-Chinatown - Exploring The Greatest Screenplay of All Time.

Humour Den
20 followers
1 Video View·Nov 16, 2022
Chinatown is often considered to be the greatest screenplay of all time, and for good reason, too.
Written by Robert Towne, it's an original story but was heavily influenced by earlier film noir.
In many ways, the story acts as a continuation and a modernization of the themes and ideas found within some of the
biggest noir films of the 1940s and 50s.
But what makes the screenplay so great is the efficiency.
How it manages to tell its story quickly while keeping the audience on the edge of their seat.
It's a movie that both follows the traditional storytelling beats,
but also changes enough to keep the audience guessing what will come next.
Today, I would like to break down some of the elements that make the Chinatown screenplay so great,
and get to the roots of why it is so frequently called the greatest screenplay of all time.
First, the movie is a real mystery.
There are no easy answers to anything.
As the story unfolds, one question is answered only for that answer to reveal two more questions.
Now, wait a minute, Mrs. Mulray. I think there's been some misunderstanding here.
However, the film never leaves anything behind.
Everything we need to know to solve the mystery is presented to us early on in the film.
The pool, the salt water, the murder, all these elements are introduced to us within the first act.
The real mystery of the film isn't the answer.
That's been there the whole time.
The real mystery is trying to figure out what question is being asked.
All throughout the film, there are small clues that add up to the end result.
These don't draw too much attention to themselves.
Instead, they're there intentionally and make repeat viewings of the film that much more valuable
because you get to pick up what's been there the entire time once you know you're looking for it.
Because it's that that person is also trying to figure out what it is that's going on.
And a lot of the film focuses on trying to throw up red herrings.
One of the most obvious examples is the motif of the water.
For the majority of the film, the primary focus appears to be Jake uncovering the water scandal.
There are certainly bigger things at play.
They all seem to be wrapped around the water.
I think that one of the advantages of creating the water is the mystery.
It really gives you something to follow that's right in front of your face,
but not exactly something that makes any sense to you until it does, until you really put it together.
Town uses the water to take us through the world of Chinatown,
show us mystery, and engross us in a much bigger and much darker story.
By the end of the film, I think it would be safe to say that the water seems rather small
compared to the momentous consequences that we see in the final scene.
One of the screenplay's biggest strengths is how it never wastes a moment.
Every scene, every interaction, and every line of dialogue for that matter is going to serve multiple purposes.
First, almost everything is going to help move the plot forward.
Some are obviously going to have a bigger impact than others,
but the end result is an advancement of the plot.
However, it doesn't just stop there, because every interaction in the movie also serves a second purpose,
and this is where some variance occurs.
Sometimes it is to tell us about a character, introduce us to an important element that will later be reincorporated,
or lay an important clue that will have big ramifications on the main plot.
I'd like to examine three moments from the film that serve one or more of these supplemental purposes.
To begin, I want to look at the opening scene.
Jake talking with Curly, a client who at first appears to be a throwaway character.
What this scene, at least initially, does so well is tell us about Jake.
He's a private eye who is both good at his job and sympathetic.
His morals are a little bit questionable, but it's clear that, at least to an extent, he cares for Curly.
However, later when Curly is reintroduced to us, we, the audience, are already familiar with him.
We don't need a few lines of exposition explaining who he is, we already know who he is.
The scene in the barbershop also helps to tell us a lot about Jake.
At first tells us that his story is out and the repercussions are real.
But it also lets us know about Jake's moral line.
He defends himself because he sees himself to be in the right.
Finally, the first scene at the Mulray house where their gardener points to the pool
and reveals the big twist less than 30 minutes into the movie.
Because of his thick accent, Jake can't understand him.
However, Jake treats him poorly, which may come from his resentments for Chinatown.
All three of these scenes are quintessential to understanding the plot and knowing our character.
Yet, while watching them, they seem minor.
And I think that's one sign of grit writing.
