For weeks, France has been gripped by huge protests which have left the country in chaos and its government in a full blown crisis. What started as student protests, have grown into nationwide demonstrations - and now strikes - in protest at the cost of living, pay and public services.
But the response from the government has been controversial, with many criticising what they see as heavy-handed tactics by police.
On this episode of the Fourcast, Alex Thomson is joined by Alice De Brito, the Vice President of the National Students’ Union of France, as well as Steve Erlanger, the chief diplomatic correspondent in Europe for the New York Times.
They discuss whether the chaos could pave the way for the far-right, if France can pay for the protesters’ demands and whether the unrest could spread around Europe.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
France is experiencing a severe political crisis as student protests over failing school infrastructure have merged with broader labor unrest. The situation reflects a deep divide between a struggling population and a government perceived as an elitist \"lame duck,\" struggling to balance unsustainable social spending and national debt against rising public demands for systemic change.
This is an old rooster come home to roost.
I've never seen such violence against young people.
Trade unions, pensions, benefits.
The problem is the country isn't growing enough
to afford to pay all this.
If we are not happy, we are going to go out on the streets.
Is that actually playing into the hands of the hard right in France?
It's the way others have manipulated
their perfectly legitimate protests.
And here I mean the anarchists.
And this does, I think, I fear, feed Marine Le Pen's politics.
And welcome to The Forecast. I'm Alex Thompson.
Now, what started out as a student protest over
the state of France's schools
has turned into a full-blown political crisis
for the French government.
Since October, France has been hit by mass demonstrations,
with hundreds of thousands of workers now striking
in protest at living standards, pay and public services.
The protests, which have occasionally turned violent,
have since spread to other countries across Europe.
And with elections coming up next year in France
and several other European countries,
will we see that anger expressed at the ballot box too?
Well, to discuss all of this and more, I'm joined by Alice Dauvrito,
who's vice president of the National Students Union of France,
as well as Steve Erlanger, who is the chief diplomatic correspondent
in Europe for The New York Times.
Welcome to both of you. Thanks very much for for making the time.
Um...
I suppose, Alice, first off,
a basic question for you as somebody very much involved,
and the same question to Steve as an observer.
Alice, from your perspective,
what was the key cause of this disruption?
Okay.
Well, I think it all started in overseas territories
in high schools where they didn't have any access to waters,
and then it expanded to the suburbs of Paris because of the state
of the high schools and the lack of teachers in front of the students,
and then it just expanded everywhere in France.
And I think the key...
The key of what made it such a massive movement
is the lack of answers from the government.
We didn't have any answers from the government for more than a month.
I
Besides, obviously, the police violence that we've seen a lot,
don't
and to be honest, I have
been in unions since I was in high school,
so it's nearly 10 years now, and I've never
seen such violence against young people,
know.
and I think it's also what...
How can I say it? What started to make these movements expand
so much because we've seen
people that were 14, 15,
16 losing eyes or legs because they were protesting and we didn't
see any answers from the government.
And even now the government doesn't want to
say anything about these young people that lost.
The eyes that were injured really badly.
So it just ignores the angers on our campuses.
Right. Steve, let me...
Alice is very clearly saying there that the government has no answers.
I think we're all agreed that the thing that started this
was clearly the students and clearly grievances about the schools.
And I think it's unarguable
that that has touched a chord across France.
Alex said a couple of times there that what's happened
is the government hasn't listened.
Is that how you've observed it from your perspective?
To a great degree, yes. It has responded, but inadequately.
It has expressed sympathy, but it doesn't have any money.
I mean, it sounds very patronising for a government to say,
yes, but we put all this extra money into education before.
When students like Alice and others look around
and don't see the results,
when so much of the education funding goes to pensions, for instance,
which brings up just the larger problem the French government has,
which is deep in debt, its inflation is going up,
it is having trouble, it can't raise the pension age politically.
It can't really raise taxes politically.
It's adrift because France is adrift waiting for
elections, presidential elections,
and then parliamentary elections this spring.
So I think, you know, there's a lot of disgust at...
At the current government, which is pretty helpless,
which is a minority government and
can't pass legislation.
So the government's silence or inadequacy is built into its very
weak position. So in short, you've got a lame duck president,
as you see it, Steve, in Emmanuel
Macron. But also you've got a country
that frankly has not got enough money to give.
