Designing Career Exploration for Outcomes + Introducing the Career Exploration Evidence Fund
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis session explores a collaborative initiative by Project Evident, the Walton Family Foundation, and BrightBound to redefine and strengthen career exploration for students. The discussion advocates for moving away from one-time events toward immersive, relational experiences starting in middle school to help students build identity, social capital, and the agency needed to navigate their futures.
Comments are disabled for this video.
All right. We're welcoming folks in. I see the number counting up.
And thank you. Thank you so much for joining.
We're going to get started in just a few minutes, folks.
We're going to wait for folks as they join. All right.
And I'll introduce our friends that are joining us today,
Farhana, Sim, and Annie, in just a moment.
But just welcome to folks as you're joining.
And feel free to check out that link in the chat for some
of the materials that we'll be talking about today.
We'll also be populating in the chat all sorts
of additional references that are going to be shared by our panelists.
All right, I see that number counting up.
And so I'm going to, when it starts slowing down
is when I'm gonna start announcing everybody.
And folks, as you join,
you'll see a Mentimeter in the chat.
Just invite you to say
what part of the sector are you joining from?
What perspective are you bringing?
What hat are you wearing as you're joining this call?
That'll be really helpful for our panelists
as we talk about career exploration today and designing.
I'm going to ask my backstage
to repaste the Mentimeter in the chat.
It looks like maybe folks have joined after it.
Just want to say a huge thank you to folks
that you're not necessarily seeing right now
on screen, Gabrielle and Megan for helping us with this entire thing.
You'll hear me asking for them off screen.
All right.
There's the Mentimeter, and it looks like...
Our, our attendee count has slowed. And so I'm going to get us started.
All right, everybody ready? All right, fantastic.
And so I just want to welcome everybody and thank you for joining this.
The work we're going to be talking about today is stood on
Thank
work that's happened the whole way through this year
and a lot of work that's happened before and has really been informed
by a deep partnership with Walton and Brightbound, Sim and Annie.
you
Thank you so much for all that you've contributed over time
very
and has been led by Farhana Hussain.
And so we're going to hear a lot about the writing,
Farhana, that you have done around
much.
this and just very much looking forward to being able to share this.
And just want to say to everybody,
we have put into our description of this that we're
going to have an announcement at the end.
So I just encourage folks, stick around.
Towards the end, we're going to have
a special announcement about where to with all this
work.
Where are we going with all of this work?
And so just an invitation just to stay towards the end.
So final thing I will say,
and then I'd like to introduce our panelists today, is that
this session will be interactive.
That Mentimeter that you see in the chat,
we're going to have a few of those and just
invite your interaction as we're talking about all this,
as well as your questions a little
past the half hour mark so we can address them.
With that, I would like to say, welcome Farhana.
You have many hats, but you're showing up here as a senior advisor
at Project Evident and just real appreciation for a lot of the writing
that you did that we are going to be talking about today.
Farhana hails from New York City.
And Sim, also from New York City,
but sitting at the Walton Family Foundation as a program officer
and has been engaged in this work since before it even began.
And so just thank you so much.
And we're looking forward to hearing from you about your perspective
and why this is important.
And then finally, Annie, coming to us from Brightbound.
I'm sitting in Boston as the Director of Grantmaking
and Programs at Bright Bound.
Thank you so much and all of the work
that you have done that this sits on the shoulders
of as well.
I'm looking forward to hearing from you
a bit about why some of this is really important
to Bright Bound.
So I'm going to ask our back, so welcome to all three of you,
and welcome to everybody that's
joined. I was wrong, that ticker is still going up,
and so if you've just joined, we are just
getting started. Welcome, everybody.
Would love to invite our backstage to show us the Mentimeter
poll to our panelists about the different perspectives
that are in the room today.
Can you show us this? So we have a...
But, um, um,
A great number of, actually, it looks like people are still filling
this out because I know that there's more participants on the call than
there is represented here, but we have a number of folks from workforce
and youth-serving nonprofits, and also from K-12 as well,
and we have more responses coming in, as well as folks
from employers wearing funder hats, researchers, and others as well.
I just encourage you to keep on clicking that link as well.
We have well over 100 people in this,
and so we may come back and revisit that.
But thank you so much for just sharing
who you are and what hat you have as you are coming
into the room today.
So with that, I want to get us started.
And so we want to just start with a quick definition
of career exploration just to kick us off.
And then I'm going to turn over to Sim and then to Annie
to talk a little bit about why this work is important.
And so when we talk about career exploration,
we talk about a continuous, open-ended, hands-on, immersive process.
which happens over time and in which young people can investigate
themselves and the world of work.
Ideally it gives young people repeated
opportunities for real world experiences, ongoing reflection,
building relationships and social capital,
and the ability to revise plans
as they learn.
