Darlie Routier appeal | Dallas News Live

Fox - 4 News
16 followers
1 Video View·Nov 20, 2026
30 years after Darlie Routier was sent
to death row for the murder of her sons,
her attorneys now are asking a Texas court to look at new DNA evidence.
Routier is claiming that an intruder attacked her and killed her sons.
Joining me live, attorney Russell Wilson.
Russell, the Innocence Project is asking the Court of Criminal Appeals
to send this case back to a district court to present the new findings.
What was your initial reaction to hearing about this specific appeal?
You know, I wasn't particularly surprised even I think during
this time frame the DNA evidence was
being just learned about it came just into existence.
So I think it wasn't necessarily
particularly surprising given the nature of what's at stake
a death penalty case
that this case would be being reviewed regarding DNA evidence.
Russell, what is the appeal process for a death row inmate?
Is it different than a normal appeal process?
Well, I imagine that they're taking advantage
of some new laws that were passed since this case,
since the initial conviction.
The appeal process is relatively the same. But in this case,
for example, the advances in DNA testing
or DNA evidence that wasn't available at the time of trial
and may not have been previously addressed
by the court is likely to be part of what they're
They're appealing now.
Past appeals for this case have been more procedural.
This is the first one talking about DNA,
and you're saying that there have been advancements in DNA.
Is there an expedited timeline because we're talking about DNA?
Does this speed up the process because this is a death row inmate,
or will things follow the normal type of timeline?
There's not necessarily an expedited process.
But with respect to a normal timeline,
of course, a death sentence would end in an execution.
And so you wouldn't expect that
that type of punishment would be carried out
while this appeal is pending.
And so as the court makes its way through the record
and addresses those issues,
we would have kind of a pause in the proceedings.
If this happened nearly 30 years ago, and yes,
Yes, there have been advances in technology.
Why would something like DNA just now come up in your opinion?
I mean, that may be one of the things that the state is responding
and the parties will have to address that.
And they'll probably also have to address whether
or not whatever the technological advances are,
whether or not ultimately they believe
that would have made a difference
in the outcome of the trial. So those are great
questions and that's the type of question
that I would expect the court to have to answer.
You mentioned because this is a death row inmate now
an execution date has not been
said and executions in general in nationwide now have
been under some scrutiny after recent
events.
But walk me through and I know being transparent,
you're on an appeals team for a totally separate
case.
But how strenuous is the appeals process?
I mean, you're working on an appeals case for a fresh case.
This is nearly 30 years old,
walk me through the steps of what it takes to even get to
this point of saying, hey, there's new DNA,
we want a court to intervene.
So the first step, of course,
is looking back at the old appellate record, particularly, for example,
a case in the late 90s, and then the advances in DNA technology.
You have to kind of gather what the evidence was.
You'd have to get access to it, determine whether
or not there was DNA on materials that were or were not tested,
and then do the testing to see whether or not that DNA would help
or contradict the claims that were being made at trial.
After that testing is done, then you'd have to introduce that,
put it into an expert report,
and then you would have to compare
that to the record at the time of trial.
And so I said it probably pretty quickly,
but that's a very lengthy process. And during that
time, DNA technology has also itself been advancing.
So I'm assuming that they have the most
And with an appeal,
and correct me if I'm wrong,
this has to go before a judge panel,
or is it just one judge that will make a decision on this?
This would be before the Court of Criminal Appeals,
and it could be before a panel.
Initially, there's usually one judge
that's making kind of an initial evaluation,
and it really just kind of depends
at what stage the claims are being evaluated.
We waited.
Ultimately, I would expect the full panel of the judges at the Court
of Criminal Appeals to have weighed in and reviewed this case.
Because I think that's the same
that you expect in every death penalty case.
Let's say that this court does not send this back,
does not believe in the validity of
new DNA evidence possibly exonerating this person.
What other remedies does the defense have for death row inmate
or is it just appealing
to the US Supreme Court before an execution?
All right. So right now this is a state court proceeding.
Whenever you lose in state court,
there are narrow rights that you can
also try to assert in federal courts. And you can go all
the way up to the US Supreme Court.
So there are pretty extensive rights that are available,
particularly as it relates to DNA testing
and or the implications of new DNA testing.
So we've seen lots of cases in past years vacated and or reversed.
Based off of DNA testing, so it's still,
I think, a ripe area, but the question that
you raise why bringing it at this particular point
is certainly one that I think the courts
are going to be looking at closely.
I know lawyers have to be strategic
and they are working on behalf of the best interests
of their clients.
Is there like a limit for the number of appeals
that a lawyer can make in a death case, in
a murder case?
There is actually a limit, there's what we call
a procedural bar where if you've previously raised an issue,
you can't continue to raise that same issue over and over again.
And you must show to the court that you have new evidence
that was not available at the time of the prior appeal.
And so that kind of addresses
that timing question that you're asking about.
So you've got to show that this is something
that you didn't have at the time of your last appeal.
And that what you have now would make a difference,
that it would change the previous outcomes of your prior appeals.
This story when we reported it yesterday,
getting a lot of interest on our website
and on social media, we'll have to wait and see what the court does.
Attorney Russell Wilson, thank you for your time.
