Claire Saffitz Makes an Apple Tart | Dessert Person

Best Comfort Food
50 followers
Oct 27, 2022
Oh god.
That was really, I don't know, that was really dumb. I didn't have to do that at all,
but I feel good about it. Hey everyone, I'm Claire Saffitz. Welcome to my home kitchen. Today I'm
showing you an ideal fall recipe. Be great for holidays, for Thanksgiving, any occasion at all.
It is a really beautiful and simple apple tart.
The source material for this recipe is a classic French apple tart. It's one of the first things
I remember making in culinary school. And I remember making it thinking like, I don't feel
like this is going to be that good. And then I ate it and it was delicious and incredible. And I
take it home. I took it home and ate the whole thing. So a classic French apple tart has thin
layers of apple layered over an apple compote baked on a simple tart crust. That's it. It is
sort of perfect in every way. But of course this particular recipe has, I think like a list of
little extra steps and little extra ingredients and things to make it extra special.
So ingredients. I have six apples. These are Pink Ladies. Just use whatever baking apple you like.
Pink Ladies are great. I also like Honeycrisp. Those are good ones. We're getting into apple
season. So if you can find fresh ones, not cold storage apples that tend to be kind of dry. We
have apple cider. This is unsweetened, unfiltered apple cider. Some dark brown sugar. Demerara
sugar. All purpose flour just for rolling out the pastry. Kosher salt. Six tablespoons unsalted
butter. One beaten egg for brushing the pastry. Some apricot jam for glaze. And half of a vanilla
bean. So this recipe uses the rough puff pastry in dessert person. Check out our episode where we
show you how to make it. Puff pastry and apples are a match made in heaven, of course. You could
also just use regular pie dough. So just one portion of that. Very little special equipment
involved. It just takes a little bit of some prep. I have a potato masher. That's really helpful for
making the compote. Pastry brush. Obviously a vegetable peeler for the apples. Then a couple
of saucepans. That's it. It's a free form tart. So you just bake it as a slab on a baking sheet.
What is a compote? It's basically a cooked down, lightly sweetened fruit mixture. So like
applesauce is technically a type of compote. And we are making a much sort of richer, slightly
sweeter, very thick applesauce. Somewhere between applesauce and apple butter. I have two and a half
cups of apple cider here. And a quarter cup I'm going to set aside for later. I have six
tablespoons unsalted butter. I'm going to do four in the saucepan. It's a half a stick. Set that
aside for later. Am I doing this right? Hold on. Yes. So the dark brown sugar. It's not a lot of
sugar because the natural sugars in the apples and in the apple cider concentrate and sweeten
the mixture over time. I'm going to do a little bit of salt. Just a half teaspoon. And the vanilla.
So basically what I'm doing here is I'm bringing together the ingredients for toffee.
And I'm going to cook it and make sort of a very quick toffee. And then I'm going to use that to
caramelize the apples. And then I add the apple cider and cook it all down. So basically what
I'm trying to do is develop all of these flavors that go really well with apple. So if you don't
have a vanilla bean, and again this is just half of a bean, you can just use extract. What I like
to do is add a little bit of water to help get it going. And that just encourages the sugar to
dissolve. Because sometimes when you make toffee, I've had problems where the mixture separates and
you have the butter kind of sitting on top. And then it's ruined. You got to start over. In this
case, I'm not going as far as cooking it into candy. I'm just boiling it all together and then
adding the apples. But I think it's a helpful little trick. So I'm going to set this over my stove.
Over like medium. And I want to bring it to a boil. Really try to get rid of the water,
create some flavor, develop some really good caramel notes. And while that's happening,
I'm going to peel and chop half of my apples. So three of the six apples. I'm going to leave
it there. I'll keep my eye on it. I have three pink ladies here. And here's how I prep apples.
You probably caught this in our Tarte Tatin episode from way back. You'll just use a knife
and trim off the very, very bottom and the very top. Not really necessary in this case,
because I'm just chopping everything. But I like to remove the peel close to the core.
And then take your peeler. You can either go straight down from tip to tail, rotating.
Or you can do like a, like a slinky spiral horse's neck. What's it called? Horse's neck?