So they develop awareness, skills, and agency to make
and remake informed choices about careers and pathways.
So I just want to put that out there
and just talk a little bit about why this is important.
So first, I want to turn to you, Sim.
You know, I know from the work that you have done over time
that career-connected learning in high school has
been a major focus of the Walton Family Foundation's K-12 work.
I'm curious about these lessons.
How do these lessons from these investments lead you to want
to better understand career exploration in particular?
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
I'm Simran. I work on the Reinventing High School team
at Walton in particular,
and I'll start by sharing a little bit more about
our theory of change on the team overall.
Awesome.
We think that the high school engagement gap, which is well documented,
has particular consequences for the students
that are most at risk. So the students that
have the least social capital,
the least support navigating complex networks, the ones with the
least exposure to high-wage careers in their day-to-day lives,
they're the ones that have
the most to lose.
When we see that all high schoolers are facing this disengagement,
given this, we really want our high school redesign efforts
to give students a safe, free, engaging place to explore different
options without having to make costly or consequential decisions.
And then we also want to prepare them with the knowledge
and skills that they need to do well and to explore these paths.
So when it comes to career-connected learning,
our first and earliest bet was really in the
Catalyst Challenge or Catalyst colloquially.
We began this in 2021, and after the first few years,
we engaged with the Bellwether team
to understand sort of what is the evidence
base behind all of the different types
of career-connected learning models we're
supporting. And when we looked into it,
career exploration was one of those models.
With the least supported evidence-based.
And this kind of created a tension for us
because we also looked at what youth were saying,
what high schoolers wanted more out of
high school. And they were all saying
that they wanted a sense of purpose and identity
that connected them to what they
were learning within the school walls. So
In 2025, last year,
we tried to engage in more of an evidence-based purpose and identity
discovery work. So this meant two projects
in particular within the Walton side. One was
Career Village. Can we scale
and use technology to reach more students as they build this identity
and purpose? And the second was our work with you.
With the Project Evidence team to do a landscape scan
and an academic review of what we learned
about career exploration to date
and where stronger evidence is needed within the field.
Well, thank you for that, Sim.
And yes, we'll be hearing a lot more about it
in just a few moments.
And so very clear and very clear how that led you
to this work and how to deepen evidence around it.
And so also wanted to hear, you know,
and just recognizing, you know, Sim and Annie,
you sit in this seat where you can actually see broadly
across the field, which is really fantastic.
And so, you know, wanted to just,
turn to you about your observations from BrightBound, Annie.
You've been focused on
career exploration, reaching young people earlier in particular.
And over the last few years,
you've led research and you've supported efforts
to better understand career exploration in middle
school. Curious about what you've learned about
that and how those lessons have shaped your
decision to deepen investment in this work.
Thank you, Gabriel. I'm so excited to be here
and share the stage with Sim and others in Farhana as well.
So over the past few years, BrightBound has invested over 12 million
dollars, like specifically in middle school career exploration
in a variety of different contexts, both in school and out of school.
And what we've heard pretty consistently from practitioners,
policymakers and young people themselves is that we need to start
earlier in talking about career exploration and career readiness.
Like.
Like, it is very valuable for young people still
to participate in career exploration in high school.
But what we found in our conversations is that the middle school age
is a very important age developmentally for self-discovery.
This age group is still.
Open to trying out new experiences without ruling out options
for themselves, and I'll
share a few specific examples of projects
that BrightBound has invested in both at the
policy level and in understanding youth perspectives
and what works and what doesn't work as it
relates to career exploration.
First and foremost, at the policy level,
we engaged Bellwether a few years ago to run
a 50 state scan.
of the status of career exploration across the country,
this is called our Extending the Runway
report. And we also worked with ESG to launch
a middle school learning network where we worked
with nine states building upon the good work
that extending the runway had uncovered for us
to create a model set of policies
or what we think of as enabling conditions
to be able to scale up a career exploration for middle school.
And in wanting to understand more about
the youth perspective for career readiness, we
also launched a research series focused
on perspectives from recent grads and high school
students and reflecting back on their experience in middle school.
Last year, we launched our first report
of the series called Looking Back and Moving
Forward, and the key finding from that one
was young people did not feel that middle
school prepared them enough for what happened next.
69% of high schoolers and recent grads say
that they would have benefited more from career
exploration in middle school,
while 70% of young adults said that they would have been more engaged
in school if middle school learning was better connected
to their career interests. We followed
up to that report with Mind the Gap,
which was released earlier this year, and a similar survey,
thousands of recent grads and high school students.
And what we found was that the opportunities
that are available to middle schoolers do not line up
with what they find most helpful from their perspective.
We also found that access is very thin. Only 38% of folks said
that their middle school gave them the right planning resources.
And we also learned that.