The likes of Alice, the money that she wants
to be pumped back into schools.
Yes, and I would add to that that Macron, you know,
people joke and call him Macron Antoinette.
I mean, there's this notion that he's an elitist,
he's a banker, he's a businessman.
After his presidency, he's likely to go into business once again.
He was always criticised, he thought,
And not doing a super tax on the wealthy,
he would create more jobs and so on.
But it again underlined this image he has of being distant from people.
And then what you had, as Alice said,
you had the students start this, but then the
unions came in and then the Gilets Jaunes,
who were, you know, she can explain, but originally
Originally, environmentalists in the countryside were angry over...
Gasoline taxes and environmental taxes,
they interpreted as elite actions by an urban political class
that didn't understand the problems of the countryside.
So there's just a lot of anger out there,
and it's all coming together this way.
Right, and it's coming together with some violence.
At least you mentioned again a couple
of times the violence of the police.
We're in an interesting situation
in that all three of us in this discussion
have all been tear-gassed by the CRS, the French riot police.
They take the lacrymogen out of the cupboard pretty quickly,
don't they, on these occasions?
Yes, they do.
But is that actually, if it's that's provoking violence,
is that actually playing into the hands of the hard right in France?
Look at the election coming.
Well, I do not think so, actually,
because we have now a massive movement that has been taking place,
but we also have young people that are becoming more
and more aware of what's happening now
and what are their values and why they stand for it.
And we have so many people now in the streets.
It's um...
They are so young and they know the dangers for us
if the far right wins the elections in April.
Thank you.
And we can hear it.
In France, we have a really famous song that says that the youth,
I'm not going to say the word, but
But...
Something not really friendly about the Front National,
which is a far right party,
I know the word.
That's good.
Yes.
And that's something that we obviously,
we always sang in French,
but now we see young people that are not in unions,
are not in parties,
that just sing it from everywhere.
And we have so many people now that know and that...
I've conscientized the fact that the far right
is not the ones that are going to help us to win rights.
So obviously we have people just seeing what's happening on the press
and that think that the far right is the only solution.
But when you go out there and talk to people,
We see that so many people also know that the far right is
And even more, it's even more dangerous
than what's happening right now in France.
Okay, let's have a look at the finances of this.
Steve alluded to this a moment or two ago.
He gave a bit of a catalogue.
You want a lot of money spent on schools.
There's a lot of demands on the minimum wage.
There's a lot of demands across the board
for the French to maintain
what is widely seen outside France
as a pretty good lifestyle.
But one which is becoming unsustainable.
When the government says, I'm sorry,
at least there is no money for this.
They're right, aren't they?
Absolutely.
Well, actually, we don't know if that's right.
When we see that in France, for example,
we have 200 billion dollars given to big enterprises.
I'm not talking about little enterprises,
but big enterprises like LVMH, for example,
without any contributions, without any conditions,
just to help them.
Thank you.
When this enterprise doesn't need any help from the French government,
it's just an offer that the French government does.
When we see that last year the government spent 100 million
on a military service that no one wanted,
right after saying that they didn't have any money,
we know now that we have money that exists.
Thank you.
Stephen was talking about taxing the rich.
Rich, obviously, that's a solution too, even though...
The government doesn't want to apply that,
but we know money exists and we know also
that economical choices are not only economical,
they are also political choices.
And now we just need the government to act
that they make a political choice on investing
in their youth, investing in their public services,
investing in workers' conditions
of life.
Sure. That's the point very clearly made by Elise there,
Steve, that, as she puts it,
economic choices are political choices.
She says the government's throwing lots of money,
military services nobody wanted, in her view,
throwing money at big corporations. You mentioned
one. Total is another one
which has brought out the petrochemical multi-giant in France.
She has a point, doesn't she,
that government is widely perceived as spending on the wrong things?
Well, most governments are perceived that way.
And she's right. I mean, choices, government makes
choices that are political, but are also moral.
And basically, the question the French are asking
particularly young people,
are these choices for the interests of the elite or the interests of
their supporters or the interests of the future.
And the sad part is you have in France the
wonderful social system, social welfare system.
It has its problems, God knows, but the health
system is quite good.
The pension system, once you get into it, is quite good.
But people are retiring early, and they're living a really long time.
And the wonderful accomplishments of les Trente Glorieuses,
of the post-war successes, often done by the Socialist Party.
