Compared! 2019 Acura RDX vs Audi Q5 vs BMW X3 vs Volvo XC60 vs Mercedes-Benz GLC

Bumpy Ride
25 followers
43 Video Views·Oct 21, 2022
Just a quick note, Acura flew me out here to test drive all these cars
and they were so confident in the new RDX that they gave us not just the cars that compete in
the segment but according to them the best cars in the segment to compare against the RDX.
Are you shopping for a luxury crossover that will fit your entire family? Well,
I've got five to choose from right here. I've got the Audi Q5, the Mercedes Benz GLC,
the BMW X3, the Volvo XC60, and of course the brand's making new Acura RDX. Which one of
these cars is right for you and your family? Well, let's take them for a ride and find out.
Can you guess what's under the hood of the Audi? There's a theme here, of course,
it's a two-liter turbo that puts out 273 horsepower and 252 pound-foot of torque.
It is made it to a seven-speed transmission and of course since it's an Audi it has quattro. Now,
there's something special about this quattro system. Let me tell you about it. What's unique
about this Audi is that it's predominantly a front-wheel drive car. You're like, hey Roman,
it's a quattro. Yeah, I get it's a quattro but Audi has a system that if these front wheels
lose traction within literally the blink of an eye the Audi can send power to the rear wheels
making it a true all-wheel drive car. But for fuel economy, if you're driving this down the road,
it's mainly a front-wheel drive car. Of course, a common theme among all these cars is a turbocharger,
specifically a two-liter turbocharged engine. And what I really enjoy about the German competitors
is that they have a silky smooth two-liter. Two-liter is not a lot of power when you think
about it. It's actually, well, it's actually pretty small for a big vehicle like this to
concede five with all of your stuff. But let me just give it the beans and I'll try to demonstrate
what I mean. There's just this effortless flow of power and the engine note feels refined.
It sounds smooth and silky. It's never harsh and that's something that the Germans do really well.
They can take a small engine and move a big car in a very pleasant and refined manner. Let me do it
one more time because it is really something that is very German indeed. No harshness.
Those shifts just happen so smoothly, so naturally. And next thing you know,
I am exceeding the speed limit like that. This Audi Q5 starts at over $41,000 and because it's
been very successful, it's actually one of the segment-leading cars. And this is a car that a
kind of entry-level luxury crossovers. Let's talk about the good, bad, and weird about this Q5.
Let's start with the good. This is probably one of my favorite cars in the segment because the
interior is just a class above this class. It's very well laid out. It's very functional and it's
very German in a good way. Now the bad, well, there are a couple of bad things about it. First and
foremost, it's the price. While it starts at over $41,000, if you start loading up all the goodies,
it gets expensive very quickly. And the weird, well, two things actually. First,
these taillights, they're built into the tailgate. So when you open it up, you've got kind of this
weird empty space here. And talking about empty spaces, no exhaust pipes. They're hidden underneath.
That's kind of weird. Of course, the other thing I like about this Audi is the interior. Audi has
really set the bar when it comes to their interior design, their use of space, and of course,
this instrument panel, which is completely configurable. I can see why this car is a
bestseller in the segment. Not only is the suspension firm yet relaxed when you want it to be,
not only is the space in here comfortable and yet sporty, and not only is the driving satisfying
yet functional, you put all that in one package and you end up with a car that is a bestseller
in this segment. Can you guess what's under the hood of the Volvo XC60? I bet you can,
because it's a two liter turbo that puts out 250 horsepower and 258 pound foot of torque.
And like all the other cars, it is of course an XC, which means cross country, which means this
is an all wheel drive car. Now we've taken these off road and while it's very luxurious, it's
actually surprisingly good when the road gets rough. You know, when the Chinese first bought
Volvo from Ford, I thought, well, that's the end of Volvo. But boy, was I surprised. This car and
many of the other Volvos that are now being produced are some of the best Volvos ever.
And the immediate sensation you get when you get behind the wheel of this car is the fact that
it's tall. And we've taken it off road up Goldmine Hill, and it is by far one of the best, one of the
most capable off roaders. So if you're looking for a car that is capable of, let's not go rock
climbing, but you know, taking you and the family to a Sunday brunch and then to your cabin, and
let's say it's snowing, I think this is kind of the perfect car for that. In terms of its driving
dynamics, well, let's find out. Let's give it a little bit of the beans and see how smooth and
refined this engine really is. Here we go. Good torque, kind of slows down. Yeah, it's a tall vehicle.
This is certainly not the race car of the bunch, but it is very capable. It is very
understated. You know, it is everything that a Volvo should be. The good, the bad, and the weird. First,
let's start with the good. I really like the design of this Volvo. This Thor's hammer design
in the headlight is way cool. And maybe what's even better is that there actually is a Volvo
here to compare because when Ford sold it to a Chinese company, a lot of us in the business
thought that Volvo was doomed. And yet the company is flourishing and designing and building really
sexy cars. Now the bad, while they're building really sexy and fun cars, this car gets expensive.