Horse's tail? Horse's tail? You guys know? Like the, what's it called in a cocktail where you
have like the long twist of lemon peel? It's called a horse's neck? Tail. One of those. I
don't know. You know what I'm talking about. Well, apparently not. I'll look it up. Anyway,
sometimes this to me is a little bit tedious, but then you get this nice long piece, whatever.
But anyway, the point is peel your apples. Then in the recipe, it says to core the apples,
which you do want to do because you don't want to use the cores, but I don't really core it.
I'll show you what I do. I just cut down along the one side of the core to remove a lobe of the
apple flesh. By the way, this is, I can, I can hear this bubbling. So I'm just going to give
it a little stir. Now toffee is a little bit different than caramel. Caramel is where you're
melting sugar and bringing it up to the temperature at which it starts to take on
color. Toffee is not the same. You can stir it basically. So rather than cutting the apple in
half and scooping out the core and then chopping it, that is more work than you need to do.
What I like to do is cut down alongside one part of the core and remove a lobe of the apple flesh.
You can see there's the core. Here's my apple. And then I have a cut side and I lay it down and
I just cut along the other three sides of the core. So sometimes you kind of don't cut in the
right place and maybe you leave a little flesh on there. You maybe take a little seed with you,
but generally speaking, you know, this is a very efficient way of cutting apples. And then
this all gets mashed down. So like the dimensions of the apples really don't matter at all. I just
give it a super rough chop. So the color has gotten a little bit darker and I can smell it.
It's doing the thing where the water is gone. So the bubbles are getting
slower and thicker looking. So carefully add your apples. The next phase is to caramelize
these apples. Now, how well they caramelize depends on a lot of things. Depends on the
type of apple, the level of moisture in the apple, the freshness of the apple.
So in some cases, especially with cold storage apples, you might actually get browning on your
apples. In other cases, they're just going to release liquid and not really caramelized,
but either way, we just want to cook this mixture for about eight to 10 minutes. And
you're just looking for the toffee mixture and the juices to cook down and concentrate.
And that's really it. No, I said that. Is that correct? Reduced by, no, hold on.
Oh, until they're soft. Right. Okay. So you also want, you want the apples to be a little
bit tender also. So we're just pre-cooking them sort of before we really start to let them break
down. So these have a little bit of color on them. I'm going to now add my apple cider and
pour slowly because this is very hot and I can sputter. We are going to bring this to a simmer
and then you don't have to do anything. Just let it cook until the apple cider is reduced by about
half. And in that time, the apples will soften. And then is when that's when we're going to like,
start to really mash and get it broken down into this coarse, sweetened, super flavorful compote.
So this is a free form apple tart. You don't have to do it in a rectangle. That's just how
I did it in the book. But I think it's easy because the rough puff pastry, you chill it
as a rectangle. So it's just easy to roll it out to that same shape. You could do it in a circle.
You could do like individual ones. It's really up to you. I think this is rough puff pastry.
I just like had randomly had it in my freezer. It might be pie dough. We'll see. I'm going to
thwack it. The thwacking is to help soften the dough without allowing it to warm up. So that
just makes it more pliable. So I think I'm ready to roll. Let me get a little more flour. Now,
if you're using a knife, cut straight down as you see I'm doing rather than dragging it through,
unless you have like a super, super sharp knife and super cold pastry. If you have a
sharp bench scraper, you could use that as well. Now this tart doesn't have a reinforced edge,
meaning I'm not like building up, you know, a double layer to make a border. I'm going to
transfer the pastry to my rimmed baking sheet. And it's still nice and cold. Like it's really,
I'm able to handle it, which is good. So fortunately it still feels nice and cold.
If this is getting warm, then you are going to want to transfer this to your fridge and
just let it chill out before you proceed. But it's just looking good. Nice straight sides.
Okay. You can dust off any excess flour if you have. And now I'm going to dock the pastry,
meaning poke some holes. So I use a fork and I'm just poking holes all over, but leave a little
bit of a border. Leave about one inch all the way around. And this just prevents puffing action in
center of the tart that would like lift. Uh, although the weight of the compote helps to
keep it down, but you're just docking it so that you have lift and separation around the edges and
not in the center of the tart. Okay. Then I'm going to use my beaten egg to brush just around
the border of the tart. You don't have to brush along the surface. We're leaving the border
exposed. We're not putting any of the apples on it. And so I want that to get shiny and brown in
oven and this will help. Okay. So just like that, very, very quick, easy application.
