Chapter 14

Elizabeth Gaskell
6 followers
Section 6 of Mr. Harrison's Confessions by Elizabeth Gaskell.
Chapter 14.
On the whole, things went on smoothly.
Mr. Holden's legacy came in just about this time, and I felt quite rich.
Five hundred pounds would furnish the house, I thought, when Mrs. Rose left and Sophie came.
I was delighted, too, to imagine that Sophie perceived the difference of my manner to her
from what it was to anyone else, and that she was embarrassed and shy in consequence,
but not displeased with me for it. All was so flourishing that I went about on wings instead
of feet. We were very busy, without having anxious cares. My legacy was paid into Mr.
Bullock's hands, who united a little banking business to his profession of law. In return
for his advice about investments, which I never meant to take, having a more charming,
if less profitable, mode in my head, I went pretty frequently to teach him his agricultural
chemistry. I was so happy in Sophie's blushes that I was universally benevolent and desirous
of giving pleasure to everyone. I went at Mrs. Bullock's general invitation to dinner there one
day unexpectedly, but there was such a fuss of ill-concealed preparation consequent upon my coming
that I never went again. Her little boy came in with an audibly given message from the cook to ask
if this was the gentleman as she was to send in the best dinner service and dessert for.
I looked deaf, but determined never to go again. Miss Bullock and I, meanwhile, became rather
friendly. We found out that we mutually disliked each other, and were contented with the discovery.
If people are worth anything, this sort of non-liking is a very good beginning of friendship.
Every good quality is revealed naturally and slowly, and is a pleasant surprise.
I found out that Miss Bullock was sensible and even sweet-tempered, when not irritated by her
stepmother's endeavours to show her off. But she would sulk for hours after Mrs. Bullock's offensive
praise of her good points. And I never saw such a black passion as she went into when she suddenly
came into the room when Mrs. Bullock was telling me of all the offers she had had.
My legacy made me feel up to extravagance. I scoured the country for a glorious nose-gay
of camellias, which I sent to Sophie on Valentine's Day. I durst not add a line,
but I wished the flowers could speak and tell her how I loved her. I called on Miss Tyrrell that day,
Miss Caroline was more simpering and affected than ever, and full of allusions to the day.
"'Do you affix much sincerity of meaning to the little gallantries of this day, Mr. Harrison?'
asked she in a languishing tone. I thought of my camellias, and how my heart had gone with them
into Sophie's keeping. And I told her I thought one might often take advantage of such a time
to hint at feelings one dared not fully express. I remembered afterwards the forced display she
made, after Miss Tyrrell left the room, of a valentine. But I took no notice at the time.
My head was full of Sophie. It was on that very day that John Brownker, the gardener to all of
us who had small gardens to keep in order, fell down and injured his wrist severely.
I don't give you the details of the case, because they would not interest you,
being too technical. If you have any curiosity, you will find them in the Lancet of August in
that year. We all liked John, and this accident was felt like a town's misfortune. The gardens,
too, just wanted doing up. Both Mr. Morgan and I went directly to him. It was a very awkward case,
and his wife and children were crying sadly. He himself was in great distress at being thrown
out of work. He begged us to do something that would cure him speedily, as he could not afford
to be laid up, with six children depending on him for bread. We did not say much before him,
but we both thought the arm would have to come off, and it was his right arm.
We talked it over when we came out of the cottage. Mr. Morgan had no doubt of the necessity.
I went back at dinner-time to see the poor fellow. He was feverish and anxious. He had
caught up some expression of Mr. Morgan's in the morning, and had guessed the measures we
had in contemplation. He bade his wife leave the room, and spoke to me by myself.
If you please, sir, I'd rather be done for at once than have my arm taken off,
and be a burden to my family. I'm not afraid of dying, but I could not stand being a cripple
for life, eating bread, and not able to earn it. The tears were in his eyes with earnestness.
