Do you realize what happens to Trump in 2028?

The Daily Report
5 followers
4 Video Views·Nov 15, 2026
Sarah Longwell, Republican strategist, publisher of The Bulwark, and author of the new book How to Eat an Elephant: One Voter at a Time, joins us to discuss the midterm results, what her focus groups of swing voters are saying, and where Trump and the Republican Party go from here
🤝 Become a Member: https://www.davidpakman.com/membership
Donald Trump has so hollowed out the Republican Party,
it is such a cult of personality, that
there's not an obvious person to take the mantle,
which means that Democrats, I think,
now have a historic opportunity to do a root
and branch operation on MAGA, in which they
burn it to the ground
and salt the earth with its ashes, and it is forced.
To reconstitute in some way today,
I'll be speaking with Sarah Longwell.
Sarah Longwell is a political strategist
and publisher of The Bulwark, also author of the
book How to Eat an Elephant One Voter at a Time.
Sarah, good to see you.
Thanks for your time.
Hey, man.
It's great to be here.
How are you?
I'm you know, I'm good.
It's a very interesting time
because we had these election results last week.
It is not yet the period where the new Congress has been sworn in.
We already had, you know,
the Hegseth impeachment situation yesterday and a letter threatening
Democrats that their oversight, if they go too far, may be criminal.
I was reading about that today.
What do you know?
You've done focus groups.
You've talked to voters
and sort of attempted to understand their motivations.
Can we really chalk up these election results
to voters basically see these first two years
of the second Trump term as a screw up
and they've decided to punish Republicans for
that?
Like, is it is that the core of what we saw?
100 percent. Yeah, they blame Trump. And listen,
I've been doing focus groups sort of like a maniac since the election,
just and really talking to Republican voters, Trump voters
who voted for Democrats in the midterms, because I want to know why.
And look, I was obviously doing focus groups the whole time going
into the election. So I heard people say over
and over again how upset they were about prices, how upset they
were about the war in Iran, how upset they were about Trump.
breaking his promises. There's a lot of that.
There's a lot of I was told he was going to lower
prices. I was told he was going to end the war, not start wars.
I was told he was going to be
transparent or release the Epstein files.
I was told he was going to drain the swamp and instead
he's super corrupt. Like the.
The voters that I'm talking to now who voted for Democrats,
basically a lot of them are saying I wanted a check on this ---- show.
And that is a quote, like the ---- show part is a quote.
There's just a lot of people who are like, it has been awful.
The economy's been terrible. I wanted a check and many of them.
And especially since these are people who voted for Trump in the past,
you know, they're skeptical that Democrats are going
to do things that they like affirmatively.
But right now they are happy with the idea that Democrats could
slow Trump down because they see his Congress is not doing that.
Thank
And I also think, though,
they're just like whoever can do something about prices meaningfully.
There's a lot of people who are like,
you
I've never even voted for a Democrat before, but
it's gotten so bad that I'm giving them a chance.
They deserve a chance now.
for
What is the value qualitatively
of a focus group where you speak to a small number of
that.
people?
In a country of 340 million,
one might reasonably think you need a proper poll with 1,200 people
Adjusted for the sample
to really glean anything big about what's going on rather
than talking to 15 people qualitatively about their views.
What is it about these focus groups that is valuable
in terms of telling us what's happening
in the country?
Well, first of all, I'm not sure we need another poll.
There's like, there's a lot, other people can poll.
There's plenty of pollsters and there's
so many pollsters that now there's a whole, you
know, a bunch of organizations that are forecasters
that aggregate the polls, like that stuff's
taken care of.
Yep.
They will tell you the what, okay, what, what,
uh, what is the number of Republicans who
think Trump, who disapprove of Trump?
Great.
I want to answer the why.
Why do they disapprove of Trump?
And when I do a focus, and also, first of all,
just the scale at which I do focus groups
is, I think, different than most people.
You know, when you introduced me, you said consultant.
