved, but also
what their standards should be,
since it really informed their sense of who they were and
what they valued.
It should come as no surprise, therefore,
that Augustus himself took quite a bit of
interest in the way that the early history of Rome was portrayed.
And, it should come as even less of a shock
that the history written by one of his close
associates, the historian Livy,
was more or less endorsed as the official history of Rome.
Odd how that works, huh?
From their all-important religious rites,
which the Romans believed helped to regulate
their relationships with the gods, and that in turn,
of course, determined whether they
succeeded or failed.
To their militarily dominant legions,
which of course by the age of Augustus were more or less at their peak.
To place names, some of which were buried in the distant past.
To the multi-tiered citizenship and class system that Rome had.
To the Senate and the various assemblies, the Romans had three of them.
The Romans saw all of their most important and powerful institutions
as having originated at some point in the deep past.
All of these things had greater significance,
and to fully appreciate them and contextualize
them, the Romans thought that you needed
to understand where they came from.
But the problem that historians working in both the Augustan
and in earlier periods had
was that Rome's early history had not been well recorded,
so really trying to get at
what was really there was a bit of a challenge.
The two accounts that we'll really look at in depth,
Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Livy,
became sort of the standard go-tos after the Augustan era,
but a lot of the fundamental
challenges that they faced haven't really changed all
that much, as we'll see.
Interestingly enough,
Livy wrote his history of Rome from the foundation of Rome all the
way until his own time, which would be about...
15 or so CE, that's about when he died,
so that would have been the latest possible date
that he could have written about.
He wrote 142 books in total,
and just for those of you who don't know, a book is approximately
a long chapter in modern terms,
but it corresponds with the amount that you could fit on a single
scroll, and if you were to translate an ancient book
of an author into English and then print
it in a modern book, we're talking about approximately 80 pages.
So, Livy wrote 142 books in total,
but he only needed one book to cover the entire period
from 753 to 509, the entirety of the Regal Period.
And then he spends quite a bit
of his time just talking about what earlier people had
said, and talking about earlier conflicting traditions about,
say, Ascanius and other
There are other figures who are sort of buried in obscurity and...
So, suffice it to say that despite the importance
of early Rome's history, this does not make
it any more abundant,
and even with the growth of a literature on early Rome, which clearly
happened before the time of Dionysius and Livy,
it still didn't amount to all that much
in the end.
Rome's early history was still shrouded in mist,
and I wish I could tell you that we're
That we're going to really clear the air and
Figure things out in a detailed fashion,
but that would be false advertising because such
an undertaking is, unfortunately, quite impossible.
Let's now preview the rest of this series.
Part 2 will cover Dionysius of Halicarnassus
and the Greek tradition of Rome.
For this, we're only going to be looking
at and analyzing the early portions of Book
1 of Dionysius' work.
Part 2 will look at Livy and the Roman tradition of Rome.
Looking at and considering the significance
of Book 1 of Ab Urba Candida.
Plutarch's life of Numa Pompilius will be our third part.
I considered doing Plutarch's life of Romulus, but in my opinion,
for reasons that I will explain at a later time,
I believe that Numa Pompilius is a more important cultural hero
and mythological figure for the Romans than Romulus himself.
And, we will conclude with an episode looking
at the modern scholarship of early Rome.
Due to the vast diversity of possible views on early Rome,
it will be by no means comprehensive,
but hopefully it will give you at least some indication
of what modern scholars working
in the field today think about the topic.