It starts at over $40,000, but if you want to get the super turbo electrified version of this,
it's going to get very expensive very quickly. And the weird, here's the weirdest part,
I think this is the only company that has an ignition knob that you turn to start and stop
the car. While it's pretty weird, what isn't weird is actually this right here. It's this iPad that
basically serves as your control center, your infotainment center for the entire car.
It's very Apple-like, and if you're into Apple products, I suspect you'll really like this
product because it scrolls just like an iPad. You can scroll up, you can scroll down, you can
scroll across. And just by accident, you can fold the back seat headrest down and bonk the
misbehaving kids in the back. Pretty darn cool. While the other German and Japanese competitors
are much more, let's call it Autobahn focused, this Volvo feels like it's much more of an
all-rounder. It's a car that will be both comfortable on-road and off-road. And it's a
car that over the years, even though it's now owned by the Chinese and still built in Sweden,
has that kind of Swedish baked-in safety goodness. It's a car that I really enjoy,
and having owned several Volvos, I can highly recommend. But this is a very competitive field,
so let's go on to the next one. So what do you think's under the hood of the BMW? Can you guess?
Of course, it's a two-liter. Puts out 248 horsepower and 258 pound-foot of torque. And
since this is the X-Drive, of course, it powers all four wheels. Now, this by far is one of the
sportiest of the bunch and yet one of the most conservative of the bunch. Isn't that weird?
The styling says, I'm here to have dinner, but the engine says, I'm here to party.
BMW has set itself upon the mission of reinventing how we shift cars,
and for the most part, that mission has not been successful. Let me show you what I mean.
Here's the newest BMW gear shift lever. Now, to go forward, you put it backward,
or to go backward, you push it forward. Why? I don't know. It's a BMW thing. So let's put it
in the gear and let's take it on the road and see how this car drives. Of course, these cars are all
relatively new, and this car has a classic BMW interiors. And BMW interiors, to me, are like
schwarze beer, dark beer. You either love it or you hate it. And in my case, I think it's getting a
little kind of outdated. It's very linear. It's very logically laid out, but it's just a little
bit boring. So how does the BMW drive? Well, let's give it the beans. Definitely is the smoothest of
the bunch. That engine is, I'd say, even a notch smoother than the Audi. It's just really well
suited for this car. You can, of course, get a hotter version of the engine, but why would you?
Because this has plenty of power for the kind of commuting that this car will end up doing.
The good, the bad, and the weird of the X3. The good is that it's been around a long time. If you
want the 3 Series of the crossover bunch, this is it. And that means sharp driving dynamics and,
of course, that BMW reputation for being very sporty. Now, the bad is that this car, at least
in my eye, is very staid and a little bit too conservative. I think BMW needs to kind of up
their game like they did with the X2 and make it a little bit more interesting. And the weird, well,
there's a lot of weird. Let's start with this. Over here, it says 3.0i, and usually that would
mean it's a 3 liter, but it's not. It's a 2 liter. Another weird thing, for the longest time, if you
wanted to get under the hood of a car, all you had to do was pull the lever. But not anymore. BMW makes
you pull it twice. Otherwise, it won't open it. That's pretty darn weird. Downshifts rapidly,
and once you're in the torque band, you can really start to feel that steering firm up,
and you can really get a sense of the fact that this car was designed by engineers that
love to drive fast. Very little body roll, very linear brakes, and actually a suspension
that's classic German in that it both absorbs bumps, but yet gives you enough road feel
that you can actually start to want to push this around corners a little bit.
Sometimes I wonder if manufacturers actually build anything other than a 2 liter turbo,
because once again, we have a 2 liter turbo, but this one puts out only 241 horsepower. But
it's made it to a 9-speed automatic, so least amount of horsepower and second greatest number
of gears. Of course, it's also all-wheel drive, and since it's a Mercedes, it's got two stars on
the hood. That's almost a good, bad, and weird. Let's take this Mercedes for a ride now. It's a
big, heavy vehicle, so the least amount of horsepower in this group might show up when we
give it the beans. A lot of torque up front, and then it kind of slows down, so I think what
Mercedes has done is they've upped the torque right at the start of the power band, and then
as you get into the higher gears, it kind of doesn't fall off a cliff, but let's say gently
rolls down the hill. But overall, this Mercedes drives really well. These cars are within
a gnat's whisker of competing with each other in kind of their driving characteristics.