What works from their perspective
or what is most helpful from their perspective
are active, sustained, and relational activities.
So think less so what we lovingly call
random acts of career exploration
and more so year-round or field-based activities
that are actually connecting young people
to adults who are already working in the field
and getting to test and try out different options
from that perspective.
And so we now have a good understanding of what
are some enabling conditions that we need from a policy level.
We also know and understand that young people
are craving these opportunities.
What we found and what we're still feeling that is missing
is that translation from policy into practice
and young peoples and what they're
Their agency and what they're looking for and translating
that into what is available in the classroom.
So as we're trying to build the case for why middle school,
we feel that it is just as important for us to bring in actual evidence
into the conversation so that we can be able to justify.
This is why it is important to invest directly in middle school
and career exploration broadly.
Well, Annie, thank you so much for that.
And also thank you for bringing anybody
that's heard us talk about this along the way in
various places knows that our favorite quote
from this field scan is random acts of career
exploration.
And so thank you for bringing that back into the conversation,
because I think a lot of
what Farhana we're going to turn to and talk
with you about is how do we actually think
comprehensively about this?
What are the components of high quality career exploration?
And can we take a point of view on that?
And so, Annie, Sam.
Sim, thank you so much.
And let's just, we heard from both their perspectives
about why they came to this work.
I'm curious Farhana, when you brought together
all of these aspects of developmental education,
workforce research, what did it suggest
that young people need from career exploration?
Over to you Farhana.
Thanks, Gabriel. And Annie and Sim did already cover a lot of that,
but I'm going to go a little deeper.
First, I want to, Gabriel's already defined career exploration for you,
but I want to take a little step back and focus on that term.
When we launched the scan, we reviewed, as Gabriel was talking about,
we reviewed a wide range of literature covering evidence from research
studies and also practice and implementation in multiple domains.
Youth development, career development, theory,
workforce development, K-12 education, and all of that.
We also spoke with practitioners, researchers,
and state and local leaders, about 50 or so of them.
So one thing became clear, like people were using
the same term, but they weren't always
talking about the same thing, right?
So the lack of definition was pretty clear early
on in terms of alignment around definition
in the field.
It's often career exploration, there are,
you know, it's presented as a step along a
linear pathway towards training
or work-based learning that narrows towards a particular
field, right?
You explore, you choose a direction,
and then you move into preparation.
But when we dug into all these types of research and kind of, you know,
zoomed back, you know, looked back, is that what we, you know,
the big takeaway for us was that we have to widen that lens, right?
It's both about awareness and readiness,
understanding yourself as you talked about and the possibilities
around you and developing the skills, relationships,
and agency to act on that understanding.
So what do young people need?
And I believe our colleagues here are going
to put up the framework that we kind of landed
on based on our evidence scan.
First is self-discovery, right.
That means giving young people the chance to learn about themselves
in relationship to the world of work.
What are their interests, strengths, values, goals,
what and where they might fit along.
So without that connection to themselves,
everything else can feel random, right.
Second is, you know, environmental exploration.
That means opportunities to learn about careers,
workplaces, education, and training options,
including possibilities that they haven't encountered before, right?
They need chances to investigate, ask questions,
and try things that might expand what they
see as possible.
And third is durable skills.
And I don't mean job skills.
I'm talking about skills, right,
that help them make sense of what they're learning and
And they're seeing from...
Self-discovery, environmental exploration, all of those,
and other kind of exploratory experiences, right?
So asking good questions,
communicating with someone new, comparing options,
reflecting on how an experience landed,
making plans and adjusting them.
So those are all parts of the durable skills.
And then fourth is relationships and social capital because, as we
know, who you know shapes what feels possible and what you can access.
So young people need adults and peers they trust, you know, teachers,
counselors, coaches, family members, community members, what have you,
who can help turn information into guidance and open doors.
And as we know, access to these networks
and opportunities is not equal across communities
and student groups.
So exploration really needs to expand those possibilities.
And fifth and last in our kind of framework is what we call navigation
and adaptive planning.
And that means helping young people use what they're learning
to make decisions that they
have ownership over, right?
So what do I want to try next?
What would help me learn more?
What support do I need?
Practice actually making those decisions
and room to revise them as their interests, experiences,
and circumstances change over time.
And all of this happens, you know,
has to happen within the environments that shape
their choices, what they're learning
in school academically, and in terms of social
and emotional development,
their families and communities, out-of-school programs in
the community, in addition to what they're learning
at school, right, and employers and
opportunities available around them.
The last thing I'll say about the framework
is that the key takeaway from the Evidence
Scan is that what we need to be working towards
is a connected set of supports in and out
of school, as Gabriel talked about,
that gives young people repeated opportunities to experience
all of these components across middle
and high school in ways that build on one another
and fit the decisions they're facing.