And I guess for a long time, I was that.
Now.
I will now mostly I do podcast. I do the focus groups.
I don't do them for clients. I do them
because I believe that people should hear the voices of Americans
and how they sound and what
they care about. And so I I started doing focus groups
because I was thinking about a specific
thing. I was thinking about how do we primary Trump
in the early days of Trump being elected
And me thinking about how do we save the Republican Party?
I mean.
The evolution over the 10 years was, number one, listening to voters
and focus groups was how I learned that actually they did want Trump
and that saving the Republican Party increasingly looked like something
that couldn't be done because voters wanted,
they didn't want the Republican Party of Mitt Romney or John McCain.
They just didn't. And then more to the point, after January 6th,
it became very clear that this was not a party
to salvage there was like this thing had to be burned to the ground uh
and then over time
perhaps something healthier can emerge uh
from the ashes of that but that's going to be like
a generational project um but so the reason
that i do focus groups is one i i found them so
helpful to me to understand what was going on in the country.
And I feel like the whole
punditry sort of world sits around
and debates with each other without listening to the people
who are ultimately going to make those decisions.
And it's not even that, like,
I still hold Sarah Longwell's opinions and like policy preferences.
But the majority of the time, I'm actually thinking in terms of,
man, it is so clear to me what voters want on this.
Voters are being so. And so I do multiple focus groups a week
and also like different kinds of voters.
When somebody says voters think this,
I'm always like, well, some voters do.
Some voters believe basically anything.
Some voters believe that the earth is flat.
But.
What are the majority of voters thinking?
What are the through lines in their narratives?
What are the ways that human beings in America talk about things
that lead you to understand what they might want in terms of policies?
And that's why so many of the conversations we have,
I'm always like, that's like a little bit true. Like
when people say voters don't care about policy, I'll be like, well.
Kind of. It's that they don't maybe care about
the actual bespoke policies. So take New York
and Momdani. It's not that they're not like,
oh, he didn't make all the grocery stores,
you know, government run. Nobody cares.
That he didn't do that, but what they cared about,
they did care that he was somebody
who had a bunch of ideas that directionally were about affordability
and being able to afford living in New York City.
So they care about the policy of being able to afford to live
in New York City and a bunch of the policies underlying that.
But the individual, like what actually happens,
they're less invested in.
You mentioned what Sarah Longwell thinks
and policy preferences and this sort
of thing.
Where are you politically right now?
Because you know, I think on one sense I see
the events you do and you know, it's you Tim
and JVL and Pete Buttigieg is there
and clearly you're on the pro democracy side loosely I
would say, but like I've spoken to Sarah Matthews about this as well.
Are you a Republican still in your in your preferences?
Would you like the 2028 presidential election
to result in a Republican that you like being
the next president?
I know you've talked about John Ossoff,
like have your politics changed at this point?
And I'll also add, you know, I've seen a couple
of these articles that are kind of like the
The Bulwark are.
Wolves in sheep's clothing.
And you got to remember that these are at the core Republicans
at the you know, I'm sure you've seen those articles as well.
Like, where are your politics
right now?
Yeah. I mean, first of all,
I would describe myself as a liberal, meaning somebody who
believes in liberal democracy.
And so you want to call me a lib as everybody on the right now does.
I mean, it is funny to be us sometimes
because if you're on Twitter or you just like follow the
discourse, Republicans think we are downright DSA socialists
and the DSA socialists think we
are conservative Republicans.
And so at some point you're like, actually, guys, I'm kind of a normie
Tell me, Lib.
I've almost become burnt out on ideological...
Um, like, like being a super ideologue, uh,
in part because look, I came up through the
conservative world
and there's a lot of things that I still think are true that I believed
before.
I believe that the national debt is an existential threat to America,
um, and our ability to
do big things and invest in our country.
I think the amount of interest we're paying
on the debt, um, is a huge problem.