I had all along been more doubtful about the necessity of the amputation than Mr. Morgan.
I knew the improved treatment in such cases. In his days there was much more of the rough and
ready in surgical practice, so I gave the poor fellow some hope. In the afternoon I met Mr.
Bullock. So you're to try your hand at an amputation tomorrow, I hear. Poor John Browker!
I used to tell him he was not careful enough about his ladders. Mr. Morgan is quite excited about it.
He asked me to be present, and see how well a man from guise could operate. He says he is sure
you'll do it beautifully. Pah! No such sights for me, thank you. Ruddy Mr. Bullock went a shade or
two paler at the thought. Curious how professionally a man views these things. Here's Mr. Morgan,
who has been all along as proud of you as if you were his own son, absolutely rubbing his hands at
the idea of this crowning glory, this feather in your cap. He told me just now he knew he had
always been too nervous to be a good operator, and had therefore preferred sending for white
from Chesterton. But now anyone might have a serious accident who liked, for you would always
be at hand. I told Mr. Bullock I really thought we might avoid the amputation, but his mind was
preoccupied with the idea of it, and he did not care to listen to me. The whole town was full of
it. That is a charm in a little town. Everybody is so sympathetically full of the same events.
Even Miss Horseman stopped me to ask after John Browntner with interest, but she threw cold water
upon my intention of saving the arm. As for the wife and family, we'll take care of them. Think
what a fine opportunity you have of showing off, Mr. Harrison. That was just like her, always ready
with her suggestions of ill-natured or interested motives. Mr. Morgan heard my proposal of a mode
of treatment by which I thought it possible that the arm might be saved. I differ from you, Mr.
Harrison, said he. I regret it, but I differ in toto from you. Your kind heart deceives you in
this instance. There is no doubt that amputation must take place. Not later than tomorrow morning,
I should say. I have made myself at liberty to attend upon you, sir. I shall be happy to
officiate as your assistant. Time was when I should have been proud to be principal,
but a little trembling in my arm incapacitates me. I urged my reasons upon him again,
but he was obstinate. He had, in fact, boasted so much of my acquirements as an operator
that he was unwilling I should lose this opportunity of displaying my skill.
He could not see that there would be greater skill evinced in saving the arm.
Nor did I think of this at the time. I grew angry at his old-fashioned narrow-mindedness,
as I thought it, and I became dogged in my resolution to adhere to my own course.
We parted very coolly, and I went straight off to John Brountner to tell him I believed
that I could save the arm if he would refuse to have it amputated.
When I calmed myself a little, before going in and speaking to him, I could not help
acknowledging that we should run some risk of locked jaw. But, on the whole, and after giving
most earnest conscientious thought to the case, I was sure that my mode of treatment would be best.
He was a sensible man. I told him the difference of opinion that existed between Mr. Morgan and
myself. I said there might be some little risk attending the non-amputation, but that I should
against it, and I trusted that I should be able to preserve his arm.
Under God's blessing, said he reverently. I bowed my head. I don't like to talk too
frequently of the dependence which I always felt on that holy blessing as to the result of my
efforts. But I was glad to hear that speech of John's, because it showed a calm and faithful
heart, and I had almost certain hopes of him from that time. We agreed that he should tell
Mr. Morgan the reason of his objections to the amputation, and his reliance on my opinion.
I determined to recur to every book I had relating to such cases, and to convince Mr.
Morgan, if I could, of my wisdom. And luckily, I found out afterwards, that he had met Miss
Horseman in the time that intervened before I saw him again at his own house that evening,
and she had more than hinted that I shrunk from performing the operation, for very good reasons,
no doubt. She had heard that the medical students in London were a bad set, and were not remarkable
for regular attendance in the hospitals. She might be mistaken, but she thought it was, perhaps,
quite as well poor John Branca had not his arm cut off by—was there not such a thing as
mortification coming on after a clumsy operation? It was, perhaps, only a choice of deaths.