I want to clarify that we weren't trying to build,
this is not a program model or this
This is not saying that.
Every, you know, every program working with a young person
or every school needs to, but
this is more about how do we connect these components
and provide opportunities for these
components across, in a holistic way,
across multiple settings to young people as they're
navigating middle and high school
So Farhana, should we leave that up for the next conversation?
I just want to, I want to signal a poll.
maybe we can focus in the...
Folks in the backstage, Gabrielle and Megan,
you can leave up the framework for a little bit longer.
Farhana, you can signal when you want to pull it down
because I think this represents, well,
I know this represents a very rich field and evidence scan
and trying to blend what we're hearing from practitioners,
from researchers, from policymakers about what, and then sitting
on top of the evidence which you cited and what components
Um, we really should be focused
on for high quality career exploration for those of you
in the audience and welcome to, uh,
there's actually a number of folks that have joined
us in the past, uh, 10 or 15 minutes.
Welcome.
Uh, and, uh, we just love, uh,
invite you to engage with the, with the, with the Mentimeter
poll.
You can just click the link and what we're.
What we're asking is, you know, from where you sit,
is there a component of this that feels under delivered
in the settings that that that you touch as specifically?
And so we'll take a look at that at the end.
But I wanted to throw back to you, Farhana, about about what we know
from the evidence that we've that that we reviewed.
How much do we know about whether
a career exploration itself makes a difference?
You know, what evidence do we have about
the outcomes for young people and how to implement
services effectively?
And most importantly, what do we still really not know?
So I want to throw back to you.
And before I move on, I also want to kind
of double click on what Annie and Sim said.
You know, as we were doing this work,
Bright Bound was also doing their surveys, as Annie
mentioned, they were surveying middle school,
I mean, high school kids who were about what
they were experiencing or their career exploration
opportunities available in middle school.
And this is one of the places where what
the evidence suggests young people need and what
young people say what they need, I wanted to highlight that.
Very, very aligned, right?
And so, you know, when we say, you know,
center young people or listen to young people, and
in this case, the evidence really backs up
the types of things that they said they want
and need in terms of the different types
of research evidence we looked at.
Thanks, Gabriel.
Now I'm going to move to your question.
Kind of going back, there's a strong, you know,
developmental case for career exploration,
as Annie and Sam have talked about.
Like, we have decades of research
on how young people develop their interests,
identities, ideas about what's possible, right?
Like, they can rule out careers early, as early as,
you know, 13, based on messages about gender.
Where they think they belong in society, class,
and those other factors that shape their perception
of themselves in terms of where they fit in society.
So it was the developmental case for career exploration,
the fact that it needs to start
early and continue, is well established.
It gives them a chance to reconsider some of the assumptions
and expand what feels possible.
What we know much less about is that what are the concrete experiences
in middle school and early high school and support longer
term success and for whom and under what conditions, right?
So some of the clearest evidence connecting
like teenage career exploration experiences
to adult outcomes come from OECD research that follows.
young people over time, including some studies that use U.S. data.
So things like career conversations with adults,
like teachers or family members,
workplace experiences, including part-time work,
workplace visits, those are associated with...
Better jobs, earnings, job satisfaction, much later on in life, right?
These studies don't establish
that these activities cause those outcomes.
These are longitudinal tracking studies.
But the consistency across countries suggests
that these experiences do matter, right?
In the U.S., we have much less of that, right,
of longer-term kind of longitudinal tracking.
Like, we have strong...
you know, causal evidence for very structured,
kind of more sector-focused type models, right?
So, dedicated CTE school, career academies,
like early college high school. So, these have,
different models have shown benefits for different types
of education and workforce outcomes,
but these are more intensive structured models
that combine coursework, advising,
relationships, and other supports.
Often within career pathways,
so that makes it difficult to isolate how exploration works
within them.
We also have evidence linking practices like advising,
mentoring, project-based learning
to near-term gains, depending on the approach,
these could include career awareness, confidence
in making decisions,
having better supportive relationships, school engagement.
And there are also structured exploratory
models built around exploration, right?
Some weave it throughout the school experience,
other focus on particular components like
mentoring.
Overall, though, just, you know,
headline is the evidence is very fragmented, particularly
and limited in very limited in middle school
and understanding the trajectory from middle
to high school, right?
So we still need to understand how these experiences
and near-term gains lead to longer-term success
So does aspiration in eighth grade change what happens
in high school or beyond, right?
So I'd like to highlight a couple of connected gaps before I end.
So like first, how do we design experiences
that build on one another in terms of what
we still need to learn?
What combinations of activities matter?
How should they look at different ages
and what should carry from middle to high school,
right?
We still need to understand what makes exploration
a connected learning experience across those
years.
How do we know whether it's helping?
We often track whether a student attended a career fair
or completed an advising plan.
