Is Doug Ford trying to privatize Ontario’s health-care system? What if we told you Ontario, much like in the United States, already has private medicine — and lots of it. Yes, Canada has universal health care, but many services are already provided by private clinics. They’re just (often) covered by OHIP (looking at you, dental). Ford says his plan to expand such services to include cataract surgeries, MRI and CT scans, minimally invasive gynecological surgeries and, eventually, knee and hip replacements, will help ease the health-care system backlog. Many experts disagree, arguing that it will create two-tiered health care and lead to patients being upsold on unnecessary procedures — and may even mark the beginning of the end of universal health care. So, what actually is private health care? And how will it affect Ontarians? Will private health care actually reduce long wait times for procedures? How might for-profit clinics impact public health care? Join TVO Today’s Maria Sarrouh as she breaks down Doug Ford's plan for an increasingly-private health-care system.
Does Ontario need more private health care?
Ontario's health care system is in crisis.
The Doug Ford government has a controversial plan it says will alleviate some of the pressure.
But first, you should know this.
Ontario's health care system includes a mix of public and private hospitals and clinics.
In all these places, Ontarians can access a lot of free health care services if they have an OHIP card.
But other services might require private insurance.
Back to the plan.
In May, the provincial government passed Bill 60, known as the Your Health Act.
The bill will allow private, not-for-profit and for-profit clinics to conduct nearly 60,000 more OHIP-covered surgeries and scans.
That includes cataract surgeries, minimally invasive gynecological surgeries, as well as MRI and CT scans.
Eventually, the goal is to fold in knee and hip replacements.
The provincial government argues that this is a necessary step to help reduce the province's giant surgical backlog and long wait times.
But experts and advocates are split on the subject.
On one hand, supporters say Bill 60 will improve patient care.
In early 2022, 105,000 patients in Ontario were waiting longer than recommended for surgery.
That's a 123% increase compared to pre-pandemic levels.
Supporters of the bill argue that outsourcing some surgeries and diagnostics will only make the system more efficient.
And as long as these services are publicly covered by OHIP, Ontarians shouldn't let their fear of US-style privatization cloud their judgment.
Supporters also argue that the bill is just a modest expansion of how a lot of health care delivery in Ontario already works.
We have more than 900 independent health facilities, which are privately-owned clinics that deliver OHIP-insured services.
On the other hand, critics see Bill 60 as a fatal risk to Canada's universal health care.
Private, for-profit clinics could lure surgeons, doctors and nurses out of the public system, because for-profit clinics can sometimes pay them more.
That could mean even longer wait times at hospitals.
The Ford government says it'll require private clinics to submit staffing plans to avoid this.
But some doctors aren't convinced. They would rather see more funding directed to the public health care system.
Plus, data out of BC and Quebec suggests that surgeries at private, for-profit clinics actually cost governments and taxpayers more.
Critics say that private, for-profit clinics could also upsell patients by recommending medically unnecessary services or upgrades that aren't covered by public insurance.
The provincial government says that Bill 60 includes safeguards to prevent patients from paying out of pocket.
But the concern is that private, for-profit clinics aren't monitored or policed enough to ensure they'll follow the rules.
So, what do you think?
If you enjoyed this video, push the like button, subscribe and click all around me to watch more helpful explainers.
I'll see you all in the next video. Bye!