“There’s no question that the Democrats, that have just won the elections and will be taking over Congress, are going to launch into investigations.”
Former US ambassador to Nato, Kurt Volker, says that as the owner of a private company involved in executive branch affairs, Elon Musk and others will be investigated by the Democrat-led Congress for impairing intelligence for military operations, which resulted in “civilian deaths” in Ukraine.
Kurt Volker was speaking to John Pienaar on Times Radio Drive. Listen live every Monday-Thursday from 4-7pm.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Former U.S. Ambassador to NATO Kurt Volker discusses the geopolitical complexities of the Russia-Ukraine war. He argues that Vladimir Putin seeks the total absorption of Ukraine rather than peace, warns against U.S. concessions, and addresses the controversial role of Elon Musk's SpaceX in impairing Ukrainian air defenses.
Whoever is responsible for it, it's happening,
and we should be trying to stop that and fix it.
And yes, you're right, if the owner of a private company
is making choices that are resulting in more deaths,
more civilian deaths at the hands of Russia,
that's a very problematic thing, and I would think people would start
to be thinking about criminal liability.
The former American ambassador to NATO is suggesting
that maybe President Trump is leading...
Trump is being led along by Vladimir Putin, being duped.
Here is Trump speaking earlier.
I think he's backing down a little bit.
I think he could be tougher.
I think he could be a lot tougher, frankly.
I think he's backing down.
I think he'd like to, frankly, I think he'd like to see it finished.
He thinks that the president, Putin,
the leader of Russia, would like to see the war
finished. Not sure the evidence completely backs that up.
Let's see what Kurt Volker thinks. The
former U.S. ambassador to NATO
and former special envoy to Ukraine. Welcome to you.
Thank you, John. It's great to be with you again.
Lovely to have you back.
So, Ambassador, you have written for Newsmax.
You said that Vladimir Putin, he's not interested in peace.
He just wants to recreate the Russian Empire and absorb Ukraine.
Do you believe that President Trump
and his envoys understand that at all?
Look, whether they understand it
or whether they're just trying to game it out.
So that they keep a peace negotiation going.
I really can't say, I don't know what's in their
heads. But what you just played from President Trump saying
that Putin wants peace, as you say,
there is zero evidence to support that.
In fact, everything points to the opposite.
Every time the United States takes a position
to provide a concession to Russia,
to do something favorable for Russia,
whether it's lifting sanctions, buying diesel.
Promising energy deals in the future.
Russia intensifies its attacks on Ukraine.
It is encouragement to Vladimir Putin.
Would it not be helpful, then,
if the United States envoys had some knowledge,
some understanding of Russian history and thinking and culture?
Because that does rather seem to be lacking.
Well, it does, because there are a couple things that jump out.
One of them is Russia always makes this assertion that,
oh, because some Ukrainians are Russian-speaking,
they're really Russians and they belong in the Russian state.
Well, you know, that's like saying Americans should all
be English because we speak English.
It is nothing of the kind.
And in fact, the most successful Ukrainians in the military
or in government or in business are native Russian speakers.
And they're very proud to be Ukrainians.
So they're missing that point.
When the Russians bring up
the European security architecture and say, oh, we need peace,
we need mutual transparency, we need restraint,
you know, we need good communication mechanisms.
The fact is that already exists.
There's nothing lacking there.
The only problem we have is that Russia is attacking that system.
So you need people who know the background here
and who know the issues in order to push
back on these Russian assertions.
And how then is it?
Is it at all possible to have the American envoys suggesting
that if only Ukraine would hand
over the Donbass territory, well, then they might be able to join NATO.
There's every reason to believe that's not, simply not the case.
That's exactly right, because all you have
to do is look at what Vladimir Putin said
in his article in the summer of 2021,
or in the demands that Russia made of NATO in December of
2021, or what they have said many, many times since then.
Ending the war in Ukraine just to cease fire
or getting land is not the end of the conflict
from Russia's perspective. That's just a prerequisite.
They talk about the lands that
they claim to have annexed as already Russian,
and they need to have them restored to Russia,
which is a bit rich to begin with. But then they still keep saying,
and we've got to make Ukraine a permanently neutral country.
We've got to change the government.
We cannot accept that Ukrainian is a separate language
or culture or identity.
It is all part of the greater Russia.
So these are frontal assaults on Ukraine's sovereignty,
its nationality, its independence.
And he's not going to stop just because he gets some land.
Yes. I mean, you contend in your piece, Ambassador, that America needs
to back Ukraine in just attacking Russia's oil revenues.
