Detailed analysis of LeBron James at his best - Greatest Peaks Ep. 13

First Athletic
21 followers
11 Video Views·Oct 27, 2022
The hardest thing to figure out about LeBron James at his peak
might just be when exactly he peaked.
LeBron hit another gear in the 2009 season, winning his first MVP
and authoring one of the most incredible statistical profiles in NBA history.
At 24, he had the perfect blend of youthful speed and explosive power.
And in his second tour of Northeast Ohio,
LeBron's offensive mastery produced incredible playoff moments.
And those seasons are great choices.
But during those championship seasons in South Beach,
his ability to do almost everything might have taken him to heights
that no one has ever reached.
This series tackles one question.
Who was the best at his best?
We start at the NBA merger and go through the best multi-year stretches
examining the legends who provided the most on-court impact.
These are the greatest peaks.
For me, it could be compared to Michael, Magic, you know, Kobe,
all the ones that's making so success in the league.
You know, it's great and I'm just keep working hard and
someday it could be another one that could be compared to me.
From a distance, LeBron just looked bigger and stronger than other players.
But zoom in and there's way more going on.
During those Miami years, his game was built around getting to the rim
and he approached the basket in just about every way imaginable.
He drops his shoulder, goes off his left foot, and finishes southpaw here.
But on this one, he dips the shoulder and jumps off two feet
to float one in from short range.
Here's another variant.
He has a runway but springs into a jump stop
and fluid, adaptable athleticism was key to LeBron's finishing prowess.
Of course, his size was a huge factor too, crossing back to the left
and notice how quickly the ball gets to about 10 feet
so he can release it away from those long Tim Duncan arms.
LeBron's mass was arguably more important than his length,
able to plow through contact from defenders.
Jimmy Butler gives LeBron a pretty healthy push here
and unlike lanky or penetrators, it barely derailed the L-train
and he still has the balance to explode for the stuff.
LeBron was probably the best ever at absorbing blows in midair
while still powering up a good shot,
which requires incredible body awareness and reactivity.
These reactions are automatic subconscious movements.
This contact blunts his vertical leap
so he adjusts by pulling the ball back and arching it over the defender.
This is unprecedented neurological wiring in such a giant explosive body.
Here, he has the instinct to dip his shoulder in front of the defender
who bounces off LeBron as he organically twists into a layup.
Some of this is just physics.
A 275-pound body moving at high speeds packs quite a punch.
Paul George goes flying here
and again LeBron adjusts off his right leg and finishes with the left hand.
And yes, it was reported that James weighed in at 270-something pounds during these seasons,
slightly heavier than the 250-260 he supposedly played at in Cleveland a few years prior
and that zapped some of his acceleration.
In 2009, his first step was quicker
and his combination of speed and power were at video game levels.
If we're submitting entries into the all-time highlight competition,
this first MVP year is the version to nominate.
But that additional explosiveness was offset by a weaker outside shot,
a game that wasn't quite as refined,
and somewhat paradoxically,
he wasn't a definitively better finisher on his drives back then.
This is because he developed so many ways to finish at the cup,
from contorting reverses to little spin moves that finished with a soft push shot.
LeBron was a master of tempo, of controlling speeds.
Take this drive into Duncan where slowing down is the key to creating space for a gentle finish.
Despite weighing more than Karl Malone,
his agility and explosiveness were still guard-like,
and with a screen he was surgical,
attacking the position of the second defender.
He leans the wrong way here,
so LeBron rejects the screen and explodes in a straight line.
Yet on this one he feels the defender too far left,
so he builds momentum going around the pick,
and then he's an unstoppable freight train,
and that is just bionic strength and dexterity that would make Isaac Asimov proud.
Oh yeah.
There were more subtle tricks too.
He knows Duncan waits to commit to a shot,
so he upfakes on an explosive jump stop before stepping through for the layup.
All of this made LeBron one of the best finishers ever.
Among qualifying players,
he has the highest field goal percentage season at the rim this century,
and since he maintained comparable efficiencies in the playoffs,
there's a great argument these are the best finishing seasons ever.
These superpowers were only amplified in transition,
where he could build ahead of steam and attack into open space.