Uh, that was like one of the things that animated me
as a conservative to be, to be sort of
a budget and deficit hawk. I'm still that person.
I think that an America at its best, which is not us at the moment,
should play a role in the world and making the world safer.
That doesn't mean nation building. It doesn't have to mean,
you know, for adventurism abroad in terms of wars.
But the idea that we are stalwarts for.
democracy and want to see democracy thrive around the globe,
don't want to see people
invading each other, like want to be a good guy,
not a cop, but a good guy on the world stage
is still something that I believe.
I believe in pluralism as, and I've always been,
I'm a big believer in immigration.
So it's actually, this is funny. I actually preach.
The voters want to close the border.
The voters, 100%.
And I don't just mean Republican voters.
I mean independent voters.
I mean a lot of center-left voters.
I believe that as a practical matter. But I think we should.
We are a country. Our entire existence is based on people coming here
because they want to be an American.
I believe an American can be born anywhere. And if you have freedom
in your heart and you want the American experience, there should
be a way that is relatively easy for you to come here and build a life.
Like I find blood and soil nationalism,
which has overtaken the Republican Party, to be.
Not just sort of like a virus, but also a complete and total
misunderstanding of what the American experiment is all about.
And so my politics, I think, has always been sort of norm.
It was always normie center right
and has moved to a kind of normie center left.
If you had to put me on a policy scale, but I was always pro-choice.
But in a safe, legal and rare kind of way, not as a form
of birth control, like, I don't know, we could go through the issues.
I grew up in central Pennsylvania,
and so I'm very comfortable around hunting and guns. At the same time,
I think that these like high capacity magazines and that like
that you can just walk into a Walmart and get them is pretty insane.
I actually think I embody a kind of,
people talk about corporate centrism, and I'm like,
actually, what I think I am is a pretty...
Close to the way a lot of average Americans think about politics,
which is, I think that people.
who need a hand up should be able to get it.
At the same time, I don't think that the American
government should be subsidizing everything for everybody.
But I also believe in a really
strong public education system
because I think that's to the national good. I think that's one
of the things that our government should
be very focused on providing all Americans at an
exceptional level of quality.
I think that we should have a social safety net around health
care. But if we're going to offer
a social safety net around health care, we also have to be we're
We're going to have to be judicious about who comes into the.
the country and gets access to that and what like,
I don't know, I feel like I'm a pretty
normie lib.
One of the things you didn't mention there,
and I wonder whether it rates for you, but
also for some of the people you talk
to that seems to have moved the line for a lot of
maybe center right voters is there was a long period
of time where the Republican Party
would clearly identify that these authoritarians,
autocrats and dictators around the world.
Are to be opposed.
In other words, they are not our friends.
And all of a sudden now
and I actually spoke with President Biden about this recently.
All of a sudden now you've got Trump kind
of paying lip service to the authoritarians.
He's impressed with Putin.
He's impressed with Xi's 100 percent conviction rate
on drug cases and all of this sort of
stuff.
And it seems that for folks maybe where you grew up
on the political spectrum, that has
had a role or played a role in shifting your view.
I mean, it's one of the reasons that I've rejected Trump from the jump.
Like, one of the reasons I wasn't on board with him,
like, 2015, 2016, and I was like,
we've got to fight this with everything we have,
is I was like, this guy both admires
dictators and wants to be one himself.
And that was very clear.
So it's very clear to me he didn't love America.
Thank
And I do think that our leaders should love America
and want America to be a best version
of itself.
And that is not what he represented.
But when I said, I think America should be.
A good guy in the world. This is what I mean.
We don't buddy up with dictators.
We don't take the side of Xi and Putin and Kim Jong-un.
you.
Like we recognize maybe that sometimes that we have
to deal with them as world leaders, but we treat them.
I think with the correct level of either,
if not outright adversarial, at least with
a healthy skepticism that is very clear about
the fact that their values and our values
are not the same and in fact are often in conflict,
which doesn't mean we have to be
in a hot war with them, but it does mean
that we should be clearly articulating what our
values are, which Trump does not do.