And the last thing before I chill this, uh, is just to add a little bit of raw sugar. You don't
have to use Demerara. If you already have just, you know, I don't have it. I want to just use
white granulated. That's fine. But just a little, a little bit around the borders.
This creates shine, crunch, a little extra sweetness. It makes it really golden and
sparkly, which looks pretty against the apples. Overall, there's not a lot of added sugar to this
tart. There's the natural sugar from the apples and the apple cider, and there's the brown sugar
in the compote, plus a little sweetness from the glaze, which is made from apricot preserves.
That looks good. It does. We're sort of making an open face pop tart. You think about it,
which is just a turnover. All right. This is going to go into the fridge. It's getting a
little warm. I want to just chill out until we assemble. Ooh, where am I going to put you?
My dream in life is to get a fridge at the cabin that has a drawer for a sheet tray.
Sounds incredible. Okay. We're turning to the compote. The apple cider has reduced by about
half, and I can tell the apples are really soft because they've taken on kind of a translucent
look, which is actually one of my favorite like states of apple being, is translucent.
So this is a point at which I'm going to go in with my potato masher. If you don't have a potato
masher, you could use like a large wooden spoon and kind of mash it against the side of the pot.
This is a really useful tool. It's like weirdly useful in baking because you want to mash a lot
of stuff. So I'm just going to go in and break up the apples. I'm going for like a coarse applesauce
texture. And I'm going to let this continue to cook down. I'll come back and mash occasionally.
And what I'm looking for is a very thick, sort of like a word that we used to describe as tight,
a tight mixture with very little liquid. I want it to be a thick mixture that kind of holds its
shape. And I'm going to cut my remaining apples as this finishes. You don't want to assemble the
tart with hot compote. So I have a swap. So I'm doing everything simultaneously. But if you're
making this at home, I would recommend doing this step ahead. And you want to let it cool down.
What you don't want to do is put hot compote on cold pastry. Then you are shooting yourself on the
foot. But I'm going to let this just sit here. I have my three remaining apples. What I like about
this recipe is you don't have to peel these apples. I actually really like seeing the little ridge of
red, you know, the red stripe on each slice. And I think it helps give the tart a little definition,
a little bit of color. So I'm doing that same slicing technique by going just down around the
side of the core. So go ahead and separate all the lobes, remove all the flesh, get the cores
out of there. If you slice with the thicker part of the blade, you're going to get slices that stick
because of all the friction. But if you slice with the tip of the blade, there's less drag and the
slice will stay on your cutting board rather than on your knife. Because if it stays on your knife
like this, then every time you have to take the slice off and do that. If it stays on the board,
you can cut faster. Okay. So I'm just using a slicing motion and dragging it across the
cutting board. And then I like to leave them actually in the little bundle of slices.
I don't want to expose the surface area of the flesh because then it can brown and it's easy
to shingle. So we're going to basically, you know, fan them out and then just go in with all the
pieces where it's going to be a really skinny slice. So here's the compote. I just pulled it
off the stove top. You can see that the color has deepened. So it's a little bit of a richer brown
and it's just a very thick, like there's no pooling liquid. It's just sort of apple solids.
So you want about a cup and a half for assembling the tart. I probably have closer to two cups here,
but that's okay. I'm actually just going to pull out a second compote that I made last night. That's
already cold. And then we're going to assemble the tart. And I actually make like a little
glaze for the apples before they go into the oven. That just is a little bit of butter. So
those remaining two tablespoons of butter and two tablespoons of the apple cider. And this prevents
the apples from just really drying out and almost like dehydrating in the oven, which I don't want
them to do. So I'm just going to melt this together. And I have my pastry brush here.
And then it gets glazed with a different glaze when it comes out. Apples go here. Let me grab
my pastry. By the way, I preheated the oven to 425. I have a rack in the center. There's that
glaze mixture and my compote. So you can see that there's like still texture in it. It's what I
would call a coarsely textured applesauce. And now I'm just going to spread this down the middle of
the pastry. I would say you want a layer that's about a quarter inch thick of the apple compote
and leave that border. You have the egg wash sugared border as your guide. And I'm probably
using about a cup and a half of the compote. If you're using the slightly smaller apples,
that's going to be closer to your yield. So I didn't weigh mine. All right. So once you have
that down, we're going to put our sliced apples on top. And this part is totally free form. It's
up to you. You can shingle them however you like. And I also recommend that you overlap them
generously because the apples shrink dramatically in the oven. So it might look like you have a
really thick layer and full coverage, but then you take it out of the oven and like you see the gaps
in between. One of the reasons why I like to leave them in their little bundles is because then they
become sort of natural clusters of apples when you go to put them over the compote. Depending
on the size of your apples, you might find that you have a lot. You can always sort of tuck them
into any gaps. I kind of like it when the directionality of the apples changes.