We know less about what they learned or what changed.
Did they consider an option they previously ruled out?
Build a relationship that they can draw on.
We know very little about how exploration drives youth outcomes
and how it creates meaningful outcomes,
both in the short run and the long run.
And then tech, you know,
what does it take to deliver exploration? Well, in our scan,
like practitioners repeatedly asked about staffing,
training, partnerships, resources, like
which approaches are feasible in what settings?
You know, how do these choices affect student
experiences? And technology is becoming a big part of that too,
right? Digital platforms,
AI, virtual reality,
we have all of these being adopted for exploration.
We need more evidence about whether they improve access
and outcomes and for whom
and what human support means to accompany them.
So all of these areas are ripe for investigation
and evidence building in the future.
We can start measuring experiences and changes more consistently,
investigate how they connect to engagement,
progress through school, outcomes.
So this would give practitioners some things they can use
to improve their work.
Well, Farhana, thank you so much for...
Summarizing months of work and thousands of pages of research.
We have three long papers.
So they just...
An invitation to click those links
that we posted about the work that is summarized,
but what Farhan was talking about,
as well as some of the related work that both Sim and Annie
have posted as well.
I'm going to turn.
To Sim and Annie in just a moment, but I wanted to pull back
that Mentimeter poll about where folks are seeing the sort
of the biggest, actually, let me say, we actually asked, what parts
of the framework are most under-delivered from where you sit?
And so.
The relationships and social capital piece is far
and away the highest, and I think
that's something that, again,
we have heard from young people that they are really very
interested in, and so that's interesting to hear
from where folks are sitting in the audience
right now, and so much appreciated.
I know that there's more of you out there
an invitation to answer that poll we'll capture
captured at the end.
And I just want to turn back actually to, first,
I'm going to talk to, I want to throw a question
to Sim. After these next two questions,
we're going to open up a Q&A for everybody. And so just
please think about if you have any questions,
put them in the Q&A feature, and we'll get to
those in a moment. And for those of you that have joined recently,
we'll have an announcement at the
So.
Sim, Annie, you have talked to and been listening to policymakers,
practitioners and educators, young people,
and so just really interested to hear how
is this playing out based on what Farhana was saying.
So Farhana described what young people need
from career exploration grounded in the research, and I'm curious, Sim,
turning to you, drawing on your research and the work that you support,
where do you see the biggest gaps in between?
The vision that Farhana is laying out and what students experience and,
you know, what would help close that?
So over to you, Sarah.
I love what Farhana said earlier about centering youth voices and what
we're seeing with our research at Walton is very aligned
with what Annie has already talked about
as well. So in particular,
we ran a survey with Gallup centered on youth voices and what Gen Z
students are, you know, experiencing in high school.
And the recent research shows
Unsurprisingly that students are really excited about learning
when it connects to their real
world experiences or their future careers.
Yet we're seeing that only about half of students have
like real work experience
or internship experience that would check this off even
though the overwhelming majority of folks
that have a work-based experience,
I think it's about 81 percent, say that it helped explore their
options and expanded their horizons in a really positive way.
So that's the core motivation of
this work. We believe that more students want
to and should have opportunities to explore
their interests, connect with employers,
experience what the world of work looks like
as part of their core education,
and we believe that not enough students get to do this.
Sim, thank you for that.
And I want to turn to Annie with a similar question, actually,
just to build on what Sim was saying, what Farhana was saying.
You know, how do you wrestle
with the gaps in your grant making particular work in middle schools?
Yeah, so I think about it from a few different perspectives.
Like, first and foremost, like,
Like I think we're.
Leaning on pretty heavily on some
of the prior research that we've done,
especially at the sort of policy slash enabling conditions perspective.
So in referencing back to one of our earlier research around extending
the runway, which is our 50 state national scan on the status
of middle school career exploration policies around the country.
We now have a good sense of what...
Some of the enabling conditions that are needed that are required
for career exploration to be successful, and that what maps back
to some of the what Sim and Farhana had talked about earlier,
like having a clear set of definitions and governance around career
exploration, a better understanding of what is required for students
and for educators, accountability frameworks, and also
The infrastructure.
And what just stood out to me just now when we looked
at the mentee poll together was that it seems like most of the folks
on this call, a lot of folks on this call, flagged that relationships
and social capital as being one of the areas that are very underfunded
or some of the biggest gaps as it comes to this work.
And that, to me, speaks
to some potentially infrastructure opportunities.
And so as we're rolling out some of our other initiatives,
we're seeing a lot of urgency and momentum around middle grades
and funding in middle grades.
It's, um,
But there's not a clear sort of sense of direction
on how we can work together right now.
Uh,
So especially among the funders, around the funder space.
And this is an opportunity for this.
It was a huge opportunity for us to partner with Walton
and partner with Project Evident
to think about how we can address some of these tensions.