He just shed smaller players like they were mosquitoes.
This is the android upgrade of what we saw in episode 5 from Magic Johnson,
out sprinting everyone and changing directions at high speeds while completely under control.
Size and speed are one thing,
but LeBron's ability to decelerate,
remain controlled,
and flow into a move supercharged his fast break scoring.
He could use those same half-court tools,
change of tempo,
varied jumping angles,
and so on,
only with ahead of steam against backpedaling defenses.
Even with big men in the paint,
LeBron could shift on the fly.
He's angling toward the middle here,
but then slides left for two.
And there is a cerebral component to many of these.
He throws a head fake to freeze a defender,
and he's unstoppable with all that space to attack.
Bron did this stuff to great defenders too.
Andre Iguodala's hips are facing left here,
so LeBron goes right,
then Andre recovers so he gives him an inside out for the full spin cycle.
In real time, the whole thing is a blur,
and it's free throws.
It was basically impossible to slow down James in transition,
running alongside him or recovering to the paint,
because of his width and change of direction.
Here the defender is basically even with him,
but since he's so much smaller,
he's essentially poster decoration.
In short,
And 2012-13 is the best two-year stretch in Synergy's database,
averaging an insane 1.4 points per possession in transition
on over four opportunities a game,
numbers he nearly replicated to a T in the postseason.
The totality of all this made LeBron one of the best scorers ever,
with his playoff runs in Miami stacking up incredibly well
against just about anybody in league history
when adjusting for opponent quality.
Another key to LeBron's scoring during these years
was the development of his post-game.
These plays weren't nearly as deadly as his transition game or half-court drives,
but adding some back-to-the-basket skills
kept defenses honest and gave him another arrow in his quiver.
He often caught it in the mid-post and went to work,
backing down smaller wings,
and with his size advantage and great balance,
he could wheel in two shots down low or bust out that spin move that he loved.
There's a Tim Duncan-esque use of the offhand
to protect the ball against Kawhi Leonard.
We often think of great scorers as having pretty fadeaways or nasty go-to moves,
but LeBron's physical dominance and fantastic feel
carved out hyper-efficient shots,
and he balanced those shots with a respectable outside game.
This was a shift from his younger years,
where he was near the bottom of the league in outside shooting percentages,
but in Miami, he jumped above league average on his long-range shots.
Behind a slightly smoother shooting motion,
LeBron was more patient getting into his jumper,
and as a result, he made about 42% of his long twos in Miami,
a step up from the 39% he made in his final two years in Cleveland.
He also improved by more than three percentage points from downtown,
after making only 34% of his threes between 2009 and 2011.
So, during these seasons, LeBron's outside shot rounded out his incredible scoring game,
but that was only half of his offensive equation,
because his playmaking talents helped take him to another level.
Because LeBron was so effective driving to the hoop,
defenses would counter by packing the paint,
forcing him to beat them with his jumper.
Dallas did this to some degree in the 2011 finals,
not overreacting to him as a shooter,
and then loading up on his drives.
Tyson Chandler spies James instead of worrying about the weak side,
and so two big men are waiting for him in the paint.
When the Mavericks clogged these driving lanes like this,
they were content with Mario Chalmers or Dwayne Wade beating them with outside shots.
There was more to LeBron's huge scoring drop-off in that series than just Dallas' defense,
but two years later, a fantastic Spurs team packed the paint again,
and made LeBron's driving gaps as narrow as possible.
It was common for multiple Spurs players to converge on him in the lane,
and this strategy limited LeBron's effectiveness
more than any other series between 2012 and 2014,
although that improved jumper still made it a solid scoring series for James.
And this is where a more diverse scoring arsenal made him so difficult to slow down,
not only with outside shots, but by playing out of the post.
Post play provided a different angle to attack from,
defenses couldn't really load up on any driving lanes in these spots,
and because LeBron was such a gifted passer, it made doubling him down there a bit tricky.
If teams weren't careful, a double team could create short, easy kickouts to three-point shooters,
and a huge part of LeBron's offensive value was unlocking long-range marksmen out on the perimeter.
With the Spurs clogging the lane, LeBron sets up a rim finish but it's really a pass,
and crafty deliveries like this gave shooters optimal breathing room.
