Classical City Guide: New York

ClassicistORG
72 followers
19 Video Views·Dec 25, 2022
I'm Francis Moroney, architectural historian, and I'm pleased to introduce the ICAA Classical
City Guide, a series of videos showcasing outstanding examples of classical architecture
and design in cities in America and abroad. We begin here in New York City, America's preeminent
commercial center and the one American city that recapitulates the whole building history
of the Western world.
What better place to begin than Grand Central Terminal, the proverbial crossroads of a million
lives. The majestic space of the main concourse is one of the treasures of New York, indeed of
the entire United States. But for me, the great thing about Grand Central Terminal
is on the outside, the monumental sculpture, the glory of commerce, the work of Jules-Félix
Coutin. It is probably the greatest monumental sculpture in the United States and reminds us
of the important relationship between sculpture and architecture in the classical tradition.
Just to the west of here is the New York Public Library, the most fully realized, the greatest
Beaux-Arts classical building in New York. Its Fifth Avenue Terrace is adorned with
these bronze flagpole bases that are among the most beautiful things in the city. Inside,
Astor Hall is an entirely marble room. Floor, ceilings, and walls. Around the back of the New
Bryant Park was redesigned in the 1930s in a classical style. The rear terrace of the New York
Public Library was the architect's cue as he sort of wrapped it around the park and in so doing
created what is likely the greatest classical park in the United States. A little bit farther
uptown on Fifth Avenue and 70th Street is the wonderful museum that we call the Frick Collection,
a museum in fact that is just so filled with masterpieces of painting and decorative art
that it boggles the mind. Originally the home of Henry Clay Frick in the 1930s, the architect
John Russell Pope greatly enlarged the building and transformed it into the museum that it is today.
The garden court inside is a place of great tranquility, one of the masterpieces of John
Russell Pope. An example of more recent classicism is to be found in the reception room of the Frick
Collection which was designed by the architect John Barrington Bailey. On the outside of the
70th Street it works together with the beautiful garden by Russell Page to create a very tranquil
and beautiful setting and a great reminder to us that the classical tradition survived
well into the 1970s and survives to this day and into the future. A few blocks farther uptown is
the Metropolitan Museum of Art, probably the greatest collection of classical art in America
from the extraordinary Greek and Roman galleries with that beautiful vaulted corridor by Charles
Colin McKim to the paintings of Paolo Veronese and Guido Reni to the classical galleries in
the American Wing which house the art from the 1820s to the 1850s in galleries that were in
fact designed by a contemporary classical architect Thomas Gordon Smith. Moving over
to the west side of the city, the Apthorpe apartment building is a great example of the
New York apartment building at its best but it's also a great example of how a building can be
based on the triumphal arch, the entryway to this building on Broadway. The great barrel vaulted
passage is magnificent but especially magnificent is the figure sculpture on the outside of the
building which is, by the way, purely anonymous work. We have no idea who did it but what we do
know is that it's of a quality that is simply as good as anything to be found in the United States,
indeed probably as good as anything of its kind to be found anywhere in the world. Moving farther
uptown from that we come to the neighborhood that we call Morningside Heights which is defined by
the great campus of Columbia University, arguably the best classical university campus in the United
States, the work of Charles Follin McKim of McKim, Mead & White. And while the campus as a whole is a
joy to experience, the building that I want to draw your attention to is a lesser noticed building on
the campus, not designed by McKim but designed by Howells and Stokes, the Stokes being the great
architect and historian Isaac Newton Phelps Stokes. It's St. Paul's Chapel. It's a beautiful compact
structure of brick and terracotta that actually is one of the loveliest classical buildings in all
of New York City. The upper west side is separated from the upper east side by Central Park. On the
upper east side on East 95th Street, just east of 5th Avenue, is a townhouse designed by the great Philadelphia
architect Horace Trumbauer, built for a woman named Marion Carhartt a few years ago. An addition
was built onto it, designed by the New York architect Zivkovic Connelly with the British
architect John Simpson. This addition, which basically doubles the size of the house and
turns it into something that we call the Carhartt Mansion, is the best example I know of in Manhattan
of contemporary classicism. A building with load-bearing masonry walls, beautiful detailing
that reminds us that classicism is a living tradition. It is with us still and with us into
the future. And now we move from uptown to downtown to where New York City began
into a wonderful example of the Greek revival architecture of the 1830s.
