Colored Pencil VS Watercolor Pencil: Which Is Better for Realism?

Inspire to Draw
26 followers
Nov 13, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Are coloured pencils or watercolour pencils better for realism?
Well in today's video we'll be
comparing coloured pencil to watercolour pencils to find out
which ones are better for realism.
Hi I'm Amy and if you are new around here
and enjoy these kinds of videos then please don't
forget to like, hype and subscribe as it really helps my channel out.
But anyway let's jump
straight in to today's video.
Coloured pencils are a type of pencil made with a pigmented core
And they are encased inside a wooden casing.
The binders are made up of wax or oil,
and the binders are what holds the pigment together
inside of the pencil.
This allows you to spread the pigment
across the surface of the paper.
Colored pencils are known for their superior quality,
high pigmentation, layering ability,
and smooth blending results.
And so it's no wonder that many artists
will use colored pencils for realism.
Watercolor pencils are a type of pencil that are soluble in water,
meaning that when you apply water to the binder, they break down.
This allows them to create very painterly looks in your drawings.
So by carefully balancing
the precision of drawing with the fluidity of painting
you can create very realistic results in your art.
Before we compare different drawing techniques
with the fluidity of painting,
let's first take a side-by-side look at both pencils
and discuss some of their main features.
When you first look at these pencils side by side they
do look very similar however they do have
some fundamental differences between them.
Colored pencils are a dry medium and they are activated
when a pencil stroke makes contact with the paper.
The pigment is then deposited into the tooth of the paper
along with the binder.
Although coloured pencils can be used on their own without any other
materials to activate them,
there are several different tools you can use with coloured pencils
to give you very realistic results in your drawings
and I will show some of these tools
later on in the video. Watercolour pencils
on the other hand are designed to dissolve in water. The
water gently breaks down the binder creating a very saturated
and painterly look.
in your drawings. When you are using watercolors you will need
to use them in combination with a
few other materials, for example paint brushes.
However you can also use watercolor pencils as
a dry medium as long as you don't break them down with water.
So now that we have taken a
side-by-side look of both of these pencils let's put them
into practice with some drawing examples
and techniques. And the first technique we're going
to focus on is layering and blending.
Layering is a technique that allows you to slowly build up depth,
dimension and texture in your drawings
to create a very realistic effect.
It is a very important technique to use,
but the process of creating layers is very different compared
to coloured pencils and watercolour pencils.
And to demonstrate these techniques,
I am drawing an apple in both coloured pencils and watercolour pencils.
The first layers that I'm applying to my drawings are the base layers.
Base layers are the initial layers of colour that you apply
and they serve as the foundation to your drawing.
When I start adding in my base layers,
this process is very similar with coloured pencils
and watercolour pencils.
I am just shading with the side of my pencils
and making sure that I keep my pencil pressure nice
and light to create that smooth shading.
And as we start to build up our layers,
That is where our techniques will change.
With coloured pencil, you continue adding layers.
As you create layers,
pencil particles will fall into the grooves of the paper,
filling in the white paper grain.
So the more layers you add,
the more of the white paper grain is filled in
and you will eventually achieve a very smooth result.
And I make sure that I build up a lot of tone, depth.
and contrast in my drawings as I am building up my layers
because this is what is going to give
your drawings a really realistic effect.
When I get to a point where I'm happy with the amount
of layers that I've created I then start blending my pencils
and when you blend your pencils it will
help you to achieve those really smooth blending results.
For this demonstration I am using the
burnishing technique which is where you apply
a heavy pressure with your pencils to blend the
Blend the colours out.
I make sure that I'm using sharp pencils,
blend in circular motions and I also hold
my pencil closer to the tip when I'm blending as well.
You can blend your pencils with coloured pencils,
a white coloured pencil or even something
like a colourless pencil blender.
Once you have finished blending you should have
a very smooth and finished result and
most of the white paper grain will be eliminated.
However, one downside,
especially if you're using wax-based pencils, is that they can
can create a bit of a wax bloom
and wax bloom is where you get a cloudy shiny film on the surface
of the paper. When it comes to watercolour pencils our layering
and blending process will be a bit
different. Once I've applied my base layers
with the watercolour pencils I actually go in with some
water and blend the layers out.