If he didn't throw it early, he had the strength to skip it across the court
where it was a longer recovery for the defense.
That's just incredible speed from that position to beat the closeout.
James might have been the best skip passer the league had ever seen,
swinging it cross-court to his bandmates,
and when teams try to sit in his driving gaps, changing sides like this is a natural counter.
Of course, LeBron also manipulated defenders,
there's no indication he's passing as he turns the corner here,
and the look-away prevents this defender from playing the passing lane, and it's a clean shot.
He could hit these same passes in transition against a wall of defenders,
the velocity on that one buys the shooter more time,
and again he uses his drive to disguise a delivery.
That move sent Kevin Garnett in the wrong direction, giving Mario Chalmers all day to shoot.
That driving pressure and a powerful dribble took him right into the teeth of the defense,
where he could spray it around to wide-open shooters.
Miami shot 38% from downtown, with LeBron on the court in his final three seasons there,
surrounding him with better three-point weapons, and going to smaller, stretchier lineups.
Unfortunately, their second-best player, Dwayne Wade,
was a poor three-point shooter, which wasn't an ideal fit next to James.
Wade was coming off one of the great peaks in league history himself,
and in many ways was functionally similar to LeBron.
He was a dangerous finisher, and difficult to keep out of the lane,
and he could spearhead an entire offense with a pick-and-roll game as well.
In effect, this made him LeBron's backup,
because the Heat could flank James or Wade with identical lineups.
But, since neither of them were really good spot-up shooters,
on possessions initiated by Wade, LeBron was less valuable standing in the corner.
A good shooter just ends up with a high percentage three there instead.
Even though Wade-centric possessions were perfectly effective,
Miami's best offense was LeBron ball,
giving him the keys and letting him make the primary decisions.
Miami actually excelled when James played without his sidekick,
logging over 40 games without Wade during these seasons at a 57-win pace.
With Wade, they were only a touch better, reaching a 59-win pace,
and most notably, the Heat's offensive efficiency was slightly better without Dwayne.
That Heat offense was good in the regular season and fantastic in the playoffs,
a pattern that has held for LeBron's entire prime,
which is a testament to his scoring and playmaking ability.
Making him the centerpiece of a heliocentric system,
with the right finishers orbiting around him,
produced historically good offense because of his decision-making.
For instance, take this pop quiz.
Where's the optimal pass?
Congratulations if you found it,
because the Thunder were blindsided by that pass, and for good reason.
We've seen him snap it to this corner if the strong side defender slides over,
and if he feels the weak side defender leaning toward the role man,
he could fire it to the other wing for more target practice.
Some of these require elite reflexes, snapping off passes when an opening emerges,
and here the role man pops away from the hoop,
and as LeBron looks for him,
it takes a millisecond before he processes the cut to the basket and delivers a laser.
Great passers not only deliver balls quickly,
but the camouflage releases from a variety of angles.
So when LeBron touched the paint,
defenses had little indication of what was coming.
A kickout to a shooter, a drop-off to a big man, or a score.
They basically all look the same until the moment the ball leaves his hands,
and he usually chose the best option.
All of this takes great spatial awareness,
tracking multiple defenders so when one moves, he knows exactly where to attack.
This one takes some grandmaster recognition,
eyeing an angle with Tim Duncan's hands down,
and throwing a rope the second his receiver gets inside position.
Like all high-end passers,
LeBron would try some into-tight coverage that didn't pan out,
and I think his vision and reads improved in later seasons.
He almost never missed straightforward layups like this one,
but he could overlook some slightly trickier hookups.
That's there for the taking,
and we've seen post players hit this cutter a number of times during this series.
He also wasn't regularly tossing this lob pass to the role man back then
like he would in subsequent years,
and sometimes his bounce passes could be a bit tough to handle for his big men.
Still, that vision and quick processing led to some spectacular passes in dynamic situations,
chugging down the court here for a lob,
and then yes, that is exactly what you think,
a touch pass where he leaves the ball hanging right in front of the rim.
Between his visual processing and that fluid athleticism,
there were moments where he was almost bird-like with some passes,
able to anticipate openings and then snap off high-value dimes.