These very important moments don't draw attention to themselves.
It's up to us as the audience to decide what is important and what to focus on,
which all helps add to the mystery and our lack of understanding of what is going on.
The development of Jake from the beginning of the film to the end takes a very interesting turn.
Early in the film, he is a perpetual loner.
He doesn't have any real relationships and just seems to exist.
He finds some purpose out of his work, but at the same time, hates the perception that others have of him.
When he meets Evelyn, he starts to open up.
He connects with her and cares for her.
After learning her complete story, he tries to take on a more protective role.
And you can see a real change from the first act until the last one.
And that, in large part, comes from the excellent performance from Jack Nicholson.
I did write it with Jack in mind.
So, his temperament, his manner, and the way he uses language,
all of it was part of the inspiration of the character.
But then things change.
During the very last scene in the movie,
any development we've been seeing of Jake throughout the story is reverted to his true nature at the very end.
After he is exposed to the real world and the real violence in the dark nature of life,
any change he thought had happened disappeared.
Not only does he lose on a literal level with the antagonist succeeding and the good people losing,
but he also loses on an emotional level.
Everything that his character had worked for vanished.
Forget it, Jake. It's Chinatown.
And this is in direct response to film noir of the 1940s and 50s.
In a lot of these film noirs, the protagonist may lose and face repercussions for his action,
but he'll oftentimes learn something and, in theory, becomes a better person.
Closer than that, Walter.
I love you too.
That doesn't happen to Jake.
The dark world that he always knew was there bared its ugly head and sent his life back into chaos.
However, that isn't the only connection to earlier film noir.
Everything from the casting of John Huston, who's the director of The Maltese Falcon,
amongst other great films from the era,
to some of the shots being heavily inspired by the genre,
or, most importantly, the writing being influenced by earlier films.
What's so interesting about this is that the inspiration only goes to a certain point.
After that, town completely flips it on its head.
For example, with Jake's relationship with Evelyn.
If you're familiar with more traditional film noir,
it would be safe to assume that Evelyn is the femme fatale of the story.
Translated literally, it means deadly woman,
and is a trope found in many films in the noir genre,
where a woman goes from being the love interest to the antagonist.
The classic female in noir films is a black widow.
The Faye Dunaway character, in a way, is a character who gives you those expectations
as being potentially that.
But in fact, she's the heroine of the movie.
Evelyn is clearly heavily involved in the entire scandal,
and is hiding something important, and just seems suspicious.
We, as the audience who are familiar with film noir and its tropes,
can make the assumption that she is going to take the role of the femme fatale
and prove to be the antagonist.
And it's the same assumption that Jake makes.
An assumption that ends up costing him in the end,
when it's revealed that she is a victim, hiding from her traumatic past.
Part of how Town is able to lead us down the road of confusion
is by taking what we already know, or rather what we think we know,
and turning it on its head.
There are countless times in which we could have guessed something
and made an assumption based on pre-existing cinema.
And in almost all those cases, we would have been wrong.
Like I said earlier, in many ways Chinatown follows
traditional storytelling mechanics and narrative beats.
But in so many more, it's unique and it's its own story.
And I think that is what makes Chinatown the greatest screenplay of all time.
Hey everyone, I hope you enjoyed.
Chinatown is one of the best movies ever made,
and I'll firmly stand in the camp saying it's the best written film of all time.
I rarely read screenplays, but this one reads like a book.
It's full of great twists and turns, and really lets you see everything come together.
I'd also like to mention that this video is made possible because of Patreon.
If you're interested in supporting the channel, this is the best way to do so.
There are a lot of great rewards over there, including early access, a bonus audio commentary,
and even getting a say in what videos come next.
So if you're interested, there's a link on screen.
There's also a link to my last video in which I looked at Seven Samurai,
and some of the aspects that make that film so great.
So if you're interested in that, check it out.
Thanks for watching.