And at its core, this is why when some people are like,
oh, Trump's just about mean tweets.
I'm like, well, you don't understand anything.
About what he has actually done to the values
of this country that were the ones that I held most dear.
And I'll just say one other thing.
I'm like the people who are like, oh, the bulwark,
this or that with the Republicans, sort of like who, who cares?
I see people who say things like.
You don't get to be in this party or that party.
I'm like, there's no party police, guys.
Like, there's just microphones and people
and audiences and communities.
And we're all talking.
And this has been America as long as America has been around.
And there's no gatekeepers here.
If people have an interest, and we do as Americans,
of how we would like to see the country evolve,
And we put ourselves on the stage to say,
This is what I think should happen,
or even for me now, it's a lot of, here's what I feel,
here's what I hear from voters about what they want to happen,
and what are the ways in which
American politics can evolve to sort of help people better,
because we are failing people,
and it is leading us into...
Flirting with and occasionally veering
into a kind of populist authoritarianism.
And so I want to solve that by hearing what voters are saying
so that we can improve their lives
so that they don't feel like they have to reach for some
of these things that are sort of really detrimental to who America is.
What's your sense of the role
that the anti-corruption story might play in this, especially looking
to 2028?
And I'll kind of couch it in this sense.
There are a lot of folks arguing that an anti-corruption sort
of platform would be more than anything
Anything else the way that Democrats can get.
Uh, center right leaning independents
and maybe even some Republicans to join them
by making really clear, like we're going
to deal with, with the corruption.
And then there's another view, which is, yeah,
that might work if you can really tightly
link the corruption to how people's lives day
to day are being affected.
But broadly and philosophically,
corruption is still a little bit distant from the day
to day concerns of voters.
What's your sense of that?
My sense is that the thing with voters
is that they think both sides are corrupt.
And Trump has done it at such a scale, though,
that it's sort of shaken people out of their
both sides-ism and to be like, this is.
horrible. It's also the contrast is really important
for voters. Trump is making all of
his friends rich while I get poorer.
A lot of it's too about like, what is Trump focused on?
What is he not focused on? Who is benefiting from Trump?
Like, hey, you were supposed to help us.
The promise of America first was you were going
to have your eyes on the American people. You
don't. It's your rich buddies. It's the tech bros.
It's the data center guys who are like
Like in our communities now, like that.
That's a big part of what is happening for voters.
I do think we should do something about corruption
because just doing something about corruption
is good on its face.
We should not live in a banana republic patronage country.
That is, again, anathema to who we are as Americans.
I do think one of the ways that Democrats
can square the circle overall is to make,
is to take where, the reason that it is an opportune time
is because Republicans are going, oh no.
We've made a huge mistake.
Democrats are about to be in a governing reign for a period of time
because the level of
the wins in the Senate and the House mean
that Republicans are going to have to chip
away at those majorities that, you know,
now they are not just something that one cycle
can likely correct.
And so and also, you know,
there's a lot of fears on the Republican side that Donald
Trump will now be an albatross around any candidate's neck.
Going forward and the Democrats have this new crop
of exciting sort of young candidates.
And so if Democrats are about to be ascendant, Republicans are like,
oh, now might be a good time for us to rein in corruption,
executive overreach, executive power.
And so Democrats have an opportunity by by saying we're going
to root out corruption across both parties.
Like it can't look retributive. It can't look like vengeance.
It has to be.
Our country has gotten too corrupt.
Some of Trump's messaging around that was correct.
He just was using it as a way for him to be more corrupt.
But like, we're gonna address it sincerely
and we're gonna do span stock trading.
Stock trading, it's funny,
isn't actually like the most important thing,
but it's one that's landed with voters.
And so do that.
Do the things that try to make our government
less of a revolving door.
Like, let's just do those things.
