Canon 5D CLASSIC VS CANON RP | image quality | usability

BHG Photo Video (Zoom Plus!)
31 followers
Hi there, thanks for joining me again.
Today we're going to look at the Canon RP versus the Canon 5D Classic.
And I know you might think it's a bit of an unfair comparison or a bit of a weird
comparison but I own both these cameras and I think
all cameras can be compared to each other. I also think there's a lot of
people that own one or the other and are thinking about buying the other one or
maybe you've got a Canon DSLR and you're thinking about moving to
mirrorless but you don't really want to get too deep into it
and the RP is an option for you but you're looking at to get the advantages
of mirrorless and most of the stuff that Canon's good
at but not having to go like deep in and buy an R5 or an R3 or something like
that. This video is for you. I recently went on a trip to the New
Forest and it's like a really very large, very old forest. There's some
wild horses in there, well actually they're more like,
I think they're wild ponies technically, they're quite small. And I took the 5D
Classic and the Canon RP and I shot with the Canon 70-200 2.82
the EF version. So I had the lens adapter
on the RP. So by doing this I'm using the same lens on both cameras.
I'm going to talk to you about what it was like, the shooting experience of
using both as a switch between them. What I kind of think about the
image quality and colour rendition from both of them as well
and any advantages of either the DSLR or the mirrorless versus each other.
Let's get into what the handling differences were. I'm just going to talk
about the stuff that actually stood out. I'm not going to talk about all the
differences between DSLRs and mirrorless, you know all that stuff.
I'm going to tell you what I experienced and how I felt that they were different
and what I noticed. So the first thing I noticed comparing
the two cameras together was with the RP obviously being able to move the
focus point around on the rear screen. I found that it didn't use the EVF.
I was much more focused on using the screen on the back because it had a nice
clear display and even in the harsh sunlight it works
very very well. I was very aware of what my exposure was
and what I was focusing on and I thought that was very good.
I know that the RP doesn't have the highest resolution screen on the back
and it's not even the largest it's a little bit smaller than the others but
I find that it was very usable and it felt like much sharper than it says it
is if that makes sense. It felt higher resolution than the specs
suggest and moving the focus point around with my finger being able to tap
where I wanted it to focus was really useful. When I was shooting I
was using a monopod on the lens as well because it would allow
me to hold the camera in this way. Trying to hold
a lens as heavy as that out at sort of arms distance
is going to be really difficult with a monopod it's actually very easy. I liked
that experience and I thought it was very good. It was
easy because I didn't have to focus and recompose and I could move my
composition around and then just hit what I wanted to track where I
wanted to focus on the horse. In comparison with the 5D I think
looking through the optical viewfinder has some real benefits of its own
and that was that I felt more connected in the moment because you're literally
seeing everything as it happens. Well I guess you are with the mirrorless
cameras now as well. I think it has to do with not having a
digitized representation in front of you. Seeing a digital screen
always feels slightly remote but I also think on the flip side of that
with the RP getting it away from your face and having it on a monopod in front
of you when I was looking around and able to
see my surroundings better that did help as well in its own way so
it was a bit of give and take on those but I felt that
when I was using the 5D that I just didn't
because I couldn't change as many things and couldn't do as much I was on the
center focus point and I felt like it was a simpler and
cleaner experience. There was a simplicity that was satisfying
within that in itself so if you ask me which is the most
enjoyable photography experience in this instance I would say I enjoyed
shooting with the 5D more but I would also say that I think for
other certain genres of photography especially for things like portrait
photography the RP would probably be much more
beneficial before things like eye tracking and so on
which really do make a real world difference and also think for
certain types of street photography if you're going to try and get the camera
down at different angles and you want to get the camera away
from your face for me that is one of the very biggest
benefits of mirrorless that has good focusing systems
such as the RP does is that I can take the camera away from my eye
and put it into unusual positions and unusual locations
well it would be very hard to do with the camera attached to your face you'd
have to lie on the floor whereas you can just literally bend down
and hold the camera floor level you can do that sort of stuff with a
mirrorless camera much more easily. When I looked back at the pictures
afterwards I noticed with the 5D that when the horses were moving and I
was photographing them moving because I wasn't seeing my exposure anymore
and I was shooting in manual mode I wasn't always correcting
as best as I could and obviously with mirrorless that's a little bit easier
because you're seeing the exposure before you take it
I didn't think that was a big deal and I hardly lost any shots but I just lost a
few to that because we had very harsh sunlight at
times. Regarding the actual focusing ability
I think I only counted about three photos missed focus on
the 5D classic and just one that I can think of on the RP and that was
actually user error because the focus box I was using kind
of the corner tip of it went over a leaf and it focused on
that instead so that was really my fault
but I didn't have any focus problems with either of these cameras I thought
the hit rate was remarkably high from both of them
so instead of going through loads of photos what I've done is I've
picked two pictures but I've picked these two pictures because for me they
illustrate the differences between the cameras
really well in terms of the look and feel of the images
so in this first picture this was taken on the 5D classic
and I'm going to point out certain things that I feel about these cameras
about the way they render and you can see perhaps some of the
differences now I know the lighting is slightly different in both of these but
they were taken at relatively close times at relatively
similar locations so when we look at this picture from the
5D classic what really stands out to me is the kind
of pop of the area that's in focus it it
almost has a slightly 3D drawn feel to it and I feel that the 5D
classic gives you a lot of that this is one of the things that I really
like about the 5D is that the separation of colors is
strong and what I mean by that is that there is no sense of a color
cast in the images where you might feel that there's like a
yellow or green filter over the picture the separation for instance between
the background color and the color of the horse is strong and this
I think aids the feeling of depth and and pop that you get with the 5D
it's very good at that and I particularly like the way that it
renders the green tones in images and when we come over to the
Canon RP file the thing that you'll notice
instantly is that the that it's got less sort of intensity
that is partly down to the lighting though so be aware of that but
what you'll also notice is the overall picture has more of a color cast to it
I don't think there's anything wrong with that and if I shown you this
picture first I don't think you would have said
anything and you wouldn't have it wouldn't have made much difference
but you can see that the the separation overall isn't as strong
however I still think that it gives a really nice file I think it's very
pleasing and there's nothing wrong with it I like
the way the greens are here too I think they look very good
and I think there's plenty of detail and it's a very pleasing image as well
I think from those two pictures you can see there clearly is a difference
between the way the two files look from each of the cameras but
you have to remember that RP is going to make your life
easier in a lot of situations all of the benefits
that mirrorless has getting the camera away from your face
the much better focusing systems the ability to touch
where you want to focus those things are going to make a really big difference to
what you get and I think that whilst I prefer the
pictures from the 5d classic that's why so many people own them the
RP still gives a really strong performance
on its own and that is going to bring it into my
next point really with this I will say this in my videos time and time and time
again when it really comes down to it the thing
that matters in your pictures is what you're trying to express the
emotion in your pictures and what it makes people feel
when they view them that is what it comes down to
I'm going to show you this final image now and I want you to
write in the comments which camera you think this was taken on
was this the RP or the 5d classic I'll be interested to know what you think
because this for me is the kind of shot that I'm after when I go out and do
something like this this would be something that would be
up to standard I guess for my work I would like you to think carefully
about what this means now does it matter to you which camera this was shot on
have a guess which one it was shot on but think if I told you that it's the
5d what does that mean to you and if I told you it was the RP what
would that mean to you as well because how you feel about those two questions
will probably help you decide whether either of these cameras are for you
if you'd like to know more detail about why I bought the canon RP
then please check out this video here