I actually use filbert rounded brushes because I find that these
paint brushes are the best for getting into all of the corners
and grooves of the paper. Also
So you want to make sure that your brush
is an appropriate size for blending.
If your brush is too small you can get very patchy results
with blending and if it's too
big you can over blend areas all at once.
I'm also drawing on watercolour paper
and that is because watercolour pencils are considered
a wet medium if you were using them with water.
And the paper that I'm using is a hot press watercolor paper
so it's a smooth type of paper
and I've also been able to use this paper
for my colored pencil drawing as well. When I am blending
I make sure that I blend from light to dark
and this is extremely important because you don't
want to muddy up your colors and also lose some of your lighter areas.
I also make sure that every
Every time I blend a colour out and transition into another colour,
I am washing my paintbrushes
before I do this and the reason why I
do this is because I don't want to transfer one pigment into
another area of my drawing.
Once I have blended out these initial layers I wait for the paper to
completely dry before I go back in with my pencils
and then what I do is I create more layers because
as I said earlier on layers are important
for building up all of the tones, contrast values
So the process for building up layers with water
Watercolour pencils is to lay some colour down initially,
blend it out with water.
Add another layer, blend it out with water and so on.
When I am blending my layers with water,
I'm only using a very small amount of water as well.
And this is because you really don't want
to oversaturate your paper with water.
So in terms of the layering and blending technique,
you can see that it's actually quite different between coloured pencils
and watercolour pencils.
Once I have finished the layering and blending process,
It's really important to go back in and redefine some details.
And that is because when you've gone
and blended everything out you can actually achieve
a very smooth result and lose some of those finer details
and textures and that is the key to creating very realistic drawings.
So you want to make sure that you're redefining these details.
When it comes to coloured pencils I'm making sure that I use very
sharp pencils and sharp pencils will help us create more finer details
because they are more refined.
I also find that oil-based
oil-based pencils are better
for creating details than wax-based pencils.
And this is because oil-based pencils have a harder core
and so they are able to retain their sharp point for longer.
So I'm focusing on adding in a few extra details
in this apple.
For example, really focusing on some of the line work,
some of the markings on the apple
and redefining these areas with my pencils.
You don't need to use any other materials
in combination with colored pencils
to create realistic results.
However there are some tools that can help you really take
your drawings to that next level.
An X-Acto knife is a craft knife and what you can do with this
is gently scratch away some layers of coloured pencils.
This will allow you to reveal some lighter tones underneath
but also pull up very specific
details another tool that you can use to create details
and preserve highlights
is an embossing tool
and you can use an embossing tool before you start a
drawing process to gently score the paper and flatten
the tooth of the paper
and when you do this it will allow the white paper grain
to stay white and be preserved
and it just helps to show up some extra fine
details an X-Acto knife and an embossing tool
can work really well with colored pencils
However, it doesn't work as well with watercolour pencils.
As a final step in my drawing process,
I always go in and add in some more highlights.
And highlights are very important
because it will help you to create a lot of value
and contrast in your drawings
and give it that finished look.
To create highlights in my coloured pencil drawings,
I normally use a white pencil.
And I prefer to use a white pencil that is wax-based
Because wax-based pencils are slightly...
more opaque than oil-based pencils.
When I redefine some of my highlights in watercolour
drawings I normally use a white watercolour pencil
and I find that the white watercolour
pencil is actually very opaque and quite bold
so it's able to give me some very bright white
highlights. So overall I think we have managed
to create a very realistic look with both coloured
pencils and watercolour pencils
and I was actually really impressed with the results that I got with
with the watercolour pencils.
As I'm so used to using coloured pencils in my drawings,
I think that as long as you are using the correct techniques
and processes with these pencils,
you can definitely achieve a realistic result with either pencil.
But I would be really interested to know which drawing you prefer.
Do you prefer the coloured pencil drawing or the watercolour drawing?
Let me know in the comments below.
If you did enjoy today's video,
please make sure that you like, hype and subscribe
Subscribe as it really helps my channel out.
And you can also become a member by joining my channel
and getting access to loads of
exclusive rewards on my channel.
I will be back very soon with a brand new video,
but until then, keep creating.
Bye everyone!