And you have them going like, you know, multiple ways. Isn't it pretty? All right. I'm really happy
with this. It seems like a ton of apple and it kind of is, but this will cook down. The last
step before we put it in the oven is to give a little bit of a wash over these apples. Again,
this just helps them from becoming leathery. So I like to give it a blast of hot air at the very
beginning. That helps to initiate the puffing action with the pastry and just get it going.
And then it gives a nice even bake through at 350. So this will take until I see a very nice,
dark golden brown border and the apples are brown in spots. 40 to 55 minutes. So I'm really glad
that I put as many apples as I did because I feel like they kind of shrunk the perfect amount where
you see, you see little peaking, like caramelly looking filling in between the apples and
they're soft. It looks so, so good. See how beautiful the separation is along the crust
edge. So flaky. You see all the layers of dough and butter. So I have some apricot jam and then
I have two remaining tablespoons of apple cider. I'm going to add that in. This is apricot preserves.
So there's solid pieces and I'm warming it up to liquefy so I can strain it. And then I just have
this translucent, smooth glaze. This is the same technique that I did on our glazed pastry cream
and fruit tart. Check out that episode. Apricot preserves is like an all purpose glaze for any
kind of tart. So you're not like boiling this. You're just warming it up until it's fluid so
that you can pass it through a strainer. I have a strainer right here set over a bowl.
So you want it liquid obviously to go through the strainer, but also to be able to spread
the glaze onto the apples and get like a mirror finish without brushstrokes or any texture. You
want it liquid. It also gives kind of a rosy hue. You know, it makes it kind of golden orange
in the final tart. So the technique for glazing is to use a dabbing motion rather than a brushing
motion. So that means you're placing the brush down and lifting up rather than dragging it
across the surface. So it's a dab, more of like a gentle pressing and lifting. And don't feel like
you have to use all of the glaze. You certainly don't have to. Anytime I have leftover glaze of
this kind, I just stir it back into the jar. I feel like this is a very tonal tart. It's all
different shades from like muted red through orange through brown. It is like every color
of fall is on this tart, which I really love. Here's my tips for transferring something very
wide and low profile like this. Grab either a fish spat, the widest spatula you have,
and better yet, a bench scraper. I will just say the only reason that I was able to do that
is because it's really well baked and it's crispy across the bottom. What I like about this
one of the things is it's like apple pizza. It's like super crisp. You can pick up a square.
That's kind of my favorite kind of tart to eat is one where it's like a good slice of pizza.
It's still hot. So I actually think it's great to eat this warm. Maybe not as quite as hot as
it is now, but I can't wait. There's beautiful browning all across the bottom. And that's one
of the reasons why we want to really create a compote that's super thick, not a lot of liquid.
That's going to enable us to get a well-baked tart all across the bottom without a lot of water.
You don't want any like squidgy, wet, undercooked pastry. So good. I'm going to take a bite from
the corner. I feel like the apple could be a little more done, but it's like the flavor is
a celebration of apples, but the texture is everything. It has flaky crisp pastry. It has
firm apple slices plus soft apple compote plus like cooked apple texture in the compote itself.
It is, I just don't know. I mean, I've probably said this before, but like, I just don't know
if there's another dessert that captures fall the way that this does. It is my ideal apple tart.
You know, there's a little extra, a few extra steps here and there, but I think it really
creates a superior apple tart. One that's so great for fall and is also a reason to go to
your farmer's market and explore different apple varieties. Maybe try something you haven't tried
before because there's so many options. You know, there's a vast world of apples beyond the
Golden Delicious, Granny Smith, and Red Delicious. So I hope you try it sometime. It's a great
Thanksgiving dessert. Thank you for watching Dessert Person, and we have more episodes to come. And like and subscribe.
You're the best grandma! You're the best grandma!
