Chenghua - the Emperor in Love with His Nanny

The Origins
17 followers
1 Video View·Nov 13, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello everyone, quick announcement before the video starts.
I've finally launched my Patreon,
so if you'd like to support the channel directly on there,
links will be in the description.
Thanks a lot,
and let's get right into it.
Emperors infatuated with their concubines is a common trend in history,
but imagine the son of heaven infatuated
with his childhood nanny,
After a troubled childhood, Chenghua, eighth emperor
17 years older than him.
of the Ming dynasty, would spend his entire reign dominated by her,
baffling the imperial court
and nearly breaking the imperial succession line.
This is the extraordinary life of the Emperor of Accomplished
Transformation. Chenghua's childhood
was stressful to say the least.
Born on the 9th of December 1447 to the Yingzong Emperor,
Zhu Jianzhen was not yet two years old
when his father was defeated
and captured in battle by the invading Mongols during the Tumu
Crisis. Consequently, Yingzong was deposed and replaced by his brother,
Jianzhen's uncle, the
Jingtai Emperor. As a compromise to not break the succession,
Jianzhen was however named Crown Prince.
In the apex of the Tumu crisis,
thanks largely to the efforts of official Yu Qian,
the imperial court rallied
and organized a heroic defense of the capital city, driving out the
Mongols. It however soon became clear that Jing Tai had
no intention of relinquishing power. When
Ying Zong was eventually released and returned to Beijing,
he was placed under house arrest by his
brother, as Jianzhen was soon stripped of his position of crown prince
and replaced by Jing Tai's
Demoted to a simple prince and isolated from his family,
the terrified four-year-old Jianzhen grew withdrawn
and developed a stutter.
To care for him, his grandmother, Empress Dowager Sun,
assigned a palace maid as his nanny,
Wan Zhen Er. Jianzhen would become emotionally dependent on her.
When he was nine, the prince's father,
Ying Zong, was restored to the throne
in a coup that ousted Jing Tai, and he brutally purged the court.
Yu Qian was notably unjustly executed,
but Ying Zong hesitated to restore Jianzhen as the crown prince,
fearing that his stutter
and withdrawn nature would make him an unsuitable ruler.
However, the restored emperor's grand secretaries, headed by Li Xian,
convinced him and Jianzhen was restored as crown prince.
Growing up in a forbidden city that had regained safety and stability,
Jianzhen nevertheless continued to rely
on one general whom he trusted above all others.
Only half of the Ming emperors up
to then had reached as far as the age of 40.
Yingdong died in February 1464 at 36.
Five days later, Zhu Jianshan took the reins
of the largest empire in the world at just 16 years old,
ascending the throne under the era name Chenghua,
accomplished transformation.
The young son of heaven could not remain celibate
and was promptly married to one Empress Wu.
However, Chenghua immediately took as a concubine his nanny,
Wan Zhen'er, twice his age, to the shock of the court.
When the Empress Wu had Wan Zhen'er flogged for a show of discourtesy,
Cheng Hua deposed her less than a month after the wedding.
Wu would spend the next 45 years
of her life in a secluded palace of the Forbidden City.
This served as a warning to her successor,
Empress Wang, who remained careful never to overshadow Lady Wan.
Despite a chaotic childhood
shaped by court factionalism,
Cheng Hua bore no grudge and sought to restore harmony in the
in the imperial court.
He posthumously rehabilitated Yu Qian
and would later do the same to the late Jing Tai as well.
The talented Li Xian, senior grand secretary under Ying Zong,
the same man who had once secured
Chenghua's position as the crown prince,
retained his position at the head of the government.
In the three years before his death,
Li Xian propelled the young emperor's rule
in a fertile direction and the Ming dynasty would prosper.
In May, the Emperor reformed the Beijing Imperial Garrisons.
Instead of training the three great camps,
infantry, cavalry and firearms separately,
he reorganized the Imperial Garrisons into 12 divisions,
each combining all three branches to improve battlefield coordination.
This intelligent reform would massively improve combat efficiency,
and it would not be long before the forces were tested.
With the affairs of the state well in hand,
the young emperor faced his first challenge.
In the southlands of the empire,
the native Miao and Yao ethnic people had repeatedly rebelled in
the last years and could not be decisively subdued.
In 1464, Yao leader Hou Dagou rose
up in rebellion in Guangxi, entrenching his armies in the remote
and heavily fortified Datang Gorge.
