CARMÉNÈRE - The Grape BORDEAUX Forgot!!!

Red Wine Collection
1 follower
In the 18th century, Cabernet Franc and Carmanère
were the most notable varieties of the Madoc in Bordeaux.
Phylloxera then hit, a lot of the vines were replanted,
and since Carmanère can give low yields,
it can be difficult in the vineyard,
producers started moving more towards Merlot
and Cabernet Sauvignon.
The original six permitted red varieties of Bordeaux
are Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc,
Petit Verdot, Malbec, and Carmanère.
These days in Bordeaux, you rarely see it planted.
There are very few producers that use Carmanère
in the blend in Bordeaux.
Chateau Clerc-Minon is one of the few,
which is a fabulous wine, by the way.
Chile has the most plantings of Carmanère,
around 10,000 hectares,
that's around 25,000 acres of the variety.
For the longest time, producers thought it was Merlot,
up until 1994, when they realized,
oh, it's a different variety altogether.
The same thing happened in Italy in the 90s.
Producers thought it was actually Cabernet Franc,
especially the famous Tanuta San Leonardo.
Then they started to realize,
oh, it's a different variety altogether.
Now the Italian government states
that there are about 1,000 hectares of Carmanère in Italy.
The variety's also flourishing in China,
where they call it Cabernet Guarnished.
I've had some wonderful examples as well.
Carmanère, when it's underripe, can be herbaceous, leafy,
even like jalapeno or green pepper,
but it can have the plush mouthfeel of Merlot.
Actually, when it's done well,
it reminds me of good Cabernet Franc.
I remember when I lived in Singapore
and I was just starting to get in wine,
there was an importer of South American wines
and he gave me a Canchi Toro Tarugno,
and I thought it was an absolutely gorgeous wine.
And sometimes I wonder why I don't drink more of these wines
because usually you can get really good value for money,
especially if they're coming out of Chile.
Here today, I have five different varietal Carmanère wines,
ranging from about 20 bucks all the way up to 80 bucks.
You ready? I'm ready.
Let's get tasting.
Carmanère wines can act like Merlot
or Cabernet Franc, Bordeaux style.
So I have my Gabriel Glass Standard Edition.
The variety is also part of some prestigious
Bordeaux blends in Chile.
So if you want a Carmanère varietal wine,
go for a Bordeaux or Universal shape glass.
I think it'll work out for you.
Let's get blind tasting.
As always, I Coravin these
and had somebody mix them up for me.
With these Carmanère wines,
there's usually no shortage of color,
which we see here, more of a purpley color.
Sometimes the Carmanère wines
that can remind me of Syrah in color.
Wine one is not green at all.
It doesn't have any capsicum or bell pepper flavors.
Maybe just like a slight hint, but not a ton.
Maybe it's only because I know
that's the thing about tasting.
Sometimes you're subject to your own bias.
I know we're tasting Carmanère,
so I think I should be finding capsicum,
but I'm not finding a ton here.
I do have some blackberry, some black plum,
but not overly jammy.
That's the cool thing about these Carmanère wines.
They're not too jammy.
Merlot can sometimes get a bit too much.
Black peppercorns, blackberries,
maybe black cherry, black plum,
like a little bit of mocha.
I'm looking for green flavors, but not finding a ton.
Mouthfeel-wise, it does feel savory.
It does feel more medium body.
It's not a massive red wine.
It does remind me a lot of a well-done,
riper Loire Cabernet Franc, maybe with less greens.
I think some people want a little bit more intensity,
but honestly, in this style, I really enjoy it.
And some of these are really affordable,
so maybe we're gonna find some gems here.
We'll see.
Two has a little bit more wood,
so maybe it's one of the more ambitious wines in the set.
It's not overly fruity or tutti fruity.
This really does smell.
I get wood.
I get just a touch of greens.
I get black cherry.
I get red cherry.
This does smell a lot like a Cabernet Franc.
This has more tannin.
You feel some of the wood tannins on the gums right here.
I think this is a more ambitious wine,
a little bit more wood,
so it might age a little bit better.
Right now, I'm preferring kind of the fruitiness
and the easygoingness of one a little bit more than two,
but two might be a wine that, hey,
you need to give a little bit more time to.
I like on these red wines, man,
it's really a nice balance between fruit
and savory, vegetal-type notes.