In transition, he was a little magic-like,
pushing the pace with speed and forcing defenses to commit so he could drop it off.
This is a three-man wall in the lane to barricade his penetration,
and that leads to wide-open threes,
and here OKC forms a wall at an angle,
which creates an alley that LeBron quickly spots for free throws.
You might have noticed how many of these assists were to Wade.
He and LeBron had really nice chemistry on cuts to the basket,
and while Flash was still a great offensive player in those seasons,
the more he receded into a secondary role, the better LeBron's numbers became.
His shot creation estimates with Wade in the game
were in the 93rd percentile historically in the playoffs,
but with Wade on the bench, they would have ranked 8th all-time,
almost perfectly matching his earlier numbers in Cleveland.
His free throw rates with Wade dipped to the 93rd percentile,
but without him they would have ranked 7th all-time,
again fairly close to his numbers as a Cav.
So as a result, LeBron's scoring went to another stratosphere in those playoffs
with his Slash brother on the bench,
surpassing even Michael Jordan
with what would be the best adjusted numbers in playoff history.
That's not entirely apples-to-apples comparison,
but it's part of why the Heat offense was more efficient
playing a larger brand of LeBron ball.
So while LeBron was the centerpiece of an incredibly effective attack,
all of his athleticism and computational power
helped on the other end of the court,
where he was a key component in Miami's defense.
During their four-year run,
the Heatles frequently attacked ball screens with a second defender,
which meant other defenders had to scramble behind the play as everyone recovered.
And this blitzing of the pick and roll
created a kind of frenetic approach on defense
that required a ton of coordinated rotations
and also forced a lot of turnovers.
Sometimes this scheme asked James to sprint across the court to a popping big man.
This would be an impossible rotation
if the screener flared to the three-point line,
but LeBron was so fast in a straight line
that he could arrive when these passes did.
He had great awareness of on-ball threats,
sliding over to help early here,
and choking off this pass, which leads to another turnover.
In Cleveland,
James' defensive success was more about brute force athleticism,
but in Miami he played a more cerebral game.
He isn't preoccupied with this cut
because he knows a middle pick and roll is coming,
and then he's big enough to battle with Duncan for the rebound.
Here he needs to help on the roll man,
but realizes he's in a pickle,
leaving a wide-open three or maybe a dunk
so he covers the pass while contesting the mid-range shot.
He was an active communicator,
calling out for a switch so his point guard could find a more natural matchup,
then instantly pouncing on a breakdown
to help influence a block from Shane Battier.
LeBron's on a sharpshooter here,
and he chases him off two screens for a decent look,
and all that action pulled rebounders out of the paint,
and it's a foul.
So the next time down,
LeBron tells Battier to take his man coming off the screen,
switches to the big,
and just blows the whole thing up.
Because of his size,
he could comfortably switch onto bigger players like this
and guard them in isolation,
and he could protect the rim like he was a big man as well.
This wasn't the incredible paint protection
we've seen from the great bigs in this series,
but LeBron added a ton of value lurking in the lane,
and since the heat would often play small ball,
he was the primary vertical presence in many of these situations.
He was potent enough as a shot blocker to deter shots,
Duncan freezes when he sees him here,
and then is totally stuck,
and some of these were elite rejections
that you would see from high-end defensive big men.
He slides over here in case there's a laydown pass,
and covers so much ground that he spikes it,
and this play is spectacular coming from the corner
after Wade whiffs on a gamble to kill a dunk.
Now, he didn't have the same numbers as a shot blocking big,
so these plays weren't always the norm.
Sometimes they could be fouls,
and other times he wasn't quite as loaded up
and vertical on some of these contests at the rim,
but his timely rotations in the paint,
and this big man-like skill,
were a major asset for the heat.
There was a horizontal component to these rotations too.
He has to cover about 16 feet in the second
that this pass is airborne,
and that prevents Steph Curry from firing,
and leads to a bad pass and a steal.
He could play a cross-court pass like this,
or explode to intercept a roll pass,
and that closing speed allowed him to be in two places at once.
These short little bursts of speed
allowed him to cover tons of court
like a rangy center fielder in baseball,
and his hands were pretty good too,
racking up enough steals
to land in the 88th percentile historically.