Trade unions, pensions, benefits, minimum wage.
The problem is the country isn't producing enough.
It's not growing enough,
creating enough tax revenue to afford to pay all this.
This has been happening now for 25 years in France.
I mean, this is nothing new.
This is an old rooster come home to roost.
And France spends more than 56% of its entire national income
On the state, and about a quarter of that alone goes to pensions,
and the problem, unlike
in America, where people build up
their pension account over their whole working lives, this
year's pensioners are paid for by...
And the UK.
Okay, bye.
Yes, well, I mean, this year's pensioners
are paid for by this year's workers.
Right.
Right, and let me put that to Alix.
Anyway.
Let me put that to Alix.
I mean, you know, it's a lovely life in France,
but you just, and in some ways we envy it,
the other side of the channel, the other side of La Manche.
I understand.
But you just can't afford it.
Yes, we...
We could, obviously,
if the choice was made to invest in public services, but we obviously,
we are really, really, really,
even the young people are really proud of the social system.
in France and we do like it very much
but for example we were Estelle was talking about
medical care with the sécurité sociale social security in France
which is amazing but now we do not have any
And he...
we have hospital hospitals that
...can't function normally, they are closing beds,
they are lacking medical staff, and all this is also
because we had for years now depressing money in this...
public service and this is the same thing
with schools actually because now we have
students are fighting for the right to have an education
which is a really basic right
and they are not only doing this because they
are asking for a new high pass in their classrooms
or I don't know they're asking to have teachers in front of them
because now we know that
In the majority of high schools,
we do not have teachers in front of the students.
And this is something that has been happening for years now.
And we just need to have medical staff.
We need to have teachers in front of people
because otherwise the country can't function.
If we are lacking medical staff now and that we have young people
that can't be educated to become medical staff,
this is going round and round and this is a never-ending solution.
Okay, now let me take you, of course,
let me take you back in time a little bit.
At least you're too young to remember, far too young to remember.
I remember.
Les événements de mai 68, the events of May 68.
There are people who say, hang on, look,
let's not get so excited about this.
France does this every generation or so.
It's the French way.
Everything gets a bit bouleversé, you know.
Everybody has a big...
A big demonstration on the streets and it starts with the students
and then the unions come out and then everything settles down.
And this is the French way.
So some of the talk about what's happening
in France at the moment is a little bit alarmist.
What, first of all, Alice, would you say to that notion?
Well, I do not think we need to be alarmed.
Obviously, it happens a lot of times in France
to have great social movements.
You talked about May 68, but we also had Devetque in 86,
which were massive student protests that were joined by the unions.
We had Le CPE in 2006.
We had the reforms movement in 2019 and 2020.
And the gilets jaunes.
Yes, and the gilets jaunes.
So it's something that really happens.
Thank
But we hear a lot of people talking about Seine-Saint-Denis
and talking about what's happening now in France.
And particularly in perspective,
we
we know that Mai 68 happened really fast
very
And that people...
much.
gained something out of it
and we we are in a movement right now that is
that is going longer in the time that Mai 68 and we
I still do not have anything,
but the thing that we need to know is that Mai 68
was a really, really violent protest happening in France.
When people talk about violence, about what's happening now,
and they talk about Meso-Saint-Denis
being all cheerful, that's not true, actually.
You see the history.
Meso-Saint-Denis was a really,
really violent protest that was happening everywhere in France.
Such as Devaquet, which ended
when a student was killed by the police in France, but it's
It has been happening in history
and it will happen again if we are not happy.
Whatever it is, if we have far-right,
if we have a centre government, if we have a left government,
if we are not happy, we are going to go out on the streets
and we are going to say it.
Because it is actually a constitutional right
in France to go out on the streets and to protest
and it's something that is really important for us
because this is also the way to be heard by governments.
Peacefully. It's not a constitutional right to go out
and set fire to Le Marais.
Yes, obviously, obviously.
Steve, what's your perspective on that? It's very interesting what
Alice was saying, you know,
everybody remembers, you know, May 68 still,
and it's interesting that she's saying it's still being talked about.
But her point was that was fairly short,
it was violent, but it was short,
but it kind of worked. This is longer and thus far has not worked.
Well it brought about the downfall of a government.
There was Algeria going on,
there was a lot going on.