I like it.
You have to kind of like more earthy,
more savory-type red wines.
People that like big, bold, fruity wines
maybe aren't gonna go for something like this,
but I'm enjoying it so far,
especially since you can get these at nice price points.
I just got back from the Concours Mondial de Brussels.
This year, it was in Mexico, the red and white session,
and my panel chair was actually a guy from Chile,
and on the last flight,
I could have swore that they were Chilean Carmeneres.
They were really herbaceous, a lot of capsicum,
yeah, plush, and when we revealed them,
I was like, oh man, they're definitely Chilean Carmenere.
They were Chinese Cabernet Sauvignon,
and we gave some good scores.
Wine three.
Okay, three has more violets
and also a little bit more wood, cherry.
Again, not so, I think one and two were a little green,
but these wines are not green at all.
I was kind of hoping for some green leafiness.
Earth.
This is such a unique wine,
and the fact that I definitely get wood.
I like wood in white wines,
actually more than I do in red wines.
I don't love really oaky red wines,
unless it's Ciroc, because Ciroc handles the oak well,
but I like the oak here.
It's like, sometimes people like their steak,
just the meat, high quality meat.
Some people like tons of pepper on it,
and you cook it, and you get
that nice crispy pepper layer on it,
and you definitely get the pepper,
but it won't overpower the meat.
That's the case here.
You definitely get the wood, but it's not overpowering.
Yeah, for some reason, I like that.
It just, it's nice, it's just wood done well.
That's really weird.
I think, so far I'm guessing,
I have a couple more expensive, ambitious Carmeneres here,
and I feel like two and three might be that,
but I don't know.
Let's move on to four.
Four smells like a younger wine.
Cherry red plum.
I, again, no greens at all here.
I'm kind of missing the green.
I want some capsicum, actually.
Yeah, red cherry, red plum, tobacco,
maybe just a touch of mocha, just a touch.
I'm really digging the mouthfeel.
I like more medium-bodied red wines,
and I think all these might,
I'll have to check the label again.
I think they're all coming in around 14 degrees in alcohol,
which should suggest a bigger wine,
but on the palate, they really feel
more like Loire Cabernet Franc,
more medium-bodied, kind of slender red wines
if you're into that sort of thing, which I really like.
Four is just in balance.
Everything really kind of comes together.
Nothing sticks out.
I really enjoy it.
It's a wine that I think maybe could age.
You could put in the cellar for five, six years,
maybe up to 10, but I'm really enjoying,
I wouldn't wait on it.
I'm enjoying that fruit now.
Let's move on to number five.
Five is deeper in color, much deeper in color.
I get like a soy sauce component,
a little bit of mocha, black cherry.
Again, no greens.
This also shows wood, so maybe this is more of the ambitious
one of the more ambitious Carbonares.
Number five is, again, one of the more ambitious wines.
It's smooth, real silky.
If you like those type of wines, smooth, smooth, smooth.
Wines one through four had these chewy tannins
I kind of like.
Again, reminded me a lot of Loire Cabernet Franc.
Pretty shocked to not get green flavors here.
Some nice wines.
One that I think's very, very, very good.
Now, here's the thing.
These are also niche wines.
People that like Cabernet Franc or like more medium body,
more savory reds are gonna get into these.
I think the normal consumer that likes big plush red wines
aren't gonna like these except number five
because there are some tannins here.
We'll see what the price points are
because I do think they offer a good alternative
to Loire Cabernet Franc.
And you can actually find Chilean Carbonares
a little bit easier than some Loire Cabernet Francs.
Let's start out with number two.
More wood.
I thought it was a little bit ambitious.
However, it didn't really move me a ton.
I thought it was very good wine.
I gave it 90 points.
I did like that wine one and two were the most green.
So this really acted like a Cabernet Franc.
It just wasn't popping to move to greatness levels.
I still think it was very good.
90 points.
Let's take a look here.
Geez, the most expensive wine in the bunch.
This is the Tenuta San Leonardo Carmenere.
2018, this comes in at 80 bucks.
So not cheap at all.
Tenuta San Leonardo is one of the great estates in Italy.
Makes very unique Bordeaux blend.
One of my favorite wines in Italy.