Some of these plays on the ball were certainly a bit risky,
and so there were some occasional misses in there.
On this one,
he's in time on the rotation
but lunges for more and comes up empty,
and sometimes he'd sell out for a pick six,
and when those plays failed,
they often exposed the defense
and led to a high-value shot.
But he rarely lost track of the action off ball.
Here's a lapse on some screening set,
although he was usually pretty aware of his own man
and the basketball from the other side of the court,
so despite a few hiccups,
he was a fairly low-error player away from the ball.
He was highly knowledgeable of opponent's playbooks
during these seasons,
helping early and rotating on point
in Miami's scrambling scheme,
and he was even known to call out opposing sets.
He switches this to blow up Indiana's screening action,
and his pattern recognition skills
were also a key to his defensive value.
That value helped the Heat
produce quality defensive ratings in the regular season
and solid ones in the postseason.
Among regular playoff teams,
they were about middle of the pack
in defensive performance during these years,
despite playing smaller lineups
than most teams at the time.
LeBron also loved rear-view blocks,
recovering to catch players from behind,
and this was part of his chase-down arsenal in transition,
where he'd just size up smaller players
like an adult playing with young children.
He tried a similar approach in the half-court,
although it was far less effective on drives like this
when James lost a step to the dribbler,
and containing ball handlers in space
was probably his biggest defensive weakness.
It wasn't that LeBron couldn't keep quicker
or smaller players in front of him.
He used his length and size to cut off angles well,
but he also had to guess and react instantly
to change directions on stops and starts,
and he was vulnerable to these
because at 270 pounds,
it took a lot to break and re-accelerate in short spaces.
His technique worked really well
whenever those little hops and reactions
were on time and in the right direction,
but if his feet were off the ground
when his man started to go,
he couldn't laterally recover at his size.
This made LeBron an interesting on-ball defender
because he regularly broke down
to change-of-direction attacks,
but when he sized it up well,
he could keep really small guards in front of him.
He was fairly successful switched onto
the shifty Tony Parker in the 2013 Finals,
and he was big enough to then switch onto Duncan
and stonewall him in the post.
Another downside to being so big
was that navigating screens was a tricky endeavor.
James didn't have that sharp cornering
required to stick with some of these routes,
and he couldn't really slide that much weight
or rely on tap-dancing feet to slip by some picks.
You see him go wide here so he can chase
with more of a running motion versus sliding,
and because he was so broad,
he offered a large screening target,
which made it challenging for him
to stay with smaller players
when they ran around like this.
All the major one-number metrics
view LeBron as a strong defender,
and with his huge offensive value,
his overall impact metrics
are right at the top of the heap.
Interestingly, these numbers were higher
in his first two MVP seasons,
when he was the lone star in Cleveland,
surrounded by outside shooters
who gave him space to attack the rim.
In Miami, he didn't have the ball as much,
and his off-ball impact paled
in comparison to his on-ball game.
He could hurt defenses with timely cuts,
he had good instincts for when to backdoor
a vulnerable defender,
but his spot-up shooting was only mediocre,
and more importantly,
playing away from the ball
took the decision-making out of his hands.
We've discussed scoring resiliency,
but LeBron Ball provided an overall resiliency
that was difficult to scheme against
because he could leverage his scoring
and playmaking off of each other.
He couldn't just plug into any offense
and add the same value,
but a well-constructed attack built around LeBron
produced a championship-level offense.
His high IQ, Swiss Army Knife defense
also made him one of the better perimeter defenders
in league history,
and that two-way impact probably made him
the greatest floor raiser we've ever seen.
So, given that he has a great argument
as a top-10 scorer and top-10 playmaker ever,
it's easy to see why so many people consider LeBron James
the greatest player of all.
For more historical content and to support this channel,
head over to patreon.com slash thinkingbasketball
and check out Thinking Basketball The Book on Amazon.
That goes deeper on a number of ideas
explored in this series.
There are also longer discussions
on many of these players
on the Thinking Basketball podcast,
and if you're curious about stats from this video,
there's an entire stat series on this channel.
Otherwise, thanks so much for watching.
I hope you enjoyed this one
and that wherever you are,
you're having a great day.