The uprising soon spread across much of southern China,
joined by Miao and Zhuang groups,
alarming the Ming court. After local forces failed to suppress it,
the government decided to dispatch
the audacious official Han Yong to lead a large military
suppression campaign with dozens of thousands of troops,
including 1,000 elite Mongol cavalry.
After early successes, Hanyong launched a direct assault
on the fortified Datang Gorge around January 1466,
against all advice.
The talented commander nonetheless successfully penetrated Datang Xia,
defeated the rebels and captured and executed Hou Dagou.
The campaign was a great victory
for the Ming. Thousands of rebels were killed
and many Yao people were captured. Men and boys
Boards were castrated and sent to serve as eunuchs in Beijing.
Among them was one youthful Wang Zhi, who as you'll see would
later become the most feared person in the entire empire.
Another notable figure was Lady Ji, a Yongyao woman brought
to the imperial palace where she became a concubine to Chenghua.
She would change the course of the Ming dynasty.
The region was brought back under Ming control.
Local civil and military administration was reorganized,
including further cooperation with some local tribal leaders.
However, the area remained volatile.
Following the Great Yao Uprising,
the Miao launched further revolts across the southwest.
In 1466, a Miao revolt in Jingzhou in southwest Hunan
was brutally suppressed by the Ming
General Li Zheng, known for his brutality, and whose name, quote,
stroked terror in the natives' hearts.
Although he declared the region pacified in 1467,
the Miao would soon rebel there again.
In parallel, another tribal rebellion broke out along
the Sichuan-Guizhou border,
where Ming forces under the Minister
of War Chengxin campaigned from 1466 to 1468,
before he declared victory.
But these were short-lived.
As the Ming failed to address
the underlying causes of tribal resistance,
the southlands kept flaring up regularly.
But ethnic minorities would not be the only source of rebellion.
Over the past decades, hundreds of thousands
of people had settled illegally in the Jingxiang region,
fleeing taxes, corvée labour
and natural disasters that had repeatedly struck the nation.
By the 1460s, the area had become densely populated
with displaced communities,
reaching around 2 million inhabitants.
They remained outside the state records
and did not pay taxes to the empire,
growing into an autonomous society
that eventually resisted Ming authority.
In 1465, the strongman Liu Tong,
supported by local religious figures, declared himself King
of Han, establishing his own state and raising a large army.
Using guerrilla tactics, Liu began
attacking and capturing nearby cities.
Such defiance could not be tolerated.
The Ming courts responded with a major suppression campaign
on their experienced commander Zhu Yong
and vice minister of war Bai Gui.
They defeated the rebels in a several-pronged attack
and captured and executed Liu Tong in the summer of 1466.
The uprising was one of the largest social
rebellions of the 15th century, but as time would show,
military suppression of the region alone
would prove insufficient.
Chenghua's reign would also be marked by frontier threats.
Trouble arose in the Liaodong frontier,
a region long marked by instability and cross-border raids
from nominal subordinates of the empire, the Jianzhou Jurchens.
These were not yet the fearsome
war machine that would eventually come to found the Qing dynasty
and conquer the Ming two centuries
But they nonetheless formed a mighty polity led
by the chieftain Li Manzhu.
On a side note, some have hypothesized
that the later name of the Jurchen, Manchu, derived from
Li Manzhu, the Jianzhou incursed into Ming territory
and frequently raided the Korean border,
generating insecurity in the frontier
and repeated complaints from the Korean Joseon dynasty.
In September 1467, the Imperial Court launched
a major punitive expedition under General Zhao Fu,
veteran of the campaign against the Yao in Datong Gorge,
and military censor Li Bing,
working in alliance with Korean forces. After a short campaign,
the Allies successfully crushed the Jurchen at Fula,
killing Li Manzhu. The frontier
was pacified, but much like in the Southlands,
the peace would prove temporary.
As the Ming dynasty suppressed rebellions and secured its borders,
Wan Zhen'er's influence within the Forbidden City grew further.
Chenghua's former nanny gave birth to his first son in February 1466,
for which she was promoted to Imperial Noble Consort.
But the child died only 10 months later in November.
With her position no longer secured by an heir,
it is believed she sought to prevent
any other concubines from bearing children,
to retain Cheng Hua's attention.