Mr. Morgan had been stung at all this. Perhaps I did not speak quite respectfully enough.
I was a good deal excited. We only got more and more angry with each other, though he,
to do him justice, was as civil as could be all the time, thinking that thereby he concealed his
vexation and disappointment. He did not try to conceal his anxiety about poor John.
I went home weary and dispirited. I made up and took the necessary applications to John,
and, promising to return with the dawn of day, I would fain have stayed, but I did not wish him
to be alarmed about himself. I went home, and resolved to sit up and study the treatment of
similar cases. Mrs. Rose knocked at the door. Come in, said I sharply. She said she had seen I had
something on my mind all day, and she could not go to bed without asking if there was nothing she
could do. She was good and kind, and I could not help telling her a little of the truth.
She listened pleasantly, and I shook her warmly by the hand, thinking that though she might not be
very wise, her good heart made her worth a dozen keen, sharp, hard people like Miss Horseman.
When I went at daybreak, I saw John's wife for a few minutes outside the door.
She seemed to wish her husband had been in Mr. Morgan's hands rather than mine,
but she gave me as good an account as I dared to hope for of the manner in which
her husband had passed the night. This was confirmed by my own examination.
When Mr. Morgan and I visited him together later on in the day, John said what we had agreed upon
the day before, and I told Mr. Morgan openly that it was by my advice that amputation was declined.
He did not speak to me till we had left the house. Then he said,
Now, sir, from this time I consider this case entirely in your hands.
Only remember the poor fellow has a wife and six children. In case you come round to my opinion,
remember that Mr. White could come over, as he has done before, for the operation.
So Mr. Morgan believed I declined operating because I felt myself incapable.
Very well. I was much mortified. An hour after we parted I received a note to this effect.
Dear sir, I will take the long round today to leave you at liberty to attend to Branca's case,
which I feel to be a very responsible one.
J. Morgan.
This was kindly done. I went back as soon as I could to John's cottage.
While I was in the inner room with him, I heard the Miss Tomkinsons' voices outside.
They had called to inquire. Miss Tomkinson came in, and evidently was poking and snuffling about.
Mrs. Branca told her that I was within, and within I resolved to be till they had gone.
What is this close smell? asked she. I am afraid you are not cleanly.
Cheese? Cheese in this cupboard? No wonder there is an unpleasant smell.
Don't you know how particular you should be about being clean when there is illness about?
Mrs. Branca was exquisitely clean in general, and was piqued at these remarks.
If you please, ma'am, I could not leave John yesterday to do any housework,
and Jenny put the dinner-things away. She is but eight years old.
But this did not satisfy Miss Tomkinson, who was evidently pursuing the course of her observations.
Fresh butter, I declare. Well now, Mrs. Branca, do you know I don't allow myself
fresh butter at this time of the year? How can you save, indeed, with such extravagance?
Please, ma'am, answered Mrs. Branca, you'd think it strange if I was to take such liberties in your
house as you are taking here. I expected to hear a sharp answer. No. Miss Tomkinson liked true
plain speaking. The only person in whom she would tolerate roundabout ways of talking was her sister.
Well, that's true, she said. Still, you must not be above taking advice. Fresh butter is extravagant
at this time of the year. However, you're a good kind of woman, and I've a great respect for John.
Send Jenny for some broth as soon as he can take it.
Come, Caroline, we have got to go on to Williams's.
But Miss Caroline said that she was tired, and would rest where she was till Miss Tomkinson
came back. I was a prisoner for some time, I found. When she was alone with Mrs. Branca,
she said, you must not be hurt by my sister's abrupt manner. She means well. She has not much
imagination or sympathy, and cannot understand the distraction of mine produced by the illness
of a worshipped husband. I could hear the loud sigh of commiseration which followed this speech.
Mrs. Branca said, please, ma'am, I don't worship my husband. I would not be so wicked.
Goodness, you don't think it wicked, do you? For my part, if I should worship, I should adore him.