They're already 55% of the way there,
according to President Zelensky in Kyiv. But that would need
a total reversal of thinking by the president in the Oval Office.
I mean, how do you weigh the chances of that happening?
It surely looks beyond, beyond impossible.
Well, yeah, I can see why you say that, but...
If what you've been doing for the last two years isn't working,
maybe it's time to try something else.
And in this case, I think Ukraine has over the past year
demonstrated a coherent and successful strategy for going after Russia.
It is going after the
finances available to the Kremlin.
It is making sure the Russian people see that
there's an actual war going on so that it's
not some antiseptic military operation.
And they're going after the capacity of the Russian military,
both in terms of reconstituting
personnel that are lost,
as well as in the military logistics and their ability to attack
Ukraine.
If we were to reinforce that, also with Europe,
to reinforce that, that would be putting pressure
on Putin to agree to a ceasefire.
Yeah, look, I suppose one could argue that the White House,
that the Trump administration
doesn't understand what's needed.
You could also argue they perfectly well understand.
With Ukraine in this struggle, we hear Ukraine say that SpaceX,
Elon Musk's SpaceX, has slowed
down the satellite technology that enables them
to intercept Russia's Shahed drones.
That means the attacks are getting through Ukraine's defences.
Musk denies that he's taken that step.
He insists that it's a technological problem at this stage.
He's changed his story.
But the latest story is that it's a technological problem.
Ambassador, who do you believe?
Well, look, I believe the facts.
If the drones that are flying faster than 161 kilometers
an hour lose coverage, that's a fact.
And what the cause is, you know, whether it's Musk or whether it's
the Pentagon or whether it's something else, doesn't really matter.
That's a fact. And it's a change from what had been working before.
So rather than pointing fingers,
I would really like to see both the administration
and Elon Musk saying, let's get to the bottom of this.
Let's fix this.
But someone knows the answer.
And we hear President Zelensky pointing the finger very clearly.
He's convinced the answer lies with Elon Musk's SpaceX.
And if that's right, you say it doesn't
matter, but surely it does matter.
If there is a conscious effort to impair Ukraine's air defences,
that is a big problem.
It's not a misunderstanding.
It's a complete lack of support.
It is not the way an ally should ever behave.
When I say it doesn't matter, what I meant is that...
And whoever is responsible for it, it's happening.
And we should be trying to stop that and fix it.
And yes, you're right.
The owner of a private company is making choices
that are resulting in more deaths,
more civilian deaths at the hands of Russia.
That's a very problematic thing. And I would
think people would start to be thinking about criminal liability.
Interesting. A strong, strong point.
Criminal liability. Tell me a bit more about that and
also the possibility
that congressional investigations might come into play here,
because there has been talk,
Ambassador of Elon Musk, among many others,
being questioned by congressional committee under oath.
Yeah, there's no question that the Democrats
that have just won the elections and will be
taking over Congress are going to launch into investigations.
There is too much buildup pressure
within the Democratic Party for them to resist
those temptations to do investigations. They'll
definitely do it. And the people that will
be most vulnerable to this, I would argue, are
the civilians like Elon Musk, not a government official, who has some
protections based on official duties.
Were they following orders? Were they in a chain
of command? How does that work?
In the case of Elon Musk, if he's just making these decisions
on his own, that would be very problematic
for the civilian leader of a large business.
Similarly, you have to really think about what
is the role of the U.S. special envoys. I think they
They are, as I was, special government employees.
So they are covered as part of the executive branch,
but they have not given up their separate
business activities.
And that is something that is going to be investigated,
I'm sure, by Congress as well.
And how is it possible, just for our understanding,
how is it possible, and I recognize this is
a might, it's at this moment a hypothesis,
how is it possible that Elon Musk may face
a test of criminal liability?
Well, you know, that's what has to be investigated.
You have to see exactly what did happen
and who made the decision and what were the consequences
of that.
And then would there be some liability for loss
of life based on the decisions that he
made?
I think that you'd have to you'd really have
to investigate what are the U.S. laws concerning
the actions of the business and whether they were fully complied with.
Are these, is this a criminal liability, which at least in theory on...
on legal paper, as it were,
might involve the possibility of a jail sentence? Are we
talking about that degree of possible culpability?
I'm not going to get drawn out, John, on speculating
what exactly it is. I think it's something
that is going to be investigated, and then we'll see.
All right. Ambassador Kurt Volker,
pleasure to talk to you as always. Thank you for joining me.
Thanks, John.