David Attenborough's Witness Statement (A Life on Our Planet)

Michael Faraday
67 followers
In 1853, the natural philosopher and great experimentalist Michael Faraday
gathered some people around a table like this one. With the lights down low,
and his volunteers concentrating on contacting the spirit world,
Faraday was investigating the existence of ghosts.
And that's what we're going to be trying to do today.
There was a real interest in Victorian society and everything sort of
supernatural and paranormal. So when we think about
these séances and table wrapping, what actually happened there?
What were Victorians actually trying to do?
You have to imagine a bunch of people who would get together into a room
with the objective of trying to contact some dimension beyond what we can usually see.
Usually this would be the realm of the dead.
They would try to correspond with ghosts.
They would try to receive some form of communication.
And the way in which the contact would manifest is that furniture would start to move.
So our volunteers are gathered around the table,
and their hands are placed on the tablecloth.
Slowly the table starts to turn.
We can see the table moving very slowly, very subtly at the moment.
Okay, so you felt the table move there, right?
I'm sure none of you were intentionally doing that.
You know, you're just feeling the table move.
And Faraday was interested in why that was happening.
People were claiming it was to do with electromagnetism.
That's partly why he starts to investigate it.
He's trying to make some measurements.
He's trying to capture some information about what's going on.
So I've recreated a device that he had made, which I will explain how it works in a bit.
I'm going to put these in front of each of you.
You can see there are some finger marks on there for you to put your fingers on.
Now I'm just going to get you to do basically exactly the same thing again.
Pushing down, you're not trying to wobble the table against the other person.
You're not trying to resist any movement.
You're going with any movement that you feel happening.
You're not fighting against the person opposite you.
You're also not fighting against the spirits that might be moving the table.
So let's see what happens this time.
Unknown forces were quite common.
Faraday, for example, had discovered the phenomenon of diamagnetism in 1845,
which showed that magnetism was a universal force of matter,
which previously had been specifically two types of material.
So in many ways, it was actually quite reasonable for people to write to Faraday saying,
Is there a scientific explanation for these phenomena that are being witnessed
and reenacted all over London and all over the country?
People hear about Victorian scientists like Faraday
becoming interested in phenomena of the supernatural.
This often sounds quite counterintuitive,
and you read headlines like he was dabbling in the supernatural and things like that.
But it's actually quite natural for scientists wanting to investigate
because, you know, there are so many new scientific discoveries.
There were so many things being made visible by marvellous devices.
You know, we better check out and see what's going on there.
By the 1850s, Faraday was arguably the most important scientific figure in the country.
He had spent nearly 30 years in the Royal Institution
making some fundamental discoveries,
ranging from the invention of the electric motor in 1821
to the discovery of electromagnetic induction,
the principle behind the transformer and the dynamo.
And furthermore, he had achieved considerable fame by his lectures
at the Royal Institution, both Faraday and Discourses,
but more especially because of his lectures.
I think when both his scientific ideas and his religious ideas and beliefs
were challenged by spiritualism, by table turning,
he felt forced to go public on this criticism.
So what Faraday did as an experimentalist was absolutely typical of Faraday,
and that is he developed an experiment to show what the real cause of table turning was.
So we can see the needle starting to move.
A couple of the needles seem to be moving now.
That's followed by very slow movement of the table.
Okay, so the table still moved.
Let me explain exactly what these indicators are doing now.
It's two boards.
There's some glass rods in there so those boards can slide across each other.
Rubber band around it to keep it central.
And then we have a needle, our indicator needle here.
If this board, the top board, gets pushed that way,
the needle will go the other way and vice versa.
So Faraday makes this to show that, first of all,
let's say there's a charlatan involved and they're pushing the table around.
This is going to reveal it because if I'm the stooge and I push the table that way,
the needle's going to show it, yeah?
None of you are a plant so no one's doing this on purpose.
But what Faraday realises is that even earnest volunteers,
people who are here, they believe this might work.
They don't know how it works.
They're not a plant.
Ever so subtly, they are pushing side to side.
They don't realise it, right?
What this does is it shows you if you're the one who's pushing the table or not.
If the table was to move under your hands, so the table is moving before the board,
then the needle will point in the direction that the table's going to turn.
But if it's you pushing the table, if you're actually slightly subtly moving the table,
then the force is coming from above
and the needle will move in the opposite direction to the way the table's moving.
What that means is you can now keep yourself in check.
You can tell whether or not it's you pushing the table or the table pushing you.
So keep an eye on the needles and if you can see the needle moving,
you'll know it's you moving the board around
so you can try and really focus on just pushing down.
So let's see what happens this time.
So yes, the table is no longer turning because the volunteers can keep themselves in check.
They can see if the needle moves,
be aware that they are pushing side to side, even if they didn't realise it,
and stop themselves.
As soon as the indicator was put on the table, the table turning stopped.
And William Carpenter, a good friend of Faraday's, a very prominent physiologist,
called this involuntary muscular action, or as we would call it, numb thumb.
And so they did not feel the table rotating.
They did not appreciate that they were actually moving the table themselves.
So Faraday's real problem with table turning and spiritualism
was the way in which it was taken up seriously by the educated middle class in Birmingham.
That's what really appalled him, that the state of scientific education was so poor
that these people were willing to accept these kind of ideas.
But this didn't quite disencourage people from still going to séances.
And it was very much a spectacle, very much an experience.
And people did flock there a little bit, like you flock to see a magic trick,
even though, you know, perhaps it isn't quite scientific, perhaps it isn't quite true.
Maybe there's still a chance there is something there.
And this is why, even though scientists became involved to debunk these things,
it still was quite popular and remained popular for quite a long time.