How do we coordinate efforts together
as co-funders and share some of our learnings,
especially as it relates to our prior research
and our prior grants, grant-making opportunities,
and how can we do our jobs even better in moving
resources to enable us to scale a career exploration at scale.
Thank you, Annie.
And I also just want to recognize
that the Q&A and chat is alive
with all of the resources
that you all are dropping right now.
And so just thank you.
Thank you to everybody
that's engaging with all of this.
Yes, we will bundle all of this
and send an email
with all of these links afterwards,
as well as a link
to this recording as well.
So don't worry.
You don't have to copy
and paste feverishly out of the chat,
but we did want to make sure
that you have access
to some of these great references
And the work that Walton and Brightbound have sponsored
and that has also come out of this
career exploration investigation that we're doing right now.
I would love to drop another link.
So based on what Sim and Annie have said,
here's actually a question that we asked
a group of practitioners at the Horizons Conference
earlier this year.
We're really curious.
We asked you sort of where some of the gaps are
based on where you're sitting.
We have a question we kind of framed as tensions,
but it's also, it's, you know, these trade-offs, right?
In terms of like, how do you actually meet
Some of the some of the aspects of.
of high-quality career exploration, and so just invite the audience
here to open up that Menti poll as we get into some of the Q&A here,
and really curious to hear from you, like, which tensions
are most alive in doing the career exploration work right now?
We've got a bunch of questions.
I want to actually start with one that came up,
actually, a little bit earlier.
And I'm going to throw to you first, Farhana,
so we're going to do a Q&A for about 10 minutes
or so and then want to, again,
step back and make an announcement as we promised.
And so I see some really great questions.
Keep the questions coming.
We're going to try to address as many as we can.
And, and.
And I'm going to turn to that in just a moment.
But first, I wanted to just say, you know,
Farhana, you know, we often hear, you talked
about this a little bit in terms of the interaction
of the definition of career exploration and
how it connects with career pathways.
But we hear this term, you know, career exploration,
we hear this term career pathways, we hear
them used together.
Can you just?
Can you help us think about how you distinguish the two
and how exploration can help young
people choose a pathway and continue learning about options as they go?
And you can also throw to Annie and Sim as well,
but I want to turn to you first.
Yeah, I think the concept of career pathway and career exploration,
they're closely connected, right?
They just serve different purposes. So career pathways,
they organize education, training, work-based learning,
experiences to help someone enter and advance in a field, right?
And career exploration helps young people understand themselves
and their options, as we talked about, and develop the skills
and agency to make decisions about where they want to go.
And that could be choosing a career pathway, right?
So, starting exploration earlier
when we talk about it shouldn't mean asking young people
to commit earlier.
And we have, we've been, you know, Simran,
Penny, and Gabriel have been talking about,
it's not about getting a sixth grader
to choose their career track, right?
This is not what that's about.
It should be, it means giving them more room to discover interest,
encounter possibilities,
and learn how to evaluate those possibilities.
For themselves. So exploration also doesn't end
when someone chooses a pathway in our kind of the
way we think about it. Sometimes you learn what matters
to you only by trying something in depth,
right? So if you try a high school CTE pathway,
for example, you may realize that that is not
in the long run for you. I was a pre-med person in high school.
I also did a career academy,
and that's not where I ended up, right?
But it was still valuable to me, right? So
A young person might enter a healthcare pathway and discover
that they're interested in the technology behind the work more than
direct patient care, or they may choose a different field altogether.
So, you know.
The reason I'm bringing that up
is because it has implications for how we define success,
and I want to differentiate that between career exploration
and career pathways, right?
We should ask whether young people
are better able to understand their options,
weigh trade-offs, seek guidance, right?
Staying in a pathway is one possible outcome,
but the larger goal is helping them make informed decisions
and have longer-term well-being.
Simran, Annie, did I miss anything?
I do want to.
You know, one of the questions that have been thrown earlier
to us was sort of colloquially, how do we
How do I ensure that somebody is not deciding a path earlier?
And so how this showed up, let me see if I can pull it up.
What if I don't want an 11-year-old to commit
to being a plumber right away, right?
How do I make this more high agency?
And I think, you know, rather than throwing this question,
I have another question I want
to throw to...
Simran, Annie, but just this,
this anchor that you're making for Hannah and that we've
all been making about the way
that career exploration can support students' choices
and agency in making sure that they are able
to see the environment that's ahead of them
and be supported to make reflective choices over time.
So they may want to become a plumber and that is great
and making sure that that's an intentional
high agency choice.
So I wanted to throw another question.
Maybe I'll start with you, Sim, about something that we've talked about
an awful lot, and Annie would love to hear about it,
particularly from the middle school point of view.
