Does Lord of the Rings have Chess?
3 Video Views·Feb 24, 2024
The Lord of the Rings is a "Mythical Prehistory" of Europe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WsquosVZeZo
*Note: Some might point out the existence of tafl games (sometimes called Viking chess), but I think Gandalf's mention of "pawns" leads us away from that conclusion and toward the standard European chess.
Check out my books (affiliate links)
King of Camelot (novel): https://amzn.to/3w1bvjs
Sunny and the Red King (children's book): https://amzn.to/3up3ft5
the people of Middle Earth had a lot of
fun hobbies hiking mountains slogging
through marshes fighting Orcs running
away from dragons you know a lot of good
cardio but what if they just want to sit
down and play a board game did they have
chess the answer is yes but it probably
wasn't like our modernday chess just a
warning this video is going to get into
the details of tolken material so if
you're not interested you can skip to
this timestamp okay moving on let's
start with some quotes from Return of
the King Gandalf and Pippen are in Min
tith talking about Sauron and the war
Gandalf says the board is set the pieces
are moving but the enemy has the move
and he is about to open his full game
and pawns are likely to see as much of
it as any later on Pippen is thinking
and talking to himself and he says a
pawn did Gandalf say perhaps but on the
wrong chessboard so that's it those are
all the clues we get but it probably
wasn't like our modern-day version it
was very likely an older version of
Chess we're going to explore two points
we're going to talk about one the
culture and Technology of middlee is
roughly equivalent to Europe around
1,000 ad and then we're going to talk
about the state of Chess in Europe
around 1 AD and we're going to map those
two timelines together to arrive at what
chess was probably like for the first
point I'm building on the material of a
previous video that points out that
Middle Earth is intended to be a
mythical prehistory of Europe let's
unpack the cultural thing the cultures
of Middle Earth have stups and chain
mail which were started being used in
Europe around the 6th Century but Middle
Earth doesn't have the printing press
which was introduced to Europe around
the 15th century other Clues such as the
lack of plate armor lead us to believe
that culturally and technologically
Middle Earth occurs roughly 1,000 ad in
Europe Point number two let's talk about
chess chess was imported from Arabia to
Europe around the 9th century Arabian
chest looked like this it had 64 squares
32 pieces each player had eight soldiers
two Rooks two horses two elephants one
counselor and one King the soldiers
would move one square forward capture
diagonally and they promoted to a
counselor when they reached the end of
the board Rooks would move horizontally
and vertically any amount of squares
horses would move in an l-shape
elephants jumped two squares diagonally
counselor would move one square
diagonally and a king would move one
square in any direction when chess moved
into Europe Europeans made a few changes
soldiers became pawns horses became
Knights elephants became Bishops and the
counselor became a queen but all the
moves stayed the same all the pieces
moved the same way Europeans also
checkered the board which made things a
lot easier so this is how chess was
played around 1,00 ad in Europe it was
in the 15th century in Spain that we get
a lot of the modern rules that we're
familiar with pawns can move two squares
on the first move pawns can capture on
pant we have castling Queens could move
in every direction and Bishop could move
freely along the diagonals but those
rules happened after the printing press
so that's way outside of the time frame
that we're looking at also the Sten
chest design which everyone uses today
was designed in the 19th century in
Spain so that's also outside of our time
frame but that's an interesting question
what would chest sets look like in
Middle Earth our best clue would be the
aisle of Lewis chess set these chess
pieces were discovered in a grave on the
aisle of Lewis just off the coast of of
Scotland and date back to around the
12th century so that's pretty close to
1,000 ad well it's a lot closer than the
ston chess design but there is one
problem European chess has Bishops and
Middle Earth definitely does not have
Bishops so what could we use instead of
Bishops well if you remember Arabian
chess had elephants Middle Earth has
elephants they're called olifants so
there we go we have olifants instead of
Bishops okay to wrap it all up here's my
best speculation on what chess in Middle
Earth would look like and play like it
would have these pieces that moved this
way it would have a checkered board like
this and the pieces would have this kind
of aesthetic now I'm sure that the
different cultures in Middle Earth would
design chest sets according to their
preferences but you know this is this
video gives us a place to start and
here's something that I would love I
would love to see people design a chess
set based upon these rules and these
pieces and make a video and send it to
me I would love to see that also if you
want to play chess I will not back down
from that challenge okay that's all I
have for you today hit the button hit
the Bell catch you
later