Through her influence over him,
Lady Wan built a network of eunuchs who supposedly monitored
every move within the inner palace, especially any signs of pregnancy.
Her eunuchs ensured that the babies
and sometimes the mothers themselves did not survive
through forced miscarriages and poisoning,
though this cannot be proven.
In any case, years passed and Chenghua remained without an heir,
which began to worry the imperial court.
However, its attention would soon return to social unrest.
The Jinxiang region, a haven for refugees,
rose again just four years after its last suppression.
A devastating famine
in 1470 drove nearly one million people into the area,
giving rise to another state within a state.
One Li Yuan, nicknamed Bearded Li,
imitated Liu Tong by founding his own regime and declaring
himself Tai Ping Wang, King of Great Peace.
In December 1470, experienced military censor Xiang Zhong
was dispatched to suppress the
rebellion, assisted by General Li Zhen in Huguang.
Li Yuan's movement was crushed
and the rebel leader was captured and executed in August
1471.
In a brutal repression which would be condemned by the court,
hundreds of people were indiscriminately
executed, thousands sent into exile
and huge numbers forcibly returned to the home regions
they had escaped. This brutality did little to truly pacify Jingxiang.
It remained a refuge
for displaced population
and would flare up one final time. The Mongols,
an everlasting problem for the Ming,
would be the next on the Emperor's mind.
Integrated Mongols within Ming borders had already risen up
in May 1468 in Guyuan for unclear reasons,
before being defeated by Xiangzhong a few months later.
Around the same time, exterior Mongols,
driven by the harsh conditions of the steppe,
attempted to settle in the Ordos Loop,
invading the empire and attacking Yulin,
Wang Yue, a censor with prior military
experience against Mongols in the region,
led the Ming into a major victory in 1470,
the first such feat since the Tuomu Crisis.
Yet, the incursions continued year after year,
forcing repeated campaigns.
In parallel, talented official Yu Zijun,
dispatched by the Minister of War as a local governor,
pondered on the problem.
Wang Yue's campaigns gave Yu the time to develop a long-term solution,
a great defensive system spanning roughly 600 miles
and reaching 30 feet in height,
supported by hundreds of forts,
signal towers, and stockades. A great wall.
What Yu Zijun proposed was a template
for the future Great Wall of China as we know it.
The costly Gargantuan project was initially rejected by the court,
but faced with continuous
Mongol incursions and the rising expense of defence,
it was finally approved in early 1474.
Growing confident in the region,
the Ming also tried to reassert control over the Uyghur region
of Khammi, where their nominal vessels
were overthrown by Prince of Moghulistan.
In 1473, they dispatched a small force
in strategic alliance with local Mongol tribes,
but they were outmaneuvered and decisively defeated.
Amidst rebellion suppression
and border defence,
the empire experienced a significant boom
in trade after decades of economic hardship.
Agricultural production gradually shifted towards cash crops
or the increasing use of
silver as a de facto currency,
and improved trade networks within and beyond China,
supported the growth of vibrant commercial cities
and the merchant class.
Production and exports of Jingdezhen porcelain
and Jiangnan silk notably expanded.
Despite this economic growth,
rural agriculture also suffered from population pressure,
climate cooling and periodic famine,
leading to inflation and social unrest.
Wealth became increasingly concentrated through elite land holdings
and especially imperial estates.
The Changhua Emperor himself was incredibly avaricious.
After the failed rebellion of Cao Qin against the late Ying Zong,
private lands were seized from the rebels and became
imperial estates, which revenue went personally to the Emperor.
During his reign, Cheng Hua increasingly confiscated
unrequisitioned land for this purpose,
to the point where a censor rebuked him.
All within the Four Seas is already your Majesty's domain.
Why should you compete for profits with your common people?
Nonetheless, the emperor expanded his personal estates further,
reducing revenue available to the state treasury.
Chenghua became increasingly disengaged from formal governance,
bypassing traditional institutions and reducing regular audiences,
ruling instead more directly through his eunuchs.
The appointment to court positions,
normally overseen by the Ministry of Personnel,
could be circumvented by having eunuchs directly
transmit appointment orders to the Grand Secretariat
using the Imperial Seal, a procedure known as Tran Phong.
The initially exceptional practice
gradually became a regular occurrence for Cheng Hua,
who used it to elevate personal favourites,
including Taoist priests, magicians and Buddhist monks.