There are so many demands on educators right now, and so,
you know, how, given the amount of demands that are on educators,
how career exploration can be actually supported
to be a part of students' everyday learning without becoming
a competing priority for educators?
You don't have to have the answer to this question,
but I'm just curious about your reaction to it and,
like, how we're trying to think about...
Sort of think about how we build evidence
that fits into an environment that educators
can implement.
Let me shim over to you first.
Yeah, well, first, I just want to affirm
that this is this is sort of like the core question
without teachers, any of these efforts,
like we'll just simply not be successful in implementation.
What we what we know to be true is that teachers
and other adults in the school system are
already navigators, like today,
this is part of their job, even beyond like core academic instruction
And we know from OECD studies that
Many teachers report that 60% of their job is in, like,
Avenues that are not just related to lesson planning
and direct academic teaching.
They carry a lot of roles.
And I think supporting teachers in any means
of implementing career exploration is like
one of the main goals here,
whether that is creating infrastructure that better connects
the education system to workforce or understanding how tools
and technology can bring time back
to teachers as they answer these questions
that they're already receiving from students.
Yeah, and I think part of what we're still very curious about
also is how can teachers,
how can we best support teachers in implementing
these types of models as well? And one answer
might be like, it can't just all be on teachers.
This could be an opportunity for
um
For schools and educators to lean on the broader infrastructure
of their local community, like what are some other nonprofits
that could provide some supplementary resources
and better connect with schools to ensure
that the career exploration opportunities that are being offered
in the out-of-school time space or by the nonprofit providers
you.
also ladder back to what students are learning in the classroom.
And it can also be seen at,
and another way to look at it is like, this is also
Offering career exploration is another way
to increase student engagement in core content
and core curriculum,
and so how do we have the conversation around quality instruction
as opposed to having a conversation about yet another thing
to add into the school day.
Annie and Sim, thank you so much for that.
Farhana, I see that you may be live answering another question.
We do have the option to sort of like type in answers.
It's hard to do all of that at once
when we're sitting in front of our audience here.
And so thank you.
Thank you all.
But there's an open question about successful models where
the kind of theory of change
for high-quality career exploration is embedded in an employer setting.
And so just wanted to invite.
Farhana if there was something that you wanted
to say about that and also maybe we could even
I don't know if you can hear me.
one of our previous respondents
to this to this work just highlighting the U.S. Chamber of
Commerce's pathways with purpose work which you can
which they're underway and is also something
that I know that Walton is heavily involved
in as well would just would just call that out is a
really interesting thing to watch in that employer engagement piece
but Farhana anything to add
Yeah, I was actually answering that, but I will answer that live.
So we have some promising examples in the paper
in terms of the employer engagement.
I think I just saw Kate from CAPS Network on here.
So we did highlight CAPS Network that connects students with business
and community partners through real projects or project-based learning
and explicitly includes self-discovery
and exploration alongside professional skill development.
We also talked about big-picture learning,
where students pursue internships connected to their interests
with a workplace mentor and support from a school advisor.
I
I've described these as examples that reflect our kind
of emerging framework rather than programs that have implemented
don't
or tested our particular framework.
So what I take from these models is that
The learning needs need to be designed around the workplace experience,
like preparation beforehand,
know.
meaningful work and relationship during it, and guidance to reflect on,
you know, what they've learned and what they want to do next.
So it takes a, it takes a
It applies some components of the framework around employer engagement,
including self-discovery
and environmental exploration, and packages it together.
The evidence is still descriptive and developing.
Both CAPS and Big Picture have had alumni survey research,
which offers useful insights,
so I would highlight that here.
I want to move to a promised announcement
in just a few moments, but I'm going to hold
the questions. There's so many rich questions here
and I just want to say we will find a way
to answer them. Do not worry.
We have captured them even if we run out of time today.
We'll find other ways and venues for answering them.
But there's a question here that Annie is sort
of fit for purpose for any reflections
from you hailing from Chicago
and thinking about extending work from high schoolers earlier
into middle school and just looking to be pointed
in the right direction about how to
carry work that's already happening in high school into earlier grades.
Let me.
Sorry, I was scrolling to find this question here.
Thank
I didn't mean to put you on the spot.
I apologize.
I apologize.
Did I?
you.
Annie, you are back.
Do not worry.
That was odd. An opportune time to be to have
an unstable internet connection here.
But anyway.
That's the only glitch. We're doing great, Annie. Keep on going.
All good. So I would first like want to better understand like what
at what level of the current engagement you're currently offering
the high school students are like, are there employers engaged?
Are there like, what's what type of hands on opportunities
are available right now at current state? And
Backwards mapping to better understand like what
is most appropriate for middle school students.
I think at this age group there there might be an opportunity for for
there to be some peer learning opportunity, peer learning potential.