Before the middle of the 18th century, we knew very little about ancient Greek architecture,
but as our knowledge increased, a Greek mania set in in America and Greek revival became the
national architectural style. Every city had to have its Parthenon. The Custom House of 1833-42
is New York's Parthenon, with its Doric colonnade and its big, blank, brooding pediment. Right
around the corner from here is one of the most beautiful skyscrapers in New York,
100 Broadway, designed by Bruce Price. We forget that it wasn't until the classical language was
brought to bear on the problem of tall office building design that our skyscrapers became
beautiful additions to a harmonious cityscape. This building, more than any other, reminds us
of that moment. A little farther uptown from here, in a neighborhood that we call the Charlton King
Van Dam Historic District, is 37 Charlton Street, my favorite example of a federal-style row house,
reminding us that from the earliest days of the Republic, New York was a classical city.
Just off Madison Square is the Appellate Division Courthouse, designed by James Brown Lord,
built in 1900, a sort of Palladian country house reinterpreted as a New York City courthouse.
What's really special about this building is its incorporation of sculpture. Not just relief
sculpture, but full statuary, as you see ranged along the top of the building,
etched against the sky. There are very few churches, houses of worship in New York City,
designed in a classical style. In this city, Gothic has always dominated for houses of worship,
but one classical church on West 16th Street is St. Francis Xavier, designed by Patrick C. Keeley,
a Roman Catholic church of Baroque splendor, both outside and particularly inside. A very
rare experience in New York. New York is much more than just Manhattan, and for the purposes
of this series, our mission would not be complete without a visit to the beautiful
sister city of Brooklyn. We're in Brooklyn, which is today one of the five boroughs of
New York City, but was once an independent city all its own, with its own grandeur,
exemplified by the Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Arch, with its magnificent bronze sculpture by
particularly the crowning quadriga, a classical form of a chariot pulled by four horses,
etched beautifully against an open blue sky of a kind that you never see in Manhattan.
The arch faces Prospect Park, a great Olmsted and Vaux Park like Central Park in Manhattan,
and it's at this entrance, the Grand Army Plaza entrance to Prospect Park,
that we really see the City Beautiful movement of the turn of the 20th century at its very best.
The City Beautiful movement wasn't simply about creating monumental buildings, but it was about
bringing beauty into the most quotidian aspects of people's everyday lives in America's cities,
as we see here with the attention paid to the design of the pavement, with the small golden
bricks laid in a herringbone pattern, the beautiful fence with its bronze vases, and
the 12-sided Guastavino vaulted streetcar shelters. Not far from here, in Brooklyn Heights,
is one of the great buildings of the early 20th century in America, the Brooklyn Trust Company,
at the corner of Montague Street and Clinton Street, the masterpiece of York and Sawyer,
the greatest bank architects in America. This building has a quality of stonework that makes
your heart melt. It's so great. Right around the corner from it is the Brooklyn Appellate Courthouse.
It's somewhat austere. It's not a heavily embellished building. In the Great Depression,
the feeling was that we should go simple, and yet the building was designed and built with great
care and quality. And who would think that a classical building of white stone set high
on a podium behind a garden could somehow be made to fit into this tight-knit neighborhood
of Victorian row houses, and yet the Brooklyn architects Slee and Bryson pulled it off as
though it were the most natural thing in the world, showing us that the classical language
of architecture can really be made to work in any context at all.
We've seen only the smallest sampling of New York's classical heritage. Henry Hope Reed once
said that New York is one of the great classical cities of the world, along with Rome, Paris,
Vienna, St. Petersburg, and Dublin. It may seem New York has taken a vacation from the classical,
but the city is still a work in progress, and the best is yet to come.