I mean then the phrase was, under the cobblestones, the beach. I'm not
sure these days you'll find the beach underneath,
you're more likely to find sewage. I think you
They have the right to protest, and they should.
If they're unhappy, it's fine.
I mean, the problem is not their problem.
It's the way others have manipulated
their perfectly legitimate protests.
And here I mean the anarchists,
the guys who come out at night with the black hoods and
the crowbars who start smashing up windows from small business owners,
big businesses
start looting, the police respond.
And this does, I think, I fear, feed Marine Le Pen's politics.
Let me put that to Alice directly.
That's a very good point.
I'm interrupting you simply because I'd love to bring Alice on that.
The point being these anarchists
are hijacking what the students are doing
in terms of legitimate protests, coming out at night,
and that plays straight into the hands
of Marine Le Pen and the far right.
Well, we know actually that even the government knows the difference
between the protesters and what's happening at night in the streets.
It's, um...
But yeah, obviously, that's what I was saying at the beginning of this.
We have the press that when this happens,
only talks about violence happening at the end of the protest.
And so it feeds also this speech of the far right.
And when we have people that...
Do not see in their own eyes what's happening
and only see what's been saying on the medias and on the press
and what the far right is saying. Obviously, it fits them.
But when we go out on the streets
or when you see some kind of press that's really neutral,
you know also that there's
a difference between the two things happening
and that we have really peaceful protests,
really cheerful protests during the days.
And that's what's been happening at night.
It's something really different.
And it is also symptomatic of the situation in the country.
Sure. That's interesting that there's an agreement between
the two of you on that. I want in the time that remains,
just if I may, to widen things out a bit.
Steve, I know you've written eloquently about
your prognosis for coming events across Europe.
We have similar demonstrations, goodness me, from Portugal to Albania,
so far as I can see, for various grievances. Big elections come up
and your essential thesis is the centrist politics.
in Europe is under real threat,
which is interesting from a British perspective at the
moment. But yeah. Yeah, well, it is.
I think in the parliamentary systems in general that are not
necessarily first past the post systems,
you end up often with coalition governments that are very
wishy-washy. I mean, in Germany, for instance,
you have really the centre-right party together
Together with the center-left party, the socialists.
And so what you come out with is a kind of weakened policies
that satisfy neither the voters of one party or the other.
You also have governments that in general
are not producing enough growth, that are drowning in debt partly
because of what they spent over COVID, but also because of social
systems that haven't been reformed or haven't been modernized.
And then you have young people, but you see it in Germany,
certainly in the former East Germany,
but you see it in France, Spain, elsewhere, you see...
You know, younger people voting for the margins,
the more toward the far left,
in France's case, Le Pen,
or in Germany, Die Linke, the left party,
or in Spain, the far right party, Vox.
And then you have challenges
to even the right-wing parties coming from farther right.
Even in Italy, Meloni's being challenged
by this former general farther to her right.
So there's an enormous pressure on the center
and there is a feeling that, you know,
traditional big catch-all parties are weakening all over Europe.
Partly because they're not producing, and partly because,
you know, let's say in France's terms, unlike Britain, you know,
they're in the euro, and the euro is great, but you can't print money.
It's a kind of a prison. And in America,
we can just keep printing the dollar and worry about inflation.
And that's one way of kind of dealing
with the problem of not having money to spend.
And, but...
You know, for all these things coming together,
plus, let's be honest, young people think
like the world is ending, the environment is terrible,
governments aren't doing enough
about it.
There's a war in Europe, Russia's invasion of Ukraine,
there's a demand that NATO countries
spend more on their military,
and these are very difficult choices for governments to
make when they don't have enough money.
Exactly. So, well, you totally read my mind
because the very next thing I was going to say, having given us
your very clear thesis on the way that the centre across Europe
is under threat, was to ask you, Alice, I mean, let's be clear.
My generation, Stephen's generation,
we have completely screwed it up for you guys. We've made a total mess.
We grew up with one existential threat, nuclear war.
And what joy we've given you guys, not one, not two, but three.
We've given you nuclear war, still there, potential.
We've given you AI, the threat that comes with that.
And we screwed up the climate, so it's collapsing.
So some people will say, and I think Stephen was alluding to that.
I didn't even ask him.
There is a sense of hopelessness out there, right?
Yes, obviously, we have brilliant people that are feeling hopeless,
but we also know that we can still do something about it.
We can still do something about climate change.