The emperor's interest in Buddhism
was also illustrated by his order to construct the
Five Pagoda Zhenjue Temple in Beijing,
erected in 1473 in a distinctive architectural style
influenced by India.
In 1472, Chenghua's second
son Zhu Youji died in infancy,
possibly poisoned by Imperial noble consort Wan,
once again leaving the emperor without an heir.
The situation left the court worried, and the monarch demoralised.
When he was 27, Cheng Hua lamented
while having his hair cut by a eunuch,
that he was growing older and still had no heirs to succeed him.
After a moment, the eunuch uttered,
but your majesty does have a son.
In 1470, concubine Ji had given birth to Zhu Yaotang,
who had been raised in secrecy to escape Wang Zhen'er's reach.
Chenghua was overjoyed and immediately rushed to meet the boy
and formally acknowledge him.
The court was promptly informed
and five-year-old Zhu Youtang was soon named crown prince in December.
He was placed under the care of his grandmother,
Chenghua's mother, Empress Dowager Zhou,
who reportedly warned him never to eat
or drink anything offered to him by Lady Huan.
His mother was not so lucky.
Concubine Ji died suspiciously only a month after the affair became
This traumatic childhood caused by harem intrigue,
even more terrifying than that of his father,
would leave a deep mark on the future Hongzhi Emperor,
who would remain monogamous throughout
his life. Although Chenghua thereafter spent less
and less time with Huan Zhen'er, he remained
devoted to her, tolerating the excesses of both her and her entourage
while punishing their critics.
His reign saw growing nepotism as Lady Wan and her associates,
including relatives such as her
brother Wan Tong and the notoriously corrupt eunuch Liang Fang,
leveraged imperial favour
to accumulate wealth and influence.
Liang Fang and other powerful eunuchs exploited their access
to the imperial seal,
essentially selling off court positions by accepting bribes
in exchange for official appointments through the Chuanfeng procedure.
As discussed earlier, Chenghua not only tolerated these practices,
but actively participated in favouritism himself.
Subsequently, many figures of no merit and little
to no talent rose to influential positions,
while eunuch power steadily grew throughout the reign.
Final pacification of the Jingxiang region would take place
in 1476. That summer,
as many as the previously expelled settlers began returning,
tensions once again rose.
This time, however, the imperial courts chose not to rely on force.
Instead of another brutal
repression, it dispatched the experienced
and benevolent censor Yuan Jie to the region.
Wishing to remain in Beijing, the official declined,
but was eventually compelled by the imperial order.
Despite his reluctance, Yuan Jie carefully surveyed local conditions
and, based on previous suggestions at court,
concluded that integration rather than expulsion indeed offered
the best solution.
Working tirelessly for months,
he allowed undocumented settlers to keep the lands they cultivated,
officially registered dozens of thousands of households,
and oversaw the creation of a whole new prefecture, Yunyang.
Yuanjie then selected competent administrators for each division
and ordered garrisons to be
increased. By the end of the year,
the center had effectively stabilized the region, succeeding where
repeated military campaigns had failed.
For his efforts, he was promoted to minister of war, but
the exhausted official would never return to the capital
and died while returning at the age of 60.
If Qingxiang was pacified,
the period would also see continued ethnic uprisings in the southlands.
Whenever the natives rose up in strategic areas,
such as routes of communication and transport
between provinces, or where its authority was threatened,
the Ming responded rapidly and often
brutally. The Miao rebelled again in Hunan in 1475,
prompting another bloody campaign under Li Zhen.
As he had done nine years earlier,
the brutal general violently suppressed the uprising
and declared the region pacified in 1476,
for which he would be richly rewarded.
In parallel, the governor of Sichuan,
Zhang Zhan, suppressed uprisings in his province
alongside the border with Guizhou in 1476,
in the northwest against Tibetans in 1478,
and another Miao uprising in 1479.
In the face of these untamable ethnic rebellions,
Junior Vice Minister of Rites Zhou Hongmo, born and raised in Sichuan,
made a memorial to the throne.
Zhou explained that current Ming civil
officials dispatched to the Southlands
knew nothing of the people they administered,
which led to custom breaking and abusive policies,
prompting the native uprisings.
Violent military suppression only temporarily restored order
and worsened resistance in the long run.