Let's talk about the good, bad, and the weird of this Mercedes GLC. The good, now this may seem
like a small thing, but to me it's not. It's these vents. Oh my gosh, they're so satisfying to move
back and forth. If God were designing a vent for a car, I'm betting this is exactly how he would
design it. Now the bad is back here. Let me show you. These cars are all about utility,
and the Mercedes has some of the least in this class. It's not particularly awful, but for a car
that is really about getting a lot of stuff and people in, it could use more space, and that's
probably because of the way this is shaped. I mean, you're losing space, and you're gaining
sexiness in a sloping rear hatch. Now another good thing is, unlike the Audi, these are actually
semi-real. The exhaust pokes out of them, even though it's not actually part of this bevel.
Now the weird, that's an easy one. Mercedes gives you not one, but two ways to actually
control the infotainment system. Let me show you inside. You gotta figure at some point,
some engineer at Mercedes said, you know what, I'm not sure how people should control this
kind of floaty screen. Should it be a knob, or should it be a touchpad? And somebody else said,
you know what, Hans, let's give them both. And that's pretty weird, because you can control
the screen using this touchpad that rests on top of this knob, and they both essentially do the
same thing, except of course with this touchscreen, you can also write letters, so that you could,
for instance, look for people in your address book. What I like about the Mercedes the most
is really the fact that I've got a really interesting interior design, and that's where
they also all compete. The BMW is very linear, the Acura is very modern, the Audi is very classy,
and this Mercedes is kind of a combination of all three of those. It's classy, sporty,
and yet at the same time very intuitive and very linear. I'd have a hard time choosing a winner.
On these press trips, guess what three words I hear the most? Best in class. Manufacturers love
to use those three words to describe their vehicle, but in a lot of ways they're right
about the Acura RDX. Once again, a two liter turbo that puts out 272 horsepower, but 280
pound foot of torque. Now it has, best in class, 10 speed automatic transmission that is mated to
Acura's latest generation of super handling all-wheel drive, and this all-wheel drive system
is pretty funky. It allows the car to appropriate up to 70% of the torque to the rear wheels,
and then take that torque and split it 100% to the left or right wheel, giving you a true
torque vectoring system. What do I mean by true torque vectoring system? Well,
there are two kinds of torque vectoring all-wheel drive system. One that breaks the inside wheel
when you're going around a corner, letting the car pivot around the wheel that's being
slowed down, or the one that actually increases torque to the outside wheel instead of slowing
down the inside wheel, and this super handling all-wheel drive system is the second kind. It
can appropriate up to 100% of the 70% of torque that goes to the back to the outside wheel going
around a turn, making it feel much more sporty. Now we've come to the part of the review that
you're probably most interested in. If it were my money, which car would I buy? So let's talk about
the Acura first. Remember we started this Acura segment by saying three words, best in class,
and the Acura offers least in class pricing. The two-wheel drive starts just around $38,000,
and if you go to the four-wheel drive, it starts at under $40,000. The other European competing cars
start a little bit higher, but end significantly higher. You can get up to, well, almost 60k in
some of those cars, and that's a lot of money. So the question is, for the least amount of money,
are you getting the most amount of car? Well, let's accelerate and talk about this two-liter,
which does produce best-in-class horsepower and torque. So here we go. The good, the bad,
and the weird of the new RDX. The good, oh, you can see it. Can you guess what it is? Look at
those exhaust pipes. I mean, those are cannons sticking out the back of this Acura. That to me
says this is a serious car with serious performance. The bad, well, that's really simple.
Acura has now gone all in on a push-button transmission. Outside of the BMW, I can't think
of a more unintuitive way to shift the car into drive. And the weird, well, let me show you that
on the inside. All of these cars, of course, have different drive modes, but take a look at this new
center stack of the Acura RDX. The most prominent thing in this car is this massive knob that lets
you select between the different drive modes that this car has, from snow, comfort, sport,
to sport plus. This car, at least the way it's designed, says, I'm serious about letting you
change all the parameters that let you drive this car in different modes. So for my money,
what car would I go for? Well, let me break it down for you in a very straightforward way. If I
wanted the most off-road worthy car, I would definitely go for the Volvo. If I wanted the most
luxurious and the most stylish, I'd go for the Audi or the Mercedes. If I wanted the most powerful
and the sportiest, I'd go for the BMW or the Acura. And that's really the bottom line. None of these
cars have significant issues that would keep me from buying them. They're all really good
in very different ways, and it really depends on what you're looking for. There are other cars that
compete in this segment, like the Infiniti and the Lexus. Why aren't they here? Well, this is a program
put on by Acura, and they felt like they should benchmark the Germans, and that's why the German
and Swedish competitors are here, even though I think if you're cross-shopping an Acura, you're
also going to be at the Lexus and Infiniti dealership. So by now, you've probably figured out that one of
the others, and that of course is the RDX, because these other four, they're all European, and they have a distinct
European flavor, while the RDX, that's a much more, well, let's call it American car, because it's
designed and engineered here in America. As always, this is Roman reporting for the Fast Lane Car.
Check out tflcar.com for more news, views, and of course, real world, family, luxury crossover reviews.
See you guys next time. Ciao.