It's got mostly Cabernet Sauvignon
with like 20% Carmenere and 20% Merlot.
They're one of the producers to help realize,
hey, it's not Cabernet Franc in the vineyard,
it's Carmenere.
This is not their top wine.
This is kind of like a specialty.
2018's a warm vintage.
That was an ambitious wine.
The wine had the wood, very Loire Cabernet Franc.
I love the producer.
I would go for their main wine,
their flagship Tenuta San Leonardo over this wine.
I think it's good, 80 bucks.
It's kind of pricey.
Let's move on here.
Wine number one, like a touch of greens.
Like wine one and two are the most Carmenere.
I just thought it was balanced, delicious.
It wasn't like popping out in any matter whatsoever.
It was just really good.
I gave it 90 plus points.
I think it was delicious.
Let's take a look and see if it's from Chile or Italy.
It's from Chile.
This is the Casa Silva.
This is kind of an iconic Carmenere, actually.
The Casa Silva Carmenere Los Linguas Vineyard,
2022, very young, comes in at 22 bucks.
Again, 14% alcohol, so it's not so big.
Now, here's the deal.
I gave it 90 plus points.
I think at 22 bucks, that's delicious
if you like that style of wine
and sometimes you can find it for even less.
So I think that's worth checking out.
Number four, Red Cherry, Red Plum, tobacco-type flavors.
It was just delicious.
Nothing really stood out.
It was really balanced.
I gave it 91 plus points.
I thought it was pretty darn good wine.
I hope it's affordable for your sake
because I'm going to say go seek this out, and it is.
This is the Enema Carmenere Pew.
This, oh, this has a little more love.
85% Carmenere, 15% Merlot,
so a little bit balanced, 13.5% alcohol.
Comes in also at 22 bucks.
Enema is in the Veneto.
They're producers of Suave.
They're Suave wines, which are white wines,
tend to be a little bit bigger in style,
especially their top-end stuff, which is barrel-fermented.
Funny enough, they're known as a white wine producer.
I've loved this wine in the past,
although this is the first time
I've had it in a few vintages.
They also make in special vintages
a beautiful Cabernet Sauvignon,
one of the better Cabernet Sauvignons
I've tasted coming out of Italy.
Can't remember the name of that,
but it's a good wine.
It's a little more expensive, but still, 22 bucks.
I highly recommend it.
It's worth checking out.
The last two here.
The number five, this was the darkest.
It was the smoothest.
It was kind of pretty ambitious.
Not to my style, big, fruity, round,
but I think a lot of you are absolutely gonna love it.
92 points.
92 points for this,
what I think is an ambitious, smooth wine.
This is the La Posta Cuvée Alexander Carmenere 2022
from Chile as well.
This comes in at 24 bucks.
This is the same ownership as Cloapalta,
one of the most iconic wines in Chile.
Cloapalta is unique.
It's a Bordeaux blend,
but uses a heavy percentage of Carmenere in the blend.
This is their single vineyard special edition,
and 24 bucks, I think that is a steal.
I think for people that like big red wines,
people that are drinking some Washington State red wines,
some Napa Cab type wines,
you pick that up at 24 bucks.
You're gonna be happy.
You're gonna be happy as a bird.
Okay, number three, which was really weird for me.
Usually don't like this style wine
because it was pretty woody,
but like I said, like that pepper on the steak,
that pepper crust in this on the steak,
it adds a really just nice flair to it.
Had some violet notes.
I thought it was delicious.
I know now what's left,
and I've never tasted this wine before.
I gave it 93 points.
I thought it was very good.
Thought it was very good.
It's a little more expensive, also from Chile.
This is the Ventasquero Oblica.
This is their top Carmenere.
From also, this is the same Appalachian as the La Postol,
the Apolta denomination in Chile.
I gotta get to Chile.
I haven't been there yet.
This comes in at 60 bucks.
Has oak, so you're gonna want that.
Again, fans of like Napa Cab,
some bigger oakier reds are gonna like it,
and weirdly enough, I liked it,
and I don't even like oaky reds.
That says a lot about the wines,
a little more expensive though.
Tell me, what do you think about the grape Carmenere?
Have you tried any of these wines before?
Do you like Carmenere?
Or even you like the green flavors of Cabernet Franc?
I'd love to know.
Drop it in the comments below.