Zhou therefore proposed that in each area
the natives should be allowed to, quote,
"...themselves nominate one fair-minded
and generous-spirited man in each to be their leader,
which post should be hereditary.
When one fails to perform properly, then another should be selected
to replace him. In this way the Han Chinese will
not harass the tribal people, and the tribal
people will not look with enmity upon the Han.
They shall then coexist in peace ever after."
Although Zhou's advice was approved, it would not be implemented.
Chenghua's increasing reliance on eunuchs would lead
to the creation of the Ming dynasty's most
terrorising institution, the Western Depot.
In 1420, the Yongle Emperor had established the
Eastern Depot, a much feared secret police
and investigative agency run entirely by eunuchs.
In 1477, Chenghua founded the Western Depot,
which soon became even more powerful than its predecessor.
The new agency allowed the emperor
to exert tighter control over political and military affairs
by monitoring officials and eunuchs, including of the Eastern Depot.
Its leadership was entrusted
to the eunuch Wang Zhi,
who promptly became the single most feared figure in the empire.
Under his direction, the western depot employed kidnapping,
torture and murder as instruments
of interrogation, coercion and terror,
rapidly becoming the most dreaded institution of the
state.
In 1481, a eunuch court jester, Ah Chou,
reportedly joked that Wang Zhi's passage on the street
inspired more fear than the emperor himself.
Chenghua's new champion was also sent
to inspect military garrisons on the northern
frontier.
In 1481, the eunuch champion was even given command
of the 12 divisions of the imperial garrisons
and appointed to lead a campaign against the Jianzhou Jurchens,
but the eunuch's reign of terror provoked growing resistance at court.
Opposition from the censorate, rivals within the eastern depot,
and military commanders eventually
led the emperor to relegate Wang Zhi to a minor post in Nanjing
and disband the western depot.
While he escaped further punishment,
his associates were stripped of office.
Nevertheless, eunuch influence steadily
expanded throughout Chenghua's reign,
including in sheer numbers.
In 1485, a censor notably complained of the fiscal burden of
imperial eunuchs, who by now exceeded 10,000.
The Hongwu Emperor, who had explicitly warned
his successors to keep eunuchs away from political power,
would have turned in his grave.
After more than two decades looming over the dragon throne,
and to the relief of many,
Lady Wan died in February 1487, at the age of 57.
Chenghua, however, was devastated,
reportedly remaining mute for the entire day.
He ordered a week of state mourning,
during which the court was suspended.
It would not be long before the court mourned again.
On the 1st of September 1487, Chenghua fell gravely ill.
No longer able to oversee the empire,
he instructed his 17-year-old heir, Zhu Youtang,
to take charge of state affairs.
Less than a week later, after 23 years on the dragon throne,
the emperor died at the age of 39.
He was buried in the Mao Mausoleum, fifth of the Ming tombs,
enshrined as Xianzong, exemplary ancestor,
and was granted the posthumous name Chun, pure.
Chenghua left behind a mixed legacy.
The first half of his reign is regarded as a period of prosperity
and capable government.
Trade expanded, the economy grew,
the southlands were kept under control and the northern frontier
secured against the Mongols and Jianzhou Jurchen.
Yet over time, the emperor distanced himself from formal governance.
Political abuses, nepotism
and corruption were increasingly tolerated or even conducted
by the throne itself.
Eunuchs expanded their influence while
the official bureaucracy became increasingly rigid and entrenched.
On a side note, Chenghua was a notable patron of the arts.
He was passionate about music, theatre, painting and calligraphy.
The emperor composed poetry and,
like his grandfather Xuande, produced paintings himself.
Conscious of his succession,
he also wrote prefaces to a collection of advice and
instructions on governance, the Wenhua Daxun,
Great Lessons for the Palace of Literary Splendour,
four years before his death.
Having survived the dangers of the inner palace and outlived
Wan Zhen'er, the teenage Zhu Youtang succeeded
his father under the era name Hongzhi,
Great Governance. Marked by his dramatic upbringing,
he would famously remain strictly monogamous throughout his life.
The era name would be quite fitting.
Hongzhi's reign would indeed become one of the most well-governed
and successful in Ming history,
later praised by scholars as an ideal of rulership.
The Ming dynasty still had good days ahead.
Thank you for watching my video, I hope you enjoyed it.
If so, please leave a like and subscribe to the channel.
If you have any questions or requests,
feel free to leave them in the comment section below.