Obviously, we cannot stop it, but we can retard it.
We can still do things about the wars.
We have young people that have been fighting for years now
about peace in the world.
This is something that we see every day.
When we talk to young people,
the peace in the world is something really important for them.
And we know that...
We can't, as one person, do something,
but we know that we can, with the mass,
tell something to our governments.
And what is really important for us also
is that we see people from your generation,
well, we see the ones that don't really care,
and this is really frustrating,
but we also see some people from your generation
that actually are aware of what's happening,
and some are feeling guilty,
some are saying this is their fault.
Anyways, but we see that...
Now we have people that are aware of what
their generation has been doing to our generation,
not knowing that they were doing it.
And this is also something that gives us hope,
because we are not all alone in what we are fighting for.
Of course. No, you're certainly not.
Our time is against us, but I want to widen this.
A final point which occurred to me thinking about what we
were going to talk about today, and it is this.
Are we, and I'll ask you this first, Steve.
Are we looking at something which is a much bigger problem beyond
any government, beyond any political philosophy, beyond economics,
which is for a variety of reasons, for the first time in the history
of our civilization in the West, the deal which we are, as parents,
are handing on to the next generation, to Elise and the students
and so forth, for the first time, it's not as good as our parents.
Which was better than their grandparents.
Which was better than their grandparents.
Something has changed.
And that, frankly, is beyond the reach of any government,
be it centre, be it left, or be it right.
Steve.
Well, I think that's true certainly since the Second World War.
I wouldn't go much before that because there was the Depression
and there were lots of terrible things.
But certainly since 1948 or so, what you're saying is absolutely true.
And it's a problem even China's having, by the way.
I mean, one of the weaknesses of the Chinese system
is you have a feeling among young people
that their lives won't be quite as good.
So a lot of it is simply...
The world has changed. Europe is smaller.
The West is smaller. It's a smaller part of the global
economy. The trading patterns are different.
So there's less wealth being created. And with less
wealth, as I say, you get less tax, you get less benefits. And I think
All these older societies who are getting older demographically
need to think this through.
This is the whole immigration problem
that the far right feeds upon also.
But you can't have a Europe
that functions even the way it functions now
without more immigration of people
who will help take care of the old,
do the teaching.
Fill the churches.
Which is...
And so this is a problem.
I mean, this becomes a psychological problem,
a cultural problem,
but it is a problem of almost existential importance.
Exactly. Well, Alice, I know you have to get out on the streets
and demonstrate, as is your constitutional right,
but just before you do, final thought to you.
As Stephen was saying, this is an existential, this is an economic,
this is a philosophical, this is a cultural problem.
The deal that you guys are getting is just not as good
as the ones that quite a few generations before had.
Yes, even though I do think that the generations before us
also did not have great lives always and we see our parents,
we see our grandparents now struggling and this is also why we have
been joining, well, why the workers have been joining us
and we are grateful that we saw such hope and such
Thank
Such thankfulness because we know that everyone now is struggling
and this is not only a youth problem,
you
it's a really societal problem that everyone is struggling.
very
Our parents, our workers, our reformed people, our people
that are people from the immigration are really struggling right now.
much.
In France, but in every country in Europe, for the LGBTQIA people,
well, everyone is struggling in their ways.
And so we know that we also need to unite ourselves
in saying why everyone is struggling and why we want to stop.
And this thing of solidarity that we've created in France
is something that is really precious for us
because we hadn't seen it before.
A lot of years now,
the solidarity between everyone and every member of the society
and every class in the society, and it is really great.
For example, I've seen, and I'll conclude with it,
but I have seen people from the
Henri IV High School, which is one of the elite high schools in France,
in the center of Paris,
which is really great in terms of conditions of studying, protesting.
And when we are asking them why they are protesting,
they can say to us, because we are seeing what's happening
in the suburbs, in the overseas territories,
and we do not understand why we have it good and they do not.
And so we do need to be in solidarity with them.
And this is something really precious for us that we've...
commonly created and we are really proud of.
And rightly so.
We'll leave it on that note.
We've covered an awful lot of ground, I think.
Thank you, Alice.
Thank you, Stephen.
Culturally, politically and economically.
Thank you very much.
Thank you.
And bon courage.
Bon courage à tous.
And that's all we've got time for on this edition of the podcast.
Thank you very much for being with us.
Bye bye.