Sarah, last thing I want to ask you about,
you said Trump is done as kingmaker, especially
as we think to twenty twenty eight.
Who has the possibility of becoming the next Republican kingmaker?
Or is it not really a role that in an open primary like
the one that is going to be coming
up for both parties you necessarily need?
So here's what's happening right now.
Yeah.
Right now.
And Tucker Carlson
and Don Jr. are trying to form a triumvirate of evil, in my opinion,
and figure out how they can take their ill-gotten gains
and their access to the presidency right now.
They are starting to, including Don Jr.
People, I think, think Don Jr. wouldn't do this.
And then I would like to just remind you
guys, this is like the Trump family.
These are not.
People who are, you know, bound by love and loyalty.
Thank
He's looking for a way to be a player in the future.
Thank
And they're all together, and they do have sort of a vision,
a, like, real America first has never been tried,
you
we will have to throw old man Trump under the bus to do this,
so
but they are trying to grab the mantle right now,
and that is the both blood and soil nationalism wing of the party,
much.
you.
it is the America alone on the world stage,
but, like, that's why J.D. Vance is saying,
They want to cut off aid to Israel.
They want to, you know, end the war in Iran
because that's the part of the base
they are trying to consolidate.
And they would like to make the party reflect that.
So I think they want to be the future.
And that America first wing,
and that would include sort of a Marjorie Taylor Greene too,
is going to be in some battle
with what I call the MAGA establishment,
which is your Marco Rubio's, your Ron DeSantis,
people who basically...
You know, they've made their peace with Trump and now, but they have
a little bit of fusion with some of the old Republican Party values,
although to me, frankly, it's not the ones that were the most,
the most, not the ones that drew me to the Republican Party.
Yeah, I mean, look, the reason I wrote the book,
just to end on that, is because I do
think there is a genera...
hollowed out the Republican Party.
It is such a cult of personality that there's not an obvious
person to take the mantle, which means that Democrats,
I think, now have a historic
opportunity to do a root and branch operation
on MAGA in which they like burn it to the ground and
salt the earth with its ashes.
And it is forced to reconstitute in some way. I'm not bullish,
though, on its prospects for the thing that emerges.
Being a healthy political party,
I think it is going to be more of this blood and soil
nationalism.
I think it's going to take some of the worst elements of Trump ism
and fuse it together
with this populist.
Well, it's going to be this populist authoritarianism,
blood and soil nationalism stuff just without
Trump's.
I don't want to call it charisma, but like without no,
but it is a sort of charisma that
appeals to some people.
Yeah.
So that's where I think it's all headed.
But I think that Democrats look, I don't know about you,
man, but I smell hope and opportunity.
And I want America like for me, and this is, again, I'm just gonna
go back to the question you asked about the bulwark and the left.
I think our political projects are fundamentally different.
And I think it leads us to not being we
are like overlapping allies at times.
And, but perhaps not, but I'm
not sure we have a shared political project.
Like their shared political project is driven by the,
like their feelings on a lot of different
kinds of policies.
Mine are about can liberal democracy,
can American liberal democracy survive and also
have a renaissance and a reemergence after we watched.
Our institutions and norms and values get tested
and be found wanting in a lot of ways.
Right. I don't want to go back to anything.
But I think the question is, if Trump's going
to burn it all down, what are we going to build?
What does an America look like that is still committed
to pluralism and the rule of law?
Like, those are what I'm focused on.
And so it just doesn't always leave us focused on the same things.
Well, we are going to be watching it together.
That's for sure.
And we've been speaking to Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark.
The book is How to Eat an Elephant One Voter at a Time,
a book that pushed my book down
one slot on The New York Times list, I must say.
Very nasty.
Your book is great, man.
Everybody should go get your book.
Thank you.
I appreciate it.
And your book is phenomenal.
Also, really good to talk to you.
I know you're busy.
Really appreciate your time.
Oh, thanks, man.
Great talking to you.