I thought she need not imagine such improbable cases. But sturdy Mrs. Branca said again,
I hope I know my duty better. I've not learnt my commandments for nothing.
I know whom I ought to worship. Just then the children came in, dirty and unwashed,
I have no doubt. And now Miss Caroline's real nature peeped out. She spoke sharply to them,
and asked them if they had no manners, little pigs as they were, to come brushing against her
silk gown in that way. She sweetened herself again, and was as sugary as love when Miss Tomkinson
returned for her, accompanied by one whose voice, like winds in summer sighing, I knew to be my
dear Sophie's. She did not say much, but what she did say, and the manner in which she spoke,
was tender and compassionate in the highest degree. And she came to take the four little
ones back with her to the vicarage, in order that they might be out of their mother's way.
The older two might help at home. She offered to wash their hands and faces.
And when I emerged from my inner chamber, after the Miss Tomkinsons had left,
I found her with a chubby child on her knees, bubbling and sputtering against her white wet hand,
with a face bright rosy and merry under the operation. Just as I came in she said to him,
There, Jimmy, now I can kiss you with this nice clean face. She coloured when she saw me.
I liked her speaking, and I liked her silence. She was silent now, and I loved all the better.
I gave my directions to Mrs. Browker, and hastened to overtake Sophie and the children.
But they had gone round by the lanes, I suppose, for I saw nothing of them.
I was very anxious about the case. At night I went again. Miss Horseman had been there.
I believe she was really kind among the poor, but she could not help leaving a sting behind
her everywhere. She had been frightening Mrs. Browker about her husband, and been,
I have no doubt, expressing her doubts of my skill. For Mrs. Browker began,
Oh, please, sir, if you'll only let Mr. Morgan take off his arm, I will never think the worse
of you for not being able to do it. I told her it was from no doubt of my own competency to
perform the operation that I wished to save the arm, but that he himself was anxious to have it
spared. Ay, bless him, he frets about not earning enough to keep us if he's crippled. But, sir,
I don't care about that. I would work my fingers to the bone, and so would the children. I'm sure
we'd be proud to do for him and keep him. God bless him. It would be far better to have him
only with one arm than to have him in the churchyard. Miss Horseman says—
Confound Miss Horseman, said I.
Thank you, Mr. Harrison, said her well-known voice behind me.
She had come out, dark as it was, to bring some old linen to Mrs. Browker,
for, as I said before, she was very kind to all the poor people of Duncombe.
I beg your pardon, for I really was sorry for my speech, or rather that she had heard it.
There is no occasion for any apology, she replied, drawing herself up and pinching her lips into a
very venomous shape. John was doing pretty well, but, of course, the danger of Lockjaw was not
over. Before I left, his wife entreated me to take off the arm. She wrung her hands in her
passionate entreaty. Spare him to me, Mr. Harrison, she implored. Miss Horseman stood by.
It was mortifying enough, but I thought of the power which was in my hands as I firmly believed
of saving the limb, and I was inflexible. You cannot think how pleasantly Mrs. Rose's
sympathy came in on my return. To be sure, she did not understand one word of the case
which I detailed to her, but she listened with interest, and, as long as she held her tongue,
I thought she was really taking it in. But her first remark was as malapropos as could be.
You are anxious to save the tibia. I see completely how difficult that will be.
My late husband had a case exactly similar, and I remember his anxiety. But you must not
distress yourself too much, my dear Mr. Harrison. I have no doubt it will end well.
I knew she had no grounds for this assurance, and yet it comforted me. However, as it happened,
John did fully as well as I could hope. Of course he was long in rallying his strength,
and, indeed, sea air was evidently so necessary for his complete restoration that I accepted
with gratitude Mrs. Rose's proposal of sending him to Highport for a fortnight or three weeks.
Her kind generosity in this matter made me more desirous than ever of paying her
every mark of respect and attention.
End of section 6
