Does the average person need to lift in low-rep ranges? | Layne Norton and Peter Attia

Health Longevity
19 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 16, 2025
So for a person who, again, is not planning to go to a power meet, um,
is there a need for them to go below four
reps in training? I would say that's an arbitrary number,
but you know what I'm getting at? I would say probably not. I mean,
you can get plenty strong, uh, even doing, you know, sets of 10,
those sorts of things. Oh, that's interesting. I wouldn't.
So I would have thought you needed to get at least into the fives and sixes
So you can get really strong doing sets 10, 15, those sorts of things.
Now you will not be as strong even per cross-sectional area as
somebody who trains for strength, because strength is a specific skill.
And even like myself, um, you know,
my best squat ever is a six 68.
And when I was, you know,
six months out from that, it's not like I, uh, you know,
I added weight to the bar that I was able to squat,
but it's not like I added that much more lean body mass because I didn't, uh,
I was practicing the skill of a one rep max,
which allowed me to better do the one rep max.
And you were practicing at what percent of ultimately became six 61?
Usually around 90, 95. Um, but not very much at 95,
mostly at 90 for like singles.
And what was your RPE when you did those singles?
So usually about eight and a half or nine. Yeah.
So you would do multiple of that just doing the math.
Let's just say that's six 20 or something like that. Or yeah.
So let's say it's called 600 pounds.
So you would do a 600 pound signal three times in a workout.
Something like that. Okay. Yeah. And what you're,
what you're kind of making gains on at that point is just your one,
it just teaches you how to grind through a lift, uh,
because a lot of people have never had the experience of really sticking with a
lift. And interestingly, the more advanced somebody gets in terms of strength,
the slower their one rep max velocity will be. And we see this in, uh,
research studies all the time. Um, somebody who's kind of new will come in.
They will absolutely smoke a weight.
You put five pounds on and then they get stapled because it's just,
they don't have that grind capacity. They don't,
they don't know how to do it. And part of that may be psychological.
And part of that's probably physiological too.
In terms of you just haven't trained your body to recruit all the fibers
that it can get. So, you know,
lean body mass and strength are very closely tied together.
But when it gets to those finer levels of strength,
it's kind of just practicing the actual, you know,
one rep max. So when it comes to, uh, you know,
getting strong, you can absolutely get strong, you know,
doing sets 10, 15, because you're increasing your lean body mass.
Do you need to do sets of three, four? No.
But what I would say is like,
don't necessarily count them out because a lot of people actually just do
really well with variety. So, you know,
periodization was kind of a big thing for lifting back in the day.
And now we've kind of shown that at least in the research studies,
it doesn't appear to produce greater gains in lean body mass,
maybe a little bit better strength gains,
but that's probably just because people peak better when you're periodizing
things.
But what tends to actually be shown is that people just tend to like
periodization better because they're varying the repetitions.
They're not as bored, right?
So you never want to kind of poo poo the
psychological effects of those things. I talk about this with diet as well.
Uh, adherence is the most important thing,
just getting people to come in and do it.
So especially for people who are coming into the gym, you know, if they,
you know, if, if they're just trying to get stronger and be healthy,
well, for me, if I'm like talking to them or coaching them or whatever it is,
it's like, well, what do you enjoy?
What's going to get you to show up consistently, right? Oh, you don't,
you don't want a free squat. That's fine. Let's leg press. You know, there's,
there's many ways to skin a cat. Uh, you don't want to barbell deadlift. Okay,
no problem. Let's do some RDLs, you know, those sorts of things. Uh, you know,
slightly less technical lifts.
They're still going to produce really great gains in terms of strength,
lean body mass, those sorts of things.
So if you're not going to specifically compete in a strength sport,
there's so many paths to Rome in terms of getting stronger and increasingly
body mass. So do you think there were some principles, for example, like, um,
let's say a person isn't, um,
confident that they have the technical ability to execute a squat or a deadlift.
Let's look at a hip thruster. Again,
you can screw that up too and you could hurt yourself,
but it's a lot harder to hurt yourself doing that. Um,
do you think there is still an essential need for some sort of compound movement
like a hip thruster, at least as a compliment or a leg press, as you point out?
You know, it's, it's pretty funny.
Like I went through a phase where everything I learned from the magazines,
the bro science, I was like, well, this all has to be junk, you know?
And now we're actually having studies come out that are validating some of this
bro science from like 20, 30 years ago.
So there does appear to be like, uh, different areas of the leg muscles,
the quadriceps, for example, that are better activated by say a leg extension,
uh, compared to a leg press compared to a squat.
So I do think it is good to have variety.
I think it is good to have compound lifts as well. Um, and in fact,
there's some interesting data that suggests that you don't have to get as close
to failure on compound lifts to still get the same stimulation compared to
isolation exercises where you,
you do seem to have to get much closer to failure to get those benefits.