If there are high school students who are very,
very excited about what they're doing, perhaps there could
be an opportunity for them to peer mentor some middle school students
to to share out like what they're learning
and how how that's translating.
to their high school choices and beyond as well.
So not the most perfect answer without a first understanding
like what the full context of your program is,
but I hope that's helpful.
Thank you. And thank you for weathering a glitch. I appreciate it.
We all appreciate it. And there's a bunch of really important
and rich questions here around social capital, around mentoring,
around validated research for different career assessments,
around employer engagement, around communicating benefits
of career exploration to employment partners. There's a lot.
And so we are going to find a way to be able to play this back.
But first.
Is it OK if we pull up the core tensions Mentimeter?
I'm going to talk about that in a moment.
And then we're going to shift to an announcement
and bring ourselves.
So we have a, the,
I'm so sorry.
I have now, I.
I'm sorry, it's too small.
So capacity and resources, making sure that we actually get the
time for being able to deliver this.
I know we have a lot of people on the call right now,
and so this is just a subset of folks.
And so just an invitation to anybody that wants to sort of
drop off their observation about where
the highest priority tensions are in career exploration for
for you right now.
We will capture that. We'll capture that at the end.
And I know that some of you have even seen this poll before.
And so I just want to say thank you so much for engaging with that.
And let's let's pull down because I want to make
a promised announcement, as we had as we had said, and and also.
We'll get a chance to throw back to our colleagues,
Sim and Annie, for any additional
reflections. And then we're going to close up
with a promise to follow up with resources and
questions. All right. So just thank you all for the great questions.
Keep them coming. You can
keep on putting them in. We'll get to them.
And just wanted to say that we are really thrilled
today to talk about a new piece of work
and how we're going to carry some of the observations
We've talked about today.
And put into the documents
that we've all just talked about forward into the future.
And so with support from both Walton
and Bright Bound as inaugural investors, we're launching a new piece
of work we're calling the Career Exploration Evidence Fund.
So what is the Career Exploration Evidence Fund?
The Career Exploration Evidence Fund aims
to expand access to high-quality career exploration
by building credible evidence of its impact on young people.
The fund will focus on co-developing.
Deeper outcome measurement, which we talked about,
the need for that shared outcome measurement,
collaborative learning,
and evidence generation across a diverse array of settings.
So just some notes.
We're going to be inviting folks from school districts,
from public charter schools,
nonprofit organizations, and technology providers,
all that we are inviting that deliver comprehensive
career exploration programming grades 6 through 10.
And we're inviting folks that are particularly interested
in partnering as a cohort to advance
evidence for the field.
The fund is going to feature financial support,
technical assistance, and a learning community
across two academic years.
And so if this is something that sounds interesting to you
or programs that you know, we're inviting
folks to complete initial easy step by submitting
a letter of interest from now until mid-December.
We're going to be sending out more detail
in the follow-up, just like we promised with
all of the links, and we will
also be hosting a separate applicant webinar where we can
dig into the details of it all
because this is just the announcement at the end of a longer
piece of work.
So, I wanted to invite Sim, Annie,
if there's anything that you wanted to add here as we
make this announcement.
We're so excited to be a part of this with Walton again,
and we think that this is a great
opportunity for us to partner together to move the field forward,
especially in advancing our
knowledge base of what works
and what could be better as it relates to career exploration.
This is.
We really see this as one of our marquee initiatives
for our middle school body of work.
And just chiming in, I'm truly
so excited about the next few years of this project at Walton.
This is really our first big bet on career exploration,
and a lot of the introductory work sort of led us here.
And I can't say thank you enough to Farhana, Gabriel, Annie.
It's been so much fun designing this with you, and I can't wait
to see what sort of the next phase of this project looks like.
Thank you both.
Thank you all three.
And this, I mean.
I get fired up pretty easily, but like the folks that I've
been talking to know just how fired up I am about this,
because a lot of the questions that have come up through this work,
a lot of the questions that are posed by the materials
that we've shared today, we are going to seek
to find some more answers to over the coming couple of years.
And so, you know, we know from this that young people really
deserve experiences that can widen what they believe is possible.
And we really hope that.
If you are as excited about this as we are,
that we can have the opportunity to partner
and build evidence together
and develop a deeper understanding of how career exploration
can drive outcomes for young people.
So if it sounds like you, please follow up.
You can tune in on December 3rd for an applicant webinar.
Again, we'll send the links out after this.
And we invite you to submit a letter of interest by December 15th.
And so mid-December.
And that is actually a few minutes early,
a wrap of our regularly scheduled programming for all of
this. We, again, we just invite any of you to follow up with questions
and thoughts. We look
forward to answering questions based
on what we have already discovered through this work to date
and to try to learn together with a cohort of organizations that are
interested in building evidence
for the career exploration field moving forward